News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by jartelt on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:41PM (#18517831)
Just want to post a reminder that solar cells are already efficient enough and cheap enough to be cost effective for power generation in many regions of the world. I am all for continued research to improve efficiency or decrease cost, but sometimes articles like this one lead people to believe that solar cells are not yet cost effective. They already are!
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by brownbat on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:08PM (#18517984)
Just to footstomp this, there are other costs that are already beginning to dominate the analysis for solar, like customer acquisition costs. Convincing someone to attach something to their house has significant costs. Like, "over $2000 per install" significant.[0]

Other soft costs, like land acquisition and taxes, still play dominant roles in many projects.[1]

The naive assumption is that solar succeeds when there's lots of sun and it's all just physics.

But these other factors, like, say opportunity costs (the cost of available substitutes), are why you're often better off installing solar in Alaska than Florida.[2]

Theoretical physics are great, but at this point I'd be far more excited about big ideas to deal with the messy economics side of solar generation. An announcement that some sort of "solar council" was going to pursue a national marketing campaign to drive solar adoption would be huge news. Or Elon deciding that strip malls were his new target, to drive installation of solar on every commercially leased roof, which would reap huge efficiencies of scale in local installation costs over residential.

Or, the cheesy TED talk clincher would be: the next big solution isn't always about electrons, sometimes it's about people.

[0] https://www.solarreviews.com/solar-leads/customer-acquisitio...

[1] https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy17osti/68925.pdf

[2] https://solarpowerrocks.com/solar-basics/how-much-electricit...

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by amluto on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:58PM (#18518244)
Sort of true. It is indeed the case that, at least in the US, the cost of the cells is a minor part of the cost of a rooftop solar array. You’re missing one detail, though: a lot of the costs you’re describing scale with the area of the array — the costs of mounting, wiring, sealing roof penetrations, shipping, physically hauling the panels to the roof, etc. are all related to the number and size of the panels. If you can shrink the array by a factor of 3, it makes a big difference.

I’ve read that the economics may already be close to favoring multi-junction cells for this reason, and they’re nowhere near 90% efficient, nor are they cheap.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by hef19898 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:01AM (#18520871)
I did an analysis of coats for residential roof top installations in Europe for my Master Thesis. Overe here around 30 to 35% of costs are the panels. Still the most expensive part but nowhere near the 60 to 70% it used to be. Panels really turned into a commodity.

What struck me is that nobody, not even Solar City and others, looked at the logistics side of things. It seemed to me that eveeybody came up with elaborate and capoztal intensive ways to sell to the people with the smallest customer Life-Time value in the whole value chain. Putting sophisticated logistics in place to cut costs (my assumption was that by doing that the solar panel cost could be reduced by around 15-20%) and selling to installers would have been the better way to go.

So I second you and the OP, it is no ponger about physics (with the exception of large power plants) and more about people and how you get solar on said people's roofs.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by danieltillett on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:02AM (#18521174)
Is your thesis in English and avalaible online?
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by hef19898 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:57AM (#18521309)
German, unfortunately I couldn't convince my Prof to accept it in English. In case you're interested and not under time pressure I can translate it or part of it. Always happy to share stuff like that. Just shoot me a mail. hef19898 (at) gmail.com
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by danieltillett on Sunday December 02, 2018 @06:01AM (#18581831)
Sorry for the long delay, but would encourage you to at least translate the key parts into English.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by hef19898 on Wednesday December 05, 2018 @03:17PM (#18612073)
Started already and managed to get to page 12 of 78 when the people realized at work that Christmas is, surprise, again on Dec. 24th. I totally forget that I wrote that many words... ;-)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by grizzles on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:39PM (#18519044)
Plug and Play Solar is one way to dramatically lower soft costs of residential pv installs. Fraunhofer is working on this [1] and there are already other 3rd party products on the market.

[1] https://www.cse.fraunhofer.org/pnp

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by tim333 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @08:07AM (#18521835)
>other costs that are already beginning to dominate

Which is an argument for trying to make cells more efficient like the ones in the article apparently looking at 43-90% as against something like 18% for typical cell. If most of your costs are installing etc then those can remain the same while you get twice the output.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by therein on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:10PM (#18518935)
> Or, the cheesy TED talk clincher would be: the next big solution isn't always about electrons, sometimes it's about people.

An even cheesier TED talk clincher would be:

> the next big solution isn't always about electrons, sometimes it's about elections.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by millstone on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:51AM (#18520683)
Honest question: do you think residential / small scale commercial solar is the future? As an outsider it seems like utility companies are best placed to deploy solar at large scale in the right locations, bypassing customer acquisition costs.

Here in California, PG&E offers the "solar choice" program where I pay extra to have 100% of my electricity generated from solar. This cost $6.50 of my $82 electric bill last month. (Yes I know electricity is fungible.)

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by brownbat on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:22PM (#18522955)
That's a tough question.

Distributed production offers some huge advantages, but in the nrel study above you'll find that utility scale is strictly more efficient.

