Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by saagarjha on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:34AM
(#17336895)
The borehole has now been welded shut and is surrounded by the ruins of the project. The actual borehole itself is pretty unassuming for something that goes twelve kilometers into the Earth's crust: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kola_Superdeep_Borehole#/media...
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by avian on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:54AM
(#17336954)
How stable are abandoned holes like that? I would imagine that at those temperatures and pressures, the rock would slowly flow and refill the hole after a while.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by mnw21cam on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:37AM
(#17337112)
It got to 180C at the bottom. That's nowhere near hot enough to melt rock. Not sure about the pressure though. I get the feeling though that rock tends to either stay put or shift all at once (like an earthquake).
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by avian on Monday June 18, 2018 @01:42PM
(#17340119)
Not hot enough to melt, but heat definitely reduces structural integrity of materials. And pressures on the rock so deep are immense. This article linked from Wikipedia seems to confirm that the hole tended to close itself when they were drilling:
"At that level of heat and pressure, the rocks began to act more like a plastic than a solid, and the hole had a tendency to flow closed whenever the drill bit was pulled out for replacement."
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by taneq on Monday June 18, 2018 @08:43AM
(#17337755)
"When the well reached a mark of about 12,000 meters, scientific equipment recorded sounds resembling the cries and groans of thousands of martyrs emanating from the depths."
I think we've crossed the line from documentary to creepypasta.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by abhiminator on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:35AM
(#17336699)
Super interesting.
It's kind of hard to believe how our species has managed to explore furthest of planets, stars and galaxies while just drilling 7.62 miles through the crust of the very planet we exist on and "dominate" [0] -- a testament to how challenging crust drilling can be, right on par with exploring deepest parts of Earth's oceans.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by avian on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:45AM
(#17336931)
I don’t find it surprising at all that we found traveling through a vacuum easier than traveling through solid granite.
Imagine how much mass that drillbit had to go through and now translate that into the density of interstellar medium. You could probably travel half way across the galaxy before your space ship went through as much matter as that drill.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by mark212 on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:18PM
(#17342078)
> a testament to how challenging crust drilling can be,
> right on par with exploring deepest parts of Earth's oceans.
except if you read the footnotes it says that Exxon beat the world's record for length of borehole in 60 days. Sounds like drilling in the crust is NBD, been doing it for years, the innovation is all in how to make it turn and twist and do so on time and under budget.
My sense is that it's just not economically rational to drill a hole straight down for no other reason than you want to see how far it can go. Why bother? But it doesn't seem at all to be a technical problem.
This article lead me down the rabbit hole to the page for Mud (drilling fluid) engineer, which might be one of the most vandalized articles I've ever seen (# vandalizing edits/total edits)
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by mark212 on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:20PM
(#17342087)
glad I'm not the only one who went down that hole (pun very much intended) and started watching videos about the Reelwell Drilling Method and horizontal displacement techniques.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by nellaby on Monday June 18, 2018 @06:33AM
(#17337087)
Really interesting experiment. Since the temperature was greater than expected would that have any bearing on being able to use bore holes for geothermal power?
I believe they are trialling this in a few places but I can't help but think that a hole that small (circumference wise!) could be easily implemented and potentially used as an energy source
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Jaruzel on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:46AM
(#17336731)
Continental crust is between 20 miles deep and 50 miles deep, this borehole 'only' managed to get to 7.4 miles deep - we've still go a long way to go before we get to The Lost World of the Dinosaurs.
I would like to understand why drilling stopped at the depth it did. Was it something to do with the material at that depth, something to do with the drill, some other factor?
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by abhiminator on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:27AM
(#17336868)
>Because of higher-than-expected temperatures at this depth and location, 180 °C (356 °F) instead of the expected 100 °C (212 °F), drilling deeper was deemed unfeasible and the drilling was stopped in 1992. [0]
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Jerry2 on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:03AM
(#17337239)
>I would like to understand why drilling stopped at the depth it did. Was it something to do with the material at that depth, something to do with the drill, some other factor?
