News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prolikewh0a on Monday August 27, 2018 @04:41PM (#17854347)
Corporate boards in USA don't include workers because workers would pull money away from the shareholders and executives in the form of pay raises and better benefits for lower level employees.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by atmosx on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:01PM (#17854933)
Hm, it did not work like that in Germany in the 90s and 00s. Workers were persuaded not to go after raises, although profits soared, to avoid losing jobs to countries like Poland. The German government decided to keep the surplus from exports and indirectly brag about it, as if countries are households. The result of this idiotic policy was of course that German industry scored record profits, but wages remained stagnant for ~20 years since by not investing in infrastructure the govt kept wages low “virtually”. Then negative interest rates came, the EU went berserk and the AfD is the third political power in Germany. So much for the surplus.

Back to the matter at hand... having workers in the board helps, but doesn’t secure raises.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by antman on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:27PM (#17855077)
Specifically in one case I can recall the workers did not go after raises because the union leader was bribed and later convicted. Even after his conviction the workers could not take back the deal.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by mpweiher on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @04:57AM (#17857450)
Er...in the 90s and 00s, Germany was "The Sick Man of Europe", significantly lagging the other Western European countries.

So there were no soaring profits to distribute at the time, and wage restraint agreed by the unions was one of the factors in bringing Germany back (note: not "the" factor, as usual there were many).

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by pluma on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:05AM (#17857657)
The reason for Germany carrying that title at the time was the cost of reunification, not the economy itself. West Germany was still doing relatively fine but East Germany required massive investments. Germany was hit by the early 00s recession but that was hardly unique in Europe.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by atmosx on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:20AM (#17857709)
True, what I wrote applies for the 00s. In the 90s, Germany was referred as the sick man of Europe.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by nstj on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:29PM (#17855962)
What does it mean to "keep the surplus from exports"?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by geezerjay on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:09AM (#17856653)
My guess is that's a loaded term to reffer to Germany's positive trade balance.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by zaphirplane on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @03:57AM (#17857237)
I have no doubt a government is to blame for the financial stagnation or decline. Thou not clear on how they are responsible for having companies produce massive profits and keeping wages low.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by atmosx on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:05AM (#17858489)
> I have no doubt a government is to blame for the financial stagnation or decline.

I never said that a government is to blame for financial stagnation or decline.

I was referring specifically to Schröder's and Merkel's tenure as chancellors (2000-2018). I was wrong to add the 90s, although it is debatable if the above strategy was already planned by Kohl.

> Thou not clear on how they are responsible for having companies produce massive profits and keeping wages low.

You have to look at this in the EU context, otherwise it's hard to grasp. For any kind of group, which share the same currency, there must be a surplus recycling mechanism in place. Y. Varoufakis has talked extensively about the lack of surplus recycling, which was and is today a major design flaw and probably the reason the EU is going burst.

In a common currency group, where no one can devalue, the exporting countries will have positive surplus vis-a-vis non-exporting countries. To revert the flow, exporting economies must invest in infrastructure (build schools, universities, public swimming pools, stadiums, roads, airports, setting up social services, public internet infrastructure, welfare which translates in jobs, etc.). The action of building infra will create scarcity in the labour market: companies will struggle to keep underpaid workforce. The secondary effect is that products, will be become more expensive. At that point the positive surplus will become balanced or negative... Then the same process should be repeated.

Of course there are a lot of important details, but hopefully you get the gist.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by walshemj on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:22PM (#17855341)
Yes IG Metal and others seemed to have dropped the ball in not getting payback for restraint earlier.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by philwelch on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:00PM (#17854932)
Maybe they just would pull money away from shareholders and executives in the form of pay raises and better benefits for senior employees, particularly the ones who run the union (https://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines). Also, by enforcing a closed shop, they could simultaneously pull money away from lower level employees, in the form of union dues, and funnel it to the benefit of the people who run the union. Sometimes they even funnel the money to the Mafia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Hoffa).