I think Hawaii is a good case study. Customers are generally frustrated with the power company's poor reliability and high rates. Rooftop solar offers a substitute for what has traditionally been a protected monopoly, and there's abundant sun, so solar adoption there is crazy strong. HECO has generally fought to slow it down.

If utilities realize this threat, they'll become competitive on price and customer service. Reliability in some places.

If they do not understand this threat, then they will just try to lobby for more and more extensive penalties for those with rooftop solar who are still connecting to the grid. Like cable companies raising rates in response to the rise of Netflix.

The most extreme version of that would be the emergence of microgrids - cord cutting from utilities by entire subdivisions.

Microgrids are potentially really cool technology, but would require some pretty intense dysfunction to take off.

So while I hope utilities figure this out, regions will vary, and rooftops put a new sort of check on how bad utilities can get, even if they don't become ubiquitous. Rooftops will inevitably be the answer in some places, not all.

Oh and if you look country by country, to places where it has been harder to get a well financed responsible utility... Parts of Latin America or Africa could really be jump-started economically by rooftop solar.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by newnewpdro on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:42PM (#18518477)
Another issue is theft. I own a remote desert property in many ways ideal for solar, but the utility electric bill averages < $20/mo.

Nobody is going to try steal the hot copper wires connecting my house to the grid.

But where there's a substantial PV array on display, there's batteries and an expensive inverter nearby, and not much to prevent taking them.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by danans on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:50PM (#18518525)
Yours is a very unusual case. Most domestic solar installations are on roofs, so not likely to be stolen, and most homes' electricity bill is much higher than $20/mo.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by newnewpdro on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:13PM (#18519201)
I don't expect the panels to be the first things taken.

The battery bank and inverter however, which are easily put invisibly to use by anyone even your neighbor, are quite the prize.

I'm not sure it's all that unusual a case. Solar is especially relevant to remote off-grid homes. Unfortunately, these are also prime targets for theft as they're often left unattended for long periods with distant neighbors.

Denser populations have a grid, and can just have a large solar installation powering that grid on a large scale.

It's a problem. Solar puts expensive infrastructure on-site, it's a mini power station.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by danans on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:23PM (#18519475)
> I'm not sure it's all that unusual a case.

> Solar is especially relevant to remote off-grid homes. Unfortunately, these are also prime targets for theft as they're often left unattended for long periods with distant neighbors.

Remote off grid homes are a very unusual case. Not saying there is no demand from that segment, but even there is a higher rate of demand from it, it's a small segment of the market vs urban/suburban rooftop solar, and I wouldn't expect major manufacturers and installers to optimize for it.

> Denser populations have a grid, and can just have a large solar installation powering that grid on a large scale.

That's already happening today. However people choose to have rooftop domestic solar for many reasons ... to fix the long term cost of their electricity consumption, to offset peak power rates, etc.

> It's a problem. Solar puts expensive infrastructure on-site, it's a mini power station.

In situations where site security is a problem, presumably custom solutions can be put in place by installers to ensure security of the inverters and batteries. It may cost more, but that's sort of the price paid for owning property in a sparse, remote location.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by eloff on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:21PM (#18518680)
Also in some parts of the world they will definitely steal your copper wires (out of the walls of your house if there isn't sufficient security!) But in those places your solar gear wouldn't last a week.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by pbhjpbhj on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:50PM (#18518846)
In the UK an acquaintance of mine has regular phone outages because the copper comms lines are pulled. They're shallow ditch laid; the thieves hook one end to a tow-hitch and drive, I gather.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by newnewpdro on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:19PM (#18519224)
I've heard about this happening, fortunately it's not that bad where my property is. Not yet anyways...
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by MertsA on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:40PM (#18523350)
>Nobody is going to try steal the hot copper wires connecting my house to the grid.

Especially considering the wires connecting your house to the grid are actually aluminum.

Is PV theft really a problem though? I mean they could sell them on ebay but AFAIK most thieves aren't just fencing everything on ebay. I can't imagine a pawn shop would give them much for it considering how hard it would be for the pawn shop to resell them. With copper and aluminum theft the thieves can just go down to the nearest scrapyard and get paid by the pound.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ggm on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:52PM (#18519357)
Are you seriously arguing deployment should cease because of a theft risk?

I don't doubt the theft risk exists. I'm asking if you are catastrophising to "..so we shouldn't do it" or just observing a downside risk component.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by newnewpdro on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:38PM (#18519523)
Nope, not at all, I wasn't aware I was engaged in an argument.

It just makes more sense in a lot of cases to let the utility provider convert to solar than turn your house into a power station you then have to secure accordingly and maintain.

I'm not interested in having to surround my property with barbed wire topped chain link fences, which is what you'll see around power stations for good reasons.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ggm on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:03AM (#18520716)
Mostly risk of death reasons. Solar and battery are not high on my list of lifestyle and risk components any more than a car parked outside or plants are.

Maybe you live in a much higher crime risk area. I know (for instance) honey hives in NZ are being predated by gangs so I can believe there are portable high theft risk things in rural settings. But I'm really unsure a Tesla battery rig is one.

I've had plants stolen. I still maintain my garden..

