News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by Latteland on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:48AM (#17598416)
what if two higher tax states both claim they are your home state because they want to fight over your taxes. this must happen. that's different than moving 'mostly' to a lower tax state. and then what's the threshold for ny claiming you moved there? what a mess.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by joering2 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:06AM (#17598491)
It happened to my buddy who happens to be millionaire and flies every few weeks cali versus new york. Two years ago state of california sued him for non payment of taxes. It went down to literally receipts from gas station making difference proving he spent over 183 days in new york versus cali. intresting - credit card purchases were not admitted because state tried to prove he used proxy (he does) so he could be in any state when purchasing off of Amazon. He won and gov appealed Then cali went after new york asking for all the evidence of his taxes knowing new york wont comply. For over year both states fight with each other with my friend being literally non-involved. Eventually cali dropped the suit some 16 months after filing appeal.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by isostatic on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:18AM (#17599058)
> proving he spent over 183 days in new york versus cali

What happens if you spend 73 days in each of 5 states? (OK the 183 day rule in NY specific).

Do you have to pick a state to live in for tax purposes?

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by gamblor956 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:35PM (#17605148)
Generally the state where you own a home or else are registered to vote.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by Latteland on Saturday July 28, 2018 @09:26PM (#17635971)
So what if you have apartments in 3 states, 2 with high taxes, one with none, and 365/3 = 121 2/3. Pick a low tax state that has nice weather in the winter, say Florida. So 123 days in florida, 121 days in NY, 121 days in cali. Then you owe no tax. If you really wanted to screw things up you could pick a 4th state say the us virgin islands just for bureaucratic fun.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by everdev on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:12AM (#17598510)
This is insane. Why don't we just pay the federal government the entirety of our tax obligation and have them partition it out to the states? I'd love to spend less than half the year in any one state or be completely state-less.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by labster on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:27AM (#17598574)
The whole point of a federal government is to decentralize authority. If the taxation power rests with a single authority in the United States, then federalism would be dead and the central government would have all the power. It's not necessarily wrong (though I believe it would be a bad idea), but this is one of those questions where the answer to "Why can't the world be simple?" is "Because the world is complex."
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by civilitty on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:39AM (#17598873)
May I introduce you to the 16th amendment:

> The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration

The power of taxation has rested with the federal government since the early 20th century.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by function_seven on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:59AM (#17598966)
This doesn't contradict the parent comment. The Federal Government isn't the single authority on taxes. The 16th amendment grants them the power to lay and collect, but it does not reserve that power exclusively to the Feds.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:05AM (#17598995)
Congress has non-exclusive power to tax under Article I; the 16th Amendment shifted the parameters of that power but did not make it exclusive.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by swebs on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:53AM (#17602165)
Yes, that is why everyone pays federal income tax. State income tax is an additional right given to state governments.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by njarboe on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:18PM (#17605418)
Or, in the American tradition, it is a right not forbidden to state governments.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by pm24601 on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @11:46AM (#17610144)
Read the 10th amendment:

> The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by cylinder on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:04AM (#17598718)
Works pretty well in Australia.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by cmroanirgo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:39AM (#17599143)
Yes, but only because states can't actually collect taxes. [0][1]

Hence, each state collects levies, fines, rates, stamp duties, privatise public services and various other money grubbing exercises in order to raise capital for themselves so that they can waste/embezzle it according to their whims.

Then there's the problem of disproportionate tax distribution, which most states, particularly WA, seem to raise constantly.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitutional_basis_of_taxati... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_90_of_the_Constitution...

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by jacques_chester on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:39AM (#17601402)
Australian states can collect income tax, and did so. But the High Court found that the Commonwealth could collect tax under the Defence power and that it could essentially crowd out any state collection by being first in line.

The states gave up on the practicalities, but they still have the theoretical power to collect income tax.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by cletus on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:39AM (#17599731)
Oh it does not. Take GST division. WA is now getting back about 38 cents in every dollar it collects leaving a massive state budget deficit. States like South Australia get back $1.20 or more.

Why? Because when the GST was introduced WA'S resource income was counted... During an unprecedented resources boom that has since collapsed. You know what doesn't get counted? Poker machine income, which is substantial in the three Eastern states.

Can it be changed? Technically, yes. Practically is incredibly difficult because no one wants to give up revenue and politicians are worried it'll be electoral suicide, which it may well be.

