Your company chose the lowest priced company and was surprised when the quality of the work wasn't great. Because this isn't just unique to just India. This happens everywhere. To counteract this story. I worked at Apple where they used offshore engineers from India and the quality of the work was excellent.
You get what you pay for.
The lowest costs, of course, will win out in this case.
The only fix for that problem is replace management, which would have to be done ... by management.
We're supposed to get incomplete specs, it's the only way everyone can end up happy. It doesn't help pointing fingers at an ephemeral 'management' for not knowing exactly how an app should work up front.
In fact, it's usually overspecced in terms of technical architecture and woefully underspecced in terms of function.
It is more than that - it takes an incredible amount of time and effort to setup a good offshore team.
It took my current company over a decade to get to a point where we can consistently get ~10% lower project costs.
That’s a decade of failed and delayed projects! And we weren’t trying to go with the cheapest devs.
When your dev spend is a few hundred million or more a year this makes sense.
However, many many smaller companies have been burned. A couple of failed projects can sink these smaller companies.
Turns out good engineers make good money. I've worked with some brilliant engineers from India-based consulting teams, and they were not cheap.
I have had good experiences with outsourcing in India itself as well, there are some serious teams there too. But there were some bad cases as well.
Money is definitely an indicator of quality, expensive might not mean good but cheap almost always means they're not top talent.
And then six months down the road, "why are all our systems so shoddy?" "Why are our development cycles so long?"
As a consultant, I've seen this pattern so many times it's insane. And depressing... and for better or worse, lucrative.
An HR manager once said each hire is a compromise in some way because no two candidates are alike.
One key in hiring remote is to take some extra time to get to know the candidates via video calls to create a connection and better determine what their strengths and weaknesses are, and get the conversation to a point where the compromise is acknowledged and you can talk about their ability to learn what they don't know and examples of that.
How effectively a developer can learn and apply new knowledge is they main thing I look for. Learning while you work is the new norm, but hiring is not always setup that way.
At the same time, its interesting how broken this ecosystem is (despite the presence of several players vetting these 'companies').
My best suggestion: talk to Indian devs you know (and respect) and ask them for referrals of people back home.
What was the initial bid of the Indian company that ended up costing $6 million dollars?
Stories like these make my blood boil. And to be fair it's not just Indian companies. There are plenty of EU/US based dev teams that consistently fail to deliver and the company still keeps paying them.
I wonder if management just can't deal with sunken costs or if someone is trying to steal money from their own company by making under-the-table deals with the development team.
I've had a couple of clients that dealt with "cheap" teams and wasted years of their life trying to get a product up and running. Taking them on felt like rescuing abused puppies from a shelter. Their eyes would light up every time they witnessed a working feature, no matter how simple it was.
Most companies know one can't hire the cheapest job applicant, they try (more or less successfully) to vet them, yet somehow outsourcing companies are exempt. One wonders how much these managers actually want the project to succeed.
They should have regularly reviewed the work that was being done and if they had issues resolved them during the warranty period.
I am working with clients in the US, Europe and Australia. I know my limitations and never bid for work that me, or my team, can't deliver. This is why I have clients giving repeat work since last 7-8 years.
Part of it is because many colleges(and by extension, firms) in India are focused on knowledge of frameworks and languages as a key indicator of skill and quality. Many, but not all. Which essentially means that, developers are hired cos they know X framework or Y language. When clients ask for devs, how do they choose? Based on skills. Now, when quality is measured not by simplicity but complexity, everything will be over engineered.
Many horror stories are caused by prematurely trying to go fast and making a bigger mess, not knowing how to design, specify, or oversee the building of software.
Overseas is as good as the garbage you can buy locally, but the problems get worse with the distance, time zone, and other things.
I am amazed that low cost outsourcing companies are able to fetch millions of dollars worth of contracts while actual competent developers have hard time landing them.
Every time the development team could not grasp what was required. You literally had to exchange 20 emails with them for each specific point. Of course, this just increased the length of time for scope and in all cases furthered the time of the project.
Each stage of the application was over engineered to infinity. Spaghetti code everywhere and nonsensical functions, callbacks, literally everything was what the hell was the developer thinking.
Of course it just about worked. They had to ship something, but it was slow. The UI was painted into a corner, in some cases doing the wrong thing literally crashed the browser because of an infinity loop or took too much memory.
Some apps had about a billion dependencies and therefore could never be secure. I'm not kidding either, it's like the developer was a plumber instead of actually knowing how to code the simplest of things.
There was no way to ever extend it to build atop newer features or have any sort of roadmap for user requests.
In every single time, management outsourced and took the bid from the lowest priced company. How to solve the problem? Start from scratch with a competent local company with an actual design and development process.
Want to know the best bit? One company I know of, who spent $6 million dollars on a project with an Indian company. An in-house developer took 3 months as a side project and rebuilt it from scratch. It ended up being the code from there on in.
I have NIH syndrome due to seeing these issues pop-up time and time again. In my career I've seen well over $15-20m being wasted in projects due to management being completely incompetent and thinking sitting on the phone with a dev team will ensure success.