The moral hazards inherent in a "handful of powerful leaders who represent the interests of $GROUP" doesn't change much when $GROUP is "workers" instead of "shareholders". Executives and union organizers are often two sides of the same coin in that respect.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by eseehausen on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:22PM (#17855058)
Except the groups they represent are different. Executives represent the shareholders and labor organizers represent labor. Even if you say a large part of the benefits are lost due to corruption in both cases, it shapes where the remainder ends up.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by AnthonyMouse on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:31PM (#17855975)
> Except the groups they represent are different. Executives represent the shareholders and labor organizers represent labor. Even if you say a large part of the benefits are lost due to corruption in both cases, it shapes where the remainder ends up.

But you have to compare it to the alternative. The question is whether the incremental amount the union gets from management over what the employee would have gotten for themselves is more than the overhead/corruption cost of the union.

For shareholders of public companies there is little choice. If you own $1000 each worth of a hundred different companies, you're not going to have the time or incentive to manage them all properly yourself (and neither is any other individual shareholder), so the benefit of hiring a board to do it is worth the cost.

The math is a lot different when you only have one employer and you're getting ~100% of your income from them. In that case people have a strong incentive to do their own research and try to get the best possible employment for themselves. It's the same reason most companies with a single owner are owner-operated.

About the only thing a union is going to get you is leveraging its monopoly power, which only works against monopolistic employers that have enough margins to pay you more without themselves becoming uncompetitive and also individually represent too much of the industry to just let everyone walk out and hire all different low level employees.

This is why, for example, unions worked well for workers in the dominant era of the Big Three American auto companies, and much less well now that they have aggressive competition from Japan, Germany and Korea.

But their cars are a lot better now. A lot more people died back then. Other people wrote scathing books and passed new laws. Uncompetitive markets are terrible.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by chimeracoder on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:51PM (#17855481)
> labor organizers represent labor.

Unions claim to represent labor, but due to a confluence of laws, there's no guarantee that they actually do, as pointed out above. Even within a union, politics exists, and those who are influential and important are able to extract resources away from those who are viewed as dispensible.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by refurb on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:24PM (#17855659)
Not sure why you’re being downvoted.

You last sentence is true for any human organization. Politics exist and those with power sometimes take from those who don’t.

That includes unions.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by geezerjay on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:13AM (#17856669)
> and labor organizers represent labor.

Actually they don't. They either represent a political organization or some other interest group. The workers only take a passive role in the whole process.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Frondo on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:46AM (#17858352)
This is a misleading statement. Labor organizers represent a labor union that's trying to organize those workers -- usually with the goal of having that newly established union join up with the union the labor organizers represent, but they never have to. The new union could join up with any other, or set off on their own.

Saying "a political organization" is misleading because it evokes an image of a super-PAC or something else overtly political, and saying "some other interest group" glosses over the reality that, yes, you could call unions interest groups that represent their workers for collective bargaining, but again, that's misleading.

The fair way to phrase this is "Labor organizers represent a union that's trying to unionize a new workplace," but that obviously sounds less sketchy.

And the workers take a verrrrry active role in the process, especially any that become involved in the organizing themselves, up to and including being fired (illegally, because firing someone for labor-related activities is not allowed).

* Not a union member, but I hate seeing anti-union and anti-labor tropes trotted out, especially on a group that usually prides itself on accuracy.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by philwelch on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:31PM (#17861489)
Most of the big unions conspicuously operate as overtly political organizations these days.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by gowld on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:39AM (#17856563)
And yet society and government generally tolerates this behavior from executives and prosecute union leaders.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by philwelch on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:58PM (#17860494)
Can you name a single executive who mysteriously disappeared after a long history of involvement with organized crime?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by cannonedhamster on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:15PM (#17865254)
You're kind of proving their point. Labor has historically been a government and capital versus the employed. How many times has the national guard been called to quell an executive uprising? None because executives always hold the power and moneyed interests always run the government. The only change in this in the US was the brief history after WW2 where FDR and Truman wielded outsize political power and the country saw the ills of the gilded age because of the enormous impact felt by the average person during the great depression. To answer your question directly there are most definitely executives tied to organized crime. Organized crime is more organized now and less violent. The Sopranos is basically based on this. The industries that organized crime generally controls are blue collar industries. People don't need to disappear anymore, they just look like regular deaths.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by philwelch on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @01:13PM (#17869917)
> How many times has the national guard been called to quell an executive uprising? None because executives always hold the power and moneyed interests always run the government.

