News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by samfisher83 on Saturday August 18, 2018 @04:09PM (#17790372)
These are the specific points they are going after:

    -display housing ads either only to men or women;
    -not show ads to Facebook users interested in an "assistance dog," "mobility scooter," "accessibility" or "deaf culture";   
    -not show ads to users whom Facebook categorizes as interested in "child care" or "parenting," or show ads only to users with children above a specified age;
    -to display/not display ads to users whom Facebook categorizes as interested in a particular place of worship, religion or tenet, such as the "Christian Church," "Sikhism," "Hinduism," or the "Bible."
    -not show ads to users whom Facebook categorizes as interested in "Latin America," "Canada," "Southeast Asia," "China," "Honduras," or "Somalia."
    -draw a red line around zip codes and then not display ads to Facebook users who live in specific zip codes.
The 1st 4 should have never been allowed. This is a 50 year old law. Its not like its something new.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by matchagaucho on Saturday August 18, 2018 @08:46PM (#17791806)
How much of the responsibility falls on the Landlord, given they created the targeted ad segments?

It's not like the Facebook Ad Manager has a guided wizard for the real estate industry to target prospective tenants.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by sorokod on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:15AM (#17793778)
It is not like there is a physical law of responsibility conservation. Multiple entities can carry 100% responsibility.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by extralego on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:02AM (#17794126)
Bless this comment. I think this is a succinct representation of the struggles we are facing as a society.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by rfugger on Sunday August 19, 2018 @02:15PM (#17795472)
Like links in a chain, they are all required for the chain to hold.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by jahewson on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:47PM (#17792268)
Facebook knows exactly what kind of advertisers they have on their platform.

https://www.facebook.com/business/success/quadrant-homes

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by vt_throwaway123 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:38PM (#17795276)
IANAL but it seems both from the comments here and common sense that the law only makes ad publishers liable for discriminatory ads, not advertising campaigns that target in a discriminatory way while advertisers are liable for both. Making publishers liable for the latter is also problematic and likely unprecedented because typically publishers do not have this information. Any given publisher only receives some portion of the entire advertising budget for the campaign and cannot possibly know how the rest of the budget is spent and whether the full campaign adds up to being discriminatory.

For example, if you own a newspaper that caters to people of a specific national origin, are you not allowed to accept any housing ads? By definition, any ad placement on that newspaper is discriminatory in terms of targeting - without knowing the full details of the campaign, they cannot verify that the overall targeting is not discriminatory. This means that any law that makes publishers liable must be restricted to the content of the ads and any law that goes after the demographic targeting likely limits liability to the entity - the advertiser or perhaps agencies - who have full control and knowledge of the targeting in question.

Does this make sense?

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by swerveonem on Saturday August 18, 2018 @09:01PM (#17791874)
Facebook did this or housing companies used the Facebook targeting boolean option to configure ad campaigns in this way?
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by twblalock on Saturday August 18, 2018 @09:57PM (#17792094)
It doesn't really make a difference, because when housing companies use Facebook's targeting options it is still Facebook who accepts the ad and publishes it on facebook.com.

If you do something illegal because someone asked you to do it, it's still illegal.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by vt_throwaway123 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:41PM (#17796070)
The problem with this reasoning is that assuming the content of the ad is not discriminatory, delivering the ad to some subset of your audience is highly unlikely to be illegal. For example, if you're a publisher that owns two magazines, one of which is popular among blacks and another is popular among whites, I don't think it's still illegal to publish ads on one but not the other, again, provided that the ad itself does not have illegal contents. The onus must be on the advertiser because the full extent of the targeting for the given campaign is not knowable for the publisher. Maybe the advertiser wants to reach men on one publisher and women on another publisher, this isn't something any given publisher can fully determine. Given how advertising works and has worked in the past, it's unlikely that any law would put the responsibility on a publisher for an entire campaign to be free of illegal discrimination on the basis of an audience it reaches.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by sjg007 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:52PM (#17796377)
In this case the targeting of the ad is discriminatory and illegal. That is the context of the ad which is just as important as the content.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by fjsolwmv on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:41PM (#17792247)
It's not obvious to me. If I photocopy an ilegal ad at Kinko's, is it Kinko's fault? If I send an illegal ad via first class mail, is it USPS's fault?
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by thisiszilff on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:48PM (#17792276)
I don't think it's the ad, per say, but the agreement for delivery. It's be like you sending housing ads and asking USPS to only deliver them to men. USPS would probably be on the hook then as well.

