News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by zorga on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:11AM (#18577317)
Wow, that's a clear sign science has become too political. Proving other scientists wrong used to be how careers were made, not something to fear.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by bchjam on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:41AM (#18577479)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brouwer%E2%80%93Hilbert_contro...

Brouwer's career suffered as a consequence of his disagreements with Hilbert.

EDIT (with links to the political aspect): Letters written more about the politics of publishing than the math itself are referenced in a book called "The War of the Frogs and the Mice" (PDF) http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.224... (see bottom of pg 9 as displayed for the letter Brouwer wrote to Hilbert's wife)

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:45AM (#18577506)
>In the later 1920s, Brouwer became involved in a public and demeaning controversy with Hilbert over editorial policy at Mathematische Annalen,

It doesn't read like the political fights were about math. Although Hilbert disagreed with Brouwer, it sounds like the falling out was precipitated by arguing over something subjective.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by danharaj on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:18AM (#18577354)
Science has always been political, within itself and in relation to the rest of society.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_drop_experiment

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:40AM (#18577468)
Your link is not a story about politics, it's a story about psychological bias.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by wpietri on Saturday December 01, 2018 @02:01PM (#18578247)
Political has multiple meanings in English, and I think this use is legitimate.

This could be just anchoring bias. But I think it's much more likely that people after Millikan did not want to look bad in front of their professional peers for fear of social and professional consequences. Which I think is something we can reasonably call political.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:45PM (#18579159)
But I think it's more likely that the bias was internal, in which case it could not be reasonably called political. Without arguing further we can agree that the parent's claim was unfounded, because the linked article did not demonstrate that the motivation was social.

(The reason I know we can agree is that unfounded is not the same as false, it just means it's a non-statement.)

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by wpietri on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:32PM (#18580805)
We cannot agree on that. Feynman's talk is mainly about social phenomena, so it's entirely reasonable to assume that this anecdote is also meant to illustrate a social point: http://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by pessimizer on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:44PM (#18578146)
Just because Feynman diagnosed the gradual charge drift as internal pressure doesn't make it internal pressure. The effect would be the same between fearing one was wrong and fearing one would be condemned and punished as wrong - changing the data to be closer to the official line.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by danharaj on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:45PM (#18578158)
Authority is always political.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:48PM (#18578172)
It's not a story about authority, either, if by authority you mean something narrow enough to always be political.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by danharaj on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:24PM (#18579041)
If you don't think Millikan's authority as a scientist was not a factor then ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:42PM (#18579140)
That's a broad enough definition of authority that all authority no longer originates from politics. When scientists are behaving correctly authority is awarded on scientific merit irrespective of politics.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by danharaj on Saturday December 01, 2018 @09:48PM (#18580499)
> When scientists are behaving correctly authority is awarded on scientific merit irrespective of politics.

I suppose then one can conclude that scientists have behaved incorrectly since Aristotle's time.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by zorga on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:33AM (#18577441)
Obviously, hence the word "too".
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by seibelj on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:17AM (#18577350)
All the labs working on this spoke to each other, collaborated occasionally, and saw each other at conferences. So making a big stink about this wouldn’t have made life easier. Plus peer reviewers for submitted papers are “hidden” but because the field is so niche they are likely people you know, and they know who you are when you publish (reviews aren’t double-blind), so it could hurt your career if the PI became angry at you and started bad-mouthing you to to the other labs.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by zorga on Saturday December 01, 2018 @11:36AM (#18577452)
I understand, but science isn't supposed to make life easier, it's supposed to progress mankind's knowledge and that necessarily entails eliminating bad information from the body of knowledge. Avoiding challenging bad papers because someone you know wrote it and you're worried they might not like you for it; well, yuk.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by sverige on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:28PM (#18579060)
You've missed the point: getting along with your peers is the most important thing. What is truth?
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by zorga on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:54PM (#18579197)
No I haven't...

> getting along with your peers is the most important thing

No it isn't, hence the yuk. Anyone who thinks getting along with your peers is more important than getting the science right, isn't someone I trust doing science. The most important thing is getting the science right, full stop, end of story.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by projektir on Saturday December 01, 2018 @08:01PM (#18580096)
The problem appears to be is that anyone who can't "get along with their peers", or otherwise "social game", is not getting close enough to attempt to do any kind of science/serious project/study in the first place.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by landryraccoon on Saturday December 01, 2018 @09:43PM (#18580480)
So you would argue that Galileo Galilei was a bad scientist? He was imprisoned for disagreeing with the pope. I suppose you'd have to argue that a good scientist in the middle ages had to be in good standing with the church and monarchy?
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by leereeves on Sunday December 02, 2018 @07:59AM (#18582135)
Galileo only needed basic tools (like feathers, balls, an inclined plane, and a handheld telescope) to pursue science.

If he'd needed access to impossibly expensive equipment available only in a few palaces around Europe, politics might have stopped him before he ever got started.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by zorga on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @01:45PM (#18602368)
You can't predict what the next great discovery will be, or where it'll come from. Generally however, they're on the theoretical side, not the experimental side, so your point doesn't really stand. Those big machines rarely do little more than confirm exiting theories and those theories can very well come from one person who is anti-social.

