News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by imglorp on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:28PM (#17854711)
One might argue that happy, engaged workers would make more money for everyone, top to bottom.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by 794CD01 on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:46PM (#17854860)
If that argument were compelling, shareholders would do that. They aren't in it just to spite workers.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by Kadin on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:19PM (#17855034)
Many shareholders (of medium to large-cap, publicly traded companies) seem to only be interested in short-term gains, not longer term. Some claim to be interested in longer-term profits and business sustainability, but they don't seem to act like it.

The market does not seem to be good at optimizing for long-term outcomes, bluntly.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by tryptophan on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:50AM (#17856599)
Could you actually give an example of the short term mentality? I keep hearing it repeated over and over and over but nobody actually points to an example or study or anything.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by coupdejarnac on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @01:41AM (#17856774)
Fine, I got you fam.

At the last large corporation I worked at, they got rid of most of the inside embedded device engineers and outsourced design to India and Japan. The reasoning was probably something like we spend $X on engineering staff here, whereas we could spend $Y to outsource development of the same products, where $Y < $X. Whoever made that decision made a fat bonus and left. The time necessary to determine the real value of that decision takes a few years, after that guy was gone. Anyway, most of the outsourcing ended up being a huge waste of money and put one of our flagship products a year behind schedule. The company has since moved embedded development back inside.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by pluma on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:10AM (#17857670)
Toys 'R' Us was doing fine and making stable profits but the company was run to the ground in an attempt to push online sales for a chance of massive growth.

It's not so much that the market favors "short term" growth. The market favors high-risk high-growth (which usually only works short term and requires an exit) over low-risk low-growth (which is usually fairly stable in the long run).

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by short_sells_poo on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:18AM (#17857704)
Part of the problem I think is that big investment companies and institutions (pension funds and asset managers) rebalance their portfolios in ever shorter intervals. The game has sped up dramatically. This means that big investors reevaluate their portfolio composition ever more frequently and thus companies have a shrinking leeway in sacrificing short term gains for long term prospects. A company whose stock is ouperformed by a competitor purely because of short term tricks runs the risk that their company will be downweighted at the next rebalancing time. This then results in further selling pressure on the stock. It's all a feedback loop really. This is further exacerbated by using the same quantitative models across many investment companies, resulting in herd behavior and clustering. There are other considerations for sure, but I see the above as at least part of the problem.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by chii on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:55PM (#17855803)
Because long term, we are all dead.

Profits today can be easily invested in another short term profit project tomorrow. Therefore, I say long term should be done by a foundation that has the explicit goal to achieve, rather than a corp whose sole purpose is to make profit.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by pluma on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @06:12AM (#17857678)
> rather than a corp whose sole purpose is to make profit

So we've all now universally accepted the Friedman doctrine?

You're aware that the Friedman doctrine isn't held as an inherent truth everywhere and by everyone, right? Not every culture sees corporations as having the sole moral duty of maximising shareholder value with no regard for societal wellbeing.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by imglorp on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @08:03AM (#17858127)
Actually neither! There is one level more pessimistic than Friedman, which is Greenspan's parting realization. [1] So it's three layers of theft now. Public corps ...

    Society's wellbeing < shareholder's value < executive's value
So you get these axemen who show up, extract whatever they can from the corporation, and then walk away from the ruins for the next thief, if anything is left. They're TWO layers removed from society.

1. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/24/business/economy/24panel....

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by skookumchuck on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @05:24AM (#17857538)
> The market does not seem to be good at optimizing for long-term outcomes, bluntly.

The S&P500 has done extremely well, long term.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by TheOtherHobbes on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:56PM (#17855202)
it's not about spite, it's about noblesse oblige.

Corporations are essentially feudal, and one of the biggest unstated goals is to maintain and signal class power differentials.

You don't do that by including social inferiors in board-level deliberations - no matter how inane, misguided, and ultimately self-destructive those deliberations turn out to be.

Here is one example of a board-level decision that a majority of workers would have said was a very bad idea, but which executives decided to complete anyway.

