News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by 40acres on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:56PM (#18826079)
I would've thought by now the security consultant industry would be really robust and large corporations like Marriott would be advised to handle low hanging fruit like "encrypt everything". Anyone know the current state of the industry?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by jjeaff on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:14PM (#18826243)
Hopefully someone in the security industry can chime in, but from the outside, it looks like a gold rush is well underway. Unfortunately, the parties that are cashing in are large companies like McAfee that are offering essentially useless "hacker protection" plans. Then on the enterprise side, the big service providers are providing similar useless services.

Security is a complex issue that requires custom, expensive, and ongoing solutions. So companies run by non-security professionals are going to trust the relatively cheap programs offered by these large providers.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ummonk on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:12PM (#18827674)
Nah, not really much of a gold rush. There is a lot of talk about how security is becoming extremely important, but when push comes to shove and companies have to spend significantly to secure their systems, or worse, slow down feature development to do so, they choose the easy route. And I can't blame them, given the financial incentives at play.

Take startups. Having a security breach won't kill your startup. Being slow to market will.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by nikanj on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:39PM (#18828405)
The ROI is not there, when there are significant costs to security, and no repercussions after getting hacked.

Without a solid ROI, it probably won't turn into a gold rush anytime soon.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by eftychis on Saturday January 05, 2019 @04:28AM (#18830735)
I think the issue is a bit more fundamental: Security is an afterthought. There are no repercussions, or gain or expected real punishment for not providing a secure solution. These hacker protection plans are just to tick off a box and satisfy a regulation (government or internal).

On the other hand if we cared about security we would not rush to assign a long lasting hard to change number to a person, and share it around... (Or worse in the case of SSN (for the U.S.) pick a number that is neither randomly assigned nor equipped with a validation mechanism.)

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by staplers on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:09PM (#18826200)

  Anyone know the current state of the industry?
Large corporations are run by business majors who often have a disdain for computer science. Usually this leads to not hiring the top security experts (either through lack of knowledge or not wanting anyone smarter than themselves at the wheel).

I've personally seen this at a few jobs. It can go both ways as often CS-saavy startup founders are the same way towards business majors.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by mr1976 on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:58PM (#18828555)
I worked for Marriott for a long time (on the tech side). They have no distain for computer science, it's not "run by business majors", and there is no shortage of security experts. They were one of the more on the ball technology and security operations _for a company of that age and size and legacy_. The company as a whole placed huge focus, resources and energy on information security from well before I joined - it was one of the most risk averse groups I've worked for.

The incident took place on the Starwood network (they bought starwood, a completely separate company with completely separate infrastructure), and this issue was discovered post acquisition and during the long running integration program (starwood had 2 breaches previously, so I guess it's not surprising). From what I've seen, if it wasn't for the controls implemented as part of the integration which formed part of Marriott's standard risk-averse approach to security generally, it probably wouldn't have been found for another 4 years.

It's complicated, and 99% of the "damn fool corporates and their evil ways!" comments are completely off the mark because they don't have the context.

The reality is that integrating another business is unbelievable difficult. Managing the (now significantly higher) infosec risks more so. You inherit a landscape with monsters you don't know about, and you still have to own whatever pops out. It's a really, really bad thing to have happened - make no mistake. And in time, the full story will out and opinions can be reached based on facts. Maybe they did screw it up. Maybe they could have done stuff differently. I don't think it's like equifax with a clear cut cause and effect, but a reasonably complicated ecosystem steeped in legacy systems opaque dependencies that is really hard to change.

It seems to be this generally accepted thing that whenever there is a huge breach, some people (aside from the person doing the breaching) have been utterly negligent, ignored all the obvious and really quite simple (I mean, just encryption all the things, amirite? duh!) and should be rounded up and shot at dawn. Perhaps - just perhaps - it's something that wasn't a result of negligence, and just wasn't foreseen because hard stuff is hard. Hindsight really does create the most impressive armchair strategists.