The fact that the government has proposed anything at all, however anemic, is kinda amazing.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by labster on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:04AM (#17598985)
OK, I'll bite. Australia has a population of ~25 million, similar to Texas. So let's work with something of a similar scale to the U.S.: Would you be okay with having all of Australia's taxes being collected by the Commonwealth, and then getting your portion that way?
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by tzs on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:50AM (#17599187)
The population is pretty much irrelevant to scaling for this problem. The relevant parameter is the number of political subdivisions that the national entity would be distributing taxes to, which would be ~50 in the US and ~6 in Australia.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by tzs on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:13PM (#17603028)
...to elaborate, population is irrelevant because the national government is going to collect taxes nationwide for itself regardless of whether or not collecting taxes for the states is added to its duties.

The "this problem" that we are talking about here is the problem of the national government handling state taxes in addition to national taxes. For this problem the national government is dealing with states, not individuals, and so it is the number of states that it has to deal with that is the main factor affecting complexity and scaling.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by meddlepal on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:17AM (#17598779)
Just because it works in Australia doesn't mean it would work in the US. Different people, different culture.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by xg15 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:35AM (#17598855)
"The world is complex" is too often used as an excuse to stop thinking. Yes, it's complex, but then show me the complexity.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by zazen on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:49AM (#17598926)
Perhaps it is used to stop thinking in some other circumstances, but I don't think that's what's happening here. When people make three-sentence internet comments featuring the phrase "Why don't we just", they often appear to have not yet _started_ thinking about the answer to their own question. I think it's fair to prompt them not to outsource all their thinking to the forum.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by xg15 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:47PM (#17604779)
You can discuss whether or not it's "fair", but it probably won't motivate anyone to start thinking. I think it comes over as the opposite: Obviously I can't grasp the complexity of the whole world, so if that is the prerequisite to proposing any kind of solution to a problem, I might as well give up.

A more useful response would be to give reasons why the "why can't we just" solution wouldn't work. (The GP indeed gave reasons)

What is the purpose of a forum if not discussion and getting (positive or negative) feedback on your views so you can improve them?

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by zazen on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @07:28AM (#17608427)
I think we have similar hopes for quality discussion in forums. And I certainly agree that a thoughtful response giving reasons why it's not as simple as "why can't we just" is more useful - assuming anyone feels inclined to write that response.

The problem I see is the following. The person who wrote the "why can't we just" has done next to no thinking of his own as to why the situation might be more complicated than his first thought suggests, but it goes beyond that. Someone who writes "why don't we just" is sending the signal that they're emotionally committed to the position that the solution _should_ be simple. If I take a deep breath and write a long, careful reply in response to the short, lazy "why don't we just" post, I'm not only taking on all the burden of thinking about the topic at hand, but there's every risk this will just be thrown back in my face by the poster who wants a shortcut to a simple answer. A "why don't we just" post has a poor chance of leading to a good discussion, and I think there will be overall more beneficial discussion on a forum if they are discouraged.

Some people are intellectually lazy. I think this is because it's easier to feel smarter when you think less. If there's a solution that seems obvious to Mr. A and he assumes everyone who missed it is a bozo, then Mr. A feels like a smart guy. If someone else comes along and starts telling Mr. A that actually it's not so simple, and there are reasons why the "obvious" solution isn't actually a full applicable solution, then Mr. A has to think harder, only to feel less smart as a result. A lot of people resist that. I don't know the full solution of how to inspire such people to start thinking more, but I think some push-back some of the time is part of the answer. A bit like when people come to stack overflow and ask for their homework to be done for them: it's good if they're prodded to try _something_ for themselves. Being "nice" and just doing their homework for them wouldn't be optimal.

Yes, "the world is complex" might not be ideal phrasing if you think it implies someone needs to grasp the entirety of that complexity. But I'm sure the poster who wrote that only meant to encourage Mr "why don't we just" to _start_ considering the complexity of the world.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by mywittyname on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:07PM (#17602971)
Getting one itemized tax bill and a having a uniform tax code across the US would be so nice. Taxes don't stop at states, there are county, city, and municipality taxes as well. These may apply concurrently with several others depending on where you work and live.