It's really ridiculously easy to list other examples from corporate history:

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2018/mar/30/homebas...

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prepend on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:17PM (#17855907)
If it were actually more valuable then someone would buy the company, fire the noblesse oblige and hire new management.

The reality is that there’s a point of decreasing returns for productivity. If the “happy workers make more money for the company” truly had a positive ROI, then the market would pay it. There’s plenty of capital willing to make long term investments that would take companies private to jack up wages.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by AlexandrB on Monday August 27, 2018 @11:42PM (#17856419)
> If it were actually more valuable then someone would buy the company, fire the noblesse oblige and hire new management.

Comical. "The Market" is far from perfect - especially in more monopolized industries. Consider the 2008 housing crash for a recent[1] example where "the market" did not behave rationally across a wide swath of professional investors. Add to that the fact that the "someone" in your example is most likely part of the noblesse oblige themselves and will default to respecting the opinion of the board (no matter how wrong) and not the workers.

> If the “happy workers make more money for the company” truly had a positive ROI, then the market would pay it.

Most often, the market behaves like a gradient descent algorithm - seeking slightly more optimal operating conditions without rocking the boat too much. This normally leads to finding local minima, not global ones. The most notable exception is "startups", where the initial conditions of the search may be radically different than a typical big-co - sometimes leading to better results.

Now consider that most medium-to-large companies have been operating for years (maybe decades) on the assumption that cutting costs - including wages - is the best way incrementally optimize profit. Reversing direction would mean going back uphill for a while as the culture, employee attitudes, and recruitment pipeline slowly change in response. How many boards do you think would put up with years of declining profits during the attempt to find the better way?

This doesn't mean that there aren't examples of companies that take this approach even for low-skilled labor[2][3]. Just that it's rare because of conventional wisdom and the corporate politics involved in making it happen.

[1] An even more recent example is Theranos - where companies that should have known better bet big on partnerships with a vaporware medical company against the explicit advice of consultants they had hired to advise them on these matters.

[2] https://www.businessinsider.com/costco-pays-retail-employees...

[3] http://brandautopsy.com/2007/01/the_starbucks_e.html

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by danaris on Monday August 27, 2018 @06:10PM (#17854990)
How compelling an argument is doesn't necessarily have anything to do with how much truth it holds.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by throwaway2048 on Monday August 27, 2018 @05:49PM (#17854872)
Shareholders don't always act in a rational way, plenty of companies and trillions in shareholder value have been destroyed by stupid short sighted shareholder demands.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prepend on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:18PM (#17855912)
In the aggregate long term they do.

Shareholders don’t act rationally, but the market eventually does.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by AlexandrB on Monday August 27, 2018 @11:52PM (#17856456)
> Shareholders don’t act rationally, but the market eventually does.

Citation needed. I hate to bring up 2008 again, but the market first acted irrationally by over-investing in garbage CDOs and then "corrected" in a way that would have tanked the economy without massive public intervention. If that's rational behavior than perhaps we should nominate the next person drunkenly weaving between two lanes for Driver of the Year.

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by prepend on Thursday August 30, 2018 @06:54AM (#17875626)
“Eventually” being a key word as there are corrects. 2008 is one year out of many.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by gowld on Tuesday August 28, 2018 @12:43AM (#17856576)
"Rational" does not mean "maximizing profit". Sometimes rational mean throwing a failed experiment in the trash, after a past irrational or poor decision.
[dead]
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by dang on Monday August 27, 2018 @07:17PM (#17855313)
Please don't take HN threads into ideological flamewar. We're really trying to avoid that here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by fake-name on Monday August 27, 2018 @08:33PM (#17855715)
Huh? I'm legitimately missing what's controversial here.
Re:Why U.S. Corporate Boards Don’t Include Workers by dang on Monday August 27, 2018 @09:39PM (#17856015)
I've written about this a lot, if you want to read about it:

https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...

Most of those comments are ironically pretty generic but there is also plenty of explanation.