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by newnewpdro on Saturday November 24, 2018 @03:50AM (#18521142)
> I've had plants stolen. I still maintain my garden..

What a world it would be if independent solar power were the cost of a garden!

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Dylan16807 on Saturday November 24, 2018 @09:01PM (#18525002)
How much do you value your time? Gardens tend to be pretty expensive when you add up the hours for a decade or two!
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ggm on Thursday November 29, 2018 @04:36PM (#18564275)
Ah yes.. economic efficacy meets relaxation and hobby. You can't buy pre-read books quite the way flann O'Brien wrote about but it feels like we're close.

Having said which, close friends ran bespoke gardening for richer garden aesthetes.

Back to the lead topic. PV is worth doing but assess your theft and vandalism exposure in risk/cost benefit.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by hyperbovine on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:42PM (#18519534)
Data, please: how many documented cases of this type of theft actually exist? No offense, but it sounds like you live in the middle of nowhere and are slightly paranoid.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by chriscappuccio on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:16PM (#18520055)
Rural theft is a big problem around here. Just a few months ago someone stole the entire generator at a tower site that is high up on top of Grey Butte, near Smith Rock in Redmond, Oregon. I picture a similar risk for solar panels.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ggm on Thursday November 29, 2018 @05:06PM (#18564560)
Yes. Rural theft is a problem. Now, explain how society advances if we give in to crime and we stop investing in rural communities
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by manmal on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:00PM (#18518254)
At some point, there has to be a standard to which roofs are built (including wiring and power ports) such that you can just buy shingles and put them in or replace from the inside. Just cut the middle men and installation costs.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by DubiousPusher on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:14PM (#18518947)
I hate to be a bummer but based on the way the construction industry works, that's almost certainly not going to happen. For example, in the U.S. most plumbing jobs fall under a bevy of regulations and yet tasks as simple as changing a faucet can frequently lead to issues like unmatched pipe diameters or thead types. We've had 100 years to standardize that and it's still a mess. You literally can't even just go buy a garden hose and know for sure it's going to fit your exterior faucet.

Electrical is arguably the most regulated, standards based and straight forward aspect of construction and even that varies a great deal based on the electrician and equipment.

A rigorous standards based construction industry would be amazing. We could design electrical systems that could be installed by a novice with almost no risk of danger or failure. Homeowners could change luminares just plugging them in and attaching them to an electric box toolesly. We could have plug and play water appliances.

Damn it would be magical but again I'm fairly certain that's just not going to happen.

Edit: Above I indicated that the construction industry doesn't operate on "rigorous standards". That's not really true. There are actually very good science based standards for most construction tasks. It's more of a problem that the industry doesn't really focus on making future work on a structure low cost. And it makes very little effort to increase accessibility by creating more consumer facing equipment and tools.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by manmal on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:45AM (#18521425)
That says a lot about the US. In Europe, you can buy only one type of garden hose because there is only one kind of port. If the EU would introduce a new standard to which roofs have to be built, then people will start using it within 3 years. And they will benefit a lot from that standard, so you will think twice before buying a new roof for 20k+ and not buy from the companies that keep to this standard. Also don’t underestimate the power of adapters.

I think you also conflate the way which something is built with the specification it is built against - like interfaces vs implementation details. If you tell companies to build a certain kind of roof, with ports and wiring, then they will not receive any money if they don’t meet your spec. They are free to use the kind of wood, nails, wires (as long as thick enough) that they like, and this is where they can compete against each other.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Baeocystin on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:57AM (#18521447)
Perhaps the parent comment has had some bad luck, but I've lived in a half-dozen US states, and have never seen any garden hose tap that was different than the standard set in the 60s. FWIW. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden_hose
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by DubiousPusher on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:09AM (#18521660)
Garden faucets in the U.S. can be 3/8, 1/2, 5/8 or 3/4 inches. They can have a course thread or if a backflow preventer is reuired in your muni, they have a fine thread.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Baeocystin on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:05PM (#18523201)
I've seen hoses with all of those diameters, but they've all had the same standard fitting size at the ends. Same with the backflow preventers- all the normal course threads. Now I'm genuinely curious, what state are you in? (not being obstinate, I really am just curious!)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by DubiousPusher on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:17PM (#18523531)
No offense taken. I'm in Western Washington state. The home I previously lived in had fine machine threads on the exterior faucet. I assume this was to prevent attachment of a hose without a vacuum breaker. Here's the item I had to purchase to attach a standard garden hose.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002OU6ZSA/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_tbA-...

Now that I think about it though I believe you are correct about the diameter of the port being consistent. It is indoor plumbing valves that I've run into a variety of sizes of. 1/2" vs 3/8 compression.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Baeocystin on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:28PM (#18523580)
Interesting. Thanks for answering!
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by limaoscarjuliet on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:15AM (#18521688)
Simply not true. In Poland we not only have two standards, they are also expressed in inches: 1/2 and 3/4.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by manmal on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:55AM (#18526058)
Yes, but only two and they are a no-brainer because of adapters.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by the-dude on Saturday November 24, 2018 @06:01AM (#18521457)
This is not true. Although Gardena has a huge market penetration in the EU, it is not a EU standard.