At that depth, pressure and temperature, the rock behaved like plastic and not solid and the drill was ineffective since the hole would immediately close as they pulled the drill. So they had to give up.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by furyg3 on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:10AM
(#17337270)
I'm no geologist, but 180C doesn't sound hot enough to make rock behave like plastic.
Ninja-edit: It looks like the temperature / pressure isn't so problematic because of rock moving around, but instead to do with cooling the drill bit (which you can imagine gets quite hot). If temperatures increase, cooling the bit becomes difficult, and at high-pressures, pumping the coolant around becomes very difficult.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by bcraven on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:32AM
(#17336889)
> Did they make any special geological discoveries?
[From the Wikipedia article:] To scientists, one of the more fascinating findings to emerge from this well is that no transition from granite to basalt was found at the depth of about 7 km (4.3 mi), where the velocity of seismic waves has a discontinuity. Instead the change in the seismic wave velocity is caused by a metamorphic transition in the granite rock. In addition, the rock at that depth had been thoroughly fractured and was saturated with water, which was surprising. This water, unlike surface water, must have come from deep-crust minerals and had been unable to reach the surface because of a layer of impermeable rock.
Another unexpected discovery was a large quantity of hydrogen gas. The mud that flowed out of the hole was described as "boiling" with hydrogen.
> Did they find any precious metals, etc.?
These concentrate in veins, so the single borehole would not be the best way to find out. They were probably recorded in mud logs somewhere.
> is it possible to measure the depth of the hole using a laser
Holes like this are very rarely totally straight as the geology likes to manipulate the drill string as it descends. Whilst this won't be a true deviated well (due to the research goals) I'd be very surprised if there's a vertical hole.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Piskvorrr on Monday June 18, 2018 @07:37AM
(#17337412)
Ah, indeed, the dreaded question "How hard can it be?" and its rarely-spoken assumption "that looks simple from my armchair". Well...most of the low-hanging fruit has already been picked, and things that look simple are chock-full of those pesky details that are handwaved away in the birds-eye view. "Just use the right technology," and you have flying cars, strong AI, self-driving vehicles, space elevators and whatnot. How hard can it be?
Geothermal isn't really sustainable (in the long, long term). The heat is built up due to some special geology, think an insulating blanket. Once you use this heat to make electricity you lower the temperature of the rock and it takes a very, very long time to warm up again.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by stareatgoats on Monday June 18, 2018 @09:09AM
(#17337922)
It is sustainable enough under any reasonable scenario, and will in effect mainly just harness some of the heat that already dissipates.
As for for rewarming the rock: if the strata that were porous and water filled were found at the appropriate levels this problem would be reduced. One would not need to hydro-shear the rock is normal in EGS plants nowadays (with some inconvenient side-effects - see Basel)[0]
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Something1234 on Saturday June 23, 2018 @11:41AM
(#17381746)
I like a lot of PBS's content. Like physics girl, and what the physics. Engineer Guy also produces good content. MinutePhysics is also a good choice. As for math related topics, I love 3Blue1Brown.
In general I find science journalism lacking.
My biggest problem with SciShow is that it's a bunch of people who lack a true science background commenting on topics. I really don't think that they do their due diligence in reporting, there's been cases where they present incorrect findings, and hype up the physically impossible.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Pandavonium on Wednesday June 27, 2018 @02:46AM
(#17406216)
Cool, thanks for the recommendations. I gravitated to SciShow because was produced by Hank Green, who's other YouTube offerings I really enjoy. I guess it's a lesson to be more critical with my sources, regardless of the author's previous work.
Looks like the drill tower used to be there, maybe they just wholesale lifted the proprietary drilling rig out of there. I'm sure they had to invent a thing or two about drilling to do this research.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by walrus01 on Monday June 18, 2018 @04:57AM
(#17336764)
You fear to go into those mines. The Dwarves dug too greedily and too deep. You know what they awoke in the darkness of Khazad-dûm... shadow and flame.".
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Fins on Tuesday June 19, 2018 @12:29PM
(#17348089)
Most of them either were educated in (old, pre-USSR) Russia, or by people who had Russian education. Once the generation changed, people educated in/by Soviet system achieved... well, you've listed it.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Fins on Wednesday June 20, 2018 @12:38PM
(#17356950)
Do you have something more substantial to offer?
