News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @12:56PM (#18636478)
Without S. Boulardii, I am a neurotic mess who can't digest anything at all nor think straight after eating anything, so I'm inclined to believe this hypothesis.

I am also intrigued about what this means for criminality and how the line between illness and evil is likely to shift given the role of microorganisms in behavioral dysfunction; and more broadly, we don't like to admit it, but it seems that completely amoral factors can be the cause of moral, amoral, or immoral behavior.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by gboudrias on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:53PM (#18637155)
Interestingly, almost no one in NA justice systems talks about evil. The causality between life events leading to crime is often ridiculously clear, and choice barely factors into it.

Believing in evil is its own kind of privilege. I for one have now seen a lot of criminal cases, and I've only seen sick people and people following the path laid before them. No evil in sight, but the concept's very existence allows for a certain social stability, to the detriment of some in favor of others.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by test6554 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:30PM (#18638141)
Theres always a choice, and choices have consequences.

The kind of people who believe they had no choice are the worst because it shows a total lack of remorse for their selfish decisions.

Phrases like “Look what YOU made me do” and “It’s societies fault” are warning signs that they learned nothing and you have a likely repeat offender on your hands.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by neuralzen on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:47PM (#18638209)
The problem to me is more an issue of repeat offenders not knowing what they dont know. They can't conceive of a better option, so they choose the option they understand, which is not usually a particularly helpful one, for themselves or others. We expect them to use better tools, but we dont help then find or make them, just punish them for using the wrong ones.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by colordrops on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:53PM (#18639385)
This thread is great. Very insightful comments about a topic not discussed nearly enough.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by vanderZwan on Sunday December 09, 2018 @08:28AM (#18640756)
> Theres always a choice, and choices have consequences.

You're missing the point: you don't always have a choice about which choices are given to you, and that has consequences too.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by e40 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @09:54AM (#18641082)
Your reply and the parent, to me, encapsulate everything that is wrong with humans today. You are 100% right. The person to which you replied doesn't see the issue. This lack of empathy is causing so many cascading failures in human society.

(To the GP of this reply, you might have misunderstood. I'm not really talking about you, personally, just using this short conversation as an example. Please don't take it personally.)

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:55PM (#18658300)
Glad someone else pointed that out. That comment felt so inhumane and perfectly shows how people cannot appreciate the privilege they are born into. And privilege does not always mean money.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Sunday December 09, 2018 @09:41AM (#18641036)
> Theres always a choice, and choices have consequences.

You're making the assumption of how your choice could have been anything different. That's an illusion and studying determinism is helpful in understanding why you're simply a biological input/output machine in a system being society. Even with the possibility of randomness existing as quantum mechanics suggests possible.. it wouldn't make a person have any choice. Personally I think quantum mechanics is just a result from a deterministic system that at this point in time is too complex for humans to analysis as determinism.

It's common knowledge that an outcome results from an action and maybe even consequences happen when the world is under the free will illusion. The problem is the actions were all based on the preceding outcomes and where nobody had any control.

> The kind of people who believe they had no choice are the worst because it shows a total lack of remorse for their selfish decisions

> Phrases like “Look what YOU made me do” and “It’s societies fault” are warning signs that they learned nothing and you have a likely repeat offender on your hands.

Ethics & morals help society strive for the best interest of humanity. The majority of society at any point in time, hasn't understood free will is an illusion and from my understanding of history. We're only capable of theorizing but from my experience, I have been able to remove resentment to persons who wronged me and because they had no control in how they became who they are with the actions they produced against me. I don't believe persons should be punished when they had no control. The best outcome is society learning how to prevent a similar unfavorable outcome and people rehabilitating the persons who were unfavorable by the universe to do a wrong.

I's a huge assumption to assume people will be repeat offenders under the belief of knowing free will is an illusion and when you're contrary to the ideology as you haven't been able to live under it for an extended period of time.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by ZeikJT on Thursday December 13, 2018 @10:25AM (#18672908)
As a fellow determinist I would point out that both believing and not believing in it are (non-religious) faith-based.

As for quantum mechanics allowing for the introduction of non-determinism; what part of the human body do people think they can influence? The brain is a neuron-neurotransmitter system, muscles expand and contract based on electrochemical signals, etc. Where in the mind-body connection is the mind/self capable of enacting this non-deterministic influence?

That being said, believing in a non-deterministic universe doesn't make life any less fun nor surprising. It does concretize my sympathy for people who are faced with unfortunate circumstances and carry out actions with unfortunate outcomes.

Are there times where I have thoughts that contradict that belief? Sure. I've accepted the highly contradiction-prone way the mind works. In the end it just makes the most sense to me.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by derangedHorse on Sunday December 09, 2018 @11:13PM (#18645139)
Everything you base your comment on is a huge assumption. You don’t know that humans are just an input/output system, you’re just using some kind of inductive logic to come to that conclusion. Because everything you see seems to have a cause and effect relationship, you impose it on the laws of nature. I’m not saying that the theory is false, but I can definitely say that you’re putting a lot of belief in it being true without any real evidence.

Taking your thought process and building off the idea that everything is deterministic, we can frame the concept of “free will” as something that’s defined within that image of reality. In this case, why should you deny the concept of “free will” within a deterministic environment? Why not just define it as the random process that governs all of our ideologies? Additionally, why should you show sympathy to those in worse situations if everything is deterministic?

If society feels a need to punish criminals and remove them from society that’s another deterministic outcome that you yourself should know makes no difference either way in the grand scheme of things. Why someone would be deterministically wired to counter an argument by using their belief of a deterministic world on HN is beyond me though.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:10AM (#18645383)
> Everything you base your comment on is a huge assumption.

No, it's a huge assumption to create the "free will" theory with no evidence and then argue against the opposite position where I'm using what is observable in nature with science. It's like religious people that argue against people that don't believe in a god.

> but I can definitely say that you’re putting a lot of belief in it being true without any real evidence

No you can't, physics, neuroscience, computer science, and mathematics all favor determinism. If you chime out quantum mechanics, go search my comment history.

> Taking your thought process and building off the idea that everything is deterministic, we can frame the concept of “free will” as something that’s defined within that image of reality.

