Brouwer's career suffered as a consequence of his disagreements with Hilbert.
EDIT (with links to the political aspect): Letters written more about the politics of publishing than the math itself are referenced in a book called "The War of the Frogs and the Mice" (PDF) http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.224... (see bottom of pg 9 as displayed for the letter Brouwer wrote to Hilbert's wife)
It doesn't read like the political fights were about math. Although Hilbert disagreed with Brouwer, it sounds like the falling out was precipitated by arguing over something subjective.
This could be just anchoring bias. But I think it's much more likely that people after Millikan did not want to look bad in front of their professional peers for fear of social and professional consequences. Which I think is something we can reasonably call political.
(The reason I know we can agree is that unfounded is not the same as false, it just means it's a non-statement.)
I suppose then one can conclude that scientists have behaved incorrectly since Aristotle's time.
> getting along with your peers is the most important thing
No it isn't, hence the yuk. Anyone who thinks getting along with your peers is more important than getting the science right, isn't someone I trust doing science. The most important thing is getting the science right, full stop, end of story.
If he'd needed access to impossibly expensive equipment available only in a few palaces around Europe, politics might have stopped him before he ever got started.
Science is about being right; not about getting along with your peers.
And then, there are the different sides of scientific discussion which produce the conclusions that the politicians warp and shriek about. Some of this is good science, and a rot of itis bad science. But whatever the politicians get to blather on about is what most people are aware of, regardless of whether it's good or bad.
And your comment points to part of the problem. It's science, so if we believe that we know everything, we're wrong. If we don't know everything, then that means we need to have the lattitude to argue about things. The argument is obviously not "is the earth warming?" but "how and why is the earth warming?". If your immediate response is "well, it's obviously humans producing CO2", then you have fallen into the trap that I'm trying to explain. Yes, humans produce CO2, and CO2 is a greenhouse gas. But the story is more complicated than that, and science needs room to wonder. The problem is the political shrieking dampens the curiosity and wonder that science is about.
In that case, it's pretty settled that there is a significant human impact on atmospheric CO2 levels; the space for room to wander are, say, the exact distribution of CO2 released. I mean, physicists don't wonder and revise basic kinematics since that science is pretty much settled that Newtonian kinematics are very good approximations of reality.
There are some facts that seem to give pause for thought though, like it apparently being much warmer than today in medieval times. This can be hard to see because temperature records don't go back that far, but we know that the Romans appeared to once grow wine near Scotland, something totally impossible today (in fact it only became possible to grow wine in the south of England very recently, a "new" thing blamed on global warming). It's unclear how the Romans could have done that unless grapes were very different or the weather was very different.
This argument is not quite up to snuff because, as it turns out, only a tiny fraction of the oil ever can be made to come out. The truth is that even after the wells have been abandoned most of the oil remains stuck in the rocks that it started in. I found this out while wondering whether or not it would be possible to burn all of the oxygen in the air (it's not, sadly ;) )
Also the oil reserves are not really running low, if they were that would be a lucky answer to carbon control.
So even if your story is true, those kids did exactly the right thing.
Regardless, the consensus that's bandied about comes from the IPC meta study of all published peer reviewed articles from climatologists; not from a few kids.
So it shouldn’t exactly surprise us that most of them agree.
> If you don't have a PhD in the field, you don't belong in the big discussions where consequences matter.
Why?
I think what we need is accountability - there should be serious negative consequences for being wrong proportional to how strongly you stand behind an idea.
Were all the climatologists who were confident we were facing global cooling driven from the industry? Stripped of their academic standing?
Then why would I trust the industry?
Counting climatologists is a bad idea because they shut critics and skeptics out of the field. We know that climate models are generally wrong. Trying saying that while having a career as a climatologist.
1. That study is 10 years old at this point. The evidence for climate change has become vastly more undeniable since then.
2. Majorities of scientists from all categories believed in climate change, even back then, according to this study.
Also, anybody who views climate prediction as intrinsically suspect pseudoscience isn’t going to want to enter the field either.
Appealing to the authority of climatologists is not going to convince anybody because everyone who thinks they are authoritative already agrees that global warming is caused by humans...
This as opposed to releasing research along the lines of 'cigarettes are fine for you! smoke more!'
Even then there are agency problems which mean that once a company gets over a certain size there is no natural alignment.
I know plenty of managers tweaking A/B tests until they get the results they want.
"in academia overfitting can get you a nature paper, in industry get you fired"
“A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.”
Or more succinctly, science advances one funeral at a time.
As a counterpoint, it seems that minsky and papert's work was partly driven from their desire to stop the funding of larger perceptrons , in which they did not believe. The winter that followed their work may or may not have delayed progress in AI by years or decades.