Or will you suggest that a country where communism is "scientific" and whole areas of science can be banned is actually capable of developing homegrown science? This is laughable on its face.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Fins on Friday June 22, 2018 @09:28PM
(#17378900)
You could have read the entire sentence -- while there were some remnants of the pre-revolution education teaching in schools, there were Nobels. Once they had died out, and the new generation educated in Soviet schools by Soviet-educated teachers appeared, Nobels went away.
I guess you have never heard about genetics? It's generally considered to be a science. Except in USSR where for a long time it was officially termed a pseudo-science and a call-girl of imperialism.
What you're talking about is Lysenkoism and it was mostly during Stalin rule. Later Soviet biologists actually criticized Lysenko and the whole anti-genetics stance. Similar movements also happened in Western science, like Social Darwinism for example.
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by Fins on Sunday July 01, 2018 @07:51PM
(#17438394)
Social Darwinism or anything like that has never been appointed as the one and only TRUE THING with scientific opponents sent off to labor camps.
Also, soviet high elementary through high school education was... I'm not sure if "better" is the correct word, but it certainly taught more science than American schools do, if we compare average American school with a good school in Moscow, Leningrad, or similar large cities.
College level education in USSR was nowhere near as good as American -- you can't have good education if teaching people to think for themselves is physically dangerous.
[Source: I attended better than average schools and a decent college in Moscow]
Re:Kola Superdeep Borehole
by dirktheman on Monday June 18, 2018 @05:35AM
(#17336899)
There's a well known urban legend about the borehole that they stopped drilling when a scientist lowered a microphone into the hole. When they played back the recording they heard terrible screams, supposedly from people trapped in hell. Nice campfire story!
"At that level of heat and pressure, the rocks began to act more like a plastic than a solid, and the hole had a tendency to flow closed whenever the drill bit was pulled out for replacement."
https://www.damninteresting.com/the-deepest-hole/
This visualises a generalised lithological log: That means, some of the rocks recovered from the hole, and their thicknesses.
https://data.icdp-online.org/sites/kola/tpl/litholog_sel.htm
Let's seee if I manage to make the script more interactive.
I think we've crossed the line from documentary to creepypasta.
It's kind of hard to believe how our species has managed to explore furthest of planets, stars and galaxies while just drilling 7.62 miles through the crust of the very planet we exist on and "dominate" [0] -- a testament to how challenging crust drilling can be, right on par with exploring deepest parts of Earth's oceans.
[0] https://www.fs.blog/2016/01/yuval-noah-hararri-on-why-we-dom...
Imagine how much mass that drillbit had to go through and now translate that into the density of interstellar medium. You could probably travel half way across the galaxy before your space ship went through as much matter as that drill.
except if you read the footnotes it says that Exxon beat the world's record for length of borehole in 60 days. Sounds like drilling in the crust is NBD, been doing it for years, the innovation is all in how to make it turn and twist and do so on time and under budget.
My sense is that it's just not economically rational to drill a hole straight down for no other reason than you want to see how far it can go. Why bother? But it doesn't seem at all to be a technical problem.
What did/does such a project cost?
Is there substantial scientific value to going further?
I can imagine some tech billionaire(s) funding a follow-on project, esp in a more hospitable location that could attract tourists, press, etc.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:History/Mud_engineer
I believe they are trialling this in a few places but I can't help but think that a hole that small (circumference wise!) could be easily implemented and potentially used as an energy source
Potentially, some extra energy to go with your geothermal energy.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kola_Superdeep_Borehole#Drilli...
In other words I'm confused by why 180C stopped the drilling process.
At that depth, pressure and temperature, the rock behaved like plastic and not solid and the drill was ineffective since the hole would immediately close as they pulled the drill. So they had to give up.
Ninja-edit: It looks like the temperature / pressure isn't so problematic because of rock moving around, but instead to do with cooling the drill bit (which you can imagine gets quite hot). If temperatures increase, cooling the bit becomes difficult, and at high-pressures, pumping the coolant around becomes very difficult.
