Hence, each state collects levies, fines, rates, stamp duties, privatise public services and various other money grubbing exercises in order to raise capital for themselves so that they can waste/embezzle it according to their whims.
Then there's the problem of disproportionate tax distribution, which most states, particularly WA, seem to raise constantly.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constitutional_basis_of_taxati... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_90_of_the_Constitution...
The states gave up on the practicalities, but they still have the theoretical power to collect income tax.
Why? Because when the GST was introduced WA'S resource income was counted... During an unprecedented resources boom that has since collapsed. You know what doesn't get counted? Poker machine income, which is substantial in the three Eastern states.
Can it be changed? Technically, yes. Practically is incredibly difficult because no one wants to give up revenue and politicians are worried it'll be electoral suicide, which it may well be.
The fact that the government has proposed anything at all, however anemic, is kinda amazing.
The "this problem" that we are talking about here is the problem of the national government handling state taxes in addition to national taxes. For this problem the national government is dealing with states, not individuals, and so it is the number of states that it has to deal with that is the main factor affecting complexity and scaling.