>And why do we assume that their actions are in the national interest when it is not defined beyond platitudes about freedom.
Are you saying supporting SA is in our national interest? I don’t need the CIA to release info about SA for me not to support them. I’m not going to change my stance because of some possible CIA motive.
Officially supporting Saudi Arabia has been the US position since Nixon was president for the purposes of lowering oil prices and assisting Israel. Supporting Saudi Arabia is undeniably in the national interest if you ask the people in this country who have been amassing power since that time. National interest and human rights are separate priorities.
Change would be nice but don't hold your breath.
It may be the case that national interest sometimes requires making humanitarian trade-offs, and there is nothing wrong with using the consent mechanisms of democracy to find a path for US policy amid those trade offs.
But I am certain that creating a pretense that US actions are driven only by humanitarian concerns and framing the larger policy issues to the public as over-simplified good vs evil is extremely dishonest, and should not be funded by taxpayer dollars.
It seems that much as the tooth fairy is practice for religion, religion is practice for politics.
Not at all. But rather than focusing on something concrete (and falsifiable) like national interest, our leaders and officials moralize and stoke righteous indignation.
This is "if you're not with us, you're against us". It was a bad argument then and it's a bad argument now. Can we try to keep such short sighted reasoning off of HN?
What we need is for the American public to rein in their military-industrial-pharmaceutical masters. But, they can't really do that, for as long as regimes such as Saudi Arabia have bought their country out from under them.
I’m not who you’re replying to, but yes it absolutely is. We don’t support SA because we secretly like mean people. We have a vested interest in keeping oil flowing.
Was interfering in the most recent political turmoils in Egypt in our national interest? When you look at how much oil moves through the Suez Canal, absolutely.
Stabilizing access to oil is in our own selfish national interest (we need oil) and in our global interest of stabilizing the world. When countries don’t have access to the natural resources they need, they tend to invade other countries to get them. We want to avoid that.
Considering the above, I really wish politicians in the US would frame clean energy as a national security issue. We are far less likely to be bumbling around in the Middle East if we don’t need their natural resources. Would we still sell hundreds of billions of dollars in arms to theocratic authoritarian nut jobs? Maybe. At the very least we should chip away at the reasons we have for doing so.
Yet everything the US does must be framed as some kind of sacrifice for some group’s freedoms, its women, children, etc.
I don’t know what would constitute a morally defensible national interest. That is not an easy question. But at least it is an honest question.
Honesty is not the goal however when there is a need to gain consent of the masses to do violence against the innocent whose lives are deemed worthless by our national interest.
there's a difference between healthy skepticism of intelligence agencies and a grasping at straws to cast doubt on anything they do.
So those who claim MBS was responsible may be right or wrong. Without a clear definition of how his potential responsibility relates to US national interest, the matter isn’t even necessarily something the CIA should worry about at all.
By skipping that step and jumping right to PR to help fuel moral indignation in Americans, the CIA is way way way out of bounds.
The agency is not supposed to be a bunch of wise elders providing moral guidance, it’s supposed to protect national security.
Quite likely most senior CIA officials have far more blood on their hands than MBS.
No, also his prosecution of the war in Yemen.
> By skipping that step and jumping right to PR to help fuel moral indignation in Americans, the CIA is way way way out of bounds.
The US at its best stands up for a free press, and against, for example, authoritarian states being free to murder their critics worldwide.
> Quite likely most senior CIA officials have far more blood on their hands than MBS.
In the light of Saudi Arabia's actions in Yemen, this statement is clearly false.
First, the CIA actions in Iraq make this almost certainly true. Yemen is a minor conflict in comparison. Even still, Saudi actions could not happen without the US. The blockade could not take place without US assistance, the bombs being dropped are from US manufacturing, and the raids dropping the bombs could not happen without US intelligence and air support.
Everyone who gets a chance? (-a few European countries who stopped recently.)
It doesn't excuse the fact that SA and MBS are also horrible.
On balance the US causes substantially more human suffering in the world than all other terror groups and despots combined.
It’s strange that character attacks on MBS work so well to make Americans assume that the US must be the good guy.
In the US there is a tremendous appeal to the narrative that the US is the (relative) good guy. American exceptionalism is a religion and it easily leverages the widespread white suoremecist views of Americans who already mistrust the brown folks.
So beware of reinforcing the American exceptionalism dogma when you cite “whataboutism”. It is often budled into that critique.
The US murders journalists.
The free press is one of the cornerstones of US national interest; allowing our journalists to be murdered because they said something about a foreign power is a threat to that.
"A propaganda system will consistently portray people abused in enemy states as worthy victims, whereas those treated with equal or greater severity by its own government or clients will be unworthy"
The free press isn't a cornerstone of national interest - it is a sometimes useful, but often inconvenient tool.
This has nothing to do with press freedom whatsoever.
What if CIA was told to do so? Apparently the SA has not paid /signed by it's deadline for a major weapons purchase. 15B I think... and oil is lower now. So CIA is to serve our interests and has the prince by the b*lls. CIA might even get their entire budget paid by this episode. Oil is under $50 a barrel now or $30+ lower
I am pretty sure Erdogan would not that outraged if the Saudis cut him a deal too.