Yah if you acknowledge you're a puppet by external forces and love your strings. Your freedom is love for how your controlled because it fits you and how you have no real control yourself but are fine with it. Yet, I myself don't consider that definition of free will what most people think and to me it just doesn't exist because that definition would be nonsense.

> Additionally, why should you show sympathy to those in worse situations if everything is deterministic?

Humanity makes progress when removing illusions from society and being rational. Society shouldn't be punishing persons who were unfortunate by the universe. Society should fix the problem of what resulted in a person having an undesired outcome and then rehabilitating the person back into society. Same goes for social, health, and financial problems.

> If society feels a need to punish criminals and remove them from society that’s another deterministic outcome that you yourself should know makes no difference either way in the grand scheme of things.

Yah, whatever happens is destined to happen and similar to how society once viewed the world as flat and until some persons came along to get the idiotic majority to understand. Time brings progress or the opposite and it's all fated to happen. I hope you're not trying to make an argument against understanding reality by the mere premise of you would dislike how it really is.

> If society feels a need to punish criminals and remove them from society that’s another deterministic outcome that you yourself should know makes no difference either way in the grand scheme of things.

See above.

> Why someone would be deterministically wired to counter an argument by using their belief of a deterministic world on HN is beyond me though.

Short answer: Go study determinism.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by fitmax on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:00AM (#18647542)
>Humanity makes progress when removing illusions from society and being rational. Society shouldn't be punishing persons who were unfortunate by the universe. Society should fix the problem of what resulted in a person having an undesired outcome and then rehabilitating the person back into society. Same goes for social, health, and financial problems.

So if you believe in group selection has a large role in how society is shaped and will evolve then perhaps society's best interest is only to rehabilitate the troubled person only if the expected cost is lower than the expected reward. If you don't believe in group selection is that crucial then maybe it would be apparent why people like to punish if you take a look at game theory and experimental results with public good games. Keep in mind you are also making the mistake of assuming society has some sort of telos, or that moralism realism is true. So in that sense, if you ask me China's government seems very sensible in several policy areas because it doesn't give a shit about individuals.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:22AM (#18648494)
I’m not making any mistake that I’m aware about from reading what I wrote. You’re implying unknown knowledge about me and when I haven’t even shared my opinion. Simply, I haven’t stated my view on if morals & ethics are ever cared for by people in power. I do believe humanity fundamentally relies on them and to reach the highest divine status for society in functioning and when the universe is without free will to everyone. Fundamentally I observe that important to the majority of people and who are religious. They are conditioned to see it as after death though.

Anyway cost of society is something I don’t even believe is worth pursuing a discussion about with me anyway. I have witnessed from my own personal experiences with how medical treatments are handled completely irrational to fixing my issue. I’m not fully aware to understand why but I assume some unknown agenda. I’m doubtful in any case, the persons going into professions from the start want that to be so.

China is interesting and I wouldn’t be surprised to find out their leaders operate with the knowledge of free will being an illusion. However it doesn’t mean they’re doing it how everyone would and with the same knowledge. Some people will treat the misfortunate as praedamnation and not care to make that go away. Believing birth into royalty of some sort is all that matters and shouldn’t change. However the deterministic universe has been progressing in the opposite direction of that.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by zkomp on Sunday December 09, 2018 @03:46AM (#18640001)
In your own head you, it is probably benificial to think there is free will and you have choices.

But besides that, how can you ever believe such a thing without appealing to authority or religion. There cant be any free will; You are fully determined to execute on the given path. But that does not remove any responsibility - your unfree will is still yours just as the concequences, no...

(I mean, your will is determined in part by your gut. Everything you ever ate could tip the balance in some way.)

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by baumgarn on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:48PM (#18638212)
people can learn, but only after the fact.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by labster on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:31PM (#18639306)
Books are magical devices which allow humans to bypass this part of their nature, 5 stars highly recommended
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by socceroos on Saturday December 08, 2018 @08:42PM (#18638714)
That's not true though, is it.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by btschaegg on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:00AM (#18640130)
There's a wonderful quote from Douglas Adams on that:

> Human beings, who are almost unique in having the ability to learn from the experience of others, are also remarkable for their apparent disinclination to do so.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by 75dvtwin on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:02PM (#18638990)
I do not know how to express this in civilized terms.

But I feel that biological parents that raised children, who later on become evil and take other people lives -- are responsible, some how.

I am mentally, far from being contempt, with all these psychopaths (who (most of them), also have seen at some point in their lives, have seen a professional phycologist, regularly) -- go and kill defenseless kids or church/synagogue goers.

These evil humans (if they can be called that) -- should not have existed, and if they existed -- their evilness must, somehow, have been detected earlier. And that's where the parents, and, perhaps, the meds-prescribing phycologists/physiatrists come in.

I realized, that in not too distant past -- the kings and czar's suppressed uprising by executed not just the active uprisers, but their whole families, including wives and kids. As a deterrent.

I am not talking about that, but, may be there a way that parents can be held accountable to the actions of their children (even if they are more adults by the time they commit heinous crimes).

May be that will also act as deterrent against pure evil that visits those humans.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by drieddust on Sunday December 09, 2018 @09:26AM (#18640972)
That's bunch of balony. I have two children who are polar opposite in behaviour. How do you account for that?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by 75dvtwin on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:32AM (#18647087)
Why would there be a need to a 'account for differences in behavior?

Here is a very hypothetical scenario, I am struggling with:

A parent shows a pattern of drinking an driving under influence. As luck had it -- nothing bad happened. Then the child, does the same (when already having a valid driver license) -- and a horrible accident happens.

Is there some moral responsible that the parent carries? Is there criminal responsibility?

Just as in my initial comment, I do not know if this line of thinking has any merit at all.

Perhaps it is a 'bunch of baloney' as you put it.

I also have no idea on how to detect, that there in what instances there is an implied accountability of a parent (or a treating phycologist/psychiatrist).

I am hoping that some folks reading this thread , have historical, or even literature prospective that explores this angle.

How far the accountability of a parent or a treating phycologist goes/overlaps with the accountability of the perpetrator of a heinous act.

I can see that out of all the feedback on my comment so far -- there is 0 overlap of accountability suggested.

Thank you for your feedback.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by drieddust on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:35AM (#18649056)
EDIT: My apologies for the angry tone but idea of reporting on every single deviation is not a good one. That's how you actually end up filling prison and creating dystopia.

