> It loses several major features of iChat sharing
Good news: if you're chatting with an other mac, iChat still exists, it's not been removed.
> Screensharing
Wouldn't work between an iPhone and a mac
> replaceable backgrounds
Terrible feature
> Multi-person chat...
Might yet be reintroduced.
Even if it were folded in iChat, those features would not be available there.
Reminds me of Quicktime 7 vs. Quicktime X: I end up having to use both, since X is a better player, but 7 is a better casual editor.
Which are all features that would ruin FaceTime.
Except multi-person chat.
That's right up its alley but probably just isn't feasible for the mobile users, bandwidth-wise.
How so? Honestly? Why would it ruin Facetime, but not ruin iChat?
I bet there are already more non-geek users of FaceTime than iChat because it's so approachable. Adding features like those caters to the wrong audience. The beauty of FaceTime is its simplicity.
(This sounds like an Apple fanboy thing to say, but I'm really not.)
I would also say using iChat also dilutes the FaceTime brand.
In the event video, the FaceTime icon had replaced the iChat icon's traditional position on the dock.
Re:Facetime for the Mac
by bradgessler on Wednesday October 20, 2010 @06:08PM
(#1813318)
The only thing I'd want extra is absolutely rock-solid multi-user audio/video chat. I'm talking more reliable than Skype, which is not easy to beat.
It loses several major features of iChat sharing- Screensharing, replaceable backgrounds, Multi-person chat...