News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by subcosmos on Thursday October 18, 2018 @11:43AM (#18249261)
This is getting absolutely rediculous ...

Epoxy resins may very well have created the Diabetes epidemic, with genetic data backing it. https://bit.ly/2J3Btq5

And the chemical used to make Teflon was dumped into the Mississippi river valley for years, leading to a spate of birth defects and other more common medical problems. Dupont paid hundreds of millions : https://bit.ly/2fFAw9Q

Carlin had it right .... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7W33HRc1A6c

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by milesokeefe on Thursday October 18, 2018 @11:51AM (#18249337)
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by pasbesoin on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:40PM (#18250374)
Thank you. I agree, and I seem to recall other comments to this effect, in the past.

The guidelines don't specifically mention URL shorteners, but they do ask posters to supply original sources:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Please submit the original source. If a post reports on something found on another site, submit the latter.

Personally, and as a suggestion for this site, I would extend that to ask that sources not be hidden behind a URL shortener. I want to see where I'm going; I also don't appreciate my click being tracked.

I go "meta" on HN only reluctantly. But, I've noticed the increasing volume of comments on HN, and it seems worthwhile mentioning that HN has some different expectations than other sites. Expectations that have helped to keep the commentary elevated and on point, up to now.

(I'm just another poster, here. The only basis for my comment is appreciating the quality of discussion here, and hoping it continues. Thanks.)

P.S. Not sure why the downvotes, but ok. As far as I recall, there are many past cases where the use of URL shorteners has been discouraged.

Somewhat akin to the advice to stick [PDF] in the submission title for links to PDF files. People don't like surprises. Or, in my case, mystery links.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by neuronexmachina on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:25PM (#18250793)
Interesting fact: BPA/epoxy resins are the active component of the thermal paper used in many receipts. Handling BPA paper results in a rise in BPA level in urine detectable after 1 week.

https://cen.acs.org/articles/95/i35/Touching-thermal-paper-r...

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by toomuchtodo on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:37PM (#18250921)
Thermal paper is toxic, and you should avoid handling it whenever possible. It is only a matter of time before it's banned due to its BPA content (which may, fingers crossed, accelerate the advent of digital receipts). DO NOT use hand sanitizer before or after handling thermal paper; it speeds the absorption of BPA.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by King-Aaron on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:11PM (#18253828)
> DO NOT use hand sanitizer before or after handling thermal paper; it speeds the absorption of BPA.

Do you have a source on that? I'm certainly not disputing it. I'm just fascinated.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by toomuchtodo on Friday October 19, 2018 @12:42AM (#18254289)
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by sizzle on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:57PM (#18253956)
This makes me wonder what off the shelf products are disrupting our biochemical pathways and if we should assume everything has the ability to, from home improvement projects to inhaling particles in the air from smoggy city. Any thoughts? This stuff is terrifying to say the least...
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by Regardsyjc on Thursday October 18, 2018 @11:18PM (#18254023)
I recently started reading The Politics of Cancer by Samuel Epstein. It was written in the 1970s and I hope/wish it is outdated because what I've read so far is terrifying. Someone reviewed the book on Amazon as a real life thriller... and they were right. I don't even want to finish the book because it's so depressing.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by bad_user on Thursday October 18, 2018 @12:49PM (#18249899)
> Epoxy resins may very well have created the Diabetes epidemic, with genetic data backing it.

That’s a ridiculous claim. The reason for the diabetes epidemic has much more to do with the increase in sugar consumption than anything else, even if other factors might have contributed, like vegetable oils or the decrease in salt consumption.

Throughout history people have gone to great lengths to exonerate sugar when the evidence is there in plain sight since early 1900s.

No, it’s not the plastics and the diabetes epidemic isn’t that new ;-)

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by gowld on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:31PM (#18250305)
Do you have any comments refuting the science of the article, or is your fiat declaration sufficient to resolve the issue?
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by Alex63 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:25PM (#18250794)
The article makes no claims, scientific of otherwise, with respect to a "diabetes epidemic" and the possible role of plastics.