I think it's more because the national guard is only necessary to suppress large-scale riots, and there aren't enough executives all in the same place to make even a small-scale riot. Executives who are charged with crimes can be individually arrested.

But all of that is beside the point, because I'm comparing union leaders and organizers with executives.

> The only change in this in the US was the brief history after WW2 where FDR and Truman wielded outsize political power and the country saw the ills of the gilded age because of the enormous impact felt by the average person during the great depression.

This completely misses the more relevant fact that the US represented 50% of the global economy at the time (due to every other industrialized nation being absolutely devastated by the war) and reinvested much of their remaining wealth into rebuilding both their allies and their former adversaries, which led to an unsustainable period of "catch-up" economic growth that faded just as soon as the Germans and Japanese started doing a better job at manufacturing than the US did.

> To answer your question directly there are most definitely executives tied to organized crime.

Citation needed.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by M2Ys4U on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:33PM (#17860842)
How about simply making closed-shop unions illegal? That's how things work in the UK.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by naravara on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:44PM (#17856040)
It amazes me how often articles about this sort of stuff treat the weakness of American labor as some sort of inherent property of the soil or our culture. People are quick to talk about squishy topics like individualism but gloss over or completely ignore the fact that we used to literally beat up and assassinate labor leaders.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by djrogers on Monday August 27, 2018 @10:51PM (#17856267)
> gloss over or completely ignore the fact that we used to literally beat up and assassinate labor leaders.

Speaking of glossing over - let’s not pretend that the history of violence in the US labor movement was all one way...

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by gaoshan on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:15AM (#17856885)
Definitely was not one way because both sides committed acts of violence right? Specifically, on one side you had people committing violence in order to retain their positions of power and advantage over a weaker group and on the other you had people doing it in order to improve their positions of weakness and disadvantage against a more powerful group. In some ways it's kind of like when a lion attacks a gazelle and the gazelle fights back... that kind of "not all one way".
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by monetus on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:28AM (#17856543)
Any examples for the rest of us?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by fsloth on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:53AM (#17856608)
Not OP but I like this answer in Quora related to your question: https://www.quora.com/How-and-why-did-some-labor-unions-beco...
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by TangoTrotFox on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:23AM (#17857716)
If you look back in US history, strikes and such were frequently supported by arms. One of the more famous was the 'Pinkerton Rebellion' [1]. It's interesting to consider the interweaving between class, guns, labor rights, and social order in general. It's certainly much more more nuanced than most people give thought to now a days.

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_strike

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by kartan on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:29PM (#17854721)
> And executives

That is the key. Executives are taking the lion's share.

https://www.cnbc.com/2018/01/22/heres-how-much-ceo-pay-has-i...

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by pathseeker on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:30PM (#17854735)
Pedantic nit: they aren't taking the lion's share, they are just taking a much larger share. CEO pay makes up a small fraction of total pay given to all employees so it's not "the lion's share".
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by perfmode on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:12PM (#17854998)
what qualifies as a lions share?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Mtinie on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:31PM (#17855098)
> what qualifies as a lions share?

If you follow Phaedrus's telling[0], introduced as "Partnership with the mighty is never trustworthy" -- all of it:

"I take the first portion because of my title, since I am addressed as king; the second portion you will assign to me, since I’m your partner; then because I am the stronger, the third will follow me; and an accident will happen to anyone who touches the fourth."

