"Sorry, the anesthesiologist was out of network, though everyone else in the hospital is in network"
After that I went to Kaiser because I'm not sure its possible to go out of network at least like that.
On particular phone call stands out. We got our insurance on a 3-way call with my SO and the hospital billing. For a urology test they charged us ~$800 for the test strip (just a single one!), which the hospital tried to claim was not covered (nothing, it seems, is ever 'covered'). Even the insurance person on the phone was aghast at the hospital: "Wait, so you are telling us that even urological tests, like a basic pH strip, at the specific office for urology, is $3000? What is our client even paying for, like, what is it exactly, that a urologist does? How much does a smile cost?"
US Medical billing makes Kafka blush.
https://www.tdi.texas.gov/news/2018/tdi10082018.html
> The problem meant consumers couldn’t get in-network anesthesia services at more than 20 hospitals and surgical centers in three of the state’s largest metro areas.
https://www.vox.com/2018/5/23/17353284/emergency-room-doctor...
> Except he wasn’t: While the emergency room where Kohan was seen was in his insurance network, the oral surgeon who worked in that ER was not. That’s how Kohan ended up with a $7,924 bill from the oral surgeon that his health plan declined.
> Separate data from the Center for Public Policy Priorities, an Austin-based think tank, finds that a staggering number of Texas emergency rooms have zero in-network emergency physicians — meaning that patients are guaranteed to see a doctor who does not accept their health insurance.
Someone up thread made a claim and the burden of proof was on them. Now multiple reliable sources have been provided to satisfy that proof.
You claim an unspecified law prohibit this and that this prohibition actually works. So now the burden of proof falls on you to actually cite the law and provide reliable sources of this law actually working.
Texas got mad here because there were no in-network anesthesia services. Having some out-of-network providers is depressingly common, and hard to guard against:
https://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20180917/NEWS/18091...
> About 25% of patient visits to hospitals in their insurance network result in balance billing from care by out-of-network physicians.
Also, from the Vox article:
> The problem with that law, Pogue argues, is that it requires patients to contact the state — and patients often aren’t aware of the option. Kohan, for example, didn’t know he had these rights until I told him. Pogue’s research suggests this is really common: Only 3,824 Texas patients have used the law to resolve their surprise bills since 2009. CPPP estimates that this is a tiny fraction of the 250,000 surprise medical bills sent out in the same time frame.
This is just Texas, too. Plenty of states don't have their 2009 state law to work with.
https://www.cnbc.com/2016/11/16/many-get-hit-with-surprise-o...
I'm not sure how this would apply to emergency care, but for non-urgent procedures I don't see why a quote isn't provided. It feels like a failure of the care providers to me.
Even my vet gives an estimate before treatment -- with a "low", "typical" and "high" estimates. I have to sign off on it before they'll provide treatment.
Why can't hospitals do the same for non-emergency care?
You'd think that for such an expensive test, the doctor or his staff would have a policy of getting our specific sign-off on the cost.
People don't become debtors simply because they don't want to pay their bills, they become debtors because they can't afford to pay their bills. The number one cause of bankruptcies in the US is medical debt, and no amount of "price transparency" is going to fix that.
This occurs in auto repair as well (though maybe less than it used to). Those repairs, in my opinion, have been quite stressful as well. Are there other industries where we bill afterward?
Home renovation. You'll get a quote, but the final price can be way higher. Any service when you are dealing with unknowns, the price is going to have to be flexible.
For a doctor, the unknown includes many possible things like drugs administered, blood administered, emergency care, hospital costs, etc. It's not as simple as an hourly rate estimate, unfortunately.
Hence my mechanic has my phone number and will call me if there is an issue, and we can agree to fix it (or not, which includes taking it to another shop).
Whatever happened to efficient markets? And why doesn't this kind of behaviour get fixed by the courts, it sounds like a lot of the players are in collusion to keep the prices high.
Sounds like they put the MRI machine on the wrong setting.
So patients must agree to a procedure -- yet only afterward find out how much it costs. That price can be shocking, and the patient never agreed to pay it. No wonder it becomes hard to collect from them.
In the rest of the economy, we agree on a price beforehand. That makes customers more likely to pay.
The medical system, however, has given up on disclosing prices to patients, because everything is paid by insurance. And now we have Doctors who say:
> “It's harder to collect from the patient than it is from the insurance,” said Amy Derick, a doctor who heads a dermatology practice outside Chicago.
If you want people to pay, then make an agreement with them before you perform the service!