There are other types, no EU involvement here ( yet ).

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by manmal on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:49AM (#18526036)
Did I say that garden faucets are standardized? Yeah you can get other sizes than the Gardena ones I guess, but those are more obscure. I think you will agree though that EU standards are usually followed.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by azernik on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:16PM (#18519863)
This is, I assume, because standards and regulation are aimed more at safety than at ease of maintenance/modification?
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by akiselev on Friday November 23, 2018 @11:04PM (#18520385)
The majority of construction regulations I've run into are relatively flexible. It's expensive but if you want to try out a new material or technique, the path to validating it and getting it approved is well defined. The problem is that few construction companies operate at that kind of scale and outside of churches, flagship venues (i.e. Disney hall), and palaces there just isn't enough money to develop new technologies.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by amluto on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:06PM (#18520232)
If you can design a roof from which a shingle can be replaced from the inside, the roof doesn't leak when exposed to wind-driven rain, the roof can hold your weight, and the cost isn't hilariously high, I'll be impressed.

Also, if you stick a power port on your roof and you live in an area with lots of lightning, I'll stay away from your house.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by manmal on Sunday November 25, 2018 @03:54AM (#18526055)
Basically every window is opened and can be replaced from the inside. How is that different?

Regarding lightning, IDK how the Tesla roof solved this, but they obviously did.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by amluto on Sunday November 25, 2018 @11:52AM (#18527586)
Have you ever seen a roof built? There’s a roof deck, and shingles of some sort are nailed in from above in a specific order. In many installations, there is a weatherproof barrier between the roof deck and the shingles. If you want to replace a single shingle in the middle, you do it carefully, and you may need a special fastener.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by manmal on Monday November 26, 2018 @02:22PM (#18536032)
That’s how they are now built, yes. Cars looked very much different 100 years ago, too.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by zamfi on Monday November 26, 2018 @12:37PM (#18535121)
Yes, and also making that house, or land, or taxes produce 4x as much energy is categorically different form reducing the cost of existing 22%-efficiency panels by 75%.

That's because higher-energy-per-unit-area panels increases the efficiency of land use, which drives all the other costs you list: land acquisition, taxes, customer acquisition, etc.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by tomcam on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:17PM (#18519643)
Plus the environmental costs of creating and, at end of life, disposing of the arrays.

You’re a good thinker and writer. I’m definitely ready for your TED talk!

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by onetimemanytime on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:56PM (#18518232)
OK, can you just buy a solar heating panel? You and your best friend can install it...depending on location you can easily get hot water for 6-10 months a year. That's quite a savings. You don't have to solve everything today ;)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by lstodd on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:38PM (#18518453)
Solar heating panel? A bunch of wooden/plywood boxes, some glazing for them (can actually reuse thrown-away window panels), a bit of plumbing with PP pipe (ridiculously lego-like easy), some kind of top tank (a common steel drum?).

And some making sure the roof/attic floor doesn't collapse, which usually is not a problem.

This can be _build_from_scratch_ in a couple of weekends with a best friend.

But for the construction codes. And unions.

It's so low-tech, so I wonder why I haven't heard of 19th century installations. Me, I actuially built two in places where construction codes are not an issue. And have seen functioning installs dating from 1950s.

I don't think it even makes any sense to mass-produce heat boxes the way the solar-electric panels have to be. It all can be either made on site or included into the house design from start.

That's maybe why you can't buy solar heating off the shelf.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by sgc on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:13PM (#18519440)
I don't agree simply because it is very common for diy solar water panel systems to leak all over the place. There at least needs to be prescriptive code to help reduce instances of crap work. But since it is a lot of pipe in a small footprint, it just makes sense to have it made in a factory with better quality control.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by briandear on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:12PM (#18518939)
You and your best friend most likely can’t install it. You not only need building permits, you also typically need a licensed electrician to do the work. Doing it without a permit or properly credentialed installers risks sanction from the municipality as well as potential insurance consequences.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by thoughtfunction on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:56PM (#18519128)
A 'solar heating panel' in most cases is a water tank exposed to the sun as much as possible painted in black. Or maybe put inside a black box. Not a lot of electricity work there.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Animats on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:12PM (#18519199)
It's not quite that simple. Flat plate collectors are roof components, and they have all the problems of roofing. Making them leakproof despite big thermal stresses takes some work. Brazed copper plumbing works. Plastics, not as well.[1]

You usually want a water tank to buffer the thing, so you can get hot water at night. Temperature will be all over the place without that. Giant hot water tanks in attics need extra structural support, which was a problem in Florida at one time.

There are some fancier setups that will work in cold weather. Some systems use antifreeze in the panels, and a heat exchanger.

[1] http://www.alternative-energy-tutorials.com/solar-hot-water/...

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by lightedman on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:45PM (#18519330)
"Convincing someone to attach something to their house has significant costs. Like, "over $2000 per install" significant."

