Re:Kofi Annan has died
by krapp on Saturday August 18, 2018 @02:49PM
(#17789940)
> So for the vast majority of history we weren’t human?
For any definition of "human" that is objective and universal, yes.
If you swore fealty to the wrong lord, worshiped the wrong god, were born into the wrong clan, ethnic group or state, you were considered something less than human. And of course, nobles claimed descent from divinity, making them more than human.
The concept of a common humanity with inalienable rights is relatively modern and in many places still controversial.
Re:Kofi Annan has died
by eric24234 on Sunday August 19, 2018 @04:49AM
(#17793338)
This is very true in Indian caste system. In fact in indian caste ladder system, one become lesser human as one takes birth in the lesser caste hierarchy. Except the Brahmin community in the indian caste system others castes are denied education as per the vedas. During the british rule everone got access to education and every one is trying to be a equal human fighting the caste system.
Re:Kofi Annan has died
by EliRivers on Saturday August 18, 2018 @02:23PM
(#17789789)
I guess that depends on how you like to define humanity, doesn't it? If it's simply being a general sort of shape, or having a particular set of DNA, then perhaps being human is a simple yes/no. This creature isn't human, that creature is.
If you like to define humanity as an ideal, or a process, or a goal, or some other such, then it becomes much more of a spectrum.
All that said, anyone who does think in terms of binary when it comes to humanity needs keeping an eye on.
Re:Kofi Annan has died
by k__ on Saturday August 18, 2018 @09:43AM
(#17788413)
I wouldn't consider this a static property.
Back in the days it was humane to make many children because most of them would die. Today it may be more humane to make only a few but to invest more time into each.
Re:Kofi Annan has died
by WalterSear on Saturday August 18, 2018 @12:55PM
(#17789351)
I see political news flagged faster and harder. Was David Bowie's death flagged?
IMHO, despite all the work done here on censorship and topic management, I've experienced a greater level of meanspiritedness and unkind comments here than on any other comment forum I've frequented.
Perhaps that's >why< there is such a presence and the need to shut down check potentially conttroversial topics. It begs the question of what is different on this forum.
Re:Kofi Annan has died
by krapp on Saturday August 18, 2018 @03:04PM
(#17790035)
>Was David Bowie's death flagged?
I know I flagged it, I flag every death thread I see.
Some of these threads generate interesting discussion, but most of them just descend into maudlin nonsense, nostalgia or a cesspool of political or pop-cultural references. If these people weren't worth discussing on Hacker News when they were alive - and let's be honest, most of them haven't been, then their deaths shouldn't be worth discussing either.
Re:Kofi Annan has died
by thefounder on Saturday August 18, 2018 @08:37AM
(#17788188)
You don't know how U.N millitary forces work. They get "final" orders from their origin country not from the UN president. The country leaders didn't want to risk the lifes of their mil people so they backed off. UN is more a "voluntary" club with very little power(see the Iraq war)
As far as the saints are concerned I don't think people want or vote for saints...just look at our leaders! Ha ha! Saint Trump, Saint Putin, Saint Orban, Saint Duterte...
For any definition of "human" that is objective and universal, yes.
If you swore fealty to the wrong lord, worshiped the wrong god, were born into the wrong clan, ethnic group or state, you were considered something less than human. And of course, nobles claimed descent from divinity, making them more than human.
The concept of a common humanity with inalienable rights is relatively modern and in many places still controversial.
If you like to define humanity as an ideal, or a process, or a goal, or some other such, then it becomes much more of a spectrum.
All that said, anyone who does think in terms of binary when it comes to humanity needs keeping an eye on.
Back in the days it was humane to make many children because most of them would die. Today it may be more humane to make only a few but to invest more time into each.
I sometimes see political news on HN, I don’t think I’ve ever seen pop culture news.
IMHO, despite all the work done here on censorship and topic management, I've experienced a greater level of meanspiritedness and unkind comments here than on any other comment forum I've frequented.
Perhaps that's >why< there is such a presence and the need to shut down check potentially conttroversial topics. It begs the question of what is different on this forum.
I know I flagged it, I flag every death thread I see.
Some of these threads generate interesting discussion, but most of them just descend into maudlin nonsense, nostalgia or a cesspool of political or pop-cultural references. If these people weren't worth discussing on Hacker News when they were alive - and let's be honest, most of them haven't been, then their deaths shouldn't be worth discussing either.
I am happy to keep such main stream news off the FP.
I am suggesting these threads were not controversial and were flagged down because they are boring.
As far as the saints are concerned I don't think people want or vote for saints...just look at our leaders! Ha ha! Saint Trump, Saint Putin, Saint Orban, Saint Duterte...