Back to your point though, it is a new domain because with your paper examples there is no one who can "undo" the illegal ad. You copy it at Kinko's and it's not like Kinko's is out there delivering it with you. With online platforms, they both Target and deliver these ads and are responsible for continually delivering them.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by Broken_Hippo on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:29AM (#17793259)
Sometimes. They sold it to you.

Example: I worked at a pharmacy with the self-serve digital photo services. A customer brought in a CD and made christmas cards from a family picture.

It turns out the picture was taken by a local photographer the customer had hired. The pharmacy I worked at got the legal notice. Supposedly, we were partly to blame since we profited off of the cards the customer printed. Nevermind the fact that we didn't generally check the customer's pictures, nor could we actually have guessed these were professional vs a good picture.

The customer cropped out the identifying marks. We had all seen pictures that looked professional, both in digital and film form. It seems none of that mattered. It wouldn't be Kinko's fault that you photocopy an illegal ad, but they can be party to the fault by allowing it to be sold.

Now, the USPS probably has completely different laws protecting it. I'm going to guess it is more likely that they try to get you for mail fraud rather than actually hold the USPS responsible.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by SOLAR_FIELDS on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:07PM (#17795119)
If you get photos printed at Walmart (or at least when I tried a few years ago) they make you either sign an indemnification agreement or refuse to print the photos. I remember one issue in particular - my wife had purchased some logos/prints online from someone on Etsy for a friend's baby shower. They still had the watermark on them and Walmart refused to print them without a signed release from the original artist.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by Broken_Hippo on Monday August 20, 2018 @04:01AM (#17798350)
That's common on the software from the companies producing the machines (we had it too), and isn't quite enough.

It is pretty ridiculous in these cases, honestly. This particular picture didn't have a "photographer's studio" setup - it was an outdoor picture with the family around a long, metal farm gate and the photographer sold the customer the CD. There wasn't much the store could do to prevent this, and we had to start physically checking a lot of pictures at that store.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by eahman00 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:44AM (#17793511)
>a pharmacy with the self-serve digital photo services

...Why does a pharmacy print photographies? I've never heard of a pharmacy selling something that isn't drugs.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by Zarel on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:51AM (#17793527)
In the US and many other countries (I can confirm this is true for Japan), pharmacies are also convenience stores, and sell many other things besides drugs.

https://www.cvs.com/

For instance, here's a US pharmacy chain – notice it mentions photos on the home page.

[dead]
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by ajdlinux on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:16AM (#17793783)
In Australia, we don't have the same culture of pharmacies being convenience stores as in the US (and certainly not selling cigarettes!), or the same issues with prescription drugs (it's illegal to advertise them here like in most places), but pharmacies regularly dedicate half of their floor space on cosmetics, and it's not uncommon to have photo printing machines too - back in the days of film cameras, the pharmacy was where we would drop off film rolls for developing.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by dralley on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:46AM (#17793689)
The "invasive ads", while really shitty, are for prescription-only drugs, and it's the drug companies behind those, not the pharmacies. You can't just walk into a pharmacy to get those drugs.

They're "convenience stores" in the sense that they also sell things like soap, laundry detergent, toothbrushes/toothpaste/floss/mouthwash, paper towels, toilet paper, cleaning supplies, etc. It has nothing to do with getting people to buy more drugs, it's just another thing to sell. Stores in the US tend to be bigger and stand alone, so if you've got a sizable building you want to fill it with something to sell.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by bardworx on Sunday August 19, 2018 @06:26AM (#17793623)
In search of continues growth, pharmacies in the US had to expand their offerings.

Since someone will go there to get their prescription filled or pick up some Asprin, it makes sense to start selling vitamins, then some household essentials, and before you know it Walgreens is selling fruits and veggies.

Pictures being printed in pharmacies have been around since 90s, at least.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by EliRivers on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:02AM (#17793926)
I did once hear that part of it is historical. That in some places, many years ago, because photo developing was a much more manual process using more primitive means, and given that pharmacists of the time were used to handling and storing chemicals, and carefully following chemical processes and so on, that there was a natural link between the two. This would be back before the time of posting your film to Snappy Snaps, or there being a centralised photo-developing laboratory with an associated chain of collection huts that simply acted as the interface to the public. Once an association is created - exposed film goes to the pharmacy to be developed - it tends to linger.