> A parent shows a pattern of drinking an driving under influence. As luck had it -- nothing bad happened. Then the child, does the same (when already having a valid driver license) -- and a horrible accident happens.

Children definately imitate parents. But I think your argument was the opposite. Parents reporting on Children's behaviour if they fall out of line.

> How far the accountability of a parent or a treating phycologist goes/overlaps with the accountability of the perpetrator of a heinous act.

World is a messy and scary place but trying to control for every variable might make it unlivable.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by dwighttk on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:04AM (#18640135)
So are you saying that evil murderers are not responsible for their evil murders because they didn’t have a choice but their evil parents are responsible, some how?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by jeena on Sunday December 09, 2018 @02:18AM (#18639801)
But more often than not it's not the parents or phycologists/physiatrists wrong doing which leads to someone doing something awful. How would you even determine that?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by 75dvtwin on Sunday December 09, 2018 @09:01AM (#18640869)
I am saying that serial murders, mass shooters & home grown terrorists had patterns and footprints -- that should, somehow have been detected by their parents and physiatrists.

I do not know how to detect this stuff, but I feel morally responsible , for behavior of my children, for example.

Why should I not be partially criminally liable for their misdeeds?

God forbid, a child drinks alcohol or smokes some chemical substance, then gets behind a wheel of a car -- and kills a family going to a picnic.

I am not even thinking of more serious premeditated horrible crimes.

As I said in the beginning of my post, I do not know how to express this correctly -- but I feel that there is more role (and accountability) that parents and doctors treating mental illness/behaviors -- should bear.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by barrkel on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:51PM (#18637740)
The ideas of free will, consequences and deterrence; morality, punishment and justice; mental illness and life choice determinism; all exist in different planes, different parallel reasoning systems about the world - rational, moral, biological/sociological. You can make linkages between the different metaphors of explication, but mixing and matching is a recipe for inconsistency. Worse, if you think mostly in a different plane to someone else, you'll forever talk past one another.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:39PM (#18638184)
I think the people who believe in free will can understand the notion of free will doesn't exist. They just have a problem with their ego and will not let go of the satisfaction the idea brings to them.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:14AM (#18639449)
I'm not sure which discussion branch to reply to you on.

But I would like to put forth the argument that people get closer to gaining the required awareness that would make them free as time passes and they gain experience. This is similar to limits in math.

That is not to say that everyone moves in that direction at the same speed - that part is indeed out of one's hands. But it is undeniable that experience increases, and with it, awareness and thus freedom.

I don't think I believe this because of ego. I just think it happens to be true.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:17AM (#18639664)
I think the assertion you make is flawed. Just because you've reached a point in time where you had experienced a great number of events and variables. Does not mean you are capable of having any will in how you're shaped into gaining a freedom or awareness that is truly your own.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:43AM (#18639735)
That's a valid view, but I don't think it's possible for us to settle this definitively. I will think more on why I seem to find that free will is real.

Just to clarify my view: I think there is a threshold of experience beyond which one becomes "formed" (as in, the word formative). Beyond that point, I think free will, and consequently, personhood is real and we're not just automatons. This is not a new argument; I just wanted to clarify my view.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:55AM (#18639760)
Understood. I enjoy the chance of enlightenment whenever possible. I'm doubtful if you will ever make me switch sides because I've thought deeply about this topic than most I assume because of misfortune by birth. I think the world would be greatly better of a system if the majority viewed reality similar to me and how there is no free will. Anyway have a good night!
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by ohiovr on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:34PM (#18637663)
Reminds me of the Monty Python sketch when the sketch artist police admit society is to blame and proceed to arrest everyone.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by berberous on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:30PM (#18637645)
I tend to be a bleeding heart and agree that many cases of criminal behavior are mental illness or environment/circumstances, but I still think there is a spectrum of morality out there -- not sure what you mean by "evil" exactly, but certainly a spectrum where people can range from high on empathy and kindness to those who care much less about others and are more amoral or even sociopathic.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by hnuser1234 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @08:22PM (#18638648)
I agree, but let's go deeper... I'd wager is there is a way to rank "empathy/kindness" in a more objective way, and that the current social environment is distanced from that objectivity.

Now even if we could perfectly, objectively rank it, should we immediately jail the bottom 1/3/10%, or should we wait for them to commit a crime? Should we give lighter sentences to more empathetic people who commit crimes, assuming they had better reasons to do it?

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by tonyedgecombe on Sunday December 09, 2018 @02:52AM (#18639879)
We are starting to understand the parts of the brain that empathy originates from. The whole question gets more complicated when you realise that these regions could be diminished through no fault of the individual.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by vahji on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:36PM (#18638171)
Believing in evil is the privilege exerted by those who've lived a life of righteousness or, at least, have tried their best.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by gboudrias on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:26PM (#18638367)
I happen to have tried my best at that so far and I think this line of thinking is mostly an excuse not to develop empathy and show compassion.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by wisty on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:31PM (#18639076)
A lot of murderers are low socioeconomic status males, but the vast majority of low socioeconomic status males are not murderers. It seems a lot like there's a choice.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:14PM (#18639250)
To me it just seems like a system and currently it's too complicated to understand why the similarity exists. It doesn't give any reason to believe there's a choice.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by frakr on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:52PM (#18637747)
They still choose to continue down that path, or to not seek healing. Maybe it would be difficult to make another choice, but impossible? I find that pretty hard to believe.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by chmod775 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:31PM (#18637923)
It would be pretty difficult to cut off your own right hand, but impossible? No. It just takes a considerate amount of willpower.

This kind of discussion leads down a path where we try to quantify something that's incredibly hard to quantify in a vacuum.

The question of willpower is also only relevant when you try to find an appropriate punishment for immoral offenses. And because this is hard, every country on earth has courts and trials - which can take forever for good reason. Because it's already hard on a per-case basis, let's not try to find an answer that would be applicable to every offence ever.