Not any more. We've got 50-state legal solar stuff where you just lay the panels out in the yard, literally plug them into your wall outlet, and every outlet on that circuit is energized. You can even leave it hooked to your power at night time, as the junction boxes have barrier rectifier diodes that prevent the panels from consuming power at night.

Install costs are becoming almost negligible due to advancing technology.

Cell efficiency is up there. Typical monocrystalline panels run 20+% now days (and look utterly gorgeous - https://imgur.com/a/sZGtYmB - picture from my job.)

Opportunity costs? Each cell runs on average $1.00 for most manufacturers, so you just need to shop around. A typical 60-cell panel at 300W runs about $150-200.

Most of your concerns have not been concerns for about 5 years.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by nihil75 on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:44PM (#18517853)
Do keep in mind that while they are "cost effective" - it takes a few years to recoup the initial investment. A more efficient panel will repay its value sooner, or will require lower initial investment.

Second, the possible applications - Low efficiency cells will support low power appliances, Or you'll need more of them / storage for more power hungry applications. A more efficient cell enables new applications where weight is an issue.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Retric on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:12PM (#18518009)
In terms of power / weight solar can already beat many IC engines.

The only thing more efficient solar brings is less packaging and use in extremely confined spaces like the roof of a car.

PS: The car thing should start taking off in a few years. A Tesla model 3 is 4.6 meters long 1.85 meters wide so 8.7 meters square. At 40% your talking about around 30kwh per day which could really extend the range and for less used cars minimize recharging.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by rightbyte on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:03PM (#18518895)
Why is weight an issue when we are talking power plants for housing?

Here's a 8.3 kW diesel generator (6.3 kW generator) from Home Depo: https://www.homedepot.com/p/Boss-Precision-Products-Inc-Port...

3900 USD.

367 lbs + fuel = 180 kg + fuel

http://www.nordensolar.se/produktdetaljer/solceller-luxor-so...

One random 265W solar panel, you need 31 off them, one is 18,6 kg gives 582 kg of solar panels to get to 8.3 kW (obviously you wont get 8.3 kW cont. from them). Not counting inverters, mounting rackets etc.

So for equal weight and way more power you have one 8,3 kW diesel generator and 402 kg of diesel.

1 kg diesel is ca 12 kWh energy. Lets guess 30% efficiency gives 1447 kWh electricty for the same weigth. That's about as much as the solar panels will produce in 2,4 months assuming 129 kWh/m2/year.

According to this site it's 3,14 USD per watt solar panel installation for consumers. https://news.energysage.com/10kw-solar-systems-compare-price...

8300 * 3,14 = 26 000 USD.

So, you can buy a generator and 22 000 USD of diesel (about 22 000 litres or 22 000 litres * 10kWh * 0,3 efficiency = 66 000 kWh electricty) for about the same price. Or about what the same dollar in solar panels will produce in 8 years with way lower peak power.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Retric on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:34PM (#18519028)
Backpacking is one example where you want lightweight solar power, but aircraft and balloons are a more extreme example. In such cases those stiff panels are a long way from what you want. Also, good luck averaging 30% effecency from a basic diesel generator for home use.

Without going to extreme: https://www.solbian.eu/en/4-flexible-solar-panels

That’s 130 W for 1.7kg. Your 8.3 KW would be 108kg which is 238 lb and thus less than the generator even excluding fuel.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by rightbyte on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:10PM (#18519185)
Ye, of course. But the comparison was with ICEs and given that you could bring an ICE weight carrying capacity is usually not that scarce like back packing or balloons.

Depends on if you need power, or, energy over time for the same weight.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Retric on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:59PM (#18519587)
Weight is often an issue to some degree. For example the US military has adopted solar for many remote bases because moving fuel is a logistical issue.

Again, I think for the most common case the only real advantage of increased effecency is lower installation costs. I am just saying solar fits in a very wide range of use cases and sometimes say for satilites you want something very specific and paying for it is worth it.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by delbel on Friday November 23, 2018 @09:55PM (#18520196)
there's an extremely efficient diesel engine called the Lister CS that became popular in the 1920s. It's claim to fame is that it can run 30-45 years without major maintenance and produce 1kwH per .125 gallons of diesel. That's 8kwh per gallon. It was banned in 2009 by the Obama administration because it was considered fuel inefficient by bureaucrats who didn't understand the design. There was a movement to try and de-list it from the ban. My dream has been trying to find one and draft it into freecad so people could 3d print cast iron molds and re-manufacture them. https://youtu.be/NhAD8D3sM2A?t=98
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by FlyMoreRockets on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:48PM (#18520357)
From what I can tell, the Lister was banned because of carbon particulate emissions, not due to efficiency. However, very slow turning engines like the Lister tend to have a more complete combustion and lower emissions.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by felipemnoa on Saturday November 24, 2018 @02:16PM (#18523526)
>>can run 30-45 years without major maintenance

I think it would be better to list the number of miles it can run before maintenance is needed. Just stating the time does not provide a complete picture.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by gpm on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:31PM (#18518735)
Woah, 30kwh =~ 210 km... that could eliminate charging on even moderately used cars.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by polskibus on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:03PM (#18517954)
Is there a calculator that can take into consideration the weather over entire year?
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by DoctorOetker on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:08PM (#18518616)
I'd also like to know where I can find decent insolation maps
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by FlyMoreRockets on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:49PM (#18520361)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ip26 on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:06PM (#18517974)
Have you examined PVWatts?
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by baron816 on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:09PM (#18517987)
The real breaking point will be when solar is so cheap that it costs less to replace a coal or natural gas plant than it would be to continue running it.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ams6110 on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:37PM (#18518128)
Well you also need to solve the storage problem. Your solar plant will not replace the coal or natural gas plant at night or on cloudy days.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Brakenshire on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:12PM (#18518319)
Yes, actually it already is cheaper to build new solar or wind than run existing plants, at least in some situations.

