If Evan can't show that he has the discipline to lead a company at this stage of it's life in the public market then the board should absolutely give him the boot in the next 24 months.
I think the narrative of "product visionary" has been spun a bit too hard by the tech media and it likely has gotten to his head.
He also took a $500mm bonus for successfully executing the IPO at a time when the company lost over $700mm in 2017. That's not a great look - but I digress.
Very funny, Snapchat has two classes of stock and he owns enough of the kind that matters that no one can oust him. I looked through the S-1 when they were going public and decided owning the shares they were selling to the public was the equivalent of a "board observer" seat. You are free to watch him run his company, but it is still his company
https://www.recode.net/2017/2/21/14670314/snap-ipo-stock-vot...
Why do people buy common shares which give them no voting rights as a shareholder?
Sure while company is minting money (or debt and marketshare) you can find a greater fool to offload your shares.
However when things turn the Zynga way, what recourse do you have with these no vote shares?
At least Bond holders and Preferred Shareholders have certain rights.
PS Then there are the Chinese stocks such as BABA where you do not even own the assets of the main company but I digress..
For many decades, the New York Stock Exchange refused to list stocks that had multiple classes of stock, except for a few companies such as Ford Motor that were grandfathered in. But they no longer have enough clout to make that stick.
Google and Facebook got away with it because they were highly profitable before the IPO. Snap was not like that.[1] They went public while still losing money, and with way too high a valuation. It's been all downhill since the IPO.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/robertberger/2017/03/07/snapcha...
So basically, we'll see it with the companies that are profitable at the time of their ipo's, but we won't see it with the companies that are unprofitable, (and maybe even losing money), at the time of their ipo's.
Sounds to me like the future Facebooks and Googles of the world will continue to set up structures like these. Before anyone jumps down my throat, I'm not complaining. I know, it's the founder's company. I get that. I'm free not to invest if I don't like the terms. I just wanted to point out that HN User "Animats'" conclusion that founders will choose this structure less and less is flawed. It really does seem to me that this structure is just going to be more and more of a reality in the future for any of the startups that are actually worth buying into. (ie - Any of the startups that actually make money.)
In the end, the founders of the winning companies don't want their money or power diluted.
Because you believe in the people who have the voting rights?
Let's get real here: for those of us buying stock with voting rights, we don't really have voting rights. The proportion we have is so vanishingly small it's the same as not having voting rights in the first place.
A bicameral congress most certainly does not disqualify the entire system from being considered a democracy.
There are 700,000 people in Washington DC. They have zero senators. There are over 3 million people in Puerto Rico. They also have zero senators.
Because they trust the founders to protect the long-term interests of the company more than activist investors trying to maximize short-term profit?
Also why are there two kind of shares?
However, financial security is not the only thing you need in life to be happy.
It has, and not only for this guy. Like the GP says, success in these things is more luck than anything else, like "vision".
I had to experience it and I think it's actually one of the greatest dangers in startups.
So part of that $700mm loss was his bonus? Meaning if he hadn't taken a bonus the loss would "only" be $200mm?
Snap posted a $2.2B loss in Q1 of 2017, it's first quarter as a public company. A lot of that was one-time stock payout to various employees, including a massive bonus to Spiegel which was 3% of Snap worth roughly ~$550mm at the time. If you take out all the one time stock compensation from that quarter, the loss comes out to $188mm.
Here's a Recode article with some sources: https://www.recode.net/2017/5/10/15617740/snapchat-two-billi...
The $700mm loss figure I initially stated for 2017 is likely the loss figure with the one-time stock expenses deducted: https://investor.snap.com/news-releases/2018/02-06-2018-2116...
This stock award made Evan Spiegel the highest paid CEO in America in 2017, that's the kicker.
He just received a massive bonus in $ value. It was massive because it was lots of Snapchat stock back when it was expensive.
Although it’s quite normal to sell such stock award as soon as they vest, in this case it looks bad.
Most of Apple's biggest successes were had by coming up with something completely new and novel, not by ignoring user feedback when iterating on an existing product.
One could say the same about Snapchat's astronomical success in its early days...
It was an iterative improvement on the Blackberry.