Other versions from around the world typically have the lion taking a majority of whatever is being divided, and whenever possible, everything.

--- [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lion%27s_share#The_Phaedrus_ve...

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Consultant32452 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:06AM (#17856855)
The better question, in my opinion, is what qualifies as a "CEO?" The article makes it clear that they just cherry-picked the top paid 350 CEOs in the country. But there's nearly a quarter million CEOs in the US.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by cannonedhamster on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:20PM (#17865276)
The article states it's the largest 350 company CEOs. Probably based on https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-compensation-surged-in-2...
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Veelox on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:50PM (#17855177)
One thing that article doesn't touch on, if we returned ceo pay to 1978 average of 30:1, how much of a raise would that give each employee?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by airstrike on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:08PM (#17855260)
In 1978, China wasn't what it is now. Wages for workers has stagnated in the US but not abroad.

Or do you propose returning Chinese workers' wages to 1978 levels in order to afford restoring American wages?

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by telchar on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:19PM (#17855919)
That has nothing to do with the parent's question. Rising Chinese salaries don't cause executives to need more compensation than the did in the 70's relative to their (American) workers. If your point is that high American worker salaries aren't supportable now due to competition, you would have to explain why American executives' salaries are increased compared to the 70's.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by airstrike on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:13PM (#17863401)
My point is that both executives and workers benefited from globalization, advances in telecommunications and transportation.

Unfortunately to American workers, it turns out that the workers who enjoyed the upside were some of the poorest in the world and not the very expensive American workers of the mid-1900s.

Fortunately to American executives, they started the race ahead of everyone else and with their multinationals corporations captured most of the upside from globalization.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jlawson on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:26PM (#17855370)
Not necessary. The economy isn't a zero-sum game. There is more wealth to go around now than in 1978.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by M_Bakhtiari on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:02AM (#17857469)
> Not necessary. The economy isn't a zero-sum game. There is more wealth to go around now than in 1978.

True, but it's been increasingly overvalued since the middle ages with the liberalisation of compound interest. That particular activity is zero sum and will concentrate wealth in one end until real wealth generation (farming, mining and refining of the results of the former two) becomes infeasible. Right now it's Venezuela, my bet is South Africa being next. Europe in our lifetime.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by airstrike on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:03PM (#17881208)
After reading your comment twice, I think you're somehow blaming the shitstorm that the Chavez / Maduro governments brought upon their own country on the liberalization of compound interest, but I can't fathom how you'd conclude that, so I'd love for you to correct my understanding of your comment.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jacobolus on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:36PM (#17855729)
Pretty sure if you reduced executive pay to being no more than 30:1 where the 1 is a typical Chinese unskilled labor salary, the executives would be even less happy about it.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by ummonk on Monday August 27, 2018 @11:14PM (#17856328)
Almost none. If you split the CEO pay across all the mass of workers, it won’t come out to much.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by dingaling on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @03:23AM (#17857085)
In absolute terms perhaps. But $20 per week extra would be significant in relative terms to many workers.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Scriptor on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:33AM (#17857985)
Exactly, small increments of money like that can mean all the difference. It can be enough to stop worrying about paying the power bill, to buy enough healthy food for dinner, or to save up more easily to get the car fixed.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by kartan on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @09:14AM (#17858541)
> If you split the CEO pay across all the mass of workers, it won’t come out to much.

I agree that if you split the CEO pay it does not affect so much the employees.

I just wanted to highlight is that the CEO does NOT want the employees in the board as they may see the CEO's salary as unfair. So, to protect his own salary, the CEO keeps employees out of the structures of power.

