News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by brobdingnagians on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:19PM (#18329208)
I realized I was checking facebook a lot each day whenever I had a spare moment, but didn't have anything really interesting happening, and I wanted to engage more with those around me and have more time for down-time thinking. So I deleted the app, knowing that making the threshold higher for checking it would reduce my usage, now I might check facebook once a month on my desktop, and still nothing happening, so it is super brief. My life is better, I feel better, my relationships are better, and I don't miss it at all.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by TuringNYC on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:07PM (#18329663)
Slightly different scenario on my side -- I want to use it, but the timeline has gotten so limited it doesn't draw me in as much. (No, i'm not on blocked lists. But strange things happen, e.g., Facebook has decided that despite my brother and I being friends and being marked "close" and not blocking each other, we dont see many of each others' posts.)

I'll confess I actually like using Facebook because it allows me to keep engaged and in touch with family with much less effort than before -- but whatever timeline changes they keep doing, I now see the same stories on my scroll. If I log in five times during the day, i see the same set of stories each of the five times.

Result: I don't check it as much, dont want to check it as much. So much for ranking functions.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by appleiigs on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:56PM (#18331350)
I want to check FB once a week or two to catch up on how my friends are doing, but the FB ranking also fails me. All I get is viral click-bait and none of the meaningful news of friends. One friend was sick, another launched an app... i found out about all this after. No reason to log in anymore.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by lambda_lover on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:46PM (#18331825)
While I'm sure FB's algos are somewhat to blame for this, it's hard to estimate just how much content has been driven away by the site since the halcyon days of 2007-2012. Most of the reason I left was because none of my friends posted photos or thoughts any more -- folks just started sharing links and regurgitating talking points without generating any original content, so I left because I have HN/Reddit for that (with better curation tools, at that). Facebook was a good place when all of my friends used it for messaging and sharing their lives, but at some point everyone I knew started to use instagram and snapchat for those things.

Snapchat has mostly been killed by monetization, but instagram is still on life support for now. Losing the chronological timeline was quite the blow, though. Is it really that hard to balance "pleasant place to share my life" and "shove ads into my face"?

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by corobo on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:55PM (#18331335)
I've actually been seeing "No more posts" a lot recently. I scroll through two pageloads of content and then it tells me there's nothing more to display.

Facebook, I've been signed up since you first opened up to non-edu accounts.. you're telling me there's nothing at all more to display?

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by te_chris on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:26PM (#18329860)
Honestly, I feel the same a bit. Like the company itself is cancerous - their complete lack of regard with the way they let hate spread on their platform is shameful. But...I've been on since the old days. I remember when it was actually a community platform and all your friends were there. That was pretty cool.

Not sure where that's going to pop up next.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by erikig on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:11PM (#18330905)
I've never been a huge Facebook app user but the company definitely has me hooked on Whatsapp. All my friends, family, business partners, seem to have gravitated to Whatsapp and WhatsApp groups. It feels like Facebook.app is dead, Long live Facebook (Inc)...
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by kd0amg on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:04PM (#18331436)
I've given up on my Facebook-curated timeline. Now I just have a "friend list" with all of my friends on it, and I read that list's feed instead.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by tintor on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:09PM (#18331497)
FB will prioritize timeline posts of your contacts that you have the most messages exchanged with over Messenger.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by mrweasel on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:12PM (#18329720)
I believe that is how Facebook dies. Not people deleting their account, they’ll just stop checking their feed, because it’s spam and stuff friends likes or share and no longer posts about their life.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by deminature on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:25PM (#18331039)
I stopped posting because of the whole thing about social media written in ink. I'm not posting something which may be held against me, or have me randomly shamed in the future because the nuance of my joke was lost in text. When I last posted in 2007, the internet seemed to be a much different, friendlier place.

Facebook in 2007 was also mostly about friends, and not selling me stuff that it couldn't possibly know I was interested in unless my movements over the entire internet were being tracked.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by sixothree on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:50PM (#18331855)
I barely log in any longer. Maybe once a month.

I honestly do like seeing pics of my friends and their many animals. I like knowing what events people are going to. Other than that, I don't care.

I can't post without feeling like an attention seeker; because that's how I see most people who do post. It's to the point where I stopped sharing things I think my friends might actually find interesting... I'm out here all by myself in the end.

I'm just done with it.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by clarry on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:36PM (#18331142)
It is frightening how the internet outrage culture is getting people fired and destroying their lives over some stupid tweet.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by deminature on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:42PM (#18331205)
The risk/reward of posting humor on the internet nowadays is terrible. Reward is maybe a few of your friends find it funny, maybe it gets ignored. Risk is someone is offended, you lose your livelihood and become an internet pariah because someone organized an angry mob against you on some Discord. Maybe someone doxes you, finds your address and starts harassing you at your home. The internet in 2018 is kind of a terrible place.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by goldfeld on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:58PM (#18331369)
Or society is just showing how barbaric it's ever been. See the elections in Brazil yesterday.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by ryan-allen on Monday October 29, 2018 @08:44PM (#18333057)
> The risk/reward of posting humor on the internet nowadays is terrible.