Once you're through with your offender you should give them a probable path to redemption and back into society regardless of whether they lack willpower or not - especially if they lack willpower. Punishing someone for their lack of willpower and then closing every door in their face is a sure way to make them a criminal for life. And it's also petty.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:48PM (#18638214)
The question of will power glosses over the cause/event resulting in the desire to cut off your own hand. Will power is merely a representation of all the preceding events with starting variables at birth, factoring into if the person will do the action of cutting off their own right hand.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by nafey on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:24PM (#18637891)
The will power required to exercise such a choice might also be inequitably distributed.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by jacksproit on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:32PM (#18639310)
Ah, yes!
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by anvandare on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:53PM (#18638015)
Human brains 'choose' something in the same sense that water chooses to flow downhill.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:46PM (#18638205)
You're assuming the impossible but what has conditioned into everyone at birth by social norms and which have not always been correct. The free will belief and I say it's wrong by understanding determinism. Every event is of a linear path with all the preceding events & variables from assigned at birth factoring into the proceeding event. People are dragged along a line of fate till death.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by ip26 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:35PM (#18637671)
Do you consider sociopathy and psychopathy to be sicknesses?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by gboudrias on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:41PM (#18639113)
Someone else already replied, I agree with them, yes. I'm curious if anyone wouldn't?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by ip26 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @10:52PM (#18639164)
I guess it could be because I'm not a psychologist, but I was always under the impression psychopathy & sociopathy were innate. Like, I don't know, being gay.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by zorga on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:28AM (#18640203)
I think the generally understanding is that psychopaths are born, sociopaths are made.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by intralizee on Saturday December 08, 2018 @06:43PM (#18638194)
Human events being unfavorable and resulting in sociopathy are as similar to how some linear process will trigger psychopathy. You can make the comparison as well to how an unfortunate person becomes ill of any illness.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by throwaway713 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:20PM (#18639269)
> Believing in evil is its own kind of privilege.

Tell that to holocaust survivors.

If you want to redefine commonly used words like "evil" until they no longer have any sort of meaning, go ahead, but in that case you might as well accept a nihilistic existence as an automaton obeying the deterministic time evolution laws of physics. I feel like the rest of society will ignore you in that case, and that's probably for the best.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by chillacy on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:31PM (#18639304)
Those prison guards found it all too easy to slip into their roles, it’s sadly a rare characteristic to resist and see the right and wrong. The majority go along with the currents. I’d like to think that I’m different but statistically I probably already engage in acts that future generations will consider evil, like eating farm raised animals or reaping the benefits of living in a first world country which invades and destabilizes weaker nations.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by PavlovsCat on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:20AM (#18640172)
If you look at the night sky you'll see more dark areas than points of light, but you still use those points of light and the contrast to define what brightness and darkness is. That would hold even if there was just one visible star besides the sun in the whole universe.

> I probably already engage in acts that future generations will consider evil

It's nothing to do with new insights coming about. If for example you reap the benefits of wars of aggressions and don't speak out against wars of aggression, what future generations think of it doesn't matter.

When you see a homeless person sleeping in the cold, and you put a warm blanket over them and they don't wake up and nobody sees it, was it a good deed? I would say yes. It will even remain a good deed if you yourself forget about it.

So why would that be different for bad deeds? It can only be bad for reasons that are present at the time. If someone is getting deceived it's hard to blame them. But if someone is ignorant because they made many little choices to remain ignorant, it's different. If someone couldn't have possibly known because of scientific discoveries made later, it'd be silly to "blame" them. But that's hardly relevant to the Holocaust.

And nobody "statistically" does x murders and y good deeds each year. We do nothing statistically, we just do what we ourselves actually do.

> Of course, the terrible things I heard from the Nuremberg Trials, about the six million Jews and the people from other races who were killed, were facts that shocked me deeply. But I wasn't able to see the connection with my own past. I was satisfied that I wasn't personally to blame and that I hadn't known about those things. I wasn't aware of the extent. But one day I went past the memorial plaque which had been put up for Sophie Scholl in Franz Josef Strasse, and I saw that she was born the same year as me, and she was executed the same year I started working for Hitler. And at that moment I actually sensed that it was no excuse to be young, and that it would have been possible to find things out.

-- Traudl Junge

While we might "pity" people in the past for not knowing many things, moral judgement has to do with the options someone has. Even if the majority is using their options badly, that doesn't mean those options didn't exist, just like there being less stars wouldn't make the rest of the night sky brighter.

> The sad truth is that most evil is done by people who never make up their minds to be good or evil.

-- Hannah Arendt

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by chillacy on Monday December 10, 2018 @05:32AM (#18646770)
It seems you're saying that moral good is doing what an individual thinks is good at that moment. So for example if I am a crusader and I think that killing non-believers is a supreme good, then I am moral. But if I think that killing is wrong no matter what and I still kill then I am immoral?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by Fnoord on Sunday December 09, 2018 @06:35AM (#18640395)
Godwin's law.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by erikpukinskis on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:55PM (#18636819)
It also casts religions with dietary restrictions in an interesting light.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by jlg23 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:30PM (#18637349)
Which major religion forbids yeast intake (and how would you guarantee that) and from which angle does one shine light on a people united in faith but with distinct local food (and yeast) sources to make it "interesting"?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by codeddesign on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:43PM (#18637407)
Look at the Seventh-day Adventist Church. Their belief isn’t necessarily yeast but dietary standards in general. Promotion of a vegetarian/vegan diet, and removal of alcohol, coffee, and sugar since the late 1800’s. As far as I know the dietary standards include the promotion of the effects of gut bateria, and the ill effects of eating things like warm bread but not necessarily removal of yeast.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by celticninja on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:05PM (#18637816)
I don't think that seventh day Adventist church is necessarily an example of being we'll adjusted
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by atomical on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:32PM (#18637929)
Just living the longest.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by atomical on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:33PM (#18637933)
You're really reaching here.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by justinator on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:04PM (#18637803)
The Catholic Church uses unleavened bread for the Host.

It's symbolic, but somewhat of an interest in this thread.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by Bayart on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:29PM (#18637917)
In that specific case it's related to Judean tradition. Jews also eat that sort of bread for Passover.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by CM30 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @08:17PM (#18638628)
> I am also intrigued about what this means for criminality and how the line between illness and evil is likely to shift given the role of microorganisms in behavioral dysfunction; and more broadly, we don't like to admit it, but it seems that completely amoral factors can be the cause of moral, amoral, or immoral behavior.

That line is already in trouble because of genetics research, psychology research, etc showing that people's actions are less based on deliberate choice than they'd like to believe.