"A separate study by the University of York in Britain that sought to assess the risks of microplastics to the environment, published Wednesday, concluded not enough is known to determine if microplastics cause harm."

Both comments are expressing opinions that have nothing to do with the content of the article.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by tzs on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:57PM (#18252049)
> The article makes no claims, scientific of otherwise, with respect to a "diabetes epidemic" and the possible role of plastics

Wrong article. You are talking about the submitted article. He's talking about the article cited in subcosmos' comment.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by rhacker on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:51PM (#18251052)
I'm at the point in my life where I treat 99% of studies with a grain of salt. I've seen studies that we've held up for 45 years to be completely toppled. Even studies that are holding in the last 5 years where our current generation is "perfect" and doesn't make the same scientific blunders of yesteryear. Our stories in science classes of how "bad scientists" that ended up being right were killed is no different today. It's just that instead of the king calling for an execution our own subjects dismiss them.

If you watch things carefully in the scientific world you'll notice that there are actually really just a couple people holding up claims and making millions of others follow suit. Even in the face of challenging data, we wait for the so called thought leaders to either embrace or reject the new information. If they reject it, so do the hordes. Yet how do we know these few are willing to take on the new information, and actually take it seriously, especially when so much money might be on the line for them.

Humans keep saying they learn from their mistakes, but we don't as it always looks different. Instead of a king's desk it's now an iPad and online forum.

It really takes generational shifts for our science to move. I think too that the reason pop-science and alternative medicine is so successful is because regular science is too quick to hold the wrong things up - they are holding up people not results. And that's our failure.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by losteric on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:59PM (#18251616)
Your statement reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of the scientific process.

If you watch things carefully in the scientific world, you'll notice every domain has hundreds or thousands of people actively researching in the field. Some individuals are on the cutting edge, they define what is worth researching next (usually by themselves), but the accepted knowledge is based on mountains of research from all over the world.

There are no authority figures. Science is iterative refinement of our understanding of the world through consensus acceptance of research results. I mean, this sentence:

> Yet how do we know these few are willing to take on the new information, and actually take it seriously, especially when so much money might be on the line for them.

is outright hilarious, and depressing, for someone who's done research. Scientists are smart people that care about advancing the frontier of knowledge - revolutionizing a field of research is the most desirable outcome. There is no money behind defending the status quo, because that isn't even science.

Science is the metaphorical tree of knowledge. A solid trunk made of facts like "2+2=4" and "Apples fall off trees", while the cutting edge is unproven branches near the top that may not survive the year... but everyone in the field knows and expects that.

The scientific process underpins every aspect of our modern era. It's how we went from room-sized computers calculating projectile trajectories to smart phones that support multi-player online virtual reality... in a single generation.

> I think too that the reason pop-science and alternative medicine is so successful is because regular science is too quick to hold the wrong things up - they are holding up people not results

Theory 1: Millions of academics across the world are united in a global conspiracy to do bad science

Theory 2: Public education has failed this generation of Americans, and now the free market is just exploiting ignorance with snake oil

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by rhacker on Thursday October 18, 2018 @06:04PM (#18252559)
There is actually nothing wrong with the scientific process, it's great and works. Also everything you're saying about the mountain of information built up by thousands of people is correct to. What I'm talking about is that the mountain is usually under extreme control from a few dictators that provide funding, and basically are the "trolls" of the community that either make vast swathes of research "laughable" or not.

None of that aspect to "science the religion" has anything to do with the scientific process.

By the way, Science, which I hope people recall, has no ability to fully describe the truth - only our best possible guess. That's also written in the scientific process.

Also many people say "because science" and note things like computers and gravity to justify anything related to science that can't possibly be wrong.

Here's a simple thought experiment to help you understand how little we actually are with science and the human body:

Dig up every article and research paper you can on coffee.

