News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atom 1.29 by DC-3 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @04:00AM (#17660443)
Honest question: can someone explain why everyone loves emoji these days, especially with regards to 'modern' programming communities such as those around JS and Rust? Is it just a celebration of the fact that we have Unicode support everywhere now?
Re:Atom 1.29 by saagarjha on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @04:10AM (#17660478)
I think the goal is adding a sense of lightheartedness and by humanizing code in general, which has historically had the perception of being dry.
Re:Atom 1.29 by afraca on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @04:41AM (#17660629)
I don't mind it being used in some (mostly) 'closed off' service, but given how commit messages from git will show up on several locations it seems a bad idea to allow users to use `:art:` in a commit message IMHO.
Re:Atom 1.29 by calv on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @06:33AM (#17661242)
Also if your coding guidelines can use emojis in commit message to mean a certain thing if you all have a common lookup and it becomes natural to see what a change affects. e.g. :bug: for fixing bugs
Re:Atom 1.29 by majewsky on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @10:14AM (#17662642)
You can do that with plain ASCII, e.g. Github recognizes the phrase "Closes #123." in commit messages and autocloses that issue when the commit is merged into master. I've seen similar commit hooks in SVN over 10 yrs ago.
Re:Atom 1.29 by matt4077 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:55AM (#17661064)
I don't think it has an explicit "goal", as in someone wondering "How can my code appear more humanizing?"

It's just that people somehow enjoy this new new dimension of expression in text-only media. It has long been pretty obvious that text lacks the subtlety of face-to-face or voice interactions, and that many problems stem from people misjudging the intended tone of writing. Emojis, while imperfect, may help ;)

Re:Atom 1.29 by PurpleRamen on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @07:01AM (#17661363)
Emojis are the new punctuation marks. Displaying emotions in written text started at some point with the exclamation mark, which over time evolved and shifted in meaning. At some point !!! become a different meaning then a single !, and !? was added too. But then someone developed the smilie and the 90's was all about :-) and ;-> and sometimes even =^o^=. But it was kinda hard to write on mobile devices and took too much space in SMS. So the emojis were invented, standards were created and at some point universal support was established and the explosion of usage begun. Now people can communicate emotional without the need to write lengthly words.
Re:Atom 1.29 by strongbond on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @07:35AM (#17661534)
According to https://blog.sourcerer.io/ascii-art-dead-or-alive-cc237391e5... the first ASCII emoticons were written by scott Fahlman in 1982.
Re:Atom 1.29 by DannyB2 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @10:57AM (#17663043)
> can someone explain why everyone loves emoji these days

What do you have against emojis? I'm hoping I can set my hostname to all emoji characters (UTF-8) so that other workstations on the network will show my hostname as those emoji characters.

Re:Atom 1.29 by crehn on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @08:28AM (#17661846)
They convey emotions and add a touch of lightheartedness and fun. It's all about a healthy balance. You can still have constructive discussions about complex topics, with emojis, without giving up the Professional Adult™ card.
Re:Atom 1.29 by wyldfire on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @09:30AM (#17662289)
Would that the unicode support was indeed ubiquitous. Then you wouldn't need to parse the message for things like ":penguin:", you could just include the appropriate character/icon.
Re:Atom 1.29 by superdaniel on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @12:43PM (#17664203)
Is there a downside to including the actual unicode emoji versus the text version that needs to be rendered? I tend to go for the former.
Re:Atom 1.29 by omeid2 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:18AM (#17660849)
I find the whole trend very childish and unprofessional. Why? Because emojis don't convey much meaning and borders on child-talk, worst yet, they're very vague and so makes for very poor and unprofessional form of communication.
Re:Atom 1.29 by Aeolun on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:34AM (#17660932)
I am baffled by your assertion that they convey little meaning. Do facial expressions also convey little meaning?

To me the combination of both gives a hell of a lot more to base interpretation of tone on.

Re:Atom 1.29 by toomanybeersies on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @09:20AM (#17662206)
The issue I have with emojis is that they are rendered different on different fonts/devices, and because of this they can convey a different meaning.
Re:Atom 1.29 by Klathmon on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @09:28AM (#17662273)
And text is read wildly differently depending on the readers's culture, mood, font, and how well they know the language.

Communication is messy as hell, and the fact that emoji's render differently doesn't add that much confusion in most cases (of course there are the odd watergun vs revolver emoji problems, but the worst offenders are slowly being brought into line)

Re:Atom 1.29 by toomanybeersies on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @08:10PM (#17668224)
If I send a text message from Android to iPhone, the message is the same. Obviously there's cultural differences etc. but I can usually work with those if I know the person I'm sending a message to.

However, emojis can change when sending them from my Android phone to an iPhone, changing the meaning of the message inadvertently.

Re:Atom 1.29 by tehbeard on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @08:25AM (#17661817)
1. The size of emoji makes them difficult to grok, probably more so when you have to context switch between language comprehension and determining the emotion of the face. Also factor in how they look different on different platforms.