Of course, this all causes issues for society since (for good or bad), a stable society kinda needs to at least pretend humanity have some general sense of free will otherwise a lot of things (like the aforementioned justice system) stop making sense.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by baddox on Sunday December 09, 2018 @12:13AM (#18639445)
Isn’t this only “trouble” if you think of legal penalties like imprisonment only as punishment for your choices? If you think about imprisonment differently, perhaps as a means to protect other people from future crimes, issues like gut biome and “free will” aren’t really relevant.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by jhayward on Sunday December 09, 2018 @02:03PM (#18642574)
> If you think about imprisonment differently, perhaps as a means to protect other people from future crimes, issues like gut biome and “free will” aren’t really relevant.

They are very relevant, because then the question becomes "how do we best protect everyone, including the offender". It's highly unlikely that imprisonment is an appropriate medical treatment or harm minimization procedure for a medical condition.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by impy on Saturday December 08, 2018 @08:51PM (#18638743)
> That line is already in trouble because of genetics research, psychology research, etc showing that people's actions are less based on deliberate choice than they'd like to believe.

I'd like to know more about this. Do you have sources for these?

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by brendanmc6 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @09:40PM (#18638919)
Sam Harris explores these topics in his book Free Will, I wasn't blown away by the read but would still recommended it if you already find yourself fascinated by the discussion.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by wufufufu on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:21PM (#18637607)
I don't see that species in the article. How did you learn about that tropical species of yeast, and how long have you been taking it? What was your digestion/appetite like with and without that supplement?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by kaitai on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:37PM (#18637945)
Not the parent poster, but I learned about S Boulardii from some German studies of probiotics. Boulardii at one point was one of the few that showed benefits in randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trials. That was a while ago so don't know what the state of the research is now.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by seren on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:36AM (#18640224)
On your second point, there is an article on The Atlantic, that is worth reading in my opinion : the Brain on Trial (2011) [0]

It explores some case of brain malfunction leading to various criminal cases and what it means for free will (or lack of). Really makes you wonder what freedom do we really have.

[0] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2011/07/the-bra...

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by harigov on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:34PM (#18637936)
Have you tried helminthic therapy by any chance? Also would you care to share your current treatment protocol? I am in a similar position with lots of dietary allergies and I am considering doing helminthic therapy because it seems to have a lot of success stories.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by redcalx on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:54PM (#18636813)
I am very interested in learning more. I will Google etc. of course, but if there are links, blog posts or bits of info you would be willing to share I would be most grateful. Thanks.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by amelius on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:23PM (#18636628)
How did you find out?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:34PM (#18636688)
I figured out that my problems were related to intestinal microflora because they became ten times worse after undergoing 3 courses of H. Pylori eradication therapy in the span of only a few months, and I never improved for years afterwards. That's the short version; in reality, I suffered for a decade and a half before I caught on that I could do something about it, and it took about 5 years after that to get any kind of positive result (which gave me the confidence to pursue it more seriously).

S. Boulardii is fairly widely known as having a pretty broad range of positive effects, so trying it out was a no-brainer. I have tried many, many things over the years and have improved greatly.

On a related note, it is common to assume that confirmation bias or the placebo effect would distort my judgment, but it turns out I am objective to a fault, as any objectively measurable intervention that I thought worked was later tested experimentally and confirmed my results.

There is actually nothing wrong with taking a guerrilla approach to health if doctors can't help you, as long as you don't fall for the "alternative for alternative's sake" fallacy, and are willing to bear the costs of iterating through the most promising interventions and not being disappointed when most of them fail.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by sametmax on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:55PM (#18636816)
I'm very interested in your experience.

Few questions:

- what positive effects did you get taking S. Boulardii ?

- did you try reuteri ? If no why ? If yes what happened ?

- what forms did you take the supplement in ? What form do you prefer and why ? Any brand recommanded or things to watch out ? Do you know natural reliable food sources ?

- can you tell me more about your 3 courses of H. Pylori eradictation ? Why ? How ? What are the results and costs ?

- did you notice what in your life may cause you to loose a proper gut content ?

And if you ever have the time, can you give a long explaination text about your overall experience ? That's the kind of information I'm mining hard for. I do understand it takes time and also that you are not a doctor and cannot be considered a representative sample. But it's very interesting and hard to find information.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:16PM (#18636945)
I didn't expect this level of attention at all. I hope it is appropriate for me to respond.

- what positive effects did you get taking S. Boulardii ?

Intestinal "well-being," feeling I can almost forget about my intestines, whereas normally my abdomen always hurts very badly, to the point my entire body is straining in reaction to it. This is only in combination with the other measures I took; S. Boulardii alone is insufficient.

Whenever my intestines felt fine, my head felt clear and my nose/sinuses would stop being congested; and vice versa. This phenomenon has been consistent throughout my illness and has led many a doctor to scratch his/her head and/or not take me seriously.

I tried doubling the dose after reading about that on the net (some people take 25m+ CFUs), but it gave me dryness/constipation and resulted in diverticulitis so I gave that up.

- did you try reuteri ? If no why ? If yes what happened ?

Only as part of larger probiotic formulations. I don't tolerate most and I'm not sure why. It may be that some strains produce histamines or include FOS (when I iterated through probiotic products, I was not aware of FOS - please see my other reply below where I discuss FOS). So I don't have any experience with it.

- what forms did you take the supplement in ? What form do you prefer and why ? Any brand recommanded or things to watch out ? Do you know natural reliable food sources ?

I take KAL S. Boulardii (ordered from iherb). I use veg. capsules because of a bias I have: I had bad side effects to a few liquid probiotic formulations I tried early on, so I ended up avoiding them as a general rule (which might be invalid but I have no further need to re-test it).

- can you tell me more about your 3 courses of H. Pylori eradictation ? Why ? How ? What are the results and costs ?

The reason I got the treatment in the first place was chronic inflammation in the stomach and intestines. I also had severe chronic sinus inflammation (enlarged turbinates specifically) that never abated, and a very bad response to histamines (redness, itching). I had asthma-like throat constriction; a doctor once told me "of course your heart rate's up, you're almost choking!" after I went in because I felt out of breath. I had a general drunken feeling, and would even get giddy at times. I have considered the possibility of auto-brewery syndrome, but there's no way to tell now. The doctor was a gastroenterologist so he focused on the digestive issues.