(no, I don't still work there. I left a few years ago. no, I don't think they're perfect. no, I don't think all corporations are evil incarnate looking to steal our data, only some of them.)

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:14PM (#18826246)
I think it's mostly the fact that the cost of data breaches is less than the savings (i.e. profit) from not implementing rigorous systems.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by barbecue_sauce on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:37PM (#18827009)
People don't seem to realize the financial planning aspect of deciding whether to do rigorous security or not. A major part of training materials for CISSP, which is really more of a security management certification than a technical one, is explicitly about doing a cost-benefit analysis of security implementation. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annualized_loss_expectancy.

That said, there are fair number of common-sense low or zero cost safeguards any technical employees could implement to help mitigate threats.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by idontpost on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:25PM (#18828289)
> That said, there are fair number of common-sense low or zero cost safeguards any technical employees could implement to help mitigate threats.

The cost isn't in the safeguards. The cost is in the governance structures (i.e. time spent by mid-level managers) that ensure the safeguards are followed and applied consistently across the organization.

Encrypting database fields is basically free. Making sure all database fields that should be encrypted are is an expensive process.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by staplers on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:26PM (#18826377)
FREE and OSS CMS' encrypt customer data now.. Don't know where this myth that it costs money to do basic encryption is coming from..
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by EpicEng on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:08PM (#18826759)
It's not only the cost to encrypt something. It's the cost to create security policies, hire people who know the field, implement protections beyond encrypting data at rest, updating old software to deal with the new security measures, etc. It's never as simple as "just encrypt that field".

Until there's a good reason to do so people aren't going to bother.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Kalium on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:41PM (#18826505)
You're absolutely right! The basic software infrastructure that can be adapted to safely and securely handle user data is completely free.

It may be worth considering that adapting said FLOSS software, doing the requisite custom integration work, and then doing a large migration successfully might all be perhaps slightly less free than the software you correctly and wisely point to.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by sbarre on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:49PM (#18826567)
Large enterprises have extremely complex and interconnected systems.

The real costs and work is in the migration and adoption of new tools (regardless of the cost of the tools themselves).

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by myrion on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:31PM (#18826427)
The cost in this case would be in switching.

They're already using a system that works for them, why bother changing to something else?

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by rosege on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:08PM (#18828146)
Your comment reminds me of this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiB8GVMNJkE
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by neogodless on Friday January 04, 2019 @06:13PM (#18828650)
It's a little chilling, but I assumed the clip you linked was the one you did!

I believe it was in one of Henry Cloud's books on boundaries where I learned the idea that people roughly fit into three categories.

- they want to treat others well, and if you inform them of a boundary they've overstepped, they'll try to correct it

- they care about themselves within the framework of our society and laws, but are not keen on giving up anything for anyone else. If you want to enforce a boundary with them, you have to find a way to shift the consequences of their actions back onto them. Only if it hurts them, will they change their behavior

- they don't care about laws, society, decency, etc - you'll need guns and lawyers.

Right now it feels like many corporations are on a wide line between the second and third description above... what a sad realization!

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Friday January 04, 2019 @10:44PM (#18829774)
I haven't seen any evidence of that. Those people respond to incentives and there are few current incentives to push companies to spend time on security, especially preemptively. Yes, there will be some public blowback if you're compromised, but that will blow over. Plus consumers are well aware that this is happening all the time to other companies, so it's become "normal" behavior now.

The fines for neglect of personal customer data need to be so high that the boards of these companies and their shareholders demand that their executives make security a priority.

HIPAA (https://compliancy-group.com/hipaa-fines-directory-year/) is a decent model and it does seem like security is taken more seriously in the healthcare industry in general. That being said, the actual fines are relatively low when you look at the size of some of these companies.

Anthem is one example: https://www.hhs.gov/about/news/2018/10/15/anthem-pays-ocr-16...

