This sort of thing is one of the reasons why I fear these systems. A world where this is common is a world where it's no longer safe to take a stroll through your own neighborhood.
I also wouldn't want to live in that world. There are many problems with it, but not being safe for "a stroll through your own neighborhood" is not a problem for that world.
I think that depends on what you consider "safe". Or perhaps I misunderstood what you were saying...
The minute you cross onto my property you're going to show up on multiple cameras that are pointed right at the boundary line. You rights to do whatever you want stop when you cross that line.
I dont think you could convince me that this makes you any less safe.
That's obviously fine for you, the property owner, camera operator, and a very reasonable person. But, imagine every house working that way as you walk around your neighborhood. Is everyone as reasonable as you?
I'm not trying to, because when it comes to my own security, what you think is or is not safe isn't relevant. Just as what I think isn't relevant to yours.
Im working for full 100% coverage of the entirety of my house, inside and out. The goal being able to control my smart house via gestures anywhere I am on the property via some machine learning and computer vision.
Also WYZE cams are 20 bucks a pop, and easily reflashed to do you own bidding. So it's not like this is some super expensive undertaking.
By the way, I have had my home pretty thoroughly automated for about 20 years now. I do recommend that (as long as you aren't using third party services -- that's a security risk all by itself). It's a lot of fun, not incredibly expensive, and pretty useful.
Maybe not but if the thieves are recognized automatically the police have a much better chance at recovery.
- put pervasive face recog databases on the big majority of the US population in hands of huge multinational companies (because America) so an opulent Joe The Programmer can feel a little extra safety over his stuff, because Those Scary Plebs can steal their Juicero juicer
- work on societal problems, reduce the inequality to reduce the risk of robbing and accept whatever risk is left because the societal cost of pervasive corp surveillance is just too high
The fact that sizable number of people feel that the former in any way preferable is pretty damning.
This kind of alerting is a bit like any of the automated alarms we have in IT (be it Nagios, CloudWatch, or whatever). They're necessary to tell us when things have gone wrong if they go off too frequently then they'll just get ignored.
In fact there was a parable about this as well, called "The boy who cried wolf".
Even if statistically the likelihood is low, I wouldn't say the fears of what this technology enables and could result in for someone simply being in the wrong neighborhood 'while black' are overly complicated or historically irrelevant/unfounded for certain areas of the US.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/08/us/airbnb-black-women-pol...
Given this is an automatic sensor, people would just quickly just ignore it without even checking the footage - this even before any racial or social prejudices had chance to kick in.
We see this all the time with software monitoring solutions in IT what sysadmins ignore if they are too sensitive so my comment here isn’t without precedence either.
But essentially we are both arguing that an overly sensitive alarm is a bad thing - just from different perspectives. You make the point about discrimination and I make the point about the alerting being worthless in a sea of ignored alarms. Ultimately we’re both skeptical
You might be. I'm not. I never once said it's a bad thing, or described it as overly sensitive, to be fair. Just that I could see how certain communities might look at the technology and what it enables and have good reason to be incredulous about how certain neighborhood actors will use it.
That's about a nuanced as I can possibly get on the topic without trying to argue in favor or against these devices in full, or taking any absolute position.
Ring: Please provide a valid email address to continue.
Me: Turns to leave
Ring: Sorry we missed you! Please state your reason for visit and someone will reach out to you. Please provide a valid email address to continue.
Ring: Warning! This entry attempt have been recorded. An unauthorized entry attempt will be reported to the cloud and local law enforcment.
It doesn't matter if it's an IP address scanning your network then hitting one system, then logging in and scooping up all your data versus a human staring at your house for a few days then walking up while you're not home and stealing your TV. You should know if someone is scoping out your perimeter in preparation for a breach, and post-breach you should know the history of the attack.
I know nothing about Next Door but from reading the comments it seems like the problem is having this information in untrained hands.
I'd go with 'undisciplined' hands versus 'untrained' hands, while admitting I'm unsure of the best way to articulate the difference in a manner that is empathetic towards the desires of residents who just want to feel like they're safe on their block but also addresses a certain pragmatic reality of what happens when 'good intentions' results in a patrol car pulling up next to you in your own neighborhood.
The reasonable expectation of your neighbors would be to assume they're normal people like you, not necessarily that they be trained in surveillance, criminal profiling or tracking persons of interest but instead disciplined in their vigilance as thoughtful and watchful community members who act when there is something demonstrably out of the norm that could affect the neighborhood.