After the eradication therapy, that all got much worse and I developed noticeable food intolerances. I think I was already sensitive to those foods, but not enough that I'd notice at the time. I specifically could no longer tolerate dairy and sugar at all, and I had to greatly limit harsh foods (acidic stuff like vinegar, or very salty foods) or else I'd get gastritis extremely quickly (confirmed on endoscopy). My scalp started to itch and lots of hair fell out in my crown area. I am better with dairy nowadays but still can't have sugar, and vinegar just destroys me (I guess because it is corrosive AND high in histamines). I also can barely eat acidic foods and have to avoid most of them.

- did you notice what in your life may cause you to loose a proper gut content ?

I had always felt great until the age of 11, then it hit me and I started to have "attacks" which I didn't understand at the time, and doctors couldn't figure them out at all. I was given a bunch of things like nasal steroids for the sinus issues, and some symptomatic treatment for the stomach.

I felt so terrible though, literally like I was dying. I imagine waterboarding feels like that, because I just felt like I was unable to breathe adequately and even though it wasn't visible, I felt like I was making a contorted face all the time because of the feeling of straining. I kept asking for help but after doctors couldn't find anything, my parents began punishing me for what they thought was malingering (long story there - but they are forgiven and we are on good terms now).

I have some theories about what caused it but nothing concrete. I moved country (continent too, in fact) just 2 years prior and hygiene was far worse. I went through several bouts of gastroenteritis. I also got a salmonella immunization (capsule) and the doctor instructed my mom to open it up and release the powder in some milk, to make it easier for a child of my age to swallow it. I got extremely sick with some kind flu-like illness + gastroenteritis after that, even though my siblings who took the same immunization did not get sick.

Please see the reply I made below for some more details if you're interested

edit: I forgot to mention something relevant that would relate my experience with the article. A while back I read an article written by an autistic man, in which he mentioned "face tightness" being part of his being autistic (I only made the connection later so I don't know how to find it again). I truly think there is something to that. I felt strained and neurotic whenever my symptoms flared up, and I was quite antisocial in high school, yet mellow on the few days my symptoms cleared up.

edit: further details added. I typed this up a bit quickly (it's late here) so I had omitted some important things.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by elhudy on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:53PM (#18637748)
>I had to greatly limit harsh foods (acidic stuff like vinegar, or very salty foods) or else I'd get gastritis extremely quickly (confirmed on endoscopy). My scalp started to itch and lots of hair fell out in my crown area. I am better with dairy nowadays but still can't have sugar, and vinegar just destroys me (I guess because it is corrosive AND high in histamines). I also can barely eat acidic foods and have to avoid most of them.

This is interesting, considering that acidic and salty environments are the ones which naturally harbor beneficial bacteria and yeasts. Quite the paradox you have!

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:42PM (#18639346)
Indeed, but they are also very harsh and my digestive tract sensitive. Sometimes it's just that simple.

Also, vinegar is fermented and thus very high in histamines, on top of being corrosive.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by code_duck on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:49PM (#18637135)
A lot of your symptoms sound similar to some things that I have been through. I found out that I have celiac disease, after suffering through a lot of physical symptoms which were sometimes paired with mental symptoms such as confusion or mood swings, which are common with celiac. The exact cost seems to be a mixture of things… release of neurotransmitters and immune system chemicals, disrupted gut flora, chronic pain and discomfort, and malnutrition from poor absorption.

Like yours, it’s a long story.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:26PM (#18637322)
I don't have any statistics, but judging from the number of sites and blogs that have popped up that deal with similar conditions, this seems to be an increasingly common problem. It seems like you could now speak about brain fog and everyone would understand what you meant, and I don't think that was the case 15 years ago.

I've only ever made 2 top-level comments related to this issue on HN and they have surprised me with the amount of attention they generated.

A lot of people are going through desperate times because of conditions like this. It's hard to appreciate how bad it can be just by trying to imagine the symptoms for an instant. It's much harder to imagine what it feels like to experience that for months; years; decades.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by code_duck on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:16PM (#18637870)
I think the conversation about that came up with chronic fatigue. These days it’s used to describe mild hangover-like states, mostly. What people with celiac suffer is more like the confusion that comes with multiple sclerosis. As far as other people’s ‘brain fog’ I think they’re referring to a much more mild condition.

Self described sensitivity to gluten is on the rise. Possibly some gluten intolerance is on the rise, too. However, incidence of -actual- celiac disease as confirmed by biopsy has not changed, but screening and diagnosis have gotten a lot better.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by kaitai on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:49PM (#18637997)
There are actually some very interesting studies looking at blood samples from the 1950s, for instance, that indicate that celiac is much more common than it used to be. See for instance "Increased Prevalence and Mortality in Undiagnosed Celiac Disease" in the journal Gastroenterology, July 2009.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by code_duck on Sunday December 09, 2018 @06:15AM (#18640332)
Seems interesting. That was written by a doctor I saw this summer, too.

This is a bit more readable: https://www.the-scientist.com/features/the-celiac-surge-3143...

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by losteric on Sunday December 09, 2018 @08:10PM (#18644427)
I recently learned about epigenetics and it's mind blowing.

In a nutshell: the expression of a gene within an individual can change over their lives, and the changes can be inherited. There are multiple mechanisms of alteration and inheritance.

The field is still in very early stages of research, but here are some paraphrases from Wikipedia to hook you:

* Children born during the Dutch famine of 1944–45 were smaller than those born the year before the famine and the effects could last for two generations. They also were at increased risk of glucose intolerance in adulthood.

* Children of women who were abused during pregnancy were significantly more likely than others to have methylated glucocorticoid-receptor genes, which in turn change the response to stress, leading to a higher susceptibility to anxiety

* Male mice that participated in voluntary physical exercise resulted in offspring that had reduced fear memory and anxiety-like behavior in response to stress.

For further reading:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epigenetics

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_epigenetic_i...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epigenetics_of_anxiety_and_str...

--- Pure conjecture ---

As an engineer, this sounds like coarse short-term evolution; a dimmer switch for various genetic functions which can improve offspring fitness relative to a sudden environmental change, possibly with negative side effects, until the environment stabilizes or genetics can adapt with new functionality.