That was the largest HIPAA fine ever ($16 million) for a company that pulls in $90 BILLION in revenue each year and 79 million people had their information compromised in that event. That fine is basically a rounding error for them. Still, this outcome is better than what happens with most non-healthcare security compromises, which is basically nothing except "we're sorry, we take security seriously, and here is one year of credit monitoring."

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by kerng on Friday January 04, 2019 @11:52PM (#18829979)
HIPPA is mostly self attestation, so it's one of the weaker compliance requirements actually. But you are correct that at least there is some fine involved. GDPR will be interesting to follow also, and to see how high the fines will go in the future.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by diminoten on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:30PM (#18826950)
Disdain? What the hell? I know more than my fair share of MBAs and they're all fascinated by my job, far as I can tell...
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ganoushoreilly on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:05PM (#18826163)
The industry is robust, companies just refuse to spend money on security because the risks aren’t all that great to them and insurance policies are paid out regardless.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by jlgray on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:38PM (#18826485)
I'm ever so slightly optimistic in this regard. As soon as we see a few GDPR-related penalties assessed, the risk-reward calculation will change drastically.

According to their 2017 annual report [1], Marriot had $22.9bn in worldwide revenue. A 4% penalty on that would be $900M.

[1] https://marriott.gcs-web.com/static-files/057a8e1a-a5c5-4c20...

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by reaperducer on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:04PM (#18827175)
I read that there was some kind of grace period involving GDPR penalties. Has the EU handed out any fines yet, or is it still letting companies adjust?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by qznc on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:52PM (#18828513)
Yes, the first case is done: https://www.welivesecurity.com/2018/11/27/german-chat-site-f...

The question is probably if it is state of the art to encrypt passport numbers. If yes, then Marriot could be fine with a similiar argument of "the company knowingly violated its duty to ensure data security".

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by kazen44 on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:56PM (#18828543)
> I read that there was some kind of grace period involving GDPR penalties.

the grace period started two years ago until may 2018...

people seem to forget that the GDPR was technically already a law in 2016, it was just not enforced.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by gamma-male on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:50PM (#18827091)
I've seen employees demonstrating every day for months in front of the Marriott in San Francisco. Didn't think they were doing that good.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by elliekelly on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:45PM (#18827057)
This is spot on. I was the Chief Information Security/Privacy Officer at an investment bank and had to _beg_ for a system to scan email and automatically encrypt if it detected PII.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by grouseway on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:19PM (#18826293)
Totally naive question, but how does this work? I have trouble seeing the extra security value.

Does "select passport from customers" no longer work as a query? Or do you store an encrypted value in the table that you then decrypt on demand? Is the decryption performed by a microservice that add an additional layer that would need to be hacked?

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by saidajigumi on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:42PM (#18826507)
> Or do you store an encrypted value in the table that you then decrypt on demand? Is the decryption performed by a microservice that add an additional layer that would need to be hacked?

That is precisely one model. In fact, there are hardened "vault" appliances designed for exactly this class of use cases. All sensitive PII is 1) encrypted on the vault and 2) replaced externally with a random token. Most of the time, the rule is that the plaintext PII is never removed from the vault. E.g. to compare a value, a new one is sent to the vault to (idempotently) to retrieve a token.

Done right, this gives you other features/requirements such as the ability to rate limit and set alarms on vault accesses. E.g. if someone were trying to brute-force retrieve vault data via token retrieval.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by mkoryak on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:27PM (#18826393)
It works pretty much as described. Now the hackers cant simply steal the db dump, they must also steal the decryption code and the key. This requires more work. The application servers are not the same as database servers, etc.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by gamma-male on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:45PM (#18827059)
Ok so I know a thing or two about that:

1. Most companies, even large ones, do not encrypt everything. Some do, usually because they have to according to some regulation of the space they operate in (HIPAA for example).

