News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by kgroll on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:18PM (#1812884)
I'm definitely not suggesting that Facetime is, or will be, a failure.

Thinking about it, however, reminded me of a passage from Infinite Jest about the failure of video chat.

(1) It turned out there there was something terribly stressful about visual telephone interfaces that hadn’t been stressful at all about voice-only interfaces. Videophone consumers seemed suddenly to realize that they’d been subject to an insidious but wholly marvelous delusion about conventional voice-only telephony.

...

EDIT: Instead of that wall of text, here's a link to the rest of that passage. Sorry about that. http://stevereads.com/weblog/2010/06/07/iphone-4-facetimeinf...

Re:Facetime for the Mac by ugh on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:00PM (#1813952)
Video chat it not the next big thing. It’s not telephony only better. It’s not instant messaging only better. It’s not telegraphy only better.

Video chat is merely a different way of communicating that might be useful in certain, even rare, cases. I actually think that Apple’s ads do a great job of capturing what those use cases might be. They are somewhat kitschy but they at least don’t suggest that video chat might be useful for, say, restaurant reservations.

Telephones are awesome. They get most any job you throw at them done with ease. Why would anyone go through all the trouble of buying expensive stuff and setting all that technology up and then paying much more just to get a grainy stuttering picture?

That was the situation until only a few years ago. If you want people to actually use video chat in those rare instances when it’s appropriate you have to make it really frictionless. Skype does a great job at that and I think Apple is also doing quite well, at least if they can increase interoperability in the future.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by commieneko on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:07PM (#1813315)
Facetime, and video-phony in general, fits into a continuum of communication strategies. When you want to _see_ someone, you video them. When you only want to hear them, you audio them. When you don't want to hear them you text them.

Then there's the whole time-shifting thingie. What I would like now is the video equivalent of an email, voice mail, or text message. I _could_ record a video, and email it, but...

Re:Facetime for the Mac by jbrennan on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:16PM (#1813719)
I agree, FaceMail or something would be incredibly nice, especially as I'm not always available to answer a video call, but would still like to see what's up eventually.

I guess it would be used like like YouTube, only privately. That is, often you see an event and video record it for sharing with others. FaceTime would let you share this live, and leaving a message seems a natural progression.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by astrange on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:13PM (#1813538)
I really don't understand why people quote fiction in support of a statement about real life. This seems to happen a lot with Mad Men, for instance. How are you supposed to know the author knows what he's talking about, except that he vaguely agrees with you?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by olefoo on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:23PM (#1813871)
One of the functions of fiction is to hold a mirror up to reality. To allow the user to imagine themselves in a novel, or impossible situation, to inform their emotional perceptions. To live through a scenario in play rather than to face it for the first time in reality.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by awakeasleep on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:38PM (#1813418)
I think about that passage all the time when I'm enjoying myself enormously during a video chat with my lil brother or girlfriend.

I think DFW was either talking about awkward video chat technology of the era, or simply trying to make a prediction.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by fredleblanc on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:22PM (#1812601)
We just downloaded it and tried it (bringing my total Facetime experiences to two, both of which occurred about 10 feet from the person on the other end). The interface is more iOS-y than normal for OS X. The picture quality was pretty good (the Mac being wired, iPhone 4 being wireless of course).

Simple to use, pretty good stuff.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by lukifer on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:18PM (#1812579)
Is there a reason they couldn't have just folded this feature into iChat?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by jws on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:07PM (#1813106)
It's not an enhanced chat. It is the trojan program that may make a go at replacing telephony. What happens when they add:

• audio only facetime.

• the ability to audio only facetime with people on telephones.

Facetime is then an open system for contacting people on a wide variety of devices with graceful fallback to even simple telephones. It becomes 1st choice and total minutes used of voice telephony dwindles.

§

Or not. Apple is comfortable putting a product in place and waiting to see if it is a goer or not. Apple TV has been sitting around for years waiting for favorable licensing. It might be getting close, or maybe not.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by mthoms on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:26PM (#1814027)
>Facetime is then an open system

I'm a big Apple fan but feel I would have to turn in my nerd credentials if I failed to point out that you just used the "o" word to describe an Apple product (without qualifying it) :-)

Re:Facetime for the Mac by johns on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:22PM (#1812600)
I'm guessing so they can do a Windows client with a consistent UI.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by bkhl on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:48PM (#1812746)
I rather have it separately because I rarely open my iChat. Adium FTW :)
Re:Facetime for the Mac by jbrennan on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:20PM (#1813731)
Curious, what do you like so much about Adium? I find it quite the abomination in terms of user experience (ex the Preferences).

