While some markets need to be torn open it's always done with a total disregard for the average Joe's who are caught in the crossfire and are paying the price for it.
I get where you're coming from about the exasperatingly impossible web of moral obligations, but you can't give up.
That's just appeal to empathy - any human has it, until he's a sociopath, but like any other basic instinct, it's human nature to reign over it and not let it run your life.
> Because he has a family. Because that's my friend and uncle and neighbor.
Most likely he's not - there are very few people who I (or you) would actually call family and care about in the way you care about family. This Joe is most likely just an anonymous person that you don't know or care about.
> I get where you're coming from about the exasperatingly impossible web of moral obligations, but you can't give up.
I can't give up something that I didn't put on myself first.
I mean should my window cleaning really be 5 bucks cheaper if that means the guy/gal doing it is not insured if he/she falls of the ladder and can never work again? If you let people choose to take those kinds of risk there will always be some people doing it. Undercutting the people who don't want to take these risk but get forced because they need to be competitive.
That's why we had those kind of labour laws in the first place. Because we thought while being allowed to compete everyone should have certain basic rights which should never be compromised.
This is a very high level of abstraction. Making the world a better place is sometimes interesting and to me, and sometimes it's something that I (or you) would be completely indifferent to. Unless you're from a Coke commercial or a hippy commune, "making the world a better place" is not really what you're after.
Now, how are all these things that you mentioned actually relevant to your or me?
Well that depends on the kind of person you are. To stay with my earlier example; I personally like the person who cleans my windows to not have to go live under a bridge if that person falls off the ladder and never being able to work again. All because my window cleaning had to be a bit cheaper.
So if its relevant for you is a matter of personal taste.
Because the next wave of innovation might send them and their market out to sea.
We've just seen the first phase of the Industrial Revolution with the automating of physical labor, and the automation of mental labor is still in its infancy, but the obsolescence of the "knowledge worker" is coming.
Are there drawbacks? Of course and these are things I rarely see mentioned because the "techies have it so well" is just too good of a narrative. Some examples: no pensions (haha, but the article mentioned it, so why not?), no unions, no overtime, some get stuck with 24/7 on-call rotations, constant need to self-improve or get laid by the wayside, average job security. I can go on.
Personally I would call government employees privileged. High job security and if you just "do your time", you get set with a sweet pension!
Compared to the UK:
Pensions suck
Tax treatment of options suck
You Don't have "any" statutory leave and much less AL period.
Sick pay is non existent a good professional employer will offer > 6 months on full payhttps://www.theatlantic.com/author/alana-semuels/
Of these eleven articles, ten of them run against Amazon, its business model, or its affects on society either directly in the headline or in the tagline listed on her author page...the only one I could find that didn't was "Free Shipping Isn't Hurting Amazon" piece.
So, as a person who had written a bunch of articles in the last 7 months criticizing Amazon, did that color her expectations of her Amazon Flex experience? It seems pretty clear she took the job so that she could write the piece, even basically admitting at one point that she was carrying around her reporter's notebook while on at least one of her Flex runs.
I doubt she made any false statements, but along with the objective statements, she included quite a number of subjective ones which clearly supported a thesis of "Amazon ruthlessly exploits the gig economy". And a significant portion of the article was dedicated to her own "tech support" issues...none of which seemed to be supported by quoted observations from the people she interviewed.
I don't doubt that there are valid problems and criticisms of Amazon Flex. I just don't know how much I can trust this article to objectively communicate them.
I trust her article because she focused on the facts:
* delivery address information wrong
* heavy boxes
* No ability to contact recipient for delivery
* unreliable app for scanning packages
* etc.
"Balance" is bs if balance comes at the cost of accuracy.
To put it another way: I also order using Flex and I've never considered working a gig. Am I somehow supposed to feel bad because of this simply due to the author's hardships or feel bad about myself because I don't need to work a gig job?
Please help me understand the zeitgeist here because the downvotes surely aren't.
If you think you'll never have to consider doing this type of work, I don't think you should feel bad about using Flex, but I hope you will acknowledge that you are enjoying a level of prosperity that doesn't seem to be available to everyone.
Also, awareness of how business is able to turn things that used to be costs into externalities may be an early step in the process of making them take responsibility for costs that seem (to me) to be rightfully their own responsibility.
Do you just want to deny these are issues? If so why?
Why is it someone else's fault if you lift something too heavy for you? What is "too heavy" is a fairly personal thing. It's trivial to tell if something is too heavy for you. Do I need to explain how?
As for not injuring yourself from lifting, that's a skill everyone should learn by themselves, like how to not fall down the stairs. It's not someone else's fault.
The weight given in the article was "over 30 pounds", which is 14kg. That should not trouble a healthy adult and could easily be expected when you sign up for a job delivering package. For comparison, airlines use the "heavy baggage" tag above 23kg, and depending on the airline accept bags up to 50kg or so.
If you can reasonably do that without damaging your back, and you choose to make an ill advised lift, maybe that's on you.
Where it's debatable is how well Amazon set you up for solving the 30kg problem in a safe way. It's quite possible they failed in providing reasonable instruction and equipment to this guy.
Without looking it up, what's the recommended technique to lift a 30 kg box from the back of a van?
Anecdotally, I flew Norwegian recently and I was the only one that handled the luggage. I had to figure out how to attach the label, which was mildly intimidating.
If a dolly will help, you can pick one up for 40 bucks or so (ironically, from Amazon!). I keep one around, because I find it useful. Many occupations require you to furnish your own tools (and if you're an auto mechanic, that can run into thousands). I've bought and used personal equipment at every job I've ever had.
I was being paid GBP 76.00 per week which has to cover heat & light, food, telephone, internet, gas for the car, car insurance, car tax, etc....it goes on. There is nothing left. I was also being paid "housing benefit" which doesn't pay anywhere near the actual cost of rent.
You should try this some time before making such poorly informed and sweeping statements.
I'm genuinely not sure if you're completely unaware of the real world financial problems low paid folks have, or are just trolling now.
But they're missing the larger critical points which are very newsworthy:
- The author almost injured themselves with an overly heavy box because Amazon didn't provide them with a dolly, warn them they needed one, and if they did injure themselves the medical bills are their own
- Amazon is asking them to deliver packages where parking without getting a ticket is a logistical impossibility and risk making negative $ for the day due to tickets
- These kinds of safety and minimum wage regulations which have been hard-won over the past decades are being completely avoided by Amazon by (possibly wrongly/illegally) classifying them as independent contractors, which seems to be a scandal that laws/regulations ought to fix, but compulsory arbitration may be preventing class-action lawsuits which would otherwise correct the situation