I’ve read that the economics may already be close to favoring multi-junction cells for this reason, and they’re nowhere near 90% efficient, nor are they cheap.
What struck me is that nobody, not even Solar City and others, looked at the logistics side of things. It seemed to me that eveeybody came up with elaborate and capoztal intensive ways to sell to the people with the smallest customer Life-Time value in the whole value chain. Putting sophisticated logistics in place to cut costs (my assumption was that by doing that the solar panel cost could be reduced by around 15-20%) and selling to installers would have been the better way to go.
So I second you and the OP, it is no ponger about physics (with the exception of large power plants) and more about people and how you get solar on said people's roofs.
Which is an argument for trying to make cells more efficient like the ones in the article apparently looking at 43-90% as against something like 18% for typical cell. If most of your costs are installing etc then those can remain the same while you get twice the output.
An even cheesier TED talk clincher would be:
> the next big solution isn't always about electrons, sometimes it's about elections.
Here in California, PG&E offers the "solar choice" program where I pay extra to have 100% of my electricity generated from solar. This cost $6.50 of my $82 electric bill last month. (Yes I know electricity is fungible.)
Distributed production offers some huge advantages, but in the nrel study above you'll find that utility scale is strictly more efficient.
I think Hawaii is a good case study. Customers are generally frustrated with the power company's poor reliability and high rates. Rooftop solar offers a substitute for what has traditionally been a protected monopoly, and there's abundant sun, so solar adoption there is crazy strong. HECO has generally fought to slow it down.
If utilities realize this threat, they'll become competitive on price and customer service. Reliability in some places.
If they do not understand this threat, then they will just try to lobby for more and more extensive penalties for those with rooftop solar who are still connecting to the grid. Like cable companies raising rates in response to the rise of Netflix.
The most extreme version of that would be the emergence of microgrids - cord cutting from utilities by entire subdivisions.
Microgrids are potentially really cool technology, but would require some pretty intense dysfunction to take off.
So while I hope utilities figure this out, regions will vary, and rooftops put a new sort of check on how bad utilities can get, even if they don't become ubiquitous. Rooftops will inevitably be the answer in some places, not all.
Oh and if you look country by country, to places where it has been harder to get a well financed responsible utility... Parts of Latin America or Africa could really be jump-started economically by rooftop solar.
Nobody is going to try steal the hot copper wires connecting my house to the grid.
But where there's a substantial PV array on display, there's batteries and an expensive inverter nearby, and not much to prevent taking them.
The battery bank and inverter however, which are easily put invisibly to use by anyone even your neighbor, are quite the prize.
I'm not sure it's all that unusual a case. Solar is especially relevant to remote off-grid homes. Unfortunately, these are also prime targets for theft as they're often left unattended for long periods with distant neighbors.
Denser populations have a grid, and can just have a large solar installation powering that grid on a large scale.
It's a problem. Solar puts expensive infrastructure on-site, it's a mini power station.
> Solar is especially relevant to remote off-grid homes. Unfortunately, these are also prime targets for theft as they're often left unattended for long periods with distant neighbors.
Remote off grid homes are a very unusual case. Not saying there is no demand from that segment, but even there is a higher rate of demand from it, it's a small segment of the market vs urban/suburban rooftop solar, and I wouldn't expect major manufacturers and installers to optimize for it.
> Denser populations have a grid, and can just have a large solar installation powering that grid on a large scale.
That's already happening today. However people choose to have rooftop domestic solar for many reasons ... to fix the long term cost of their electricity consumption, to offset peak power rates, etc.
> It's a problem. Solar puts expensive infrastructure on-site, it's a mini power station.
In situations where site security is a problem, presumably custom solutions can be put in place by installers to ensure security of the inverters and batteries. It may cost more, but that's sort of the price paid for owning property in a sparse, remote location.
Especially considering the wires connecting your house to the grid are actually aluminum.
Is PV theft really a problem though? I mean they could sell them on ebay but AFAIK most thieves aren't just fencing everything on ebay. I can't imagine a pawn shop would give them much for it considering how hard it would be for the pawn shop to resell them. With copper and aluminum theft the thieves can just go down to the nearest scrapyard and get paid by the pound.
I don't doubt the theft risk exists. I'm asking if you are catastrophising to "..so we shouldn't do it" or just observing a downside risk component.
It just makes more sense in a lot of cases to let the utility provider convert to solar than turn your house into a power station you then have to secure accordingly and maintain.
I'm not interested in having to surround my property with barbed wire topped chain link fences, which is what you'll see around power stations for good reasons.