iChat is a breath of fresh air by comparison.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by bkhl on Thursday October 21, 2010 @03:44AM (#1814630)
iChat doesn't support accounts other than AIM and MobileMe, does it? I haven't really checked the updates on iChat for awhile so it might have been updated since the last time I tried to use it. User experience wise..it doesn't bother me at all, or I can't remember the last time I got annoyed by Adium. Also, the customizable (with a lot of external themes that you can download) layout of the buddy list and the chat windows are quite amazing.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by jbrennan on Thursday October 21, 2010 @01:01PM (#1816369)
iChat supports Google Chat (natively and also all jabber, too).
Re:Facetime for the Mac by bkhl on Friday October 22, 2010 @06:07PM (#1821715)
How about MSN Messenger and Facebook? (Don't have my mbp with me at the moment to check)
Re:Facetime for the Mac by e1ven on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:26PM (#1812618)
I wish they had-

It loses several major features of iChat sharing- Screensharing, replaceable backgrounds, Multi-person chat...

Re:Facetime for the Mac by masklinn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:24PM (#1812914)
> It loses several major features of iChat sharing

Good news: if you're chatting with an other mac, iChat still exists, it's not been removed.

> Screensharing

Wouldn't work between an iPhone and a mac

> replaceable backgrounds

Terrible feature

> Multi-person chat...

Might yet be reintroduced.

Even if it were folded in iChat, those features would not be available there.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by lukifer on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:36PM (#1812677)
Reminds me of Quicktime 7 vs. Quicktime X: I end up having to use both, since X is a better player, but 7 is a better casual editor.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by johns on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:41PM (#1812710)
Which are all features that would ruin FaceTime.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by roc on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:38PM (#1812975)
Except multi-person chat. That's right up its alley but probably just isn't feasible for the mobile users, bandwidth-wise.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by e1ven on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:45PM (#1812728)
How so? Honestly? Why would it ruin Facetime, but not ruin iChat?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by johns on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:46PM (#1812735)
I bet there are already more non-geek users of FaceTime than iChat because it's so approachable. Adding features like those caters to the wrong audience. The beauty of FaceTime is its simplicity.

(This sounds like an Apple fanboy thing to say, but I'm really not.)

Re:Facetime for the Mac by slantyyz on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:56PM (#1812793)
I would also say using iChat also dilutes the FaceTime brand.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by derefr on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:23PM (#1812912)
In the event video, the FaceTime icon had replaced the iChat icon's traditional position on the dock.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by bradgessler on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:08PM (#1813318)
The only thing I'd want extra is absolutely rock-solid multi-user audio/video chat. I'm talking more reliable than Skype, which is not easy to beat.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by mikedanko on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @10:58PM (#1814101)
I was laying in bed and for whatever reason it just smacked me in the face. Yes, there's a reason, and I was reminded of an anecdote regarding blackberries being served in the lobby to the press.

iChat is a presence and messaging framework that's completely ad hoc. The server frameworks don't do anything but presence and messaging.

Not so with Facetime. Apple just aimed a loaded gun at RIM, Avaya, and Ericsson today, and Facetime is the proof of concept. Verizon on the iPad was cocking the hammer. Apple has just shown the world that it has full enterprise communication stack integration from LDAP to device and more importantly the network in-between... and that network in between has a lot of control. Apple needs these guys a lot.

Submitting the protocol stack to the IETF is a win with consumers, but I'm sure that RIM, Ericsson, etc., are seeing this as spit on the face and more to the point it's probably why the guy at RIM completely lost his cool last week.

Apple is going at the enterprise in a remarkable manner, and probably the only way they could have.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by meelash on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:52PM (#1812772)
I'm thinking because it's not using AIM or any chat server, seems like the backend is new, run by Apple, and dedicated solely to this.

If I were to predict the future, I'd say iChat will probably stagnate feature-wise, and the features that they want to keep will be migrated to facetime.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by jmreid on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:31PM (#1812646)
It's based on whole new video standards. It's not compatible with the existing setup and would have been hard to integrate for a beta.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by johns on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:40PM (#1812702)
Are you speculating or do you know that for a fact?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:21PM (#1812895)
FaceTime is based on numerous technologies:

    * H.264 and AAC – video and audio codecs respectively
    * SIP – IETF signaling protocol for VoIP
    * STUN, TURN and ICE – IETF technologies for traversing firewalls and NAT
    * RTP and SRTP – IETF standards for delivering real-time and encrypted media streams for VoIP
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facetime

Sounds very similar to iChat videoconferencing, which also uses h.264, AAC, SIP, RTP and SRTP. The only difference I could find is in the way iChat traverses firewalls and NAT, which it does via SNATMAP.

http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1507

Re:Facetime for the Mac by johns on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:21PM (#1812900)
I wasn't contending that. I was wondering if the commenter had an knowledge that integration was difficult.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by jmreid on Friday October 22, 2010 @02:32PM (#1820849)
I guess I mean that FaceTime doesn't support all the iChat features and would be hard to just fit into iChat. Not to mention iChat is based around buddy lists, AIM service (or Jabber) and FaceTime uses your address book, push notification server, etc.