2. Passport numbers are a grey area. Is it public information? Is it private information?

3. Even if you encrypt your database, the key will most often be lying next to it. Unless your company really cares about security, because they have to by design, they will most often not architect an infrastructure that protects the key.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by bdamm on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:54PM (#18827114)
4. The systems that use the encrypted data are themselves vulnerabilities; if the attacker can collect the data through systems that can decrypt the data for them, then they may not even know that the data was encrypted. Attacks on these kinds of databases are often through services and not by just taking the database wholesale. Thus encryption is not really a robust protection against theft, it only protects against theft via discarded media and the like.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by v_lisivka on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:06AM (#18830868)
Numbers are too easy to crack by enumeration. You can just enumerate all possible passport numbers, encrypt them, and compare two hashes. It takes seconds on modern CPU. Even if salt is used, all 5E6 records can be cracked in about 2 months on modern desktop, or in 1 day on 60 node cluster.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by gamma-male on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:55PM (#18835559)
That’s if you own the encryption key. If you own the encryption key you can just decrypt
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by gamma-male on Friday January 04, 2019 @06:26PM (#18828739)
Good point as well. Sometimes a SQL injection will go right through this kind of Transparent Database Encryption.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by v_lisivka on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:02AM (#18830848)
Passport record and number of passport record are protected by Privacy Act[1].

(4) the term “record” means any item, collection, or grouping of information about an individual that is maintained by an agency, including, but not limited to, his education, financial transactions, medical history, and criminal or employment history and that contains his name, or the identifying number, symbol, or other identifying particular assigned to the individual, such as a finger or voice print or a photograph;

[1]: https://www.us-passport-service-guide.com/is-passport-inform...

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by gamma-male on Sunday January 06, 2019 @02:19AM (#18837065)
This is a US answer only. Other countries might have different laws.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by slifin on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:46PM (#18827071)
low hanging fruit like "encrypt everything"

...what? A database stops working as a database if you encrypt every field

If you encrypt at rest/in transit (which you should legally) then you're only protected against a very limited set of threats

Encryption is not going to save you if you have SQL injection or webserver breech

Encryption is good but protects against hardly anything, usually physical attacks, do not try and encrypt at the application level, password fields are encrypted because you should never need to query it

Passwords are the exception not the rule

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by 40acres on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:00PM (#18827151)
I'm not a security export, so "encrypt everything" is simply a hand-wavy way to say "handle low hanging security holes". When you look at the cause of some of the large breaches in the past, many times they are very simple attack vectors and weak protections: phishing, passwords stored in plaintext, etc.

As engineers, we are awed when flaws like Rowhammer and Spectre are exposed, but the fact is that a lot more data is being exposed by very simple means. The fact that corporations are still being breached by these efforts is troubling. I think it shines a bad light on both corporate entities and security consultants.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by LinuxBender on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:54PM (#18827515)
At my workplace, all attributes in the database are encrypted. In fact, we are contractually obligated to do so. This does not limit the use of the database. Rather, it changes how we use the database. i.e. We decrypt, store working sets in memory, re-encrypt prior to storing in the database.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by idontpost on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:28PM (#18828321)
That's impractical for the vast majority of use cases. The performance costs would be enormous, turning millisecond response times into seconds in many cases.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by LinuxBender on Friday January 04, 2019 @05:36PM (#18828390)
For existing database design for many, sure. This requires rethinking how you access your data and changing the architecture and data flows accordingly. I am not in any way suggesting it would be trivial for existing applications to suddenly do this. It requires forethought.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by v_lisivka on Saturday January 05, 2019 @05:11AM (#18830883)
They store unencrypted data in memory instead of hard drive. From security perspective: nothing changed, so their access times may be even faster than with traditional approach.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by LinuxBender on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:48AM (#18846077)
Actually it means that you must be able to access memory when the server is running. Still possible, but much more difficult and requires gaining root on the server while it is running and has decrypted the data, or finding some RCE that allows direct access to this memory. We have numerous pen testers and code reviewers that look for and test for such things all the time. This also means evading various monitoring tools that security and network operations centers are watching. Again, still possible, but much more difficult.