Then we can argue if is that lack of power the one that keeps or not workers salaries low. But workers are not represented becuase is against the CEO best interest so her own salary can grow unchecked.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by kamaal on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:21AM (#17856906)
On the same lines, if you take little from each worker and give it to the CEO, its worth a lot to one individual.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Marazan on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @03:47AM (#17857187)
What if you raised the workers' wage rather than reducing the CEO pay?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by ummonk on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @03:23PM (#17862019)
If it's a high margin business (e.g. Apple), that will help the workers a lot, while depressing shareholder returns.

If it's a low margin business, it will go bankrupt.

Note that in the past several years, shareholders have experienced massive returns due to rising corporate profits, largely because corporations have held workers' wages stagnant throughout the economic recovery/boom.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by M_Bakhtiari on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @04:49AM (#17857424)
But what motivates the board to pay the executives so much?

Either the board is corrupt and is wasting company money on their executive buddies and the shareholders ought to discipline the board (and perhaps putting some salt-of-the-earth workers on it may be a good way to do that, but certainly no silver bullet), or they pay what they need to keep the executives from jumping ship and go work for a competitor, and they are in fact not overpaid. I suspect there are companies that fit in either category.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by cannonedhamster on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:23PM (#17865304)
Typically boards and executives at top companies are a very insular group. I.E. you have to know someone to be someone. Same as the mob except greedier.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Consultant32452 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @02:05AM (#17856852)
That article is about the top paid 350 CEOs in a country where there are nearly a quarter million CEOs. Do you have any stats on how CEO pay has actually changed on average?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by e40 on Monday August 27, 2018 @04:55PM (#17854464)
Unless they had a majority, that is not true. Having 1 or 2 workers on the board would be a good thing, I believe. Too many boards are out of touch with what goes on in the company.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by justonepost on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:21PM (#17854663)
THey don't need a majority. They'd use it as negotiating leverage, ie, I'll vote this way if you vote that way.

What's interesting though is that Germany is an industrial powerhouse compared to the US.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jayalpha on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:00AM (#17857843)
"What's interesting though is that Germany is an industrial powerhouse compared to the US."

There are two reasons for that.

1. The US has the stuff she develops produced abroad (IT, Computer, Phones etc.), mainly due to tax reasons (Produce in China, sell to Hongkong, sell to the US, major mark up in HK is done tax free).

2. German companies don't not pay their engineers. You can make more as a dog walker in the US or an English teacher in China than as many engineers in Germany.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by skookumchuck on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:20AM (#17857529)
> What's interesting though is that Germany is an industrial powerhouse compared to the US.

The DAX is up 37% since 2015, the S&P500 is up 74%. (That's as far back as DAX goes on Yahoo finance.)

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jayalpha on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:00AM (#17857848)
He said industrial powerhouse, not financial powerhouse.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by skookumchuck on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @03:49PM (#17862239)
It's not the banking industry that is driving the stock market in the US.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jayalpha on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @06:24AM (#17867111)
Based on P/E ratios, it's not the economy either.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by smsm42 on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:58PM (#17855210)
And one worker on the board would change that? How? If the managers - whose duty is supposed to be knowing what's going on, that's literally what they are paid for - can't, how one person whose job is doing something else, could in addition to that gain adequate knowledge of what's going on that is impossible for others to gain? Especially in a company that has, say, a hundred of people? Best case they would know what's going in their corner of work, but in any company which doesn't fit in a single room that won't be representative of others. Unless you make that worker spend whole day on figuring what's going on, talking with all workers from all other rooms, systematizing and analyzing and processing this information to make conclusions - by which time, you just made him a manager.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by geezerjay on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:17AM (#17856684)
> Unless you make that worker spend whole day on figuring what's going on, talking with all workers from all other rooms,