Doing so under your own name, yes. That's why I think places like Reddit are better suited to these kinds of silly things, assuming you don't get doxxed, which can happen.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by kazinator on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:58PM (#18331933)
Unless they sit in the Oval Office; then they can tweet whatever they want.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by scarface74 on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:08PM (#18331494)
I am careful about what I let get out on the Internet. I’m more concerned about being embarrassed about some of the juvenile arguments I got in using my real name on Usenet back in the day than what I post on FaceBook.

Any company that wouldn’t want to hire me because they find my bleeding heart libertarian pro-capitalist views offensive is not a company I would want to work for. Hell they would probably be confused about where I stand on most things.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by ModernMech on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:58PM (#18331927)
> When I last posted in 2007, the internet seemed to be a much different, friendlier place.

But then something happened...

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by deminature on Monday October 29, 2018 @06:27PM (#18332163)
I'd love to know what happened, because I'm honestly not sure what it was. I just remember posting fearlessly about all sorts of random stuff I'd ashamed to think I put on the internet nowadays.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by bogomipz on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:59PM (#18331383)
>"I stopped posting because of the whole thing about social media written in ink."

What are you referring to here? Could you elaborate? Newspaper coverage of social media?

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by mishac on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:09PM (#18331499)
I think he means "written in ink" in the sense that something you post cannot be erased, much like how if you write something with a pen, vs with a pencil.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by crankylinuxuser on Monday October 29, 2018 @08:42PM (#18333045)
Same thing as HN btw. Ive known a few European citizens asking for their posts and account deleted, and was refused point blank.

Remember that. We're being used here just as much as on the FAANG platforms.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by dredmorbius on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @03:18AM (#18334462)
HN have a stated (though difficult to find) policy of removing content on request:

We don't delete comments outright except when the author requests it.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16698937#16728471

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by rstupek on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:09PM (#18331501)
They're referring to social media being permanent, no take backsies. Everything you share is going to be on the internet for all time
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by hirundo on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:08PM (#18331485)
S/he's updating the phrase "written in stone" for the internet age.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by tbabb on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:14PM (#18331552)
I used to use it daily, but now basically do not interact with it at all. I left because a year ago I spent a week away from it, and when I logged back in it was insanely spammy and clingy with irrelevant "your friend liked this post" notifications that I literally couldn't turn off.

The unmutable spam in my inbox forced me to turn off all Facebook mail notifications, and the user-hostile behavior made me hate the platform and not want to come back to it, almost out of spite.

I'll bet these underhanded tactics performed great in A/B testing. But big picture, they should not be surprised that people are leaving in droves after deliberately degrading user experience.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by a3n on Monday October 29, 2018 @09:43PM (#18333383)
Perhaps you are not the product that they prefer to cultivate. You are not useful to them, so driving you off is actually a benefit to them. Win-win!
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by 2sk21 on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:16PM (#18330946)
That pretty much exactly describes me - I never did delete the app on my phone but I can't remember when I last opened it. I just have no interest in checking it anymore.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by leeoniya on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:44PM (#18331220)
you should probably delete it. in case it's sending your juicy phone data back to the mother ship in the background. (it probably is).
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by mal808 on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:52PM (#18331306)
Or even just for the battery savings
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by r00fus on Monday October 29, 2018 @06:21PM (#18332117)
Does it matter if FB (super)cookie and http beacons are still reporting back what they're browsing?

FB can always promote Instagram or Whatsapp into their main money cow.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by thirdsun on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @04:41AM (#18334787)
Yes, that's how I see and use Facebook as well. It's there if someone not close enough to have my phone number wants to reach me, but other than that I simply don't open and use the app, let alone post content. It's just not worthwhile to me.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by chrisco255 on Monday October 29, 2018 @05:46PM (#18331824)
So like Yahoo email then.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by MattBearman on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:33PM (#18329324)
This is exactly how my leaving facebook started. After a few months without the app I logged out on desktop, and then it wasn't long until I deactivated my account.

I'd like to delete it entirely but at the moment too many people still use messenger to contact me.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by toomuchtodo on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:34PM (#18329336)
Anytime I speak with someone on Messenger, I mention my cellphone # and email. Gotta prime that OOB comms pump, otherwise you'll never break free.

If only there was a Messenger API to setup an autoresponder with alternate contact info...

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by bdamm on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:19PM (#18329780)
It's nice that phone numbers are so stable these days.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by rootusrootus on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:29PM (#18329903)
I wonder how long that will continue. I get so many spam calls every day (about a dozen now) that I am looking towards a future where I don't have a POTS number.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by illegalsmile on Monday October 29, 2018 @03:44PM (#18330648)
The spam phone calls and especially texts have dramatically risen over the last two years. Any idea why this is?
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by sudosteph on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:39PM (#18331177)
So this is just my two-cents based on working for a VOIP company for a couple years, but I noticed a few patterns, specifically the industry-wide pressure to compete with Twilio, that seem to make it easier to spam text/calls.