This makes filing taxes a nightmare on top of being horribly inefficient for local governments. The federal government could handle tax collection and refunds for everyone, and come up with a standard set of rules that apply across the US. It makes life easier and more efficient for everyone involved.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by skgoa on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:14AM (#17598768)
And yet this works fine outside the US.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by WorkLifeBalance on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:05AM (#17598990)
Exceptionalism makes it really difficult to engage with conversations about US politics where you try to say, "It doens't have to be this way!" but get told that the US is somehow different to every other developed nation and couldn't possibly apply what works elsewhere.

This happens across the US political specturm, whether about their tax system, banking system, gun reform, electoral reform, and many other issues; it's a frequent refrain that the US is so different it can't learn from others.

As a US citizen who is resident elsewhere it is infuriating to watch.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by zeveb on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:42AM (#17601437)
> This happens across the US political specturm, whether about their tax system, banking system, gun reform, electoral reform, and many other issues; it's a frequent refrain that the US is so different it can't learn from others.

Alternatively, it's a frequent refrain that the U.S. _should_ learn from others, which is e.g. why we should preserve our federal system, electoral system and rights.

I think it's a _good_ thing that the several states are separate sovereigns from the United States, and I think it's a good thing that the states are entirely reliant on the United States for their budgets (and in fact, those places where they are reliant, e.g. the highway budget, have led to anti-federal things like a uniform drinking age, something which is 100% not the business of the United States government).

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by WorkLifeBalance on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:59AM (#17602226)
I am happy if someone claims that something politically isn't possible in the US. (Gun control may be a good example) I can't claim otherwise, my issue is when instead of arguing that, someone claims that a measure wouldn't have the same outcome in the US or technically isn't possible in the US without any evidence of such.

It shifts the blame from the current politics which is something people can engage with to "reasons out of anyone's control", which just helps maintain status quo.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by UncleEntity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:34PM (#17603775)
> ...or technically isn't possible in the US without any evidence of such.

Most of the times it comes down to constitutional issues in which case they are technically not possible.

Case in hand; the federal government has no constitutional right to prevent the states from collecting taxes -- which would be required for there to be one official Collector of Taxes for all the states.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by taejo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:27AM (#17601878)
States learning from each other is good, but there's no reason to restrict that learning to other states within the same Union (which for cultural and numerical reasons are more homogenous than the total population of all states).

If the United States looks only inwards, however, there's nobody left to learn from in terms of how to run a Union, since there is only one United States, and its powers and responsibilities are (because of federalism) quite different from those of the states.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by Swizec on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:32AM (#17599113)
As the popular Onion headline says: “No way to prevent this says only nation where this regularly happens”
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by bumholio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:32AM (#17598846)
> "Why can't the world be simple?" is "Because the world is complex."

"Because the world is political, and any change will be bitterly fought by those who are impacted to the point of inventing whole national mythologies."

Really now, centralized collection of taxes, even in the face of different local rates, is a standard feature of the civilized world. It works in countries with gun rights, it works in socialist countries, in advanced and poor countries, it's not a cultural aspect.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by ajdlinux on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:39AM (#17598620)
That's the Australian approach, where the federal government collects all income taxes (courtesy of some interesting legal maneuvering in WW2) as well as sales taxes, leaving the states only able to collect payroll taxes, land taxes, mining royalties and a few other limited types of revenue.

All sales tax revenue is 100% distributed back to the states - but it's done under a principle of "horizontal fiscal equalisation" (https://www.cgc.gov.au/index.php?option=com_content&view=art...) which means that richer states subsidise poorer states. Income tax is used to cover federal expenditure but also pays for a lot of federal grant money which is paid to the states.

In general, the Australian approach to federalism is a lot more federal-heavy than in the US, and some part of that is driven by how the feds have completely taken over most forms of taxation and thus control all the purse strings.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by consp on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:11AM (#17599021)
While not a federation or federally instituted, this is exactly how it works in the Netherlands. The central government collects income tax, VAT and social security taxes, etc. The local government (e.g. municipalities mostly, provinces sometimes) get grants and spend it. Example: Healthcare is locally instituted by the municipalities/cities ("gemeenten") while the tax (social securities) are collected nation wide together with income tax. Please note that only the executive part is local.

The municipalities can also levy taxes but usually only on common goods like sewage, water and on home ownership or equivalent for people who rent. The provinces do the same but it is far less than the central government does.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by UncleEntity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:46PM (#17603843)
Why stop there, really?

The EU should collect taxes for all the member states and then give it back to them in some equitable fashion. It would certainly stop all the bickering over tax havens and countries not collecting their "fair share".