You can't screen share, file share, or multi-person video chat in FaceTime. It would be confusing to users if FaceTime was just tacked onto iChat as is.

It just makes more sense to have it be a standalone beta.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by metageek on Thursday October 21, 2010 @09:34AM (#1815283)
They could have created FaceTime to be compatible in the first place.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by jmreid on Friday October 22, 2010 @02:34PM (#1820856)
Maybe they don't want it to be compatible.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by alexophile on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:36PM (#1812671)
My understanding is that that may be the end result, but this is a beta, so it's on its own for now.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by citricsquid on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:19PM (#1812581)
it's not REVOLUTIONARY then, is it?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by bkyle on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:38PM (#1812690)
Revolutionary: no. Magical: yes.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by neovive on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:59PM (#1813064)
Facetime could become a strong competitor to Skype once a Windows client is available as the UI seems very polished and well "integrated". Now only if my parents had a Mac so I can test it out. They always seem to have issues getting video chat working on Skype/Windows.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by moe on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:24PM (#1813169)
Not really.

Skype is strong in businesses. In the office-setting people first and foremost use the text-chat, then the audio calls, then the conference calls. Video calls come dead last. I wouldn't be surprised if even desktop sharing is used more than the video feature.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by alphabeat on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:07PM (#1813690)
The desktop sharing of skype has a long way to go to be used seriously. I can only assume from your comment that you haven't used it. They may have their audio codec down, and the video codec works for live video, but not for content. It's the same deal with JPEG for text for instance.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by pohl on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @09:12PM (#1813853)
In our office we use any old jabber client for text chat, telephones for audio & conference calls, and only resort to Skype for video calls.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by callmeed on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:05PM (#1813100)
I was actually thinking today that Apple should buy Skype ... recalling the recent post about Apple buying Facebook, I think Skype would be a better fit.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by bobx11 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:36PM (#1812674)
called the wife from the mac to her iphone... she didn't know the difference. later she called me back on facetime to the pc and it just popped up - overall not bad!
Re:Facetime for the Mac by philwelch on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @02:50PM (#1812384)
Accounts are tied to the email address on your Apple ID. Interesting way of getting around having to create another IM account.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by e1ven on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:04PM (#1812487)
It's also portable to when there is a version of FaceTime for Android/etc. They had originally claimed it to be an open standard.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by glhaynes on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:15PM (#1812562)
Yeah, has there been any progress on publishing specs?
[deleted]
Re:Facetime for the Mac by mikedanko on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:56PM (#1812794)
Are you sure? That seems to be nothing but delivery of transport streams over HTTP and suggests nothing of negotiating calls ala SIP.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by alexophile on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:07PM (#1812831)
My bad - that was for HTTP Live Streaming. FTTM.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by mikedanko on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:03PM (#1813091)
According to the presentation, it's supposed to be made a standard. I'm assuming this would hit the IETF's Audio/Video transport working group, so that'd be where to keep a lookout.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:34PM (#1812658)
Nope.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:50PM (#1813021)
"It's also portable to when there is a version of FaceTime for Android/etc. They had originally claimed it to be an open standard."

Android 3.0 (Gingerbread) is rumored to gain support for the same protocol used in the desktop version of Google Talk: Jingle. Jingle sounds a lot like FaceTime, I wouldn't be surprised if the two are compatible.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jingle_%28protocol%29

No word from Apple so far, but I recall them saying that they would share the code with whoever wants to implement it, which isn't quite the same as open sourcing it.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by irons on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:23PM (#1813369)
The sticky wicket isn't the protocols used to schlep the video, it's the session initiation. Apple's mapping phone numbers (for iPhones) and email addresses (for iPods and now Macs) to a central hub to initiate calls. That's how the FaceTime Mac application launches when someone initiates a call to my email address; on iOS I presume it uses push notifications.

Open-sourcing the protocol doesn't solve the integration issue, and Apple hasn't said anything publicly about letting third parties join this particular sandbox.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by _b8r0 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:51PM (#1813252)
Pending ping integration?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by dmpatierno on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:45PM (#1813005)
My favorite feature of FaceTime for the Mac: it stays full screen even when you tab away to do work on another monitor.

