News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by nemild on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:43PM (#17241855)
Hans Rosling's work is famous for pointing out how media incentives, statistical illiteracy, and our preconceptions give us a flawed sense of the world.

In the vein of Hans Rosling, I've done add'l research on media coverage vs actual stats for death. What's covered is what we most want to read about. As a society, we need many more lessons on statistics and the incentives behind news:

The deaths that are most covered are a tiny fraction (<1%) of the way we die

https://www.nemil.com/s/part3-horror-films.html

Today’s biggest threat to democracy isn’t fake news—it’s selective facts

https://qz.com/1130094/todays-biggest-threat-to-democracy-is...

How Media Fuels our Fear of Western Terrorism

https://www.nemil.com/s/part2-terrorism.html

EDIT: As some commenters point, news covers "new" things — and so of course it's at odds with data.

The problem is that most consumers of news don't understand that just because something is heavily covered doesn't mean it's common — or relevant input for personal decisions they make. This speaks to the issue of media literacy, and I'd argue is why Rosling's book is so important.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by titanix2 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:01PM (#17242011)
> The deaths that are most covered are a tiny fraction (<1%) of the way we die

They are precisely covered because they are exceptional. No one care about car accidents because that's a banal cause of death. But a plane crash is not. In countries like France where islamic terror attacks have became common place, small scale attacks causing a few deaths are not covered for days and days anymore.

Also event like a terror attack informs more about the state of a country and the world than an one suicide (suicide rate or aggregate can be valuable insight hough).

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by randcraw on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:18PM (#17242168)
Of course. By its very nature, outliers are the only thing that news covers. Exceptions make news. Conventions do not. If you're hearing it on the news, it's useless information, like a TouTube video of a cat playing the piano while juggling mice.

Once upon a time, I think news was an invitation to get engaged in your community because change was needed or forthcoming, and as a citizen, it was your duty to know about the subject in order to contribute constructively, perhaps in a town hall meeting or at least in a civic (civil) conversation with neighbors.

Today nobody acts upon what they learn in big media news, other than to form misinformed opinions fraught with bias, to vote only every few years for a bad binary choice in rigged elections fielding untrustworthy candidates who pretend to address problems but actually perpetuate them via myopic self-interested gangsterism.

Pop news is 99% clickbait and 1% fact.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by devoply on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:23PM (#17242204)
The point of mass media is propaganda and entertainment in that order.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by jrs95 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:36PM (#17242314)
And given that the point of entertainment, from the perspective of “the elite” (government officials but also other wealthy and powerful individuals who are a part of the same de facto governing system) the primary purpose of entertainment isn’t much different from a form of propaganda anyways. Mass media is largely about programming the populace. Now of course it’s not all produced with malicious intent, but that doesn’t stop the powers that be from influencing them, and by extension “the people” through mass media.

But this is just my relatively uninformed opinion based on casual observation, not any serious study of the issue. Although given that if this were studied and published in a journal it would have likely gone through institutions which are subject to the same system which would be criticized by the research so...how much good could that really do?

I suppose my cynicism towards the people I’m supposed to trust is the primary thing prevents me from having a more fact based view of the world.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by alter_eco123 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:47PM (#17243774)
> I suppose my cynicism towards the people I’m supposed to trust is the primary thing prevents me from having a more fact based view of the world.

How so? Is it not a fact that politicians can't be trusted, and that, as you said, the mainstream media is largely about programming the populace?

"Cynisism" is what people call realism when they want you to stop talking about reality.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by jrs95 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @10:16PM (#17243881)
Perhaps at one point I was realistic but I think at this point I’ve seen enough blatant deception that I am overly paranoid as sort of a defense mechanism. This is probably still more accurate than how I viewed things before, but all I really meant by cynicism is that I am conscious of the fact that I am probably even more distrustful than what would be reasonable, just as a result of negative experience. Perhaps I’m right, but I don’t have an objective rationale for this, it’s largely based on heuristics.

To be a bit more concrete, it’s true that politicians and the media are liars, but then to extend that further to education, entertainment, and those who are culturally influential in general can be quite the stretch outside of a few specific data points. And how is it connected? How does this system actually work? It’s so complex it’s almost immeasurable. A critical view of this is necessarily heavily influenced by intuition and emotion IMO since you’re unable to trust a large body of your learned information from that mindset.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by alter_eco123 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @10:33PM (#17243949)
> And how is it connected? How does this system actually work?

Look at things and keep asking: "Who benefits?"

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by DrScump on Wednesday June 06, 2018 @02:54AM (#17244898)
The point of mass media is profit.

Consumers with poor sense of perspective and poor critical-thinking skills are more easily manipulated by advertisers. Therefore, dumbing down your viewers is in your direct financial interest.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Namrog84 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:40PM (#17242343)
"By its very nature, outliers are the only thing that news covers. Exceptions make news."