Workers representatives are picked to represent workers in negotiations and discussion, and their job is to spend the whole day figuring what's going on.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by smsm42 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:56PM (#17863278)
Then it's just a kind of manager (in the better case, in worse it's a union functionary with a political agenda which may have little to do with worker's interests in a particular workplace).
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by gowld on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:41AM (#17856566)
By the same argument, shareholders shouldn't be on the board either, since they aren't management.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by smsm42 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:57PM (#17863293)
If the only consideration is "knowing what's going on" then yes. But shareholders are owners, so they may demand participation even if they don't know anything, just for the fact they actually own the company (at last partially).
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by cannonedhamster on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:25PM (#17865317)
By that token employees who own company stock should have a place on the board.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by walshemj on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:24PM (#17855358)
They would be acting as a nonexec director it would effectively be a fulltime role maybe 2 days a week minimum.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by ProAm on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:04PM (#17854543)
> Too many boards are out of touch with what goes on in the company.

Do you have examples of this?

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jayalpha on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:00PM (#17854931)
Sorry, but have you ever worked in a bigger company?

The problems in a company are obvious for most workers.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jimduk on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:13PM (#17855001)
I used to work for a while as a management consultant, and, in my personal experience, would rephrase the above as "a subset of the smart, engaged workers in a company, can often tell you 80%, of the main problems in week 1, which makes you wonder why the CEOs ( who are smart) hire you to address those problems, as well as the trickier 20%
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by forapurpose on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:29PM (#17855089)
> The problems in a company are obvious for most workers.

I agree that workers see things that management doesn't, and good managers are aware of that and work hard to overcome it. However, having seen both sides of that coin, workers also lack awareness of many issues and constraints. They think, 'why don't we just do X? It's obvious!', without realizing that X would cost the company a major investor or partner, or put the company in the crosshairs of a dangerous competitor; or that X would divert resources from a higher priority; or that the CIO, who is great in every other way, opposes X and it's not worth alienating them; etc.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by ProAm on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:27PM (#17855080)
I have, and in reality most of the problem are not real problems (at least the ones from the workers perspectives) when viewed from the C-level and board perspective. But Im still waiting for examples of companies where this is taking place and am certainly willing to accept my position is a wrong one but no one has provided a credible example yet.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by cannonedhamster on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @11:29PM (#17865341)
Tyco, Ericsson, Comcast, IBM, GE to name a few. All of these companies are rotting from the inside out and management and contractor heavy.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by ProAm on Wednesday August 29, 2018 @10:13AM (#17868338)
Can you provide examples as to how? People just keep naming companies but no examples.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by geezerjay on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:22AM (#17856701)
> The problems in a company are obvious for most workers.

The workers at best see a part of an individual tree, but the job of the board is to manage the whole forrest considering how the entire world is at that moment and where it will be in 5 or 10 years in the future.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by jayalpha on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @07:10AM (#17857880)
I meant "workers" in a broader way. Maybe even everything below the board.

I have friends that were laid off (in the end) and the problems in their company were obvious to them. They did not even bother trying brining it up (hint: Never do!).

Now a major consulting firm is trying to restructure the company. They have zero understanding of the business (niche) and based on his former perspective of the company many decisions are major major mistakes (e.g. they only see the profits that a business devision brings in but they don't see how many other divisions rely on that business devision to bring in their business).

He had a genius idea (trust me) how to combine two different fields that could have started a complete new business division with basically close to zero start-up cost. He never bothered brining the idea up because "this company is too conservative to even consider this".

So, a guy with a tremendous insight into the problems and possible solutions goes totally unnoticed. And this is just one example.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by yardie on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:08PM (#17854570)
TSLA
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by mysterypie on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:26PM (#17855950)
I had to google TSLA to realize it was Tesla. What's up with using stock symbols? You saved one letter by not writing Tesla.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by ProAm on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:12PM (#17854600)
How are they not in touch with what is going on in the company? The chairman seems extremely aware and involved with it. Im not being sarcastic, I'm really interesting in how/which companies people think the board is out of touch and how they are out of touch.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Joky on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:44PM (#17854836)
You had to pick THE company whose CEO is actually spending a large part of his time in the factory?
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by imglorp on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:28PM (#17854711)
One might argue that happy, engaged workers would make more money for everyone, top to bottom.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by 794CD01 on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:46PM (#17854860)
If that argument were compelling, shareholders would do that. They aren't in it just to spite workers.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Kadin on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:19PM (#17855034)
Many shareholders (of medium to large-cap, publicly traded companies) seem to only be interested in short-term gains, not longer term. Some claim to be interested in longer-term profits and business sustainability, but they don't seem to act like it.