As you say intermittency and time of day is the issue. Although I think we should just reflect lower costs in time of day tariffs. I suspect there are a lot of use-cases where people would happily shift demand to save money. For instance if you could just put your clothes in a washer dryer, and leave it to handle the cheapest time. Or air conditioning which creates ice earlier in the day then uses the cache later. Provide the tariffs, open the market opportunity, and see what technologies emerge.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Godel_unicode on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:27PM (#18518403)
So you agree with GP that the storage problem is currently a problem and needs to be solved.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by fpoling on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:25PM (#18518993)
It is only a problem with current solar prices. With much cheaper solar one can produce, say, methanol and store enough of it to generate electricity for months. And that will be cheaper than burning natural gas.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by PuffinBlue on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:44PM (#18518813)
Controversial statement alert:

The storage 'problem' doesn't really exist. Do we 'store' electricity currently? No, we just generate it all the time and it's 'used' straight away. Well, what we do technically now 'store' will continue to be stored if using wind/solar (e.g. pumped hydro 'Electric Mountain' in the UK).

Shall we also pedantically say we current 'store' electricity in the form or chemical energy in gas/fossil fuels or whatever? We can use that definition I suppose.

Even with that definition no leap to any new 'storage' method actually needed if we look at the functional output required to keep the system operating the same way it does now. You just need need to have enough renewable over-capacity to generate enough electricity to meet the 24h cycle. Which is functionally what we do now.

The "it's always windy/sunny/tidal somewhere" solution is the same as what we do currently, we just put our hands over our eyes and ignore the 'energy security' implications of not producing enough oil/gas to meet our own needs so it feels like somehow what we have now is more certain.

That's not to say it wouldn't be more efficient to store electricity and release it as needed. But just like now what would solve the problem is over capacity with enough resilience to feed the 24 hour cycle.

Can that be done with 'just' wind and solar? I don't know,I guess not. Nuclear would seem a good addition to the mix, and tidal or wave power.

But it seems like we should at least approach the problem openly without hamstringing ourselves worrying about 'storing' electricity being something we absolutely must 'solve' before renewables can be relied upon.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by IanCal on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:38PM (#18519039)
> No, we just generate it all the time and it's 'used' straight away.

Right, and we vary how much we produce to match demand. We can't make it sunnier just because everyone has gone to put the kettle on at the same time.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by PuffinBlue on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:18PM (#18519218)
We vary how much we produce by having over-capacity, and using a portion of that to 'turn up the generators' as needed.

If there wasn't enough generating capacity in the fossil fuel system it would be equivalent to 'can't make it sunnier'. The flip side to 'can't make it sunnier' is you can add more solar generating capacity (over-capacity) and add mixed generation through wind/solar/tidal. Both options end up at the same place - over-capacity in order to meet peak/daily/yearly loads.

Classic fossil fuel generating stations quite literally sit idle waiting to go, that's the over-capacity. The same thing can be done for renewables (the whole mix, not just solar).

And to answer the inevitable 'but we've always got access to fossil fuels, like at night when the sun doesn't shine'...

Right now we 'store' the electrical energy in fossil fuels (really we release it) and say this system if inherently more stable because we assume access to those fuels is immutable. And we say that the energy 'stored' in the wind or tide or sun is not.

In reality, fossil fuel energy security is a delicate balancing act of just in time logistics and political power plays, for most nations without vast resources or nuclear generating capacity for instance.

Functionally, perceived limitless access to fossil fuels gives the false impression of superiority and conversely give the the perceived absolute need for renewable storage because of the very obvious daily cycle of light/wind/tide.

I simply say that adopting a system of over-capacity like we currently have for fossil fuels and recognising that neither renewable/fossil fuel resource access is certain is a sensible middle ground upon which to build a sensible generating program. Both systems can rely on having more capacity to handle peak loads, both systems have the ability to plan for their faults and both can work without massive grid scale storage.

Adding storage to renewable generation would actually be a huge step up over the current system and would be fantastic. I would love to see such a system work, and I believe it will do anyway through distributed smart grid/EV usage and large grid scale battery storage.

It's just the uncertainties of the current system are hidden from the average user and I'm just saying we're setting a higher bar for renewable use and storage because the access limitation are that bit more obvious on the daily cycle.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by yholio on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:47PM (#18519339)
Sure, but the reverse side of that is the proportional cost increase of solar that has excess capacity. Solar has negligible running costs, it's irrelevant that you use the energy or not, the capital costs will have to be recovered from the price of the fraction of energy that you do use.