Sure, mistakes happen, my own PhD contained a major blunder (discovered several years after submission -- at least somebody read it ...), but I'm extremely open about it.
I think that the hard sciences aren't necessarily so dependent on papers derived from isolated results, or even replication of those results, because there is more of a "web" of knowledge. An idea is hopefully supported by an experiment, but possibly also by theory and multiple different kinds of experiments, sufficient to be usable by non-experts and laypeople. For instance the basic theory of electromagnetism is good enough for virtually any kind of engineering, and it would take some monumental discovery to prove it false, even if a portion of the supporting work fails upon replication.
Another thing is, perhaps because of the precision of physics, we get proven wrong every day, and it ceases to be an embarrassment. The road is littered with the wreckage of failed theories and experiments.
Or more succinctly: mathematics doesn't give us truths, it gives us consequences. The statement, "2 + 2 = 4" is not an empirical fact intrinsic to the universe. It's a consequence of our definition of natural numbers. It's considered a useful definition because (among other things) of its application as a foundation for engineering and the sciences. But many other useful areas of mathematics have essentially no basis in reality.
Then physics isn't a science either since only parts of the field fits this criteria. I think you will realize that the distinction between physics and math isn't as clear cut as you imagine, it is not uncommon for physicists to publish in math journals and vice versa.
Ultimately though, the math that is natural science is just called “physics”, right? ;) The reason math can’t be a hard science is because we can’t prove abstract math by physical experiment. That’s all “hard science” means - things you can show by physical experiment. We can prove math theorems by showing they’re consistent under all the other math theorems, but generally not by conducting physical tests.
I think turning math into a purely abstract game came later, and we owe our fun to the discipline's more humble origins.
There are of course other viewpoints that math has a Platonic metaphysical reality in and of itself, independent of the natural world.
So what was it?
what your wife is describing is what is commonly called "progress one death at a time"
"We have learned a lot from experience about how to handle some of the ways we fool ourselves. One example: Millikan measured the charge on an electron by an experiment with falling oil drops, and got an answer which we now know not to be quite right. It's a little bit off because he had the incorrect value for the viscosity of air. It's interesting to look at the history of measurements of the charge of an electron, after Millikan. If you plot them as a function of time, you find that one is a little bit bigger than Millikan's, and the next one's a little bit bigger than that, and the next one's a little bit bigger than that, until finally they settle down to a number which is higher.
Why didn't they discover the new number was higher right away? It's a thing that scientists are ashamed of—this history—because it's apparent that people did things like this: When they got a number that was too high above Millikan's, they thought something must be wrong—and they would look for and find a reason why something might be wrong. When they got a number close to Millikan's value they didn't look so hard. And so they eliminated the numbers that were too far off, and did other things like that."
Point being: Feynman’s ideas should have been judged on their merit, rather than Richard’s career. Same for the papers published by the institute mentioned above.
I adore Feynman's work, but he was human and had human failings, too.
the dead ringer for these groups is a PI who has a reputation for taking on extremely ambitious projects with all sorts of funding sources. typically, the PI is vindictive and controlling in my experience.
but yeah. you can see them from a mile away. they tend to run sweatshop-style labs where everyone is very hard pressed for results. so "results" are produced, whether or not they are real.
Here is the biggest funder of biomedical research in the world admitting that $27 billion out of $30 billion per year is wasted on unreproducible research: https://nihrecord.nih.gov/newsletters/2016/07_01_2016/story3...
And I would say that is optimistic because it does not consider misinterpreted results (interpreting your data correctly is even harder than figuring out how to perform and report reproducible experiments)...
I also wouldn't consider math a science since it doesn't require comparing your results to data.
It may very well be that you have your own peculiar definition of "hard science", or that you personally disagree that biology or biochemistry should be classified that way. That's fine, you're allowed to have your own opinions. But you having your own crackpot opinions doesn't make it fact in the real world.
These fields in particular are not even close to being hard, especially oncology which appears to (somehow) be even worse off than psychology.[1:3]
I bet less than 1% of people with masters or greater in a bio field have used calculus for anything in the last 5 years. While of course the definition of "hard science" is arbitrary, here are some decent overviews of the differences between physics and bio:
https://www.cell.com/cancer-cell/fulltext/S1535-6108(02)0013...
https://meehl.dl.umn.edu/sites/g/files/pua1696/f/074theoryte...
Refs:
[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/483531a
[2] https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/effort-to-reprodu...
[3]https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/01/rigorous-replication...
>"Precise definitions vary,[4] but features often cited as characteristic of hard science include producing testable predictions, performing controlled experiments, relying on quantifiable data and mathematical models, a high degree of accuracy and objectivity, higher levels of consensus, faster progression of the field, greater explanatory success, cumulativeness, replicability, and generally applying a purer form of the scientific method." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_and_soft_science
That same page does group biology in with physics and chemistry, but with no justification. From personal experience biology is much closer to a social science than it is to physics. I mean, most people who study biology-related stuff "hate math".