Again, not sure how I can best articulate that thought, or even what steps a community has to take to avoid everyone "narcing" on everyone else for boring, mundane behavior (say, like for instance, retreading your steps through the neighborhood after you lost your phone or some other item the night before) while still remaining active enough to do the right thing when you see someone you know isn't your neighbor picking up packages off someone's doorstep.
considering that it is easy to surf news sites and find video captured by home surveillance systems showing people taking packages, trying to get in, or having broke in, it is not unreasonable to install such a device.
the issue is that the data would be available to the police without the homeowners permission. people coming to the door have no expectation of privacy on property they do not own and if need be a simple sign on the property can declare as such.
>considering that it is easy to surf news sites and find video
This is confirmation bias in action. You need statistics on your residential area to make decisions around home security.
It is trivial to find videos of people committing crimes, but that does not imply anything about its likelihood. Meanwhile the state has an excellent record of abuse of power for ends that are unrelated to the reasons given for the power. See: the use of “terrorism” to justify militarizing domestic law enforcement, or parallel reconstruction.
The issue is that this idea that centralization of information will somehow avoid the pattern of abuse of centralized power in the hands of people with perverse incentives.
This video stream should be considered private property IMHO which requires a warrant like anything else.
Where is the issue here? That we provide suspicious activity reports, or that our police SEEMINGLY can't reliably deal with those reports?
Feeding false positives to law enforcement causes them not to work what is important or to redirect resources to filtering reports.
The first thing that comes to my mind is that people who use these systems would be causing innocent others to be included in Big Data databases without their knowledge or consent. I think that it's not only immoral to do so, it is straight-up antisocial and harmful to community and society.
We have more than enough of that sort of thing already.
If you or some grandma install a cloud system that auto sends my info to multiple third parties I would think that is worse than creepy.
I could see grubhub delivery people end up at wrong adresses, a system detecting unusual arrival at 9pm, send alert, the system pulls other data about this person, combines it. This is shared with multiple groups of people. Now humans look through it and see her going to the sex toy store earlier in the day and the abortion clinic and the (insert non-popular religious place here) - and whatever.
All it takes is one person in multiple groups to get heated about this person's lifetsyle or 'suspicious activity' to put out a pull over and find some reason to get more info, write a ticket, fine, get them to rack up other issues.
In an extreme situation you end up one of the cog wheels that started a Sandra Bland situation because a suspicions wrong address was given via GPS to a delivery driver.
Even without wrongful deaths, having people look into your life like that and make jokes about you or whatever is pretty lame.
At least when this happens with Msoft's one drive, one could say that someone agreed to the terms of lack of privacy with the corp. Not that I would buy that as 100% true in 100% of most cases, but at least then it could be argued.
Most people would use that option if they had the opportunity; tracking potential troublemakers has obvious benefits. The problem is you are not being given the option "to track [a] person". You're being given the option to record video and apply an automated tool to identify "likely faces" and as way to compare those images against a local database using a definition of similarity that is poorly specified[1], extremely complex, and opaque/unexplained. Jumping right thinking of this as "tracking a person" ignores the many layers of metaphor shear between the desired goal and what the actual implementation does.
Metaphor shear is what you experience when you realize that interface doesn't match what is actually happening. The metaphor was lost somewhere in the hundreds of layers of abstraction connecting input to output. The map is not the territory. Efficient and powerful tools are very useful, but they also let you efficiently shoot yourself in the foot in powerful new ways.
Since metaphor shear is about the error between an expected ideal and actual measured reality, it compounds across layers of abstraction similar to how experimental error loses precision with each calculation. Any particular layer of abstraction is probably fine in isolation, but the interface metaphor loses significant digits as more and more layers are added.
If intellectual labor is going to be surrendered to a device, we need to be very clear and specific in what we are surrendering and what the device is expected to do.
(Video essayist Kyle Kallgren does a much better job of explaining[2] the problem of metaphor shear, using examples from sci-fi [Black Mirror, HHGttG, R.U.R.])
[1] poor in the context of trying to track someone. I'm sure the face matching algorithm is very well specified with respect to matching images of faces. The poorly specified part is when "matching images of faces" becomes "tracking someone" (what does "tracking" mean? How are probabilities about matching faces mapped to identifying "that person"?)
But if I have video footage of someone approaching my door, not knocking and just looking aroud to then leave; and I'm given the option to track if that person shows up again in future video footage, you bet I would use that option.
This is not because I'm paranoic and I think right away that anyone showing up to my door will murder or rob me, but because said person already exhibited suspicious activity around my private property.
Why would I take for granted that this person was simply lost or innocently looking around? If that's the case, then my camera would never see them again. But if they show up a second time, I want to know that.