So you are effectively asking for a 3-5x lower solar cost before it could replace existing sources. Never mind that there are seasons and periods of the day when no amount of excess capacity will cover the demand, there is simply no significant solar energy on continent-wide scales.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by PuffinBlue on Friday November 23, 2018 @07:32PM (#18519701)
Everyone keeps talking about solar. Probably for the classic 'sun doesn't shine at night' thing.

I've repeatedly said to use a mix of renewables, just like a mix of fossil fuels is used, so deficiencies in one is balanced by another.

The exact same thing is done in traditional generation. You don't use a nuclear plant t for a TV pickup for instance, you wouldn't use solar for the whole grid.

Balancing the way you generate reduces the amount of over-capacity required (and subsequently the cost), exactly as is done now in traditional generation.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by allannienhuis on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:59PM (#18519144)
I think the point is that the existing grid has the ability to do that on-demand scaling, so adding variable solar or wind capacity to the grid means the problem is already dealt with. Of course as we transition to higher percentages of solar and wind capacity the demand scaling will become a bigger issue and storing the solar and wind output will be needed. I'm not sure how far away that is now - perhaps the existing hydro and nuclear capacity is enough to deal with all of that variability, but I expect at some point we'll need to figure out the storage issue.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ben_w on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:50PM (#18519096)
We definitely need more in the way of cost-effective energy storage. There are only limited places for pumped hydro, unfortunately, and battery tech isn’t yet cheap enough over its lifetime.

I’m optimistic, but we’re not there yet.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by zepolen on Friday November 23, 2018 @08:01PM (#18519810)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ben_w on Saturday November 24, 2018 @04:53AM (#18521295)
“A 120-meter (nearly 400-foot) tall, six-armed crane stands in the middle. In the discharged state, concrete cylinders weighing 35 metric tons each…”

120 m * 35,000 kg * 9.8 m/s/s = 41.2 MJ = 11.4 kWh.

LiIon: 250–693 W·h/L, 100–265 W·h/kg, 250~300 USD/kWh in 2018

-> 11.4 kWh = 45.7-16.5 litres, 114-43 kg, $2850-$3420.

Concrete is much harder for me to find number for, seems to be $92/cubic yard, 2.4 tons/cubic meter.

35 tons -> 14.5 cubic meters -> ~19 cubic yards -> $1748 plus whatever the cost of a crane that can lift 35 tons is.

My knowledge of cranes is whatever came up first on Google:

“””A Comadil CTT 361-20 is a good size crane able to do concrete panels, max jib length is 75 meters and they have a max lift capacity of 20 tonnes. These cranes can go up pretty high without needing to be tied into the building. This crane will cost around $1 million”””

Article later talks about renting smaller 4-5 ton capacity cranes for $1500-$2000 per week.

The problem is neither LiIon nor concrete with cranes nor hydrogen are cheap enough. Not yet.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Godel_unicode on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:27AM (#18520797)
We use the word "solved" differently.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Brakenshire on Saturday November 24, 2018 @07:16AM (#18521694)
Yes, I agree it’s a problem, or rather a series of problems. Each one you solve allows the percentage of renewables to increase. What I’m saying is you need to set up the market opportunity as early as possible so that people can start working on commercial-scale solutions.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by atupis on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:09PM (#18518306)
Just convert electricity to hydrogen.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Brakenshire on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:07PM (#18518294)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by epistasis on Friday November 23, 2018 @04:33PM (#18519024)
Existing coals pretty expensive these days, and that's not even counting its high costs for health and carbon. For example, Indiana is retiring tons of coal and replacing it with renewables to save money:

https://www.utilitydive.com/news/even-in-indiana-new-renewab...

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by sfifs on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:40PM (#18519530)
This misses the investment context which leads to companies choosing coal oil and gas over solar.

The limiting factor on deployments continues to be "what to do when the sun doesn't shine bright". Night for starters and in a lot of the world, you have whole seasons where the skies are overcast nearly all day (monsoons).

If you anyway have to couple solar with something else to make up for the variability in power generation (largely fuel based because Hydro and nuclear are massive government led projects) and you have to invest in expensive and bulky power storage to handle even the nights, why not pay a little more incremental money and get a slightly bigger fuel based power plant.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by zmix on Saturday November 24, 2018 @05:09AM (#18521337)
It's not just about costs. It's about size!

The higher the efficiency, the less solar cells you need.

This has impacts on environment (solar cell farms), adds possibilities for miniaturization (what, if a vehicles rooftop could feed all the energy needs of said vehicle or, at least, constantly refuel it?), mobile device chargers (could be even become the outer hull of a battery, so you just need to place the battery in light to charge it), small cells, that produce high energy, could be made part of clothing (must not be this tech, I am thinking about miniaturization in general). Possibilities seem endless...