Tell me now, for sure, is Coffee Good for you or Bad for you?

That's probably a lot harder to answer than:

Is plastic in Salt Good for you or Bad for you?

And then ask yourself if you drink coffee or drink melted plastic and try to reveal your biases and realize every scientist is doing the same.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by Cogito on Thursday October 18, 2018 @11:18PM (#18254025)
With only a little bit of hyperbole, that's because the question "is Coffee Good for you or Bad for you?" isn't scientific.

At best, science can try to answer the question "Do people, that are very similar to you, perform better on some metric when they drink coffee or don't drink coffee?"

Especially when it comes to food, there are so many variations on what "good or bad" looks like, and what "you" looks like, that we should expect different studies to come to different conclusions they look at different populations, and measure different things.

Even when we try to measure the same thing, on similar populations, it can be really hard to isolate all the important factors. Even then we expect different results.

The problem you are talking about is not a science issue, at least not directly.

It's a Popular Science issue, or at a stretch a Science Communication issue.

Everybody loves a powerful model - a simple description that explains a lot - but those are rare and far between in science. In attempting to reach for new models, such as modelling the effect of coffee on human lives, there is a tendency to take scientific results and reduce them so that they look like a powerful model. Coffee is Good! Coffee is Bad! This process is not science! At best this may spur researchers to test if the model is correct, but more often it's just fuel for press releases, popular science journalists, and social media battles.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by smsm42 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @06:55PM (#18252938)
> Theory 1: Millions of academics across the world are united in a global conspiracy to do bad science

You don't need a conspiracy to do bad science. Just as you don't need a conspiracy to do bad code - and we all on HN know how much of bad code is around. All you need is to write code - with the best of intentions - and to neglect to follow best practices or cut corners from time to time, or just lack experience or foresight to predict potential problems. Sometimes you don't even know it's bad code until you come back to it a couple of years later and stare at it in horror - how could anybody do this?

With code, though, there's an evolutionary pressure acting on it - it is actually meant to be run. If the code does not perform, if it is buggy, if it's insecure or unmaintainable - it creates incentive to be replaced, so some of it dies off and hopefully is replaced with better one (or one bad in different way :). With scientific papers, bad paper can linger around for years until either it obviously contradicts reality in a way making its claims unsustainable, or is refuted by other paper. But for many papers just finding out it is wrong requires doing the same work as the original author did, sometimes more - and the incentives to do that are usually much less prominent.

> The scientific process underpins every aspect of our modern era.

True. But the fact that this process allowed us to achieve much does not mean every part of it is perfect - just as the fact that Facebook has billions does not mean every piece of code running Facebook is great. Some of them is surely terrible.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by module0000 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:45PM (#18251954)
I don't know enough to ask the right question...but do you think there is any type of research being paid for with a specific outcome targeted? Not to break out my tinfoil hat, but the conspiracy theory part of me assumes that pharma/manufacturing companies with the most to lose, would be willing to part with large sums to skew research majorities in their favor.

Like I said I'm mostly ignorant of that domain, and curious what more informed people would say on that topic.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by simonh on Thursday October 18, 2018 @05:20PM (#18252222)
Absolutely science for hire is a real thing and even unconscious bias is dangerous, but the scientific method is based on reproducibility and predictive power. Important results will get tested and picked apart and studied over and over. It might take time to arrive at a really solid conclusion, but the only way we have to fight bias and error is to repeatedly compare our ideas to reality. That’s all science is.

In this case, it seems like a claim that most table salt contains micro plastics should not be a very hard result to refute or reproduce. Usually scientists will avoid making claims that they aren’t really sure of and are easy to disprove.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by felix_nagaand on Thursday October 18, 2018 @05:26PM (#18252281)
The scientific method has been compromised and the proof is in the pudding , so to speak. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Replication_crisis
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by simonh on Saturday October 20, 2018 @03:31AM (#18262214)
There has always been bogus science, since before there was science. The fact is we know there is a replication crisis. How to we know that? By applying the scientific method to try to replicate results.