However, I've not been able to find any evidence of this. It could just be a just-so story.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by rmc on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:02AM (#17793928)
It's very common in UK for pharmacies to print digital photos (and in the past, develop films). German drug stores also have this service.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by jahewson on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:51PM (#17792285)
What a dumb question. No, of course it’s not.

If you ask USPS to display your illegal ad in their window then it certainly is their fault. That would be an actually comparable situation here.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by mirimir on Saturday August 18, 2018 @11:07PM (#17792338)
Well, there was a criminal case against FedEx for delivering illegal prescriptions from Internet drug stores. But it got tossed.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by fit2rule on Sunday August 19, 2018 @03:42AM (#17793087)
Is FedEx marketing itself to drug distributors as a way to filter out the chaff and get straight to the drug users of highest value?

I think not.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by tekromancr on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:11PM (#17792139)
The geotargeting polygon was literally RED!?!

I can believe that being an oversight, but holy Shit those optics... yikes

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by jahewson on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:17PM (#17792155)
For those outside the US who may be wondering why this is so significant:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redlining

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by nasredin on Sunday August 19, 2018 @12:01PM (#17794768)
>>In the United States, redlining is the systematic denial of various services to residents of specific, often racially associated, neighborhoods or communities, either directly or through the selective raising of prices.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by EdwardDiego on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:35AM (#17793485)
Ah, thank you :)
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by downandout on Sunday August 19, 2018 @05:39AM (#17793496)
What exactly is wrong with excluding certain areas from seeing your ad? If I'm selling high end jewelry, for example, I don't want my ad shown to people in low income areas, because every click is a waste of money. Similarly, a discount store in a bad part of town may want to exclude wealthy neighborhoods, as people from those neighborhoods are unlikely to come to the store. That doesn't seem like something anyone should be upset about...it's common sense.

I guess it's a little more murky when it comes to housing, but how many people in downtown Watts are going to be legitimate potential leads to rent a house in Beverly Hills? I'm not sure that advertisers should be forced to pay for ads to be shown to people that cannot afford or would otherwise not be interested in what they are trying to sell.

[dead]
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by downandout on Sunday August 19, 2018 @08:45PM (#17797050)
My comment was in response to a specific comment criticizing the exclusion of certain zip codes. To my knowledge, zip codes are not legally protected discrimination criteria. I suppose one could argue that they can be a proxy for excluding people based on criteria that is legally protected, however, that argument is unlikely to be successful if the primary motivation for using zip codes was to target those of certain income levels, which is also not legally protected.

In the future, before saying such snarky things (which are of little value to the discussion), perhaps you should read the comment you are responding to. The first sentence of my comment limited its scope to the location issue:

What exactly is wrong with excluding certain areas from seeing your ad?

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by tekromancr on Monday August 20, 2018 @01:24PM (#17801852)
Because zip codes can, in many cases for many historical reasons, strongly correlate with brown and black folks, which are legally protected classes.

As much as you might think you are being clever by just saying "Oh, I'm just excluding AREAS, not people" you are still running afoul of the law since you are effectively using zip codes as a proxy for race. This has been tried before and the courts aren't really fooled by it.

So, no, there is nothing inherently wrong with excluding certain areas from seeing your ad, unless you are using the area exclusion mechanism as a proxy for excluding based on race/sexuality/religion or some other protected status.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by downandout on Monday August 20, 2018 @05:57PM (#17804377)
you are still running afoul of the law

The point is that you are not necessarily running afoul of the law by excluding zip codes in the absence of other evidence that you intended to discriminate. Excluding poor neighborhoods from seeing a $10 million home listing is common sense, not discrimination.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by rocqua on Sunday August 19, 2018 @09:01AM (#17794119)
A common trend when tech companies are hit by regulation outside their direct business is to argue the regulation shouldn't apply. Sometimes the reasoning is that the issues of regulation are solved by tech, sometimes it is that the regulations impede innovation, sometimes the reasoning states that the net benefit outweighs the occasional loss.