Science is about being right; not about getting along with your peers.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by anoncake on Monday December 03, 2018 @04:55AM (#18587577)
What he actually did was closer to calling the pope a moron.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by gmueckl on Saturday December 01, 2018 @02:43PM (#18578505)
No, something like this can spiral: they can write bad reviews about your work, tanking your publication rate, which makes it harder to find funding etc...
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by scarcely on Saturday December 01, 2018 @12:47PM (#18577846)
Though worth pointing out "political" is ambiguous and that this a case of politics in the "office politics" sense not in the "use science to justify policy" sense
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by afterburner on Saturday December 01, 2018 @07:15PM (#18579919)
It turns out, people are always political, because they're people.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by anotherthrow456 on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:28PM (#18578052)
You want to know where this is the worst? Climate science. Everyone has an axe to grind on one side or the other and moderated opinions are flamed into oblivion. We can't even talk about the science because it becomes a discussion about destroying the planet.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by Sharlin on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:58PM (#18578232)
Isn’t the moderate position in climate science (regarding anthropogenic climate change) the mainstream consensus position? There are no two ”extreme views” with the truth somewhere in the middle. There’s the overwhelmingly supported by evidence scientific position and then there’s the pseudoscientific position.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by anotherthrow456 on Saturday December 01, 2018 @02:12PM (#18578318)
Yes, I suppose I've conflated two things. The first is the strident shrieking of politicians and those who echo what politicians say,for which I would argue there are two extreme sides. And neither of these sides actually has constructive discussionin my opinion.

And then, there are the different sides of scientific discussion which produce the conclusions that the politicians warp and shriek about. Some of this is good science, and a rot of itis bad science. But whatever the politicians get to blather on about is what most people are aware of, regardless of whether it's good or bad.

And your comment points to part of the problem. It's science, so if we believe that we know everything, we're wrong. If we don't know everything, then that means we need to have the lattitude to argue about things. The argument is obviously not "is the earth warming?" but "how and why is the earth warming?". If your immediate response is "well, it's obviously humans producing CO2", then you have fallen into the trap that I'm trying to explain. Yes, humans produce CO2, and CO2 is a greenhouse gas. But the story is more complicated than that, and science needs room to wonder. The problem is the political shrieking dampens the curiosity and wonder that science is about.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by jhanschoo on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:13PM (#18578657)
But if Earth in ancient prehistory was dominated by CO2 that was eventually sequestered by plants under the ground, and that today our oil reserves are running low, then wouldn't it make simple sense that human use of fossil fuels must have a significant impact on atmospheric CO2 levels?

In that case, it's pretty settled that there is a significant human impact on atmospheric CO2 levels; the space for room to wander are, say, the exact distribution of CO2 released. I mean, physicists don't wonder and revise basic kinematics since that science is pretty much settled that Newtonian kinematics are very good approximations of reality.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by repolfx on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:34PM (#18578764)
Well, it does make sense yes, which is why that view has become accepted.

There are some facts that seem to give pause for thought though, like it apparently being much warmer than today in medieval times. This can be hard to see because temperature records don't go back that far, but we know that the Romans appeared to once grow wine near Scotland, something totally impossible today (in fact it only became possible to grow wine in the south of England very recently, a "new" thing blamed on global warming). It's unclear how the Romans could have done that unless grapes were very different or the weather was very different.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:56PM (#18579835)
>today our oil reserves are running low

This argument is not quite up to snuff because, as it turns out, only a tiny fraction of the oil ever can be made to come out. The truth is that even after the wells have been abandoned most of the oil remains stuck in the rocks that it started in. I found this out while wondering whether or not it would be possible to burn all of the oxygen in the air (it's not, sadly ;) )

Also the oil reserves are not really running low, if they were that would be a lucky answer to carbon control.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by tomsmeding on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:37PM (#18578782)
Of course a fair point, but I think it's worth considering that basic physics was conceived quite a bit longer ago than the idea of CO2 as a greenhouse gas began to spread. So physics has had quite a bit more time to settle and for people to prove it incorrect (which they haven't), while the reasoning for cause(s) of planetary warming is really still in its infancy, however sure many people think they are.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by SamReidHughes on Saturday December 01, 2018 @02:38PM (#18578482)
Most of the impression of a mainstream consensus is formed when some kids polled a ton of scientists what they thought of global warming, but then restricted their published number to a small subset of those, climate scientists. Plenty of other scientists are like, hey, these guys are full of crap.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by zorga on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:51PM (#18579184)
Scientists who aren't climatologists have uninformed opinions about the climatology, aka the climate; they shouldn't be listened to just as you don't poll brain surgeons about the intricacies of heart surgery. Being a scientist doesn't make you qualified to speak on the climate, being a climatologist is what makes you qualified to speak on the climate. You don't ask climatologists about physics, and you don't ask physicists about the climate. If you don't have a PhD in the field, you don't belong in the big discussions where consequences matter.

So even if your story is true, those kids did exactly the right thing.