The replication crisis is an example of science working the way it is supposed to. It’s scientists using the scientific method to call their colleagues to account. It’s just that it takes time.

There’s nothing wrong with the method itself. Make testable claims. Have other people test them. What the replication crisis tells us is we need to do this more, not that we need to do it less or not at all.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by losteric on Thursday October 18, 2018 @05:54PM (#18252494)
In specific fields that have always been regarded as less scientific (social sciences and pharmaceuticals).
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by Retric on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:51PM (#18251997)
Medical research is paid for by people that want a specific outcome. But, they also care about the truth as they don’t want drugs that kill people for example.

Net result a small bias, but not the kind of conspiracy worth talking about.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by losteric on Thursday October 18, 2018 @05:26PM (#18252276)
tobacco/fossil fuel companies come to mind - it's never explicit, but there is nudging to disprove certain claims.

You can see how well it's working - money delayed but did not change the truth.

Science is very difficult to pay off. Individuals can spend another 10 years studying after high school just to get enough responsibility worth bribing... and even if they accepted the bribe, peer review would still reveal the sham research forever tainting their name.

So, yeah, people don't really accept bribes.

The worst you'll see is in pharma, where they're testing drugs - a researcher might select test subjects that will react well to a drug in order to make it look better (hiding side effects).

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by Greenisus on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:17PM (#18251752)
"I treat 99% of studies with a grain of salt"

now with microplastics! :P (sorry, i couldn't help myself)

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by refurb on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:56PM (#18251595)
You have to remember the impact that grant writing has on how scientific findings are shared. Unless the author "spices up" the science, there is a good chance they won't get another grant and their lab will close.

Example: "Levels of plasticizers in urine across the US" - maybe you'll get another grant

Just take your original research, add in a few references to crappy studies that show a "possible link" to diabetes

"Plasticizer exposure possible link to diabetes epidemic" - oh, yeah, you'll get grant now

I know this because I helped write grants.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by sizzle on Thursday October 18, 2018 @11:00PM (#18253968)
This makes me wonder what off the shelf products are disrupting our biochemical pathways and if we should assume everything has the ability to, from home improvement projects to inhaling particles in the air from smoggy city and vaping chemicals. Any thoughts? This stuff is terrifying to say the least...
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by AndyNemmity on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:52PM (#18251062)
There are several books I've read from the 1800s concerning it. I don't know what dictates plain sight, but it was certainly a concept even then.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by crescentfresh on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:41PM (#18250962)
Off topic, but I don't enjoy listening to Carlin. I feel like he must be an acquired taste because he's so loved. He's called the inspiration of many of my own favorite comedians, but when I listen to him to me he sounds like a really smart and insightful/philosophical person....rambling angrily. His sets don't set me up for a tension-breaking punchline like my brain expects.

End ramble.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by erikpukinskis on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:04PM (#18251166)
That makes sense to me. He is from a different time when there was just less audible chaos being pumped into our lives.

You could easily go a whole day without someone throwing a hyper-edited escalating sonic experience at you. Now, after decades of movie trailers one-upping each other and those editing capabilities being distributed to teenagers, we are maximally sonically marinated and we expect some politeness when people are trying to deliver sound bites.

In Carlin’s time watching an act like his was possibly the most exciting verbal experience you would be exposed to that week, if not that year. We cherished the performers who could dial up to 12 without losing coherence because it was rare and exciting.

