Most interestingly are the justifications for these things. Widespread ANPR means it's easy to find people who are driving their cars without MOT, VED and insurance. People without those are liabilities to us all, so we don't want them on the road, right?
It's just a happy coincidence that the security services also get to monitor more and more movement in the country.
I wish they'd fund health and social care with as much enthusiasm.
The problem is not so much the _initial_ justification. It's the inevitable "control creep" [1]. When something bad happens, they'll just go "hey we have this vast surveillance network in place, why don't we just re-use it for XYZ". That is the fundamental reason why people need to be so vigilant and militant against mass surveillance. Whatever the initial justification was for putting it in place is irrelevant in the long term.
[1] Control creep is where the data generated for one form of governance is appropriated for another
I can't see how the DVLA could alone justify plonking £10k in hardware, £30k in installation alongside a little rural road in the middle of Norfolk.
Ah crap, I'm running out of excuses.
>It's just a happy coincidence that the security services also get to monitor more and more movement in the country.
Automated and near-perfect enforcement of minor civil infractions sounds pretty damn Orwellian to me.
I think you've got the scope creep backwards. They get all these systems in place by screaming about security and terrorists then say "well since the system is already here let's use it to keep our citizens on a tighter leash". Then they justify it vilifying these people who commit minor civil infractions as criminals when in reality they're your neighbors.
My point is you don't even need to wheel out terrorism every time to get this stuff through comfortably. You can just play the social injustice card.
[1]: I've completely forgotten the name of it. I've read a few studies on this and they're just amazing how strongly people feel about people unfairly getting one over on them. If anybody reading this knows the name of what I'm talking about, I'd appreciate a reply to remind me.
Us technologists should know how much this stuff matters from the huge effect good design has on product adoption. (Or dark patterns on user behaviour). This is the same effect in action - changing defaults changes the behaviour of the majority.
Another example: People say that “if you make guns illegal only criminals will have guns”. Yet here in Australia very few crimes are committed using firearms. This is the same effect in action. (I’m not arguing for gun control - just that these laws have an effect)
And with that in mind, I think the reason why we’re finally seeing a big push from the 5 eyes is because finally, finally one of the big chat platforms (WhatsApp) has rolled out end to end encryption. That lowered the bar far enough that privacy from the government is becoming the default.
One implication of this way of thinking is that it changes where the battle lines are. To win, the government doesn’t need to make end to end encryption impossible. They just need to make end to end encryption a bit difficult and non-obvious. Doing that will probably push the % of criminals who use proper encryption back into single digit percentages. After all, if you can research and understand the implications of application and messaging security, you can probably make a better living working at an IT desk somewhere than you can from stealing cars. Law enforcement would probably see that as a huge win, even if all us techies can keep sideloading Signal or whatever.
Personally I don’t consider that good enough - I want a society where everyone has privacy. Not just those who have opted in to it.
From your last paragraph, I think we basically agree.
I doubt that. I think the main thing keeping cars safe from the 1% or so who don’t care about the law or ethics of theft is that it’s almost impossible to get away with it. Those with the relevant skill and the willingness to be criminals probably just take an easier approach, like card skimming.
This belief is based on how much second hand cars are worth and therefore how few cars a thief would need to steal each month for a very big salary.
Likewise if they ban end-to-end encrypted chat apps from the app stores, I bet that would decimate the number of people who used them. Even if anyone could just get an android phone and sideload signal, in practice adoption would still fall low enough to make law enforcement happy. Even amongst criminals.
The context of this comment seems to imply these have something to do with the state?
Regardless of who owns the ANPR, since their sole purpose (if you ignore the survelience aspect) is cutting down crime, the data will end up with the state eventually.
www.npcc.police.uk/FreedomofInformation/ANPR.aspx
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automatic_number_plate_recogni...
I know we're already talking about the law, and there are always ways around this, but you're probably better off sticking a foreign plate on the car.