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by vezycash on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:45PM (#18517862)
You are right. But let's humor the pitch. What happens if solar gets to 60% efficiency and costs - 20cents per watt?
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by nihil75 on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:53PM (#18517907)
That solar-powered plane that circled the globe can carry three times as many people ;)
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by nihil75 on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:58PM (#18517927)
But seriously - The energy density of sunlight is around 1KW/m2 at sea level. So at 60% efficiency you get 600 watt - almost 1 horsepower (~750watt).

That's enough to power a scooter, and with no batteries!

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by petra on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:28PM (#18518085)
Given that often, cars park outside most of the day, could they charge enough , enabling cars with much smaller batteries(for going to work for ex.) sold meaningfully cheaper - without needing creation of a charger network, which is a huge barrier?
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by gregknicholson on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:59PM (#18518248)
If Sono Motors' Sion lives up to its description, it's approaching usable for commuting using only solar power.

https://sonomotors.com/sion.html/#st-viSono

Edit: Ah, this car is mentioned in the article. Good!

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:53PM (#18518537)
From that site:

> This in turn means that up to 30 kilometers’ additional range can be generated per day in Germany through solar energy

I suppose that 30km does cover a lot of commutes (15km each way), although "up to" is a notorious weasel word.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by teraflop on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:41PM (#18518795)
Based on the numbers quoted on the site, 30 km of range is equivalent to what you'd get if all of the solar cells got 4 hours of direct illumination.

On the one hand, they can't all be in direct sunlight at the same time, given the car's geometry. On the other hand, many locations get more than 4 sun-hours per day on a horizontal surface[1], especially in summer. So it doesn't seem too implausible.

And if your commute is 30km per day, then even if you don't get enough sunlight to reliably charge the battery every day, you still have more than a week of buffer in your battery.

[1]: https://www.nrel.gov/gis/images/solar/solar_ghi_2018_usa_sca...

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by elihu on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:55AM (#18520862)
It could work, depending on your use case. For someone who only drives a couple miles a day and parks in the sun, they might need to charge less often or not at all.

If you're going on long road trips, it probably wouldn't help much. In that sense, solar isn't particularly useful for extending range (which is why you'd want a large battery in the first place), but it might make a big difference when it comes to how often you have to plug in to a charger.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by Brakenshire on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:15PM (#18518339)
I think you can buy panels as extras for existing cars, they provide a couple of miles a day under the best circumstances. If it was 10 miles under best circumstances and a couple if left anywhere outside, I could see them becoming mainstream.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by jamesrcole on Friday November 23, 2018 @10:02PM (#18520218)
It's also important to realise that, in any given situation 'cost effective' doesn't necessarily mean 'affordable' (or affordable-enough to lead to the people installing them).

The people need to have the available funds, etc. It may save momey but that's not an immediate payoff.

Any increase in efficiency vs costs will help with that equation.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by kumarvvr on Saturday November 24, 2018 @12:08AM (#18520548)
Improving efficiency means lower footprint per kW of installed capacity. People are now viewing solar in terms of area of installation, contract with power company, etc.

Even in rural India, the idea that solar is cheap has crept in. Farmers are buying solar power pumps across many states.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by simion314 on Friday November 23, 2018 @12:46PM (#18517865)
Still could be good if the surface area available is limited.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by agumonkey on Friday November 23, 2018 @01:40PM (#18518147)
I only wish we'd have less ~toxic PV cells production. So far silicon requires CO2 and chlor- compounds.

Anyone with 20%~ efficiency and a clean manufacturing process is rich for the next millenium.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by bsder on Friday November 23, 2018 @06:46PM (#18519552)
Um, you do realize that silicon fab lines generally recycle practically everything in terms of waste materials?

It used to be that the waste material from processing was more pure than the actual industrial infeed material. So, the first thing that semiconductor fab lines would do would be to take their "new" industrial material and feed it into their "used" line for reprocessing. I think this has changed as the industrial sources have gotten better, but I suspect that recapture is still almost perfect.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by agumonkey on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:00AM (#18520707)
No I didn't know that, I read a few pages saying waste materials weren't recycled hence my comment.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by smaddox on Friday November 23, 2018 @02:40PM (#18518466)
You do realize that table salt is a "chlor- compound", right?

Yes, refining silicon requires the use of dangerous chemicals. No, that does not make it "dirty" in the way that burning coal is dirty, i.e. expelling carcinogens into the air.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by agumonkey on Friday November 23, 2018 @03:09PM (#18518621)
I know but still.
Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by ben_w on Friday November 23, 2018 @05:02PM (#18519160)
No, not “but still”. Water is one oxygen atom from being bleach. Chlorine is metabolically essential.

Chemistry doesn’t care about buzzwords. If you don’t specify what exactly is bad about the industrial handling of whichever chemicals actually are toxic in this case, you’re just flag-waving, not helping.

Re:Using carbon nanotubes and rectennas to yield a 90% effic... by agumonkey on Saturday November 24, 2018 @01:00AM (#18520705)
what buzzword, the cleaner the process the easier it is to produce anywhere, the easier it is to use solar instead of fossile fuel. I just forgot the actual name: tetrachlorosilane when I typed my first comment

To avoid this http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/03...