Now it sounds overblown and maybe a little aggressive to a modern ear.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by twiceaday on Thursday October 18, 2018 @06:58PM (#18252965)
For what its worth, you are describing Carlins newer specials. His career spanned over 40 years. And yeah look at the shift in tone just from the names of his HBO specials

1977 On Location: George Carlin at USC

1978 George Carlin: Again!

1982 Carlin at Carnegie

1984 Carlin on Campus

1986 Playin' with Your Head

1988 What Am I Doing in New Jersey?

1990 Doin' It Again

1992 Jammin' in New York

1996 Back in Town

-------------------------

1999 You Are All Diseased

2001 Complaints and Grievances

2005 Life Is Worth Losing

2008 It's Bad for Ya

If you are interested, check out his older stuff like Carlin on Campus. "A Place for My Stuff" [1] for example.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvgN5gCuLac

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by drblast on Thursday October 18, 2018 @07:49PM (#18253316)
Listen to "Class Clown."

It's an earlier recording and he was extremely mellow and funny.

His later stuff was kinda funny at the time but has not aged well at all comedy-wise IMO.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by strainer on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:36PM (#18251883)
That old Carlin routine - "let species go extinct cause thats what they do / environmentalists aren't interested in saving the environment ..." seems to be presenting these attitudes as words to the wise. I get the feeling most of the audience took it that way. Is that right?
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by pcurve on Thursday October 18, 2018 @08:18PM (#18253443)
"it wanted plastic for itself" never fails to make me laugh. @5:35

"plastic. assholes"

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by i88y6 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:23PM (#18250229)
H2O is deadly in high enough doses.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by hinkley on Thursday October 18, 2018 @12:35PM (#18249758)
Yeah but Carlin also said that us thinking we were powerful enough to cause global warming was pure arrogance.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by mattnewton on Thursday October 18, 2018 @12:45PM (#18249869)
I remember him saying that thinking we were going to save the planet was pure arrogance- we were trying to save ourselves, because “the planet isn’t going anywhere- we are. Pack your shit” He seemed to be pretty supportive of the idea that climate change was man made.

And maybe we ought to rebrand saving the environment as saving our property and arable land and it will resonate more with some skeptics. Because Carlin was right: this rock we call earth will continue orbiting the sun without us, but “we’re f*ed”

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by gowld on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:32PM (#18250316)
That's what the word "environment" means. We aren't trying to saving the Earth for its own sake, we're saving the environment we live in because we need it for our own survival.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by derefr on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:26PM (#18250797)
No, the word for the parts we use is “habitat.”
[dead]
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by dang on Friday October 19, 2018 @12:42PM (#18257955)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News?
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by raws on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:34PM (#18250328)
There's also making sure that we leave a thriving environment when we leave no?
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by bdamm on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:46PM (#18250413)
If we're leaving then leaving a thriving environment would be low on the priority list for anyone. Really the ultimate tragedy of the commons if you think about it... if the problem is so bad that our survival is reduced to zero, then it follows that there is no possible way to make our last act as a species to correct the garden to be some definition of "thriving". The fact is, something will thrive, it just won't be us, no matter what we do. Even nuclear winter will leave survivors that will adapt to the new wasteland.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by hinkley on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:10PM (#18251217)
Leaving is often a euphemism for dying (individually, as in leaving the planet to your successors). I don’t think GP was talking about flying to Alpha Centauri.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by pantalaimon on Thursday October 18, 2018 @08:17PM (#18253432)
Life itself has been pretty resilient when faced with the last couple extinction events.

On a very selfish level I'm pretty fond of human life though.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by twiceaday on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:40PM (#18250375)
He said preventing global warming specifically in the name of “saving the planet” is arrogant. The planet doesn’t care if it has humans. His offence, as usual, was with the wording.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by i88y6 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:25PM (#18250251)
He also thumbed his nose at PTSD. Basically mocking any advancements in understanding it and it's treatment, because "back in WWI they called it shell shock"
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by marnett on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:31PM (#18250298)
That is so far from the point that joke was making. I recommend you listen again. Not only does he not "thumb his nose" at PTSD, he says if we used language that better communicates meaning, such as shell shock instead of 4 letters, people would actually care for vets.

He was a smart man. The world could use another Carlin.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by hinkley on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:15PM (#18251261)
I know I sounded glib in GGP, but that bit about global warming is pretty close to the only thing Carlin said that ever really pissed me off. For a comedian that’s as close to perfect as you can expect.