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by BigJono on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:33AM (#17598848)
Shouldn't the fiscal equalisation strategy result in better infrastructure and more incentives for businesses and people to move to smaller states? It seems like the market is focused entirely on Sydney and Melbourne, and it's orders of magnitude more difficult to find a good job elsewhere.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by ajdlinux on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:20AM (#17599065)
I imagine the answer to that is that it does result in better infrastructure and more incentives to move to smaller states, and if we didn't base our tax policy around HFE then it would be even worse than it is now.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by patrickmay on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:19PM (#17602453)
> Why don't we just pay the federal government the entirety of our tax obligation and have them partition it out to the states?

That would give far too much power to a federal government that already far exceeds its constitutional mandate. I suggest the inverse: The federal government should get its funding only from the states. Each state can decide how much to contribute and how to raise the money. That would decentralize power significantly.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:23PM (#17602508)
The Articles of Confederation want their failed idea back.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by patrickmay on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:10PM (#17602997)
It was only a failure if you think a strong federal government is a good idea. I offer the current situation as evidence against that.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:04PM (#17603987)
Or a failure if you want a functioning government. There's a reason the Articles were thrown out, and the inability of the Federal government to raise revenue so it could actually do stuff was one of the major reasons.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:06PM (#17604002)
> It was only a failure if you think a strong federal government is a good idea.

No, a stronger federal government was a solution that was proposed (and adopted) for it's manifest failure. It wasn't the idea that a strong federal government was good that led to the belief the Articles had failed, but exactly the reverse.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by keithpeter on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:52AM (#17598938)
UK: local authorities charge a property tax based on the value of homes determined some time ago. The amount raised is insufficient to cover costs so central government provide a 'revenue support grant' to each of the local authorities in the UK country in question. That money comes from income tax which is paid to the central government in the UK.

The formula used to calculate the level of revenue support changes, some would say that the changes are politically based.

My feeling is that, given the robust politics that appears to exist in the US, coupled with what again appears to be frequent recourse to litigation between levels of government, you don't want to go down that route.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by isostatic on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:20AM (#17599068)
Now that Scotland can collect income tax separately, I wonder if we'll start seeing similar anomalies.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by boobsbr on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:39AM (#17600872)
It's the approach in Brazil, and it does not work out. States heavily depend on the Federal Government and have to constantly plead for funds. It's a mess, and I guess taking into account the size the of the US, the higher number of states, and a huge difference in their wealth/GDP, the situation will likely repeat itself.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by taejo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:29AM (#17601895)
There are anyway US states that are dependent on federal funds: the transfers are just sneakier and less efficient than in places where this is a constitutionally recognized process.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by toomanybeersies on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:53AM (#17598671)
That's what's done in Australia.

I'm not sure of the specifics of how the tax money is doled out, but all my income tax and sales tax goes to the federal government, which then divvies it out to the states.

There are additional taxes in some states though, which are collected by the states, such as payroll tax, but I don't see that on my payslip.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by efnx on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:21AM (#17598549)
That sounds dangerous.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by idiocratic on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:59AM (#17598695)
Dangerous in what way? I'm European and baffled by this sentence.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:15AM (#17598771)
Concentration of power inevitably leads to abuse - the only question is how long it will take until the taxation burden becomes overwhelming. It appears we're fast approaching that point and the next decade will break many Western nations while what are currently considered developing or emerging markets will rise to prominence.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oblio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:20AM (#17598793)
1. US had the longest period of high growth when taxation was "overwhelming" (post-war boom).

2. Several developed countries have "overwhelming taxation", yet quite high economic growth and are among the world's top 10 regarding human development.

3. Developing countries will have to increase their taxation. That's how development works: you get a bigger and more effective state that can offer advanced services reliably.

4. Almost all underdeveloped countries, on the contrary, have weak states that can barely collect taxes.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by jandrewrogers on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @01:00PM (#17602907)
The effective income tax rates in the US in the 1950s, even on the top 1%, were barely higher than they are today and in many cases lower. The tax structure was significantly different, so a naive comparison might lead you to believe otherwise.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by zeveb on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @10:46AM (#17601476)
> US had the longest period of high growth when taxation was "overwhelming" (post-war boom).

