Re:‘Five Eyes’ Nations Quietly Demand Government Access to E...
by pixl97 on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @08:32AM
(#17917308)
Can you not be corrupt out in the open, yet hold a monopoly on violence that no one can challenge?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:‘Five Eyes’ Nations Quietly Demand Government Access to E...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @08:41AM
(#17917359)
The monopoly on violence that defines a state is specifically the monopoly on legitimate violence; it is not a monopoly on capacity for violence but on the legitimacy of violence.
Re:‘Five Eyes’ Nations Quietly Demand Government Access to E...
by Nasrudith on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @04:39PM
(#17921709)
The legitimacy is a function of sufficient supremacy than any moral rightness. Otherwise organized crime and fundamentalists wouldn't be capable of reducing governments to failed state status. The legitimacy is that any who wield it openly will be crushed like if say the Hell's Angels decided to try to annex New York City by force of arms. If they couldn't then well there is your new government by strongman
Re:‘Five Eyes’ Nations Quietly Demand Government Access to E...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday September 05, 2018 @06:04PM
(#17922303)
> The legitimacy is a function of sufficient supremacy than any moral rightness.
It's a function of popular acceptance (or at least acquiescence) which can acheived by any combination of perceived rectitude or overwhelmingly capacity (in practice, it's usually a blend of the two, and not just one or the other, in any stable state.)