He is sorely missed.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by Baeocystin on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:04PM (#18251657)
I think you need to listen to those bits again, because he was clearly saying we were going to be screwed by our own actions. ie, yes, we're potentially causing our own demise with global warming. Same with the PTSD one- his point was that adding more euphemisms was not helping those who were/are suffering.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by i88y6 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:00PM (#18250540)
That's not far from "dumb it down". If science has proven a link between all forms of trauma such as accidents or rape, then its worth reflecting that in the name. His skit was a slap in the face to psychology that is actively researching how to help vets and other PTSD sufferers. Hes redirecting the frustrations caused by the disease back at the very community trying to fight it
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by derefr on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:53PM (#18251073)
Words don’t just have textual meaning (where a term can be “inaccurate” or “imprecise”); they also have emotive force.

Carlin’s point was that “shell shock” is more visceral and evocative than “PTSD”, in a way that would be helpful as a rhetorical shield in the hands of its sufferers.

Saying that a rape or accident survivor has “shell shock” communicates by analogy the problem they’re facing, even to laymen who have never experienced such trauma—everyone has seen a war movie where artillery shells are landing all around someone, and most can (if prompted) easily picture what chronic exposure to such a traumatic stressor would do to them. This creates empathy in the minds of laymen who may not understand what was so traumatic about the particular trauma the PTSD suffered encountered.

Whereas saying “they have PTSD” does the opposite—it communicates the symptom without painting a picture of the cause, inviting a layman to minimize the imagined cause.

It’s like saying that someone is a “battered spouse”, vs. “a victim of domestic violence.” The former could have been taken to just mean the latter—non-physical forms of violence and all—but instead, in pursuit of accuracy and precision, an umbrella term that does not evoke a central example is used, and has settled into, more often than not, being mentally interpreted by the listener as implying the least-bad thing that still merits the name.

To put this another way: this is the reason that security vulnerabilities have started getting names like “Heartbleed.” That is an evocative name. CVE-2014-0160? Not so much. More useful to researchers! But less useful as a rhetorical device to communicate the impact of the problem. It’s a PR campaign in support of solving the problem!

Going from “shell shock” to “PTSD” is like going from the named vulnerability to the numerical designation. You’re doing anti-PR, making a buzzword on the tongues of the public into something that’s too much effort to buzz about at all.

Sure, the term might have more diagnostic “clarity.” When in medicine has that ever mattered? Do we name bones or tendons for what they do? No, we just give them ridiculous “legacy” names inherited from some conversation someone had once in 400BCE. Because those names are catchy, in a way that systematic names wouldn’t be.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by dvlsg on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:40PM (#18251929)
I completely agree, but I would also point out that being manipulative by using an evocative name isn't always great by default. Personally, I think it would be beneficial in those cases (shell shock, battered spouse), since dehumanizing suffering is awful at best.

But then names like the "patriot act" also come to mind. Or for something a little closer to home, "anemic domain models".

I suppose appreciating emotive language would depend on whether or not you agree with the purpose behind it.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by derefr on Thursday October 18, 2018 @05:23PM (#18252253)
Definitely.

In this case, I imagine that psychiatrists, as a kind of medical doctors, would generally want to do whatever gets their patients the help and consideration they need. Thus, when they consider naming (or re-naming) a diagnosis, they should probably have that purpose in mind.

PR in general is neither good nor evil. But when people are seeking to do good, they should really make sure that their usage of PR (accidental or otherwise) aligns with their goals.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by StrictDabbler on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:39PM (#18251451)
Carlin's routine is meant to draw attention to the ways that authorities and systems fuck around with words and how, even with the best intentions, these changes gradually benefit the institutions instead of the downtrodden.

Most of Carlin's routines involve ironic hyperbole. He had a bit about how everybody on the road driving faster than you is a maniac and everybody driving slower than you is an idiot.