FaceTime is now my preferred video conferencing software.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by pluies on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:10PM (#1813117)
Why set the minimum OS to Snow Leopard? That sounds a bit of a far-fetched requirement for some videoconferencing software.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by g_lined on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:06PM (#1813515)
My guess is that it uses some newer APIs which were introduced in 10.6. This may be because they wanted to use Grand Central Dispatch (better multi-core support), a later addition to Core Graphics or simply an API which gave their GUI the more iOS feel compared to the GUI elements in 10.5.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by rantfoil on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:15PM (#1813141)
Forced obsolescence.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by eli on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:55PM (#1812790)
It would be exciting if I'm proven wrong, but I'm not buying the hype about video chat.

Even if/when I'm able to video chat anyone from my iPhone without being on wifi, I still don't imagine it being terribly useful. And the few times I've tried using video chat in a business setting have not been very fruitful.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by gurraman on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:48PM (#1813645)
Video chat is just one of those nice-to-haves in my opinion.

I work remotely a lot and always choose audio chat over video chat. Video chatting, in that context, just doesn't add anything for me.

Video chat was great when my girlfriend was living abroad for a couple of months though!

Re:Facetime for the Mac by jw84 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:16PM (#1812871)
I work in a startup in SF. I've been using video chat for awhile. We go out of our way to find good quality stable video chat solutions. Everyone on our floor of startups use video chat.

People not able to video chat with us are now equal to people asking us to fax something in.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by rflrob on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:09PM (#1812535)
"the call rings through on every Mac you own, even if face time isn't running"

Does this sound just a little too intrusive to anyone else?

Re:Facetime for the Mac by ynniv on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:13PM (#1812555)
Have you heard of a telephone? Do you know how they work?

You can turn it off in the preferences.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by Samuel_Michon on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:17PM (#1813145)
You just made me laugh out loud, which I rarely do while sitting at a computer. I honestly thought rflrob's comment made a lot of sense, until I read yours.

I have to say though: I absolutely loathe doorbells and ringing phones, they stress me out. Ideally, my doorbell would have a vibrate mode, making the floor gently purr.

Re:Facetime for the Mac by glhaynes on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:14PM (#1812559)
You can toggle it on or off individually per device, they just mean the FaceTime app itself doesn't have to be "open".
Re:Facetime for the Mac by rbanffy on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:34PM (#1812662)
So, it's actually running. You just can't see it.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by ben1040 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:53PM (#1812778)
Yep -- looks like it's got a push listener running in the background, even though FaceTime isn't running.

    $ ps ax | grep FaceTime
    5317   ??  S      0:00.38 /Applications/FaceTime.app/Contents/PrivateFrameworks/IMCore.framework/imagent.app/Contents/MacOS/imagent
    5318   ??  S      0:00.25 /Applications/FaceTime.app/Contents/Frameworks/ApplePushService.framework/apsd-ft
Re:Facetime for the Mac by nico on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @07:08PM (#1813524)
I just wish there was a Facetime API.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by todd3834 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:05PM (#1813097)
I like the icon. I am really glad to see they didn't go the same direction as the new iTunes icon.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by thought_alarm on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @04:42PM (#1812989)
Judging from this FaceTime app and the new iLife apps, it looks like there will be all sorts of new iOS-like UI goodies for Cocoa 10.7 developers to use.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by hasenj on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:05PM (#1812500)
Is this different from yahoo messenger's video calls?
Re:Facetime for the Mac by swilliams on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:06PM (#1812506)
In that you can video chat with someone with the proper iOS device.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by zacharycohn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:09PM (#1812528)
iPhone <--> Desktop
Re:Facetime for the Mac by pt on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:26PM (#1813172)
Both have platform limitations at this time:

Facetime: iPhone <--> Mac

Yahoo Messenger : iPhone <--> PC

Re:Facetime for the Mac by contol-m on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @08:13PM (#1813706)
Nope. Yahoo Messenger video chat works on a Mac as well.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by zacharycohn on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @05:56PM (#1813282)
Sorry, I guess the implied "mac" part of "Desktop" didn't come across.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by eddieplan9 on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @02:35PM (#1812249)
Unfortunately, it mistakenly points to iWork 09 trial download for now.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by philfreo on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:00PM (#1812471)
First 2 times it didn't work, then I got it: http://appldnld.apple.com/FaceTime/061-9589.20101020.Mbgt5/F...
Re:Facetime for the Mac by tptacek on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @02:46PM (#1812343)
Use the bottom download button; it works.
Re:Facetime for the Mac by CharlesPal on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @02:56PM (#1812434)
Use the bottom link. The top link is pointing to iWork 09
Re:Facetime for the Mac by ceejayoz on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @03:11PM (#1812545)
Can't get it to connect. @SteveStreza reports his doesn't work on a wired connection at all.