Often such arguments are just trying to prevent regulation, but there are situations where regulation wasn't written with this tech in mind and therefore doesn't quite apply. At the very least, the discussion can be fruitful.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by bumholio on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:17AM (#17793211)
Redlining does not mean simply drawing red polygons on the map. To be guilty of redlining, Facebook must have known the ethnic/racial/religious composition of the excluded areas and it must have known that the advertisers were using the tools for discrimination. Quite a tall order.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by themarkn on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:40AM (#17793867)
I don't consider it a tall order, it's exactly what I'd expect advertisers to do with these tools, if there was no specific process to prevent them from doing so.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by tekromancr on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:54PM (#17795366)
This case hinges on three facts. First, displaying housing ads that exclude protected classes is illegal. Second is that Facebook built tools that allowed advertisers to create said illegal ads. Finally, Facebook had no oversight process to reject potentially illegal ads. The fact that Facebook created tools that allowed advertisers to effectively cause Facebook to break the law in an automated fashion isn't really much of a defense.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by eahman00 on Saturday August 18, 2018 @05:28PM (#17790849)
>to display/not display ads to users whom Facebook categorizes as interested in a particular place of worship, religion or tenet, such as the "Christian Church," "Sikhism," "Hinduism," or the "Bible."

It says "such as"; I'm interested if this list includes "synagogue" or "Torah". Is there any place the entire list is included?

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by dsr_ on Saturday August 18, 2018 @10:13PM (#17792145)
No. The point of non-discrimination is not to protect certain classes, but to protect everyone. The list to check against has to grow over time to reflect current usage.

"colanders", "pirates", "meatballs": the Pastafarians are just as much a protected class as Catholics, Jains and Druze.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by int_19h on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:45AM (#17792802)
> the Pastafarians are just as much a protected class as Catholics, Jains and Druze.

Only if they can demonstrate that their religious beliefs are sincere. There have been some court cases along these lines already.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by vkou on Sunday August 19, 2018 @01:55AM (#17792826)
Nobody asks a Christian to confirm that their beliefs are sincere, and that they aren't just pretending to believe in God, for the social benefits it brings.
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by shard972 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @02:42AM (#17792938)
Have you been watching US politics in the last few years?

At this point people just seem to make the assumption that people like donald trump are just lying about their faith as if it's a completely normal thing to assert about someone.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by ben_w on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:10AM (#17793172)
That exact thing happens in the UK.

https://www.sundaypost.com/news/uk-news/school-places-withdr...

For purposes of going to secondary school, I was raised Catholic. Slightly more completed my case as although my dad was an atheist, my mum thought she was taking it seriously (given how many New Age books and Hindu icons and statues she had, I don’t count her as a proper Catholic).

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by roel_v on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:38AM (#17793862)
Well just the last week, the Dutch highest administrative court ruled that Pastafarianism is not a real religion. Do you at least see why (you don't have to agree, just understand)?
Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by Retric on Sunday August 19, 2018 @07:55AM (#17793905)
I can understand the reasoning. However, that ruling does not apply to the US.

It’s something of a cultural identity issue in the US. Mocking religious beliefs in the abstract is often acceptable, but mocking specific people is far less so.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by int_19h on Monday August 20, 2018 @02:24AM (#17798064)
Like I said, there have been similar court rulings in US. Look up Stephen Cavanaugh for one example.

So, yes, it does apply in US as well - you have freedom of religion, but it has to be an "actual religion", whatever that means. Things might have been different if the Constitution just spoke of freedom of consciousness or some such; but we have what we have.

This, by the way, is one of the reason why the Satanic Temple has been a lot more successful with its lawsuits so far (e.g. https://religiousreproductiverights.com/lawsuit-status/lawsu... - but also numerous cases where a mere threat of a lawsuit causes the local government to change its tune) - because it tries to present itself in a way that makes it clear that trolling isn't the only thing it is about.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by Retric on Monday August 20, 2018 @10:43AM (#17800297)
There is plenty of nuance here. Washington County, Minnesota is an example of backing down vs FSM.

Really, Cavanaugh's seeking 5 million and an exemption from various prison rules put the issue in different light than officiating marriages.

Which is why the generalizing rulings is tricky and you need to keep jurisdiction in mind.

Re:HUD Files Housing Discrimination Complaint Against Facebook by creaghpatr on Saturday August 18, 2018 @06:32PM (#17791210)
I guess you could in theory go buy some ads on fb and see what it lets you scope