Hell, go back further: consider Mendel's discovery of the rules of genetic inheritance (and thus founding the field of genetics) by painstakingly planting, replanting, combing and recombining pea plants. It's hard to imagine a more pure and rigorous application of the scientific method, in any field.
I'm sorry, but your position is beyond absurd. Even the page you link disagrees with you. It sounds very much like you once met a biologist who said that they didn't very much like math, and since then you've carried a personal prejudice against biologists. You admit as much in your comment.
Ironically in the same vein as the OP article!
The sad part is it will never improve to become a "hard science" if people think it already is one. I mean really think about it. Biology is the study of how complex systems change over time, yet learning the primary tool we have to study/analyze change (calculus) is not a prerequisite. Doesn't that seem strange for a "hard science"?
That being said I get where the commenter is coming from. Much of biology is a qualitative science. Darwin's evolution was originally elucidated through descriptions not hard numbers and statistics. Taxonomy in zoology is also largely qualitative.
But, if a person does share that opinion, I can see how that person might be inclined to ignore tone, and focus on supporting that opinion.
You cannot call an idea itself insulting unless you yourself are a biased person. Ideas in itself are just statements with no malevolence intended. Only people can express malevolence.
I don't agree with him. But I see where he's coming from. A lot of biology is just observing behavior and documenting observations. It is very different from employing the scientific method in an experiment. It is also very different from trying to quantify everything. The line between hard and soft is blurry.
>"Precise definitions vary,[4] but features often cited as characteristic of hard science include producing testable predictions, performing controlled experiments, relying on quantifiable data and mathematical models, a high degree of accuracy and objectivity, higher levels of consensus, faster progression of the field, greater explanatory success, cumulativeness, replicability, and generally applying a purer form of the scientific method." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hard_and_soft_science
1) Producing testable predictions
--- The predictions are almost all vague, of the form "x will be correlated to some degree with y".
2) Performing controlled experiments
--- Maybe, but I very often see that proper blinding procedures were not used.
3) Relying on quantifiable data and mathematical models
--- Mathematical models are rarely used to make precise testable predictions.
--- There was some progress on this front from Armitage and Doll way back in 1954 but interest has largely fizzled out.
4) A high degree of accuracy and objectivity
--- As mentioned in #1 and #3, making a precise prediction at all is rare. Accuracy doesnt matter much if you predict vague stuff.
5) Higher levels of consensus
--- Not sure this should be here. "Hard" vs "soft" is a matter of the procedures used, not the results.
6) Faster progression of the field
--- Not sure this should be here. "Hard" vs "soft" is a matter of the procedures used, not the results.
7) Greater explanatory success
--- Not sure this should be here. "Hard" vs "soft" is a matter of the procedures used, not the results.
8) Cumulativeness
--- The more research that has been done on cancer the more complex things have gotten, to the point where now they say "cancer is many diseases". This is the opposite of what happens when you gain a cumulative understanding and figure out "natural laws" that make things easier to understand.
9) Replicability
--- Seems to be well less than 50% of studies can be repeated (see my links here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18578282)
This describes some of the mathematical economics I've read.
Spend time with condensed matter physicists. What you describe is not what they do. A lot of results are not reproducible.
If replication is the benchmark, almost no one does it (physicist or otherwise). In all my time in academia, I didn't find a single person attempting to replicate anything. You don't get funding, tenure or papers from it.
I was referring to everything else in your comment.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3246348/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/18234196
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2643041/
http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/21195070
But yes it is extremely rare. It is very frustrating because it is hard to come up with a precise model when you only half-trust the data to begin with, and when the replications are (rarely) run it appears that half-trusting the reported results is optimistic...
All my work got rejected (everything was being accepted before, and the rejected batch was a full level higher quality). So yes, it did set back my career for two and a half years if I have to approximate. I am probably never submitting to certain publications ever again to avoid having them as reviewers. I am gradually moving away from their field entirely. I was so short on publication then that I couldnt even move away to nearby fields, having accomplished vengeful rejections in my field. These days I wish I had done a second PhD in a different field, just to get away from them! I'd have had a much easier career path.
This is by no means an exaggeration, I am actually downplaying what happened.
My wife is a biochemist, and during her PhD they were working on an area of research with a handful of labs publishing about it. One lab in particular was known for a decent amount of questionable publications, but the PI was a big deal and no one would officially question anything. So they would whisper amongst each other and just ignore that paper (and all the additional papers built on top of it) because they all knew it was bullshit.