The market does not seem to be good at optimizing for long-term outcomes, bluntly.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by tryptophan on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:50AM (#17856599)
Could you actually give an example of the short term mentality? I keep hearing it repeated over and over and over but nobody actually points to an example or study or anything.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by coupdejarnac on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:41AM (#17856774)
Fine, I got you fam.

At the last large corporation I worked at, they got rid of most of the inside embedded device engineers and outsourced design to India and Japan. The reasoning was probably something like we spend $X on engineering staff here, whereas we could spend $Y to outsource development of the same products, where $Y < $X. Whoever made that decision made a fat bonus and left. The time necessary to determine the real value of that decision takes a few years, after that guy was gone. Anyway, most of the outsourcing ended up being a huge waste of money and put one of our flagship products a year behind schedule. The company has since moved embedded development back inside.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by pluma on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:10AM (#17857670)
Toys 'R' Us was doing fine and making stable profits but the company was run to the ground in an attempt to push online sales for a chance of massive growth.

It's not so much that the market favors "short term" growth. The market favors high-risk high-growth (which usually only works short term and requires an exit) over low-risk low-growth (which is usually fairly stable in the long run).

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by short_sells_poo on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:18AM (#17857704)
Part of the problem I think is that big investment companies and institutions (pension funds and asset managers) rebalance their portfolios in ever shorter intervals. The game has sped up dramatically. This means that big investors reevaluate their portfolio composition ever more frequently and thus companies have a shrinking leeway in sacrificing short term gains for long term prospects. A company whose stock is ouperformed by a competitor purely because of short term tricks runs the risk that their company will be downweighted at the next rebalancing time. This then results in further selling pressure on the stock. It's all a feedback loop really. This is further exacerbated by using the same quantitative models across many investment companies, resulting in herd behavior and clustering. There are other considerations for sure, but I see the above as at least part of the problem.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by chii on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:55PM (#17855803)
Because long term, we are all dead.

Profits today can be easily invested in another short term profit project tomorrow. Therefore, I say long term should be done by a foundation that has the explicit goal to achieve, rather than a corp whose sole purpose is to make profit.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by pluma on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:12AM (#17857678)
> rather than a corp whose sole purpose is to make profit

So we've all now universally accepted the Friedman doctrine?

You're aware that the Friedman doctrine isn't held as an inherent truth everywhere and by everyone, right? Not every culture sees corporations as having the sole moral duty of maximising shareholder value with no regard for societal wellbeing.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by imglorp on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:03AM (#17858127)
Actually neither! There is one level more pessimistic than Friedman, which is Greenspan's parting realization. [1] So it's three layers of theft now. Public corps ...

    Society's wellbeing < shareholder's value < executive's value
So you get these axemen who show up, extract whatever they can from the corporation, and then walk away from the ruins for the next thief, if anything is left. They're TWO layers removed from society.

1. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/24/business/economy/24panel....

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by skookumchuck on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:24AM (#17857538)
> The market does not seem to be good at optimizing for long-term outcomes, bluntly.

The S&P500 has done extremely well, long term.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by TheOtherHobbes on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:56PM (#17855202)
it's not about spite, it's about noblesse oblige.

Corporations are essentially feudal, and one of the biggest unstated goals is to maintain and signal class power differentials.

You don't do that by including social inferiors in board-level deliberations - no matter how inane, misguided, and ultimately self-destructive those deliberations turn out to be.

Here is one example of a board-level decision that a majority of workers would have said was a very bad idea, but which executives decided to complete anyway.