1.) VOIP providers have low-barriers to sign-up (typically just a credit card fraud check + check to see if IP or address is from certain countries where fraud calls are common). The up-side to this is that it makes the user experience more friendly to real customers b/c they don't have to wait around, but the downside is that any spammer semi-familiar with the checks that get done can sign up and start sending spam calls for a day or two before most places get complaints and shut them down. The fact that many voip providers allow users to set their Display Id to anything too without any approval also is also really convenient for spammers (ie, there aren't usually ways to immediately detect when a user fraudently set their Caller Id to the name of a bank or something)

2.) APIs everywhere. Twilio got big in part b/c it made APIs available, but the smaller providers are catching up and also adding APIs for texting and calling services. Spammers can automate their spam and re-use the scripts between different accounts when they get banned, so it makes sending out spam texts easier too.

3.) VOIP companies actually are ok with some degree of spam, as long as the spammers pay their bills. So they don't have a motivation to actually stop all of it. Instead of blocking all spam-ish calls outright, some places will just make a deal so that some callers (identified by having a high rate of unanswered calls + very short length calls) pay a higher rate to compensate for potential reputation damage. This is meant for legal cold-calling I imagine, but in practice, they don't know what is actually being said on those phone calls.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by simcop2387 on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:39PM (#18331173)
I imagine a large part of it is the dramatic lower barrier thanks to services like twilio and competitors. They enable a lot of really cool tech but the programatic access to the phone network like that makes all that stuff significantly easier
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by rtkwe on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:22PM (#18329818)
Yeah used to be it'd be the opposite. We'd try desperately try to migrate everyone to using something like Messenger (eg: AIM or ICQ) because we couldn't count on our number remaining the same.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by davchana on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:45PM (#18329451)
Are not there some messenger bot which could do this?
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by alexchantavy on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:47PM (#18329470)
Sounds like it's time for Trillian to have a reboot just like Winamp did recently :-)
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by sdegutis on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:12PM (#18329715)
Oh man that brings back fond memories of creating Trillian 0.73-0.74 skins! I was just thinking the other day that I should make an app for Mac that lets you skin it via XML in the same way. Away with the conformity of Aqua and Aqua Dark, let creativity reign free!
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by johnchristopher on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:07PM (#18329666)
You can't set up a bot or an automated message for personnal accounts, only for pages.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by nickbarnwell on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:26PM (#18329866)
But you could use the Bitlbee FBMQTT Plugin [1] and WeeChat's scripting functionality to implement it for your personal account. Probably an afternoon's worth of work if you have a VPS or t1.micro lying around to run a daemon on for a few months :)

[1]: https://wiki.bitlbee.org/HowtoFacebookMQTT [2]: https://weechat.org/

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by phreeza on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:56PM (#18329550)
Wait, you can deactivate your account and still use messenger?
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by tomjakubowski on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:41PM (#18330020)
I did this one time and my account ended up in a broken state where friends couldn't send me messages in long-running one-on-one Messenger chats (they got some mystery error like "This user is not accepting messages right now."). Group chats still worked and I could send messages to those same long-running Messenger conversations.

Re-activating the Facebook side of the account resolved the issue. Caveat deactivator.

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by tomphoolery on Monday October 29, 2018 @02:43PM (#18330049)
You can indeed! You can even reactivate your account _only_ for messenger.

I kinda wish you could do that for events...

Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by dvtrn on Monday October 29, 2018 @03:17PM (#18330379)
Better yet I wish Events were integrated into messenger, but part of me thinks Facebook knows it that a substantial portion of users would probably stick to messenger and never visit the news feed ever again because that's the only thing many of us care about.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by parthdesai on Monday October 29, 2018 @03:30PM (#18330520)
Yup, i exclusively use FB for group chats and events. Have uninstalled Fb app and messenger app and my phone's battery and ram thank me.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by strifey on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:58PM (#18329579)
Yep. It currently explicitly states this and does it by default when you get to the final deactivation step. Previously it was an option you had to notice and click.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by mpg33 on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:57PM (#18331354)
I deactivated my account over 3 years ago. Would I be able to use messenger?
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by strifey on Monday October 29, 2018 @07:59PM (#18332792)
My guess is if you reactivate and immediately deactivate, it should do what you want. I don't know what else that triggers, though.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by diogenescynic on Monday October 29, 2018 @03:49PM (#18330693)
Checking Facebook became the digital equivalent of looking in the fridge. You already know what’s in there, but you look anyways. Eventually people get over this. I notice far fewer of my friends seem to be posting and using it.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by incadenza on Monday October 29, 2018 @07:29PM (#18332631)
It’s like checking the fridge when you’re not even hungry. On steroids.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by cheeze on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @12:01AM (#18333943)
I worry if not Facebook its something else. I deleted fb but now I check this website a hundred times a day...
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday October 30, 2018 @09:33AM (#18336259)
You and me both. At least HN is educational. That's what I keep telling myself, at least.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by brightball on Monday October 29, 2018 @01:53PM (#18329532)
The only thing that keeps me on it is that college football season is really entertaining.
Re:Facebook exodus: Nearly half of young users have deleted ... by nadim on Monday October 29, 2018 @04:11PM (#18330909)
Sometimes I feel this way about the Internet in general.