Source: https://geekswipe.net/research/engineering/how-deep-can-we-d...
Did they find any precious metals, etc.?
Also, I'm wondering, is it possible to measure the depth of the hole using a laser?
[From the Wikipedia article:] To scientists, one of the more fascinating findings to emerge from this well is that no transition from granite to basalt was found at the depth of about 7 km (4.3 mi), where the velocity of seismic waves has a discontinuity. Instead the change in the seismic wave velocity is caused by a metamorphic transition in the granite rock. In addition, the rock at that depth had been thoroughly fractured and was saturated with water, which was surprising. This water, unlike surface water, must have come from deep-crust minerals and had been unable to reach the surface because of a layer of impermeable rock.
Another unexpected discovery was a large quantity of hydrogen gas. The mud that flowed out of the hole was described as "boiling" with hydrogen.
> Did they find any precious metals, etc.?
These concentrate in veins, so the single borehole would not be the best way to find out. They were probably recorded in mud logs somewhere.
> is it possible to measure the depth of the hole using a laser
Holes like this are very rarely totally straight as the geology likes to manipulate the drill string as it descends. Whilst this won't be a true deviated well (due to the research goals) I'd be very surprised if there's a vertical hole.
This is what makes me think that drilling to great depths and utilizing the energy there for sustainable power generation should be possible.
It's just a matter of developing the right drilling technology. How hard can it be?
As for for rewarming the rock: if the strata that were porous and water filled were found at the appropriate levels this problem would be reduced. One would not need to hydro-shear the rock is normal in EGS plants nowadays (with some inconvenient side-effects - see Basel)[0]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enhanced_geothermal_system
Ok, is the reported depth the true depth, or the length along the hole?
https://realt.onliner.by/2015/11/19/kola
The depth is the true depth, apparently.
Would be surprised if it's perfectly straight. Drills for oil etc can turn .
In general I find science journalism lacking.
My biggest problem with SciShow is that it's a bunch of people who lack a true science background commenting on topics. I really don't think that they do their due diligence in reporting, there's been cases where they present incorrect findings, and hype up the physically impossible.
- Andre Geim, Physics, 2010
- Konstantin Novoselov, Physics, 2010
- Alexei Alexeyevich Abrikosov, Physics, 2003
- Vitaly Ginzburg, Physics, 2003
- Zhores Alferov, Physics, 2000
- Pyotr Kapitsa, Physics, 1978
- Ilya Prigogine, Chemistry, 1977
- Leonid Kantorovich, Economics, 1975
- Nikolay Basov, Physics, 1964
- Alexander Prokhorov, Physics, 1964
- Lev Landau, Physics, 1962
- Pavel Cherenkov, Physics, 1958
- Igor Tamm, Physics, 1958
- Ilya Mikhailovich Frank, Physics, 1958
- Nikolay Semyonov, Chemistry, 1956
List of Nobel Prizes educated in post-Soviet Russia:
Or will you suggest that a country where communism is "scientific" and whole areas of science can be banned is actually capable of developing homegrown science? This is laughable on its face.
Your claim is that most of these Nobel prizes were educated in the Russian Empire is simply false based on their age.
Can you provide examples of these whole areas of science banned in the USSR/socialist states?
I guess you have never heard about genetics? It's generally considered to be a science. Except in USSR where for a long time it was officially termed a pseudo-science and a call-girl of imperialism.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_technology_in_the_...
https://www.quora.com/Do-you-believe-Soviet-Union-education-...
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2ycco6/how_d...
What you're talking about is Lysenkoism and it was mostly during Stalin rule. Later Soviet biologists actually criticized Lysenko and the whole anti-genetics stance. Similar movements also happened in Western science, like Social Darwinism for example.
Also, soviet high elementary through high school education was... I'm not sure if "better" is the correct word, but it certainly taught more science than American schools do, if we compare average American school with a good school in Moscow, Leningrad, or similar large cities.
College level education in USSR was nowhere near as good as American -- you can't have good education if teaching people to think for themselves is physically dangerous.
[Source: I attended better than average schools and a decent college in Moscow]
Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Well_to_Hell_hoax