One's economy tends to do well when one has intact factories & workforce while the rest of the civilised world has been levelled and much of its workforce slain. We'll never see something like the post-war boom again unless we see something as utterly, senselessly destructive as the war itself (note that the economy would ultimately have been better in the long term had there never been a war).

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by Retric on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:15AM (#17601740)
Rebuilding took far less time than you might think.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by kmd511 on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:05AM (#17600619)
"you get a bigger and more effective state that can offer advanced services reliably"...are you kidding? The healthcare system in the UK is in danger of collapse and likely to be bankrupt in another decade or so. A "bigger and more effective state" sounds like an oxymoron to me. Many of those countries that have high tax burdens also have a culture that values working and as such, they do not as many social parasites as we have in the US.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by rcxdude on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:41PM (#17602706)
The UK healthcare system is in danger of collapse because it has been slowly starved of the income it needs to operate effectively, by a government which is idealogically opposed to its existance and whose members generally stand to gain substantially from privatising it.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by waluigi on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @02:02PM (#17603501)
Thank you for pointing this out. It seems that "Governments are ineffective" is taken as a universal truth around here, without considering the fact that pro-privatisation governments have a very strong incentive to make programs inefficient. If you want a more efficient government, vote for people who support government programs.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oblio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:12AM (#17600664)
The US has many social parasites? I think you're too caught in the day-to-day to notice how things are. The US is one of the hardest-working places on the planet. You take fewer days off and work longer hours than most people.

You value work too much, if anything.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:07AM (#17599004)
1. There are numerous cyclical factors that affect the productivity of a population. Growth in the US post-WWII was strong enough to offset taxation. Additionally, the US has enjoyed a status of economic core which has helped to prop up the tax regime. However, it is plain to see that has been crumbling since the early 2000s.

2. Name some countries - are they growing more than 10%?

3. Increasing taxation is how the strangulation of a population works, so in that sense you are correct. The state always fails. If it didn't, and taxation "worked", we would be living in a utopia.

4. Weak States that cannot enforce taxation are the ones where the population has freedom to grow without onerous tax burdens and corporate protectionism.

A static view of the world assumes taxation is necessary. A nonlinear view recognizes the destruction it causes.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oblio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:19AM (#17599060)
1. Ok.

2. Sustained growth at more than 10% is not realistic, especially for developed countries. I'm from a developing country and turning dirt farmers to office workers consistently will grow your economy by 10%. At some point you're going to run out of dirt farmers. This point is moot.

Regarding high, realistic growth (2-3%) for developed countries: Singapore, Sweden.

3. States tend to fail far more often due to external factors. In the modern era that's becoming rarer and rarer as the cost of destabilizing a foreign state generally outweighs the benefits.

4. I'd be very happy if you could show me some examples. Which "weak states" are developed states? I wouldn't call any state in a developed country a "weak state".

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:15AM (#17599297)
2. Sustained growth at that rate is unrealistic. Going from dirt farmers to office workers is the kind of shift we're looking at over the next decade, but with a shift from office/service to creative work. Machinery displaced farming and automation/robotics is starting to push office labor off in a different direction. I would argue that developed nations are less prepared for that as their economies and retirement structures are ill-suited to that paradigm. Established systems also tend to fight to to bitter end by increasing taxation to make up for lost revenue.

3. Yes, most states are not part of the core; peripheral nations fail long before the foundation does. Thankfully the cost of such failure has become much less likely to result in loss of life.

4. Not weak states that are developed states - ones that are considered developing, yet experience growth largely due to lack of excessive taxation and regulation thanks to weak government. They are thus progressing toward becoming developed. Two examples are Georgia and Puerto Rico - the amount of growth and development in those locations are proportionally far greater than other nations in similar locations and situations. This is directly affected by investment capital, much of which has left high-tax jurisdictions.

Which country are you from?

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oblio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:41AM (#17599413)
2. The economic limit to growth for developed countries is that you can't just force ideas out of people's heads. Automation/robotics improve things, but the productivity difference when averaged over a whole country is still not 10% per year, between developed countries. Keep in mind a growth rate of 7% means a doubling of an economy every 10 years. It's not reasonable to expect a doubling of economies every 10 years for developed countries, history has shown this repeatedly.

