News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by shawn on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:25PM (#17864942)
It's the other way around. Why does Facebook think it has the right to remove years of their users' contributions?

As the years march on, I think we'll see more and more data protection laws in favor of users rather than companies. Data is the new uranium, not the new oil. It needs to be protected and taken seriously.

You can argue that it's Facebook's site and that they can do whatever they want. I argue that they cause material harm to users by removing years worth of social interactions among their family and friends. Emotional harm is still harm, and it should be treated as such.

In other words, it's a shame that they didn't catch this use case sooner, but that's really not the users' problem. The fact is, users were doing this. And now that they've been doing this, it's unethical to wipe all of their conversations just because you feel you can.

The largest companies are mostly monopolies. When there's nowhere else to go to have a conversation with the people you care about, what are you supposed to do when companies suddenly tell you that your conversations are violating their terms of service?

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by Bucephalus355 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:31PM (#17864979)
This:

“Data is the new uranium, not the new oil”.

Looks like Facebook is sitting on the largest legal liability of the 21st century.

It’s kind of like being a major manufacturer in the US in 1970...you’re about to get screwed by 40+ years of environmental law (considering the river in Cleveland caught in fire in 1969, one can see why some of these laws were passed).

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by pdelbarba on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:45PM (#17865064)
*caught fire 13 times

(river is the Cuyahoga)

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by Xylakant on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @05:35AM (#17866943)
The Great Lakes Brewing Company has a Burning River Pale Ale as a toast to that. https://www.greatlakesbrewing.com/burning-river
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by acjohnson55 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:05PM (#17865186)
Just some?
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by dasil003 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:53PM (#17865122)
I'm all in favor of restricting what companies do with our data, but mandating that they continue to host everything we post ad infinitum? That doesn't seem reasonable to me.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by taurath on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:02PM (#17865172)
At the very least they're completely breaking the social contract they have with their users. Users post their data, they get the service, in return for Facebook making money off of that data. If Facebook decides to stop providing a service that keeps people on Facebook, Facebook will stop getting the data.

Users paid for the service with their data, which Facebook can turn into money. The idea that users don't "pay" for Facebook ignores what Facebook does.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by dasil003 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:10PM (#17865217)
I feel like you're conflating what I said with a sibling comment. Paying has nothing to do with my point, and I don't see what social contract that Facebook is obligated to host anything and everything they once allowed forever.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by taurath on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:45AM (#17865704)
They built the feature that people's post histories stay forever. They promoted it, with things like memory posts. People used it with the expectation that it would stay.

They took the posts down, with zero warning, zero hey we're deprecating this, back up your things. If your stuff was taken down and you care about it, one would hope that you would trust facebook less.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by drewmol on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:44AM (#17866185)
Yes I agree but didn't this just happen? It's not like they actually deleted anything, maybe it's an initial twitter purge for impact, and they'll restore the old ones after some breif period? Toward your point, Facebook is currently promoting themselves as newly invigorated protectors of your data, which certainly implys retention.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by conradev on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:56AM (#17865998)
and this is exactly why Archiveteam has to exist: https://archiveteam.org

They try to stay ahead of troves of data going dark so they can save them somewhere first.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by zaarn on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @07:17AM (#17867319)
I'm uprading my current storage capabilities so I can make a few backups of some sites as well (HN might be a good first test)
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by joe_the_user on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:52PM (#17865111)
Why does Facebook think it has the right to remove years of their users' contributions?

Huh? We're talking about Facebook refusing to keep reposting stuff from another site. That seems like exactly the opposite of the stuff Facebook might have some responsibility for, if it did have responsibility for stuff.

I mean, obviously, it's ambiguous whether Facebook is a repository, a gate-keeper, a community, a blogging-site or what. But the situation of stuff being reposted from other sites seems to be the least repository like. Deleting years of stuff that might not exist in other places would certainly be much more draconian.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by int_19h on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:56PM (#17865143)
> We're talking about Facebook refusing to keep reposting stuff from another site.

We're talking about how Facebook not only turned off the API that enabled reposting, but removed all past posts that were made via that API. Which, at that point, was exactly the kind of user data that they had responsibility for.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by gehwartzen on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:17PM (#17865261)
Well the good news is that Facebook seems to be incapable of actually deleating anything so I’m sure this data is not lost forever ;)
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by dragonwriter on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:58PM (#17871967)
> We're talking about how Facebook not only turned off the API that enabled reposting, but removed all past posts that were made via that API.

No, they cut off the API. The old posts were still there, and tied to the apps that were used to send them. When Twitter then killed their app (apparently, because it wouldn't be usable going forward and in ignorance of the way existing posts were tied to it), then the old posts that were made through that app were deleted. Not because they had used the API, but because they were associated with a removed app.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by joe_the_user on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:57PM (#17865155)
I'd assume posts made with the API would exist still on Twitter.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by jefftk on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:08PM (#17865206)
The fb discussion threads those posts initiated are gone, though.