Edit, it's true the co-founders were in a dorm room and came up with an idea for girls to securely send nudes. There is a reason it is commonly referred to as snachchat.
Admitting part of their success was luck is tantamount to admitting "I went from nothing to a billionaire because the dice came up right."
I don't know many people who would be comfortable truly accepting that. And even fewer who could do so AND be the type of driven person necessary. All while everyone around you is looking to you for answers.
This is because the introduction of such a data driven mentality meant the only people empowered to suggest decisions or experiments or approve the work were all in marketing. Because they were basically deciding what workload they wanted and of course you won’t put more on your plate if you don’t have to.
This isn’t to say it’s about data vs. vision. The original success is usually created in large part due to a healthy collaboration between the visionaries, the engineers, and whoever else is in the mix. Once you take one part of the team out of the equation and tend too heavily towards a particular bias then you might well have lost the secret to the initial success.
You can just as easily A/B your company to death.
A/B usual represents an incremental comparison from one situation to another, and it helps 'walk down the feature path' ... but when you need to change paths, A/B testing is not going to help, this is where a bit of great PM talent is going to work.
Moreover, the more subtle the change, or more the basis' are not very comparable (two different apps), the less A/B has value.
For example: Snap was considered 'too complicated' for many users, they needed to make it simpler. But by doing so, they may alienate a bunch of current users, with the objective of making the app more amenable to the masses. This is a serious strategic issue. They might have gone about it somewhat differently but it's a difficult thing to do in any case, and they had to make changes.
The existential issue for Snap's problems is not this app change, it's the fact that all of Facebook's products are trying to eat them. Instagram, WhatsApp, Messenger etc ... these are the real threats.
Perhaps Snapchat as it exists now would've taken off just the same, but because the new version represents such a jarring departure from the old, it flops.
A better example of this might be Microsoft keeping the Start Menu for over 20 years. While some cheered for its demise, most users decried the change at the time.
That said, the problems with Snapchat as it exists today run far deeper than merely disrupting people's existing habits, so it's not the best example. Personally I think the app is now poorly-engineered trash. Nonetheless, the notion is an interesting one to at least consider, if only in an abstract sense.
Many possible changes have positive effects short term, but negative or even disastrous effects long term. A/B tests won't ever run long enough to discover these long term costs. When A/B facts displace common sense instead of it complementing it, you can a/b yourself into your own grave.
It's generally assumed that with advertising, more time == more money, but even that's somewhat questionable.
In a B2B context, time spent per day cut in half sounds like a huge productivity boost. Of course, it could also be that you've made it so difficult to use now that people do a little bit, export to CSV and then use some other tool. But the data won't tell you that.
That's a strong lesson I've learned in life. Successful people _rarely_ know the precise reasons that they are successful, almost exactly for this reason.
You may be aware of many of the components of your success, but you won't be aware of all of them and it will be impossible for you to rank their importance correctly.
Keep this in mind when successful people talk about their success and offer suggestions on how to replicate it.
It is however still a merit that somebody raises it. It's probably the biggest Elephant in the room that there ever was. Especially if you are born in the third-world slums paying rent to the slumlord.
Reminiscent of Digg v4.
Perfectly stated. "Pivoting from something shiny to an actual business plan" should be SV CEO's prime skill.
I genuinely believe the best path forward for Snapchat is to completely reset back to pre-redesign as a way of making amends to all the users that left, and then re-designing again from there with their new focus.
Once a company gets to this level, they need to recognize the role that luck played into their original product and design. They hit a resonance with people, and it was probably more luck and timing than anything else. Changes to that core product need to be treated as an experiment and conducted as such. Show some discipline.
You can still innovate but those ideas should be made to stand on their own, grow on their own. Just because you have control over a platform with millions of users and can make changes doesn’t automatically mean you can do no wrong at this point. It just means you will have more time and resources before those mistakes take you out of the game completely.
He should be punished for his mistakes by the board installing some experienced adult supervision for a while until he shows he can fix his current mess (reverse negative growth) and innovate in at least an additional major product category tangential to Snap. If he can’t do that in the next 24 months, he should step down for the good of the company.