3. I'm an optimist, I don't see any signs of the foundation falling. The counterargument is that the fall is rarely seen ahead of time. Still, I think we can just file this as a difference in perspective and call it a day :)

4. Georgia, the state, I assume? Assuming it's the state, ok. But how come the vast majority of high-flyers still don't move to these states? How come those "oppressive" taxation regimes keep producing heavy hitters? Same thing is happening in Europe. Sweden, Norway, Germany, France, the UK, etc. have high productivity and high taxation. You'd expect everything to leak over to the low taxation countries. Yet these countries to lose a percentage of the high productivity members but come up with new ones. There must be something at work here (such as high taxation, coupled with half-decent administration, creating a good overall environment for productivity).

Romania. Not sure it's relevant :)

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:04AM (#17599855)
2. Agreed. Out of curiosity, would you consider it sensible to directly tax the production of a robot?

3. The larger the trend, the easier to forecast. Historically, empires fail slowly and then enter a rapid final decline. Martin Armstrong may be of interest, as he has built an extensive database and system that has analyzed the set.

4. Georgia the country, although the US state is one that is doing better than others[1] in the nation. Residence is sticky since it's expensive to relocate, so the incentive to move must be particularly high. There are certainly perceptions that persist with a lag since a practical perspective depends heavily upon direct experience, e.g. NYC is not the same place depicted in movies from the 1980s. The magnitude of resources available to be redistributed within a highly dynamic system can be significant. It is almost impossible to pinpoint the exact breaking point but the trend can be much more easily observed.

Turkey is an interesting place - domestic production includes almost everything except higher technology, yet the economy is precarious due capital fearing the government.

Romania is on my travel list :)

[1] https://www.businessinsider.com/san-francisco-bay-area-resid...

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oblio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @08:21AM (#17600319)
2. I don't know.

What I'd personally favor is super high income tax brackets for the very rich (income > $1 billion puts you in a 95% tax bracket for everything above 1 billion) and the state getting a percentage of a corporation automatically after it goes above a certain scale (say 5% at 1 billion, 20% at 20 billion), with the restriction on the state's share usage. This should take care indirectly of the "robot production", via the owners. Once you'd do this universal basic income would be interesting.

This should only be implemented if there's some sort of global tax agreement, otherwise the state that does this will have its tax revenue slither away to other countries.

But this needs an attitude of "fixing the state", not "starving the beast". Treat the state as an unavoidable single point of failure and harden it. Checks and balances, more transparency, more direct democracy, etc.

3 & 4. This is already getting super philosophical. I need to follow this phenomenon more, can't really say anything super relevant. Intuitively I'm not sure I agree.

> Romania is on my travel list :)

Go to Bucharest for the night life (preferably with a somewhat reliable local guide). Go to Brașov, Sighișoara, Sibiu for the medieval monuments and buildings. Go to Bucovina for the great landscapes and the beautiful monasteries. Go to Maramureș for the same reasons, but with a different twist. Go to the Apuseni for the rural life, unchanged since centuries.

Avoid the Black Sea (Constanța, Mamaia), except for the Danube Delta, which is a nature reserve.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @05:06AM (#17607864)
I've been both a wage earner and a business owner, having gone from a similar perspective as yours to wondering why I was funding incompetence, laziness and war by paying taxes. Most business owners I've met, both small and large, share that stance yet are genuinely good people who feel obligations to their employees in terms of providing a secure environment and paycheck. Our life experiences definitely shape our views.

Thanks for the recommendations!

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oever on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:37AM (#17598863)
Germany goes even further. The authorities collect tax for the religious organizations since 1919. If you're a Roman Catholic moving to Germany, suddenly you're faced with 8-9% of extra income tax.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_tax#Germany

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by taejo on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:49AM (#17598928)
8-9% of the income tax. Since income tax is substantially less than 100%, the church tax is substantially less than 8% of income.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by isostatic on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:27AM (#17599095)
With income tax of say 30%, that's still well over 2% of your income funding a cult? How is that possible?
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by michaelt on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:47AM (#17599443)
People who aren't members of a church-tax-collecting denomination don't have to pay it. So it's entirely voluntary.

Much like signing up for Netflix, except more expensive and a slightly different collection mechanism.

And if you think that's weird, look at the British "Chancel repair liability"

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by isostatic on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @06:56AM (#17599803)
That I think comes from various claims to the land which, while freehold, has certain obligations (just like you may have covenants for neighbours to be able to access their land over yours).