If this happened to me I'd be extremely upset: I've had many very good discussions on Facebook that it would hurt to lose.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by zaroth on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:16AM (#17866072)
I assume you haven’t downloaded a copy for yourself yet?

I would not assume Facebook has any duty to maintain historical posts. That would be up to the TOS.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by int_19h on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @04:53PM (#17871922)
Legally, they do not, of course. But it's generally considered rude to do something like that with zero warning.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by samstave on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:30AM (#17866136)
Another angle is that I would like to have the right to demand that FB remove any and all mention of me, my handle(s), or posts I have made on any non-FB property.

I would want to ensure that FB can't host data which I submit to twitter/reddit/HN without providing me the authority to be able to request its removal from FB.

I'd think that this could set some precedent to allow for this.

Clearly, though, the FB anti-stance would be that it cannot do so in such granular fashion, which clearly is not true given the fact that any data/posts are tied to both source site and source person...

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by joe_the_user on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:18AM (#17865586)
This is a point I hadn't considered.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by drewmol on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @02:34AM (#17866145)
I'm guessing it may be temporary. Either a by-product of change or intentional(wipe Facebook of the tweets to drive home the message they've eliminated this feature, then silently start displays the old ones in a few months). Seems unlikely that Facebook deleted something.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by diminoten on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @03:45AM (#17866457)
> I've had many very good discussions on Facebook that it would hurt to lose.

I genuinely don't mean to be snarky, but that's a surprise. I have literally zero Facebook discussions I even remember, let alone "would hurt to lose".

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by KayEss on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:48AM (#17865972)
> Deleting years of stuff that might not exist in other places would certainly be much more draconian.

This is exactly what the report says they did. The original post may exist on Twitter, but the conversation that happened on Facebook does not.

I just checked my feed, and my Twitter posts do seem to still be on my FB profile, at least when I look at it.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by tejtm on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:55PM (#17865469)
> Why does Facebook think it has the right to remove years of their users' contributions?

I'm guessing that since their fleet of lawyers wrote that wall of legalease everyone must have clicked on, they are pretty sure exactly what their rights are w.r.t who owns the contributions voluntarily sent to their servers.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by shawn on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @12:02AM (#17865502)
Property rights must have seemed a radical idea at the time they were first introduced. And the time seems right for data rights. Actions like this only solidify the need for such protections.

One of the central questions of our generation is, who owns the data we create? Do we, or do the corporations?

Seeing as Zuck was dragged in front of congress back in April, I think questions like these will only become more important over time.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by wilsonnb3 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:42PM (#17865408)
> Why does Facebook think it has the right to remove years of their users' contributions

Why would they not have the right to control content posted on their platform?

If someone lets me and all my friends communicate by posting signs on their front lawn for free, should they have an obligation to keep my signs on their lawn until I decide to remove it?

Saying it causes emotional harm is a pretty weak defense. Basically any action can cause emotional harm to someone.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by ISL on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:11AM (#17865830)
FB might not have that right, in practice, if the poster feels that their posts are their own.

My "wall" is not generally referred to as "FB's wall documenting ISL's interaction with friends", but rather, "ISL's wall".

If a society believes a thing to be true, it will tend to vote in politicians to make it so, whether it is presently contractually written that way or not.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by xevb3k on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:13AM (#17865841)
If it becomes an established practice, over several decades... probably?
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by thaumasiotes on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:32AM (#17865915)
Over several decades, they definitely do have that obligation. With just signs, it'd be hard to make a case for adverse possession, but easy to make the case for an easement.

If you're a little more permissive and let someone live in a little hut on your lawn, then after several decades, they'll own the lawn, and you won't.

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:36PM (#17865012)
> Why does Facebook think it has the right to remove years of their users' contributions?

How much were they paying for the service?

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by jdc on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:39PM (#17865033)
Exactly as much as Facebook would allow them to.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by JBiserkov on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:55PM (#17865139)
And exactly as much as Facebook asked them to.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by dasil003 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:55PM (#17865135)
That's a clever re-framing, let me try: how many users would Facebook have if they charged $0.01 to sign up?
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:12PM (#17865228)
In terms of money, as in "pretend you can insert your penny into the front of the computer", probably about the same number.

(But even a 0¢ credit card requirement would have an enormous negative impact.)

Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by baq on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:59AM (#17866007)
Thousands of dollars worth of my time.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by r721 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @10:56PM (#17865146)
They paid with their attention.
Re:Twitter’s deletion of its FB app caused old cross-posts t... by nradov on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:20PM (#17865272)
The concept of "emotional harm" is absurd post-modern nonsense. I am responsible for my own emotions, not Mark Zuckerberg.