The ubiquity of US dollars in international trade allows US to torpedo the economy of any country it so desires. It is like the US has a kill switch to shut down any economy it wishes to. But the only reason the rest of the world plays along and allows the kill switch to exist is that they trust the US to use it responsibly and only in extreme circumstances. Now with the erosion of that trust, it is to be expected for the world to move towards eliminating that threat.
And that's exactly why this is necessary. The above is only cool if you're part of the ~5% of the world that is American.
I'd contend that holding a basket of currencies is even more stable and reliable. Basic diversification logic would suggest that a basket of USD / EUR / GBP / AUD / CAD / NOK is safer than just USD.
But it's true that the advent of Trump makes the bullying more difficult to accept because it's now absurd and incoherent; if some other powers unite and find a way to resist the bullying, then at least some good will have come out of trumpism.
In the grand scheme of things I'm also happy the rest of the world seems to be becoming less dependent on the US. It removes single point of failure scenarios. Economies and nations keeping each other more at arm's reach would help ensure the world acts in a more democratic fashion while simultaneously also providing insulation against the failing of any given nation's poor decisions - be those social, political, economic, or military.
This is completely ahistorical. You're describing the "balance of power" system that governed international relations and we know what happened: hundreds of years of European wars culminating in two world wars.
All our current system of relations has done is turn US into the world's final word on everything. This creates more of an autocratic than a democratic system of world relations. That Saudi Arabia sits on UN human rights council, chairing their advisory committee (which chooses appointed 'independent experts') speaks to how functioning our international institutions are. They are a little more than a proxy for US influence. I do not think any single government should have such a unilateral influence on the happenings of the world.
Europe has a lot more to loose on an unstable Iran than the US and can't risk deals being undone because the US has a new regime every 4 years.
2 wrestlers fight for some good amount of time. When they're tired enough, a 3rd wrestler gets in and beats both.
That was World War II for the most part. After World War II, most of the world was destroyed except for the US.
After the war, the US never left. Overseas bases still exist in Germany, Japan and many other places.
They had everyone adopt a financial system (Bretton Woods) which was largely abused making the US absurdly rich for a few decades... highways, higher education for a bunch of people, space exploration, absurd wars thousands of miles away, a gigantic navy and air force, you name it.
After other countries realized it was a scam (aka "exorbitant privilege"), this golden era ended and the US started to slowly meet reality, rapidly accumulating debt.
The inevitable fate of the US is to collapse in the same way the Soviet Union did in 1989. This will likely happen before 2050 and you read it first in the comments section of HN.
Once the US collapses, the Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance will be worthless and South America will be taken apart in a giant pinata party starting by the Argentinean Patagonia.
While the final phase took several years, USSR collapsed in 1991. 1989 was de-facto collapse of Warsaw Pact (Berlin Wall).
I lived in USSR/Russia back then, and for the last almost 2 decades i've been living in the US. While a bunch of things went downhill during that time here, the US and USSR doesn't even come close. Specifically, in major part the USSR collapse was due to lowest (at least among developed countries) productivity of its economy, from agriculture to high-tech. The country basically ran out of food. Compare that to the US where economic productivity, from agriculture to high-tech is among highest in the world. Granted, the current administration seems to be hell-bent on doing as much damage to the US economy as possible, yet i think the US economy will be in pretty good shape even after those 6 more years that Trump is going to spend in the office (the damage he is going to do in the next 2 years wouldn't be enough for his electorate to trim their enthusiasm).
The US is largely living beyond its means at the moment and this situation is not sustainable in the long term.
And this isn't even me being a jingoistic American, I was born in Canada.
When someone wants to know how americans currently think and look like, then they just take a look at their current president. /s
"It's weird to think that the actions of the few who wield the most - but not the majority - of the power in the US are talked about as if they are the US."
Sometimes, we narrow this down; we say, the X administration. But is that accurate? Does it convey the emotional reality?
Maybe we should say; [Person], acting in their duty as [Role] on behalf of the US, has [action].
But, does this have the inevitable effect of distancing those people from the country that has given them power?
More than half the voting-power of the US voted for Trump, and some portion of that power is then invested in these decisions; at the same time, less than half the voting-power of the US voted for trump, and some portion of that power is then disinvested in those decisions.
It's almost like we need different words to describe the national entity when that entity is democratic than the words we inherited from monarchies.
Maybe we take a page from swarms - perhaps instead of "The US imposed sanctions", we say, "From the US emerged sanctions", or, "Those empowered by the US imposed sanctions". But, none of these use as few words as: "the US did X". Brevity wins.
1.) Do nothing. Poland, and the parts of Germany that used to be East Germany, might not like the long term consequences of this plan.
2.) Start a nuclear war, killing hundreds of millions of people. A few disadvantages to this plan as well.
3.) Economic sanctions. You can certainly say this will kill people by way of depressing GDP growth. Will it kill fewer people than a full nuclear exchange between the US and Russia?
|US invasions| >> |Russia invasions|
But maybe it is because of the difference in GDP: |US invasions| / GDP ~= |Russia invasions| / GDP4) The democratic way: ask people in this "another" country and if the opinions split then restructure it: either convert it peacefully into two countries (like Czechoslovakia) or confederation/federation.
Both of these are the best exports of American influence and require the US to be at the center of all things financial.
That was all nice and fine. Unfortunately it's no more sustainable with a president, who can kill a country's economy with an early morning twitter tantrum.
With Trump, it is clear that he only wants to exercise such power without considering the consequences of it.
With the trust towards US fading, in and out of West, a complimentary mechanism will be created. US will control/influence where its hard power can still reach, but not beyond.
True, but they're also starting to think seriously about building storm shelters for the next time a storm blows through.
The data is pretty clear on this, it does not lead to regimn change or whatever else the country wants.
Now people will claim that the Iran deal is a counterexample, but it is not. I was the US who realied that their sanction had no effect on the nuclear program was going fast. The US then compromised even more.
The US is very good at making sanctions, but bad at removing them.
The way the do it in the Iran case is directly and clearly against all the international laws the US claims to stand for.
Its a sad state of affairs when Iran observes international law and the US spits on it.
Trump shouldn't have pulled out of the Iran deal, but preserving that power for the future is more important.
Here's a good article about OFAC, the Treasury Department group that handles sanctions:
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-sanctions-insight-idU...