I find this type of thing the easiest place to purchase number plates because they don't make you jump through a load of hoops with sending copies of the V5.
UK statute is painful to read and interpret though. I may have missed something.
And doesn't even work, people use fake number plates.
Must match make model and color with the number plate, also must make sure that the real number plate isn't used ~simultaneously somewhere distant.
And do what, dispatch the police immediately to both plates? It's also a question of not be caught _for how long_
Of course the story would be slightly more believable if not for the fact that shortly after I read it, the police sent me a speeding ticket for a car which I had sold nine months earlier.
takes plate from car
FTFY
"I wish they'd fund health" How do you know they're state funded cameras?
Just a happy coincidence that a large portion of my job is interfacing booking systems with ANPR installations. The ones down the road are MAV cameras. Not cheap.
Yeah, they might be using them as CCTV. But that's a lot of wasted money.
This is arguably the biggest problem of all. Selective enforcement is already a thing, and is only going to become a bigger problem. Just look at all the bullshit prosecutions that have happened in the UK over things said and done on social media.
Police are also increasingly keen on downloading the entire contents of people's smartphones (and prosecuting you if you don't give up the password). So anyone who comes to the attention of the police is at risk of having their entire life pored over to look for any other infringements.
Maybe Apple could fork the iPhone line with devices that retained nothing locally. That ran entirely in RAM, working with minimal data from iCloud. And which fully wiped RAM whenever not in active use. Basically like Tails.
That's a maybe. You are however vastly overestimating the time it would take for the UK government to go to tender over such a platform. Then you are overestimating by an order of magnitude the private sectors ability to deliver such a platform within a reasonable budget and within the next few decades.
Have you looked at government infrastructure projects? Thankfully they set a reassuringly pitiful benchmark.
For now..
I agree with the rest of your comment wholeheartedly.
You assume that they work with the same enthusiasm on the projects we benefit and on the projects they benefit.
Of course, if the government was competent then we wouldn’t have this problem in the first place…
Fixing the issues you list, are part of regaining trust in the political system overall. If it doesn’t get fixed slowly and methodically thing will just get worse and worse until something snaps.
… which is impossible? This would require that the government never gets corrupt because you need secrets to get rid of a corrupt government.
…
At least, that’s the good outcome.
It's a function of popular acceptance (or at least acquiescence) which can acheived by any combination of perceived rectitude or overwhelmingly capacity (in practice, it's usually a blend of the two, and not just one or the other, in any stable state.)
Because the former, I absolutely agree with you. I’m imagining the latter.
It’s not just phones or computers, either — The UK was well known for having high CCTV density well before the proliferation of low-cost digital cameras; By my estimate is now well within government spending limits to put all movement under surveillance by putting cameras on every corner which combine ANPR and facial recognition to cover pedestrians and cyclists as well as motorists; and laser diodes are so cheap every window, never mind person, can be surveilled with laser microscopes.
This is also cheap enough for criminals to do it. I recently got (fake) scam blackmail emails demanding bitcoin under the threat that they had used my webcam to record me watching porn (duct tape over my webcam says they didn’t), but imagine a local crime gang doing that with a drone pointing at your window.
We have to change a lot of stuff in out society very quickly to keep us all safe. We need a world where none of us need secrets, because very soon we won’t have the ability to keep them. We also need the ability to survive ourselves breaking the law, because the law was created with the (at the time reasonable) belief that only important violations would be brought to the attention of the authorities, because most of us can’t get through the day without violating several [1], and because even though current state-of-the-art A.I. can’t automatically enforce all those laws, we should assume that is coming.
But not just what, also how fast it changes and how slow we react: How long ago was it demonstrated that keys can be duplicated from a single image taken by a telephoto lens? And how many keys have been made safe against it since? The only thing keeping us safe is that even the bad actors aren’t keeping up with the tech. That isn’t good, because it means that whoever does use it will look, what’s the phrase, “indistinguishable from magic”.
[1] https://mises.org/library/decriminalize-average-man