It was particularly bad until recently, as the obligations were often hidden. They no longer are - if there's an obligation it's right there on the land register, just like covenants, and show up in the standard searches during the conveyancing process. It's effectively a land tax to support a local amenity -- churches are part of the cultural background of British villages. I'd rather a formal land tax system to support all local amenities.

A larger concern to me are faith schools.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by zaarn on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:27AM (#17599993)
You don't have to pay that if you actually bother but it also has some other implications. IIRC if you pay church tax then the church you are part of is required to hold your burial, otherwise there is no direct obligation though they can if they want. In turn the church has the ability to levy rules, laws and taxes (as long as they don't break or inhibit existing law), ability to set religious holidays (which your employer will have to honor), religious school classes and some other neat stuff.

Of course, as mentioned, you can not have that and just pretend you're not in any of the recognized religious organisations.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by cylinder on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:13AM (#17598758)
Americans are deathly afraid of government. It's not just the lower or extreme classes. As you can see it's pervasive even on HN. The irony is that Europe, Australia etc are much less "dangerous" than the US
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by isostatic on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:26AM (#17599093)
Have you seen who they elect?
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by chlvsl on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:37AM (#17601974)
removing danger is not the primary goal lol. better to die a lion than live as a sheep.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by cylinder on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @07:41PM (#17605812)
Keep believing you live in a movie, works great for society.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by chlvsl on Friday July 27, 2018 @03:14PM (#17628429)
I don't live in a movie, but I definitely don't want to remove anything remotely dangerous to my person (see: everything) because it has the capacity for danger.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by oblio on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @03:14AM (#17598764)
We have a different mindset and tend to see the state as a big, albeit slow and annoying, institution that's meant to work for us (minus corruption). See Rousseau's "social contract". From what I've noticed Americans tend to lean more towards "state = bad; state = tyranny".

There is a certain irony, seeing that bar outright dictatorships (China), the US state is and has been the strongest one for over half a century...

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:31AM (#17599358)
The US as a nation was/is strong thanks to its people, not the government. This has been due to the fact that the US Constitution is restrictive - individual freedoms are expressly permitted and functions of the state are explicitly limited. In effect, the government was disciplined as opposed to incredibly overbearing; individuals were allowed to grow, learn and create for themselves instead of relying on government.

That system has been attacked from the beginning and the US is rapidly becoming a nation where government replaces the family as social structure. What is now will not always be - the trend is of far greater importance than momentary status.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:35PM (#17602637)
"individuals were allowed to grow, learn and create for themselves instead of relying on government."

Individuals are not able to do any of that when they're stuck working 3 jobs just to get by, or when they go bankrupt due to a simple medical procedure.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by miscreanity on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @04:58AM (#17607843)
Death was more of a concern in the 1800s regarding medical procedures.

Multiple jobs just to get by sounds a lot like today yet plenty of people still grow, learn and create.

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by boobsbr on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @09:42AM (#17600893)
It's how it's done in Brazil and it does not work out. States constantly pleading for more money while the Federal Government wants to spend it itself, or gives preferential treatment to certain states, while others languish.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by efnx on Wednesday July 25, 2018 @12:33AM (#17606924)
Dangerous because I don’t trust our current federal government to appropriately redistribute those taxes.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by raverbashing on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @04:15AM (#17599038)
This is how it works pretty much everywhere, state taxes are only for specific things (not income tax).

Or at least the states should have a double taxation treaty (but of course that would make sense so it's not going to be implemented)

Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by s73v3r_ on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:23PM (#17602497)
Do you want the Trump administration to be the arbiter of what states are able to spend their revenues on?
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by everdev on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:07PM (#17604938)
I wouldn't want it changing every election cycle, so I'd say it should be some combination of population or area. If states want more revenue than that, they they can add other consumption taxes like bridge tolls, sales tax, etc. that is collected at PoS. I just don't like having a complex math problem to do every year.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by lemonghost on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @11:57AM (#17602210)
This happens all of the time. For example, it is very common to live in NJ and work NYC. In that case, you pay NYC tax, NY and NJ tax and receive credit for your NJ tax based on the NY state tax you pay.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by o_nate on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @12:19PM (#17602452)
The NYC commuter tax was repealed in 1999. You still have to pay NY state tax obviously.
Re:New Yorkers Trying to Flee High State Taxes Find Moving I... by lemonghost on Tuesday July 24, 2018 @05:25PM (#17605081)
You're right. Maybe I was confusing it with the Metropolitan Commuter tax.