2. What about emoji's that aren't faces, or that have taken on a different meaning (see, eggplant or that infernal clapping emoji that's taken over twitter)

Re:Atom 1.29 by simias on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:51AM (#17661039)
I never use emojis (I'm not even sure how people manage to input them on a keyboard, I assume they're using mobile devices?) but I try to avoid the kneejerk reaction of hating on them, they're mostly harmless. It's very tempting to go on a "back in my days we couldn't even put accents in commit messages" rant but in the end it doesn't really matter.

If it makes writing commit messages more fun and it means that people will make more of an effort to come up with descriptive messages then I say amazing. I can't count the number of open source projects where people write absolutely useless commit messages, even coming from projects I respect. I'll take emojis over "several changes, new stuff" or "some other small fixes" (to quote actual commits from an open source project I've been hacking on lately).

Of course both things are largely unrelated but I just wanted to point out that there's not a very strong "commit etiquette" in the hacker community as of today, it's not like much of value will be lost by letting kids use emojis in them, and maybe a little could be gained.

Re:Atom 1.29 by omeid2 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:57AM (#17661075)
> they're mostly harmless.

I don't believe that, the confusion around the meaning of emojis are well established[0][1][2][3].

I strongly suspect that the confusion and vagueness is even more predominant in professional communications than personal. Please consider that everyday the likelihood of someone reading your code who is from a different culture or context is even higher, somethings might seem obvious to us, but that is not necessarily objectively so.

If you think I am making an argument for using plain and simple language and not just avoid emoji, you're right, that is the point.

From a pure economic point of view, considering the arguably nonexistence value emojis provide, any risk or cost is too much.

0. https://www.businessinsider.com/science-reveals-the-most-con...

1. http://fortune.com/2016/04/14/emoji-miscommunication-study-u...

2. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3549376/Frust...

3. https://www.mrporter.com/journal/modern-problems/the-most-co...

Re:Atom 1.29 by ensignro2340 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @10:39AM (#17662861)
Your first 3 links are all referencing the same University of Minnesota study. Your last link seems to be based on the writer’s observations (I did not find it linking or mentioning any study). I’m not even disagreeing with the fact that some emojis can be misunderstood (especially cross-culturally and when they are displayed very differently on devices) but you can’t just link 3 news stories covering the same study as if you’ve found a mountain of evidence to support your claims.
Re:Atom 1.29 by oblio on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:38AM (#17660961)
Assuming we're talking about commit messages and such, you're probably right.

But in day-to-day chats they're useful. Text is extremely bad at conveying emotion and nuance. Stuff like humor, sarcasm, irony is really hard to transmit, especially with more people. A well placed emoji/smiley can help.

Re:Atom 1.29 by DC-3 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:49AM (#17661028)
I agree with this. I'm certainly not averse to dropping a :-) or emoji equivalent when appropriate. But emoji party hats every time a PR is merged, or READMEs covered with emoji, or worse of all, CLIs that use emoji in them are annoying to me and I don't understand the appeal.
Re:Atom 1.29 by type0 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:57AM (#17661079)
> talking about commit messages

I heard that for some folks it makes it easier to find the right commits, unfortunately it's the opposite of being inclusive because other collaborators can become easily distracted by them.

Re:Atom 1.29 by matt4077 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:51AM (#17661040)
I can't really see how emojis are "vague", or ambiguous. And even if: ambiguity is a great feature in any form of communication, by allowing us, for example, to express criticism early and subtle, defusing social problems before they blow up.

I also think you're placing to much value on some vague notion of "professionalism" which seems to exclude all emotion and any fun.

"Professionalism" in this sense stymies business success by, for example, prohibiting the effective means of communication people choose for themselves with some nebulous argument to appearances.

Re:Atom 1.29 by omeid2 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @08:11AM (#17661736)
See my response to sibling comment. Emojis are a very poor language and very culture dependent far more than words in a natural language like English or whatever.
Re:Atom 1.29 by DC-3 on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:35AM (#17660942)
I agree that they are unprofessional. As far as I can determine, some people feel that they make a project or community seem more inclusive or welcoming - goals which I definitely consider worthwhile. But I don't personally feel that they are helpful in this persuit. Who are you trying to be inclusive of, seven year olds?
Re:Atom 1.29 by vertex-four on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @05:53AM (#17661052)
Outside of your friend group, most of us have been using smileys and emoticons in day-to-day chat for years - the presence of rich emoticons used to set messenger platforms aside from each other - and emojis are simply the latest generation of that. They’re primarily useful for providing some emotional context to some text - and whether displaying emotion is professional or not is really down to personal preference.
Re:Atom 1.29 by wool_gather on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @08:42AM (#17661930)
Maybe I'm just a robot, but by and large I don't believe that log or commit messages require emotional context. (I do use emoji for some messaging, Slack specifically.)
Re:Atom 1.29 by bschwindHN on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @06:16AM (#17661167)
You sound like a very Serious and Professional Adult, feel free to ignore our Fisher-Price word-pictures.