Huh? If anything the Snowden revelations showed that they'd been hoovering up even more than previously understood. Those revelations make it more credible that they were intercepting communications of ostensible US allies like the Saudis.
Weren't Snowden's releases about the NSA, not the CIA?
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/us-id...
[[[ To any NSA and FBI agents reading my email: please consider ]]]
[[[ whether defending the US Constitution against all enemies, ]]]
[[[ foreign or domestic, requires you to follow Snowden's example. ]]]Of course in this case, there would be no charges, or trials or anything of that nature, but I'd think the same principle is at work. It puts pressure on certain people when they let everyone know that they know. (Along with the not so subtle subtext reminding everyone that their information gathering reach is long, and their memory longer.)
Nor does it answer the question of why the agency chose to selectively promote the claim, which is the main issue.
We know from many other examples that hard data is used to sell and add credibility to analytical opinions that are at best informed hunches. Yet we are led to believe that the data speaks for itself.
It should be known that Khashoggi's uncle made billions as a weapons broker and helped the CIA funnel guns to Osama Bin Laden when he was fighting for the CIA as the Mujahdeen.
My inner conspiracy theorist says that the CIA is pissed that Trump shut down their gun running operation in Syria and they want to keep the middle east in chaos forever because it's good for their budget
The fact this story has been covered so much by the media because of "freedom of the press" while they completely ignore China routinely disappearing journalists tells me there's an agenda being pushed. Nothing about this story seems organic
Were the Chinese journalists you mention also employed by a prominent American newspaper and residents of Virginia with influential friends? If not it seems very easy to see why this case has gotten more publicity.
The WSJ actually cares about this issue, and they want to stay on their good side as they're a huge help in their PR campaigns. Nothing they are releasing is really new, this release was already claimed by a Saudi aide, and their releases have happened at times where they'll easily be missed.
After doing this, they disposed of his body (which they still have not returned) and promptly lied dozens of times in a row about the circumstances of his disappearance and death. They originally pitched he had wandered out of the embassy. Then that he had disappeared unrelatedly. Then that he had died, but no one knows how. Then that it was after a fight in the embassy. Then eventually admitting that it was a targeted murder, but by rogue agents. At each step, they lied until their lies were publicly and definitively exposed, largely by the Turkish government who are understandably mad that a foreign government exploited the diplomatic easement given to embassies to murder someone on their soil.
In conversations following up on this affair, the position of the Saudi government has been simultaneously that Khashoggi was a dangerous anti-government subversive who no one should mourn because he deserved to be killed, that KSA should face no consequences and be the ones to determine what justice means, and that no one not being charged by the KSA could possibly be involved in the decision to do this.
We have two possibilities from this stage: Case 1: This was ordered by either the Crown Prince or someone near him; or Case 2: This was a wonderful act of serendipity that the Crown Prince thinks was a very good outcome, but which was independently pursued by Very Bad Men Who Will Be Executed, and surely they were acting alone.
How would we be able to tell between cases 1 and 2 (besides the fact that case 2 is completely implausible and is "Kid with Crumbs Around Mouth Claims Dog Broke In To Cookie Jar" nonsense)? Well, we'd know for sure that case 1 was true if for example we had access to the Crown Prince's private correspondence and it demonstrated that he was involved. It would be difficult to discern between the two without this. Okay, so we all agree that the next step in this investigation is someone who intercepted the Crown Prince's correspondence to confirm what it says.
Note that at this stage in my post, the United States and its intelligence community has not been mentioned and nothing said so far relies on its credibility. So, given this, would you care to make a case for Case 2? Would you care to hypothesize which institutions, globally, we might rely on to make Case 1?
The CIA and FBI suck and have agendas. Turkey sucks and has an agenda. KSA sucks and has an agenda. And yet we can do better than nihilism when it comes to adjudicating this situation.
I think it addresses only the evidence, not the motive for the campaign to spread the news about the intercepted data.
Personally I have no means to determine veracity and don't have a reason to believe anyone who says anything at this juncture. Here's what I do know: there is a lot of money and power at stake and a number of interested parties who would like to sway public opinion, in the US, KSA and internationally.
I believe Trump has had some run ins with the CIA, and them giving him a black eye politically could be a motive. Trump probably has to play nice with KSA, there isn't a practical economic way around that at the moment. MBS also has made a lot of enemies in KSA, many of whom no doubt have incredible means and connections. But really no way to tell what the truth might be. Not sure it matters for me personally other than a disgusted headshake at all involved parties.
The intelligence agencies have a lot of credibility to earn back after the Snowden revelations. No claims should be trusted without conclusive source material.
The question is, why is the CIA trying to sway public opinion about this? Why do we tolerate the CIA or FBI being PR agencies for selectively leaked information? And why do we assume that their actions are in the national interest when it is not defined beyond platitudes about freedom.