This also means, disks walking away are always encrypted. We physically shred all of our disks, but humans can make mistakes.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by idontpost on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:44PM (#18860939)
You're assuming that all your unencrypted data fits in memory. For most of us, that's not the case.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by PurpleBoxDragon on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:01PM (#18827572)
>password fields are encrypted

If you are encrypting your passwords you are already doing it wrong.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by grumio on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:45PM (#18827946)
I hope by "password fields are encrypted" you mean that only hashes are stored.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by munchbunny on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:40PM (#18826499)
I think this blog post from Brian Krebs captures the problem pretty well: https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/12/a-chief-security-concern...

There's a lack of attention at the executive and organization levels in these major corporations, so they're not set up to deal with security threats in a forward looking way.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by wonderwonder on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:08PM (#18827637)
Unfortunately in the hotel and timeshare industry (large overlap) IT is not a central concern it is an expense and often treated as one. Meaning large portions of the system development is outsourced to dev shops out of the country or teams are brought in from India etc. This is not a slight on those engineers as they are often highly skilled. The issue is that they are working off of requirements produced by senior management level people who are very lacking in knowing the low level details. The engineers also don't have the background on what is a surprisingly complicated process and things get lost. These engineering teams were brought in to save money and as such corners are often cut everywhere especially security. The engineers are also often not in a position to push back as they are contractors from poorer nations and rely on these salaries to a far greater degree than a US citizen might.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by tibbon on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:11PM (#18826781)
I personally find that people in product, sales, upper management, etc... want to push for features, things being easy/fast, etc over everything else.

They tell developers to "not worry about it" and force deadlines on them that don't allow for doing things right.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Friday January 04, 2019 @10:28PM (#18829708)
Why would it be? There is almost no risk to ignoring security issues, and the risk only decreases the more this happens to other companies because consumers start seeing it as normal behavior that affects all companies they do business with.

I'm almost certain Marriott has security people telling the higher-ups that they need to do X to protect security, but if other companies are not subjected to that same risk, revenue growth is always going to win over security.

This will never change until governments start holding these companies liable with severe penalties that are not simply "the cost of doing business."

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by duxup on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:25PM (#18826903)
The sheer volume of folks in that industry who have borderline ZERO clue is shocking. It really is an amazing mix of absolutely empty suits and good people.

Companies seem to have no idea who is who.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by walshemj on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:50PM (#18827093)
Absolutely I have seen a major hotel chain totally (no names no pack drill) mess up a site migration - had to revert and do it again after a co worker and I had laid out what they should have done in the first place.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by duxup on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:10PM (#18827221)
I worked with one when I was an outside vendor.

90% of their IT staff's time was calling up their vendors support teams and convincing them to join a conference call together and then telling vendors from different companies to just make it work, whatever it was. They thought that was just how you did things.

Eventually we told them "naw we're not doing that anymore stop eating our support team's time". They threatened to move on to another vendor and tried... but couldn't actually pull it off because... they simply didn't have the manpower or technical knowledge.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by theseatoms on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:37PM (#18826479)
The costs of hacks are still largely external, while the costs of avoiding such hacks are high and internal.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by manishsharan on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:09PM (#18826202)
Its likely that all major enterprises are waiting for Oracle to come up with data -at-rest-encryption and then they will likely follow along.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by iancnorden on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:11PM (#18826226)
TDE has existed for a while, and is certainly not fixing these things for us InfoSec folks. https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/database/security/tde-faq...
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by briffle on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:03PM (#18826703)
There are a LOT of companies that can't run that, since it requires Enterprise Edition of Oracle.. That is a huge jump in price over standard edition, even for most larger companies.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by bogomipz on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:34PM (#18826460)
I don't see how encryption at rest helps with an online attack.

Once the file system is mounted the filesystem is unlocked. This is way things like LUKS which has bee around forever work today.