Regardless, the consensus that's bandied about comes from the IPC meta study of all published peer reviewed articles from climatologists; not from a few kids.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by nostromo on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:25PM (#18579672)
I believe the mainstream take on climate change - but it’s worth noting that you can’t even become a climatologist today if you disagree with the mainstream view of climate change.

So it shouldn’t exactly surprise us that most of them agree.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by sheepmullet on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:25PM (#18579668)
> being a climatologist is what makes you qualified to speak on the climate

> If you don't have a PhD in the field, you don't belong in the big discussions where consequences matter.

Why?

I think what we need is accountability - there should be serious negative consequences for being wrong proportional to how strongly you stand behind an idea.

Were all the climatologists who were confident we were facing global cooling driven from the industry? Stripped of their academic standing?

Then why would I trust the industry?

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by cultus on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:11PM (#18578645)
That's uhh, not true. At any rate, shouldn't we be listing to the climatologists on this matter, because their specialty is, you know, climate?
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by SamReidHughes on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:35PM (#18578772)
Yes it is true. The often cited statistic comes from https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1029/200...

Counting climatologists is a bad idea because they shut critics and skeptics out of the field. We know that climate models are generally wrong. Trying saying that while having a career as a climatologist.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by cultus on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:43PM (#18578822)
You're really veering off into conspiracy theory territory here. It's clear you haven't the faintest how climate models or any geophysics works. Don't mistake a facility for computers for expertise in all science. I actually have a PhD in a geophysics field, I know what I am talking about here.

1. That study is 10 years old at this point. The evidence for climate change has become vastly more undeniable since then.

2. Majorities of scientists from all categories believed in climate change, even back then, according to this study.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by SamReidHughes on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:18PM (#18578998)
I'm not disputing global warming. I am disputing the impression of a 97% consensus. And this is a great example of what I'm talking about, you're trying to call me a conspiracy theorist, and making up stuff about what you think I know.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by cultus on Saturday December 01, 2018 @04:24PM (#18579035)
No, you aren't just disputing the consensus. You are claiming that climatologists "shut critics and skeptics" out of the field, so we shouldn't listen to them. Yes, they do shut out pseudoscience, as do other legitimate sciences. That is different from disagreement on scientific facts. Climatologists disagree about very fundamental things all the time.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by SamReidHughes on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:25PM (#18579676)
There are people on the record saying certain kinds of results simply shouldn’t be published.

Also, anybody who views climate prediction as intrinsically suspect pseudoscience isn’t going to want to enter the field either.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by cultus on Saturday December 01, 2018 @08:09PM (#18580119)
So now you are saying that climatology is literally pseudoscience.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by viridian on Sunday December 02, 2018 @08:50AM (#18582289)
That isn't what was said though. This entire conversation chain is painful to read, I would encourage you to read up on the principle of charity. It's a dialectic tactic that seems to be fast fading in the world of click bait and outrage, and I think everyone is suffering for it.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by whatshisface on Saturday December 01, 2018 @07:03PM (#18579862)
Putting on my conspiracy helmet and tightening it all the way, how can you prove that that's not the same as polling the Department of Constructive Mathematics about the law of the excluded middle? Every field self-selects for people who believe that whatever the field studies is actually possible to figure out, all the way from physics to Paranormal Studies. Someone who didn't believe that climate models could predict anything wouldn't make any.

Appealing to the authority of climatologists is not going to convince anybody because everyone who thinks they are authoritative already agrees that global warming is caused by humans...

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by crimsonalucard on Saturday December 01, 2018 @03:38PM (#18578791)
There is a definitive difference. Global warming has been confirmed across multiple different experiments that have been repeated... this study covers obscure results that are unlikely to be repeated.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by RA_Fisher on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:04PM (#18577927)
I believe this applies mostly to public science. Private science is anchored by a market-based mechanism that naturally expunges fraud.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by r00fus on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:18PM (#18578001)
Is this a joke? Profit motive is far more likely to put the cart before the horse: pushing for evidence to support outcomes.
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by jessewmc on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:27PM (#18578043)
I think they were referring to internal research that says 'if we do X we can sell more' which has naturally aligned incentives.

This as opposed to releasing research along the lines of 'cigarettes are fine for you! smoke more!'

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by sheepmullet on Saturday December 01, 2018 @06:29PM (#18579699)
> if we do X we can sell more' which has naturally aligned incentives.

Even then there are agency problems which mean that once a company gets over a certain size there is no natural alignment.

I know plenty of managers tweaking A/B tests until they get the results they want.

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by RA_Fisher on Saturday December 15, 2018 @08:18AM (#18688279)
Easy fix: hire a statistician. :-)
Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by RA_Fisher on Tuesday December 04, 2018 @05:34AM (#18598156)
This is a quote from a preeminent scientist: https://twitter.com/bmbaczkowski/status/1069891514275385344?...

"in academia overfitting can get you a nature paper, in industry get you fired"

Re:Psychology’s Replication Crisis Is Real by lostlogin on Saturday December 01, 2018 @01:19PM (#18578010)
Not so much. When you pay someone to get a result, that’s what they do.