Only now, our population is mixing over broad geographic areas subject to an unprecedented acceleration of environmental changes, with often no prior genetic training, as cultures shift towards sedentary, inside, less-social lifestyles that have fewer children at greater ages.

An inter-generational epigenetic analysis of celiac, autoimmune, and other "new" diseases could be ground breaking. I'm wondering to what degree they are emergent symptoms of possibly conflicting epigenetic adaptations accumulated over multiple generations. The timing is just so suspicious.

The mouse study of stress tolerance also suggests follow-up studies that may have fascinating political ramifications.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by code_duck on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @02:05PM (#18657862)
Interesting. As far as heritability, my symptoms closely resemble my mother’s, who is also diagnosed with celiac.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by sametmax on Sunday December 09, 2018 @03:33AM (#18639966)
Thanks a lot. I know it takes time to write those long comments.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by starchild_3001 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:24PM (#18637890)
There's a whole group of people who're benefit from eliminating histamins, FODMAPs etc---and even any form of fiber, which probably you already know. Check out carnivores (again if you don't know yet): https://zerocarbzen.com/about-me/... there're facebook groups with many 10ks of members. Another is Dr Ray Peat adherents. They essentially cut out everything but orange juice and milk and meat... :) Curious sort of people. Might give you some ideas.

What works for my "aging" problems (age 40)? Carnivore diet helps to some degree (with weight, testosterone, energy etc). LLLT on the head works really well for me to boost mental acuity, or any form of stimulating light (10k lux lightlamp). It's has been life changing for the past 1.5 years (LLLT device costs $30). https://www.selfhacked.com/blog/my-review-of-lllt/

Best of luck!

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by gnoppa on Sunday December 09, 2018 @03:55AM (#18640015)
Yes, going carnivore led to a massive improvement of my health. I am curious about LLLT, sounds a bit like wishful thinking to me but I'd like to try it out. Where would I get a cheap device to play around with and do you use it like stated in the selfhacked article?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by starchild_3001 on Sunday December 16, 2018 @12:53AM (#18691938)
I could never stick to carnivore long term, but I like the short term effects. Here's the LLLT device that I use: 1) Aweek® 96 Leds IR Illuminators Light IR Infrared Light LED infrared light CCTV Camera Night-vision Fill Light for CCTV Security Camera, Standard 45°

2) CMVision UL Listed Regulated Power Adapter, 12VDC, 2Amp for Camera, LED Light, IR Illuminator

both from Amazon. 850nm, 96 LED, 2amp 12V adapter.

Don't forget to close the light sensor in the lower left corner when you apply I apply it for 60 sec on upper-front head area every other day. The effects are pretty noticeable for me.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by gnoppa on Monday December 17, 2018 @09:36AM (#18699152)
Thanks, will check it out.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by atomical on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:29PM (#18637918)
It's a great option for people obsessed with pseudoscience I suppose.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by Nomentatus on Saturday December 08, 2018 @07:49PM (#18638477)
low-FODMAPs are University (Monash) science, peer reviewed - if you know of contrary recent studies, please drop some URLs. Mere gainsaying and vituperation is never a contribution to a discussion.

One article that comes to hand: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/10/06/when-gluten-sensiti...

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by wolco on Sunday December 09, 2018 @01:48AM (#18639742)
For a number of people the earth being round was pseudoscience until it wasn't
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by whitepoplar on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:41PM (#18636724)
Did you adjust your diet, or are you taking supplements?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @01:52PM (#18636796)
Both.

Regarding diet, I started observing the effects of everything I ate and adjusting accordingly, somewhat like an elimination diet. I was actually really clueless at first and had numerous deficiencies as a tradeoff for some of the symptoms disappearing (which was great but not sustainable). Over the span of years, this has improved and today I have no deficiencies and only relatively mild symptoms remain.

The biggest breakthrough was limiting fermentation, by taking the FODMAP IBS diet to its natural conclusion, and eliminating everything that would ferment (and thus increase intestinal microorganisms, which for me were imbalanced). What prompted me to do this was trying 2 similar probiotic formulations, only one of which had FOS. The one with FOS caused a huge flare up. So I greatly reduced fermentable things ("resistant starches," "soluble fiber," "FOS," "FODMAPs", fructans, sugar alcohols...). Caprylic acid supplementation really reduced fermentation whenever I made a dietary mistake.

I googled that idea and found the blog of Dr. Norm Robillard which advocates for a similar low-fermentation diet. Interestingly, the people who commented on his site seemed to divide into 2 camps: low-fermentation people vs. those who did well on the opposite diet (high starch / fermented foods).

Adding S. Boulardii then reduced my symptoms further (brain fog, chronic intestinal inflammation) and I feel pretty decent now.

I cannot yet figure out how to make it so my intestinal microflora is balanced enough that eating fermented and/or fermentable foods wouldn't destroy me. I'm still working on that in my spare time.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by brm on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:30PM (#18637036)
Not sure which reply chain to jump into here, but during endoscopic evaluation have you ever had biopsies taken to check eosinophil counts in your stomach or esophageal tissue?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:42PM (#18637102)
I've had several gastroscopies and always had biopsies taken. Eosinophils were within the normal range, so whatever I have is not a true allergy.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by brm on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:54PM (#18637162)
More than an allergy I was curious about something to the effect of eosinophilic esophagitis or one of the other eosinophilic gastrointestinal disorders. I present with a similar timeline and symptoms to your description and was querying to see if that was a point of divergence.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by hugelgupf on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:20PM (#18636980)
Brain fog, intestinal inflammation. Sounds so very familiar.

Do you have research notes, on methodology and things tried? I'm now very curious for myself.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:44PM (#18637110)
I don't have notes per se, and I am afraid to say something that can be considered advice. I can answer any question you might have though (assuming it's appropriate for me to do so here, I hope I don't annoy HN users).
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by dageshi on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:27PM (#18637902)
I don't think anyone is going to find your comments in this thread annoying, quite the opposite.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by nyc111 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:30PM (#18637350)
@theprotocol With your permission, I hope, I copied your comments to my wiki http://www.zeynel.a2hosted.com/index.php?title=Digestive_Hea... I think it will be useful to others as well to read them as a whole. I'll update if there are new relevant comments. Thanks!
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:44PM (#18637412)
Sure, but please note that it is not to be construed as advice, merely an example of what might work for someone, and that everyone is different (for instance, one of my posts mentions that a subset of people do extremely well on a diet opposite mine - high starch).

edit:

I've also not written anything about methodology, so I hope my writings have not given the impression that one can play fast and loose with supplements. I actually follow a safety-first approach, and I do this only after a doctor reaches a dead-end.