Maybe you live in a much higher crime risk area. I know (for instance) honey hives in NZ are being predated by gangs so I can believe there are portable high theft risk things in rural settings. But I'm really unsure a Tesla battery rig is one.
I've had plants stolen. I still maintain my garden..
What a world it would be if independent solar power were the cost of a garden!
Having said which, close friends ran bespoke gardening for richer garden aesthetes.
Back to the lead topic. PV is worth doing but assess your theft and vandalism exposure in risk/cost benefit.
Electrical is arguably the most regulated, standards based and straight forward aspect of construction and even that varies a great deal based on the electrician and equipment.
A rigorous standards based construction industry would be amazing. We could design electrical systems that could be installed by a novice with almost no risk of danger or failure. Homeowners could change luminares just plugging them in and attaching them to an electric box toolesly. We could have plug and play water appliances.
Damn it would be magical but again I'm fairly certain that's just not going to happen.
Edit: Above I indicated that the construction industry doesn't operate on "rigorous standards". That's not really true. There are actually very good science based standards for most construction tasks. It's more of a problem that the industry doesn't really focus on making future work on a structure low cost. And it makes very little effort to increase accessibility by creating more consumer facing equipment and tools.
I think you also conflate the way which something is built with the specification it is built against - like interfaces vs implementation details. If you tell companies to build a certain kind of roof, with ports and wiring, then they will not receive any money if they don’t meet your spec. They are free to use the kind of wood, nails, wires (as long as thick enough) that they like, and this is where they can compete against each other.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002OU6ZSA/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_tbA-...
Now that I think about it though I believe you are correct about the diameter of the port being consistent. It is indoor plumbing valves that I've run into a variety of sizes of. 1/2" vs 3/8 compression.
There are other types, no EU involvement here ( yet ).
Also, if you stick a power port on your roof and you live in an area with lots of lightning, I'll stay away from your house.
Regarding lightning, IDK how the Tesla roof solved this, but they obviously did.
That's because higher-energy-per-unit-area panels increases the efficiency of land use, which drives all the other costs you list: land acquisition, taxes, customer acquisition, etc.
You’re a good thinker and writer. I’m definitely ready for your TED talk!
And some making sure the roof/attic floor doesn't collapse, which usually is not a problem.
This can be _build_from_scratch_ in a couple of weekends with a best friend.
But for the construction codes. And unions.
It's so low-tech, so I wonder why I haven't heard of 19th century installations. Me, I actuially built two in places where construction codes are not an issue. And have seen functioning installs dating from 1950s.
I don't think it even makes any sense to mass-produce heat boxes the way the solar-electric panels have to be. It all can be either made on site or included into the house design from start.
That's maybe why you can't buy solar heating off the shelf.
You usually want a water tank to buffer the thing, so you can get hot water at night. Temperature will be all over the place without that. Giant hot water tanks in attics need extra structural support, which was a problem in Florida at one time.
There are some fancier setups that will work in cold weather. Some systems use antifreeze in the panels, and a heat exchanger.
[1] http://www.alternative-energy-tutorials.com/solar-hot-water/...
Not any more. We've got 50-state legal solar stuff where you just lay the panels out in the yard, literally plug them into your wall outlet, and every outlet on that circuit is energized. You can even leave it hooked to your power at night time, as the junction boxes have barrier rectifier diodes that prevent the panels from consuming power at night.
Install costs are becoming almost negligible due to advancing technology.
Cell efficiency is up there. Typical monocrystalline panels run 20+% now days (and look utterly gorgeous - https://imgur.com/a/sZGtYmB - picture from my job.)
Opportunity costs? Each cell runs on average $1.00 for most manufacturers, so you just need to shop around. A typical 60-cell panel at 300W runs about $150-200.
Most of your concerns have not been concerns for about 5 years.
Other soft costs, like land acquisition and taxes, still play dominant roles in many projects.[1]
The naive assumption is that solar succeeds when there's lots of sun and it's all just physics.
But these other factors, like, say opportunity costs (the cost of available substitutes), are why you're often better off installing solar in Alaska than Florida.[2]
Theoretical physics are great, but at this point I'd be far more excited about big ideas to deal with the messy economics side of solar generation. An announcement that some sort of "solar council" was going to pursue a national marketing campaign to drive solar adoption would be huge news. Or Elon deciding that strip malls were his new target, to drive installation of solar on every commercially leased roof, which would reap huge efficiencies of scale in local installation costs over residential.
Or, the cheesy TED talk clincher would be: the next big solution isn't always about electrons, sometimes it's about people.
[0] https://www.solarreviews.com/solar-leads/customer-acquisitio...
[1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68925.pdf
[2] https://solarpowerrocks.com/solar-basics/how-much-electricit...