It's really ridiculously easy to list other examples from corporate history:

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/mar/30/homebas...

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prepend on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:17PM (#17855907)
If it were actually more valuable then someone would buy the company, fire the noblesse oblige and hire new management.

The reality is that there’s a point of decreasing returns for productivity. If the “happy workers make more money for the company” truly had a positive ROI, then the market would pay it. There’s plenty of capital willing to make long term investments that would take companies private to jack up wages.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by AlexandrB on Monday August 27, 2018 @11:42PM (#17856419)
> If it were actually more valuable then someone would buy the company, fire the noblesse oblige and hire new management.

Comical. "The Market" is far from perfect - especially in more monopolized industries. Consider the 2008 housing crash for a recent[1] example where "the market" did not behave rationally across a wide swath of professional investors. Add to that the fact that the "someone" in your example is most likely part of the noblesse oblige themselves and will default to respecting the opinion of the board (no matter how wrong) and not the workers.

> If the “happy workers make more money for the company” truly had a positive ROI, then the market would pay it.

Most often, the market behaves like a gradient descent algorithm - seeking slightly more optimal operating conditions without rocking the boat too much. This normally leads to finding local minima, not global ones. The most notable exception is "startups", where the initial conditions of the search may be radically different than a typical big-co - sometimes leading to better results.

Now consider that most medium-to-large companies have been operating for years (maybe decades) on the assumption that cutting costs - including wages - is the best way incrementally optimize profit. Reversing direction would mean going back uphill for a while as the culture, employee attitudes, and recruitment pipeline slowly change in response. How many boards do you think would put up with years of declining profits during the attempt to find the better way?

This doesn't mean that there aren't examples of companies that take this approach even for low-skilled labor[2][3]. Just that it's rare because of conventional wisdom and the corporate politics involved in making it happen.

[1] An even more recent example is Theranos - where companies that should have known better bet big on partnerships with a vaporware medical company against the explicit advice of consultants they had hired to advise them on these matters.

[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-pays-retail-employees...

[3] http://brandautopsy.com/2007/01/the_starbucks_e.html

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by danaris on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:10PM (#17854990)
How compelling an argument is doesn't necessarily have anything to do with how much truth it holds.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by throwaway2048 on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:49PM (#17854872)
Shareholders don't always act in a rational way, plenty of companies and trillions in shareholder value have been destroyed by stupid short sighted shareholder demands.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prepend on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:18PM (#17855912)
In the aggregate long term they do.

Shareholders don’t act rationally, but the market eventually does.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by AlexandrB on Monday August 27, 2018 @11:52PM (#17856456)
> Shareholders don’t act rationally, but the market eventually does.

Citation needed. I hate to bring up 2008 again, but the market first acted irrationally by over-investing in garbage CDOs and then "corrected" in a way that would have tanked the economy without massive public intervention. If that's rational behavior than perhaps we should nominate the next person drunkenly weaving between two lanes for Driver of the Year.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prepend on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:54AM (#17875626)
“Eventually” being a key word as there are corrects. 2008 is one year out of many.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by gowld on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:43AM (#17856576)
"Rational" does not mean "maximizing profit". Sometimes rational mean throwing a failed experiment in the trash, after a past irrational or poor decision.
[dead]
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by dang on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:17PM (#17855313)
Please don't take HN threads into ideological flamewar. We're really trying to avoid that here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by fake-name on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:33PM (#17855715)
Huh? I'm legitimately missing what's controversial here.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by dang on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:39PM (#17856015)
I've written about this a lot, if you want to read about it:

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

Most of those comments are ironically pretty generic but there is also plenty of explanation.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by incadenza on Monday August 27, 2018 @04:56PM (#17854471)
Yeah agreed, I don’t consider this complicated.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by mac01021 on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:30AM (#17856547)
The board is supposed to be all about shareholders, right? Why are executives a consideration?