General approach for evaluating supplements:

1- Find out about something that sounds promising, either by accident, or googling ideas and stumbling upon something that claims to improve your condition in some way.

2- Skim reputable sites (that cite research) listing the potential pros and cons of the supplement in question. Stop here if there is an unacceptable level of risk.

3- Skim any research about the supplement vs. your condition.

4- Read Amazon/iherb/other customer reviews for formulations of the supplement. Do not get excited. Most of these reviews are fake. What you are doing here is scoping out the ideal claimed outcome as a screening tool. If the ideal outcome is not worthwhile, stop here.

5- Dig into the research yourself. Confirm the level of risk. Check interactions. Determine whether there is a chance of the supplement working.

6- Purchase and test product. Remain objective. The baseline expectation is that nothing will work. Don't be emotional about that. I love having experience with products regardless of whether they work for me or not. I find it very interesting either way.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by nyc111 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @03:26AM (#18639942)
How do you react to grains, like rice or Quinoa? Are you in Twitter? How can we get in touch with you?
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:42AM (#18640236)
I can eat small amounts of wheat and any amount of rice without any symptoms. I haven't tried quinoa because I have sufficient grains in my diet now, and don't want to risk reacting to a new food.

Here's a temporary email address: [email protected]

Please email that address and I will give you my real email address there. This is to avoid publishing my email for perpetuity.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by nyc111 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @04:34PM (#18637664)
> everyone is different

Very true. I added your disclaimer.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by CuriousSkeptic on Sunday December 09, 2018 @05:46AM (#18640245)
Not only is people different but what might be helpful for some, in others might create chronic issues.

Killing of species of your gut microbiome (by eliminating foods) should probably not be somethig to take lightly.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by nyc111 on Sunday December 09, 2018 @10:50AM (#18641373)
True. But I eliminate foods out of necessity. Recently I stopped eating legumes as part of FODMAP diet and I see it makes a difference. I also suspect that we may be eating too much variety. I like for instance Fukuoka's approach to diet http://criticality.org/four-types-diet-masanobu-fukuoka/
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by yellowbuilding on Sunday December 09, 2018 @04:07AM (#18640030)
I am new to having these symptoms but this is very useful stuff!

I have been taking the peppermint oil tablets from helpforibs.com and they are good for temporary comfort here and there but my gastroenterologist has not recommended the things mentioned here. He has written off probiotics as useless and also downplays dietary adjustments for some reason. It’s really wild. I have found fiber and grains are great for me and eating rice every day is an enormous help.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by alan_wade on Sunday December 09, 2018 @04:10PM (#18643295)
Hi! Thank you so much for sharing!

I'm suffering from somehing similar. Did you look into Candida? A lot of the symptoms sound very similar. H. Pylori antibiotics could have killed off good intestinal flora, causing candida overgrowth.

Could you describe what other changes did you make, aside from adding S. Boulardii? Diet, supplements, medications? What helped you the most?

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Monday December 10, 2018 @03:47AM (#18646272)
Candida is what a lot of people assume it is, but there's really no way to know for certain what microorganism is imbalanced in your gut, so like many people I started off thinking it was Candida but then moved to more general approach as I learned more (and learned of many, many things other than Candida that could be the problem). It is ultimately very limiting to assume that it's Candida; you'll find most people who think their problem is Candida struggle a lot and the suggested protocols for treating it do not seem to work very well.

You are right to assume that the problem is fungal, since it started after antibiotic therapy, but I find that fermentation of any kind makes me sick - even supposedly anti-candida things made me worse if they were fermented (claimed to provide tons of antifungal probiotics). I have had much better results admitting that I do not know the actual imbalance, and thinking of this as a known unknown.

The supplements that helped me most were caprylic acid (for reducing gut dysbiosis) and S. Boulardii, even though you cannot take both at the same time (the former weakens the latter).

I also benefited greatly from taking nutritional supplements to top off any deficiencies of vitamins and minerals I might have had, but I do not take these things continuously, because supplements usually have specific forms of ingredients that may compete with others - for example, you'll often find Vitamin E as alpha-tocopherol, which is OK for topping off your levels but in the long run, it depletes other forms of Vitamin E such as tocotrienols and other tocopherols.

See my other comments for more details, I wrote quite a bit.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by acover on Saturday December 08, 2018 @05:11PM (#18637841)
Do you think a survey of people with similar problems would have helped narrow down effective treatments?

What about instead of sampling randomly selecting individuals to try a treatment?

I'm often overwhelmed by the amount of information about options out there.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by theprotocol on Saturday December 08, 2018 @11:59PM (#18639405)
I think you'd have to reduce the problem set/space for that to be effective (which is a very similar concept to reducing how you define your state space in AI, if you're familiar with that). If the problem set has too many variables, I think it becomes too challenging to analyze.

My approach is to rely very heavily on heuristics in order to screen potential treatments. I wrote some steps describing how to do that elsewhere in this thread.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by acover on Sunday December 09, 2018 @02:21AM (#18639808)
Yeah, I guess I really don't have a handle on the complexity.

Your heuristics seem useful. I've been just trying stuff for a month and seeing how they go. Trusting the professionals to guide me in semi-useful directions.

Thanks.

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by nyc111 on Saturday December 08, 2018 @02:43PM (#18637108)
@theprotocol thanks for this detailed explanation. Very helpful.
Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by dcx on Saturday December 08, 2018 @03:35PM (#18637373)
Adding my thanks to this. I have IBS and have done a ton of self-experimentation over the years to fix my symptoms (with reasonable success). I totally get what you mean about free will and being unable to think straight when your digestive system is not managed. This is an interesting pathway that I had not discovered yet; from my initial reading it looks like the mycobiome is somewhat at the cutting edge [1].

[1] https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2607/6/1/22/htm

Re:Gut bacteria may offer a treatment for autism by yellowbuilding on Sunday December 09, 2018 @02:57AM (#18639894)
Can you recommend a brand?