It's an extremely important bit for understanding his work. Carlin believed that everybody should express their opinion loudly from their own point of view, be aware that a lot of the time those opinions will be wrong, but know that when we do not express those opinions the fuckers always win.

When he shouts that the transition from "shellshock" to "PTSD" has been a tool used for government control he's absolutely right. It was. By making a disease name for it and creating PTSD treatment programs the military could look like it was addressing the problem, where the actual problem was the military using human suffering as a tool to reinforce American political power for economic reasons.

If you told George Carlin "yeah, but rape victims have the same experience, don't we need to include them" he'd probably have told you to call that cock-shock. You'd say "that's gross" and he'd say "rape is gross, the name for what happens after it should be horrible, not clinical".

By saying things like this, Carlin highlights hypocrisies and illusions in our lives and thought processes. Carlin wants to make sure you see what you've forgotten by moving to the new words.

I'm reminded of when Vonnegut pointed out how dangerous it was to move from Armistice Day to Veteran's Day.

"It was during that minute in nineteen hundred and eighteen, that millions upon millions of human beings stopped butchering one another. I have talked to old men who were on battlefields during that minute. They have told me in one way or another that the sudden silence was the Voice of God. So we still have among us some men who can remember when God spoke clearly to mankind.

Armistice Day has become Veterans’ Day. Armistice Day was sacred. Veterans’ Day is not."

Vonnegut doesn't mean that later veterans didn't suffer, that their service is worthless or that their pain shouldn't be noted. He's saying that by including new individuals, the message of the day - that it is horrific to murder millions of people for any reason - has been erased for the good of the military system.

People like Vonnegut and Carlin aren't trying to say things that are correct. They're trying to say things that expose truth. It's very different.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by darkerside on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:50PM (#18251988)
Thanks for an incredible comment. I'm inspired to listen to a ton more Carlin, and go back and re-read some Vonnegut.
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by i88y6 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @06:20PM (#18252674)
Thank you for this reply. I do agree that euphemism creep is a thing. My position is just that his skit on this particular topic seemed very anti-intellectual. It's the same kind of bogus logic used when people who say "just get over it" to someone with serious depression: "back in my day, we just kept a stiff upper lip (meanwhile ignoring all those between now and then who blew their brains out because their lip strategy failed) ".

I do agree that in most cases the language can be contorted to conceal or smooth the direct adjective. I.e African American, minority, margininalized, etc

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by romwell on Thursday October 18, 2018 @08:14PM (#18253423)
>My position is just that his skit on this particular topic seemed very anti-intellectual. It's the same kind of bogus logic ...

It really is not; just like others here, I would urge you to go back and re-watch that skit, having in mind that others do not perceive it the way you do. There's nothing more to add to the parent post.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by i88y6 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @11:43PM (#18254101)
The downvote is not a "disagree button". Grow up
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by dang on Friday October 19, 2018 @12:34PM (#18257893)
Could you please not post uncivil and/or unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? We ban accounts that do that, because we're trying to keep this site a bit better than default level.

Also, downvoting for disagreement has always been ok on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16131314.

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by gowld on Thursday October 18, 2018 @01:34PM (#18250326)
No he didn't. He thumbed his known at euphemisms that hide the truth.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSp8IyaKCs0

Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by i88y6 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @02:03PM (#18250588)
Not all war PTSD is caused from "shells". So to use his logic, unless your flashbacks and hyper awareness (oops those are newfangled psychological terms, guess they have to be dumbed down right?) are caused by the use of mortar shells, then any other use of that term is disingenuous, right?
Re:Microplastics found in 90 percent of table salt by newen on Thursday October 18, 2018 @03:10PM (#18251220)
His argument was that the term PTSD is euphemistic. Not that terms should be hyperaccurate. Shell shock recalls weapons amd war while PTSD calls to mind vague "trauma". It's a term that is a step away from what it actually is.