Eventually won't the fact that the news only covers exceptions reverse in on itself when covering a non exception is in itself the exception?

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Retra on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @07:31PM (#17243110)
No, because the exception is with respect to people's experiences, not with respect to what the news reports. People experience regular stuff every day, whether the news reports it or not.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by morsch on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:48PM (#17242381)
Just so that people don't get the wrong idea: small scale terror attacks are not commonplace in France, nor anywhere else in Europe, by any reasonable sense of the word. From what I can recall, there have been two instances of fatal Islamist terror attacks in France in 2018. It's certainly in the single digits.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by jaredklewis on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:33PM (#17242297)
I would say they deserve different kinds of coverage.

A plane crash or terrorist attack is the kind of immediate news story that can dominate a news cycle for a week and that makes sense. But news papers and magazines also devote plenty of coverage to long term, on going problems, such as the coverage devoted to sexual harassment in the past year. And indeed, even when there have been no major terror attacks in several months, there is still always an endless stream of articles discussing the issue and how we might best approach it.

We should expect that our news sources to devote more of their long form, investigative pieces to domestic problems like heart disease and traffic accidents.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by nemild on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:49PM (#17242389)
Agreed, but see my edit. The problem is that readers will see heavy coverage as "this is important" and I should be worried about this.

For example, after 9/11, 1k more Americans died in car crashes, because they decided not to fly.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by nemild on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:08PM (#17242078)
Absolutely, but many people use this news coverage to then make decisions. Statistically, this is crazy.

Like Rosling, the point is that we need to understand why the media covers things the way it does.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by losteric on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:30PM (#17242272)
It's even in the name: news

The deregulated "news" industry is primarily motivated by profit, informing the public is secondary. That's why we see a handful of stories on repeat for days - maximizes profit, minimize journalism and education.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by amelius on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:57PM (#17241976)
The fundamental problem in media is their financial incentives, leading to clickbait articles, and sometimes even fake news.

Government subsidies for proper, independent news reporting could help tremendously here. But unfortunately, now all politicians are looking at Facebook to solve the problem.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by nemild on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:09PM (#17242085)
I think another way is to train readers to understand the issues, and over decades, change the incentives faced by media. Or for us to push back on the incentives that social networks set for media outlets.

I wrote a media literacy guide for engineers in this vein:

https://github.com/nemild/hack-an-engineer

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by roywiggins on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:12PM (#17242121)
Are government-owned news outlets significantly better on this particular issue (of deaths)? What does the BBC, CBC, ABC, Al-Jazeera cover? I'd wager it's substantially similar. You'd have to have orders of magnitude more articles about people dying of heart disease (or whatever) to make up for it, and I don't think eg. the BBC spends its resources that way.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by alter_eco123 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:50PM (#17243788)
> Government subsidies for proper, independent news reporting could help tremendously here.

If your reporting depends on government subsidies, it's very much not independent.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by ManFromUranus on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:25PM (#17242231)
I don't think it's media that fuels are fear of terrorism, I think it's actually the Terrorism. You are implying that the media makes it out to be worse than it is, I disagree. I think the media largely downplays terrorism and makes sure that we all think it just fell out of the sky and it's just crazy people and there's no rhyme or reason to it so there's no way to predict anything or take any action to stop it. The media just mollifies us and makes sure we don't get angry or take any steps, or do anything at all about it all except feel bad for the victims.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by philwelch on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:32PM (#17241756)
One of the best things about reaching the Bill Gates level of wealth is probably being able to say, "man, I really liked this book, I think every college graduate should read it," and then realizing you can literally buy it for all of them.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by hkmurakami on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:57PM (#17241977)
I regularly buy books for friends for whom I think it would be useful. Sometimes business books for entrepreneur friends, sometimes fiction that I think they would enjoy (or I really want to talk to them about!).

Nothing stopping any of us from doing something similar at a smaller scale. (though the ability to reach people who we don't know, at a large scale, is definitely much much harder)

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by technotony on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:18PM (#17242167)
Who knows how much this is even costing him. It's pretty good PR for the publishing company and will probably generate sales from non-graduates. Could just be a genius marketing move which benefits brand Gates and the publisher.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by raven105x on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @06:50PM (#17242788)
You don't need marketing moves with a net worth of over 90B USD. If he wants to act, he'll buy the required companies/patents & do it.

How would this, as a "marketing move", make any sense for him - or even be worth his time to do in the first place?

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by technotony on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @08:09PM (#17243312)
Recruitment for his foundation?
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by philwelch on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:48PM (#17242377)
It's more the scale than the basic idea of gifting books that I find remarkable :)
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Chinjut on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:13PM (#17242129)
Buddy, it's an e-book. There's no genuine cost here; the publisher's thrilled to arrange for the publicity.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by darkstar999 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:24PM (#17242208)
Ok, you go ahead and make that arrangement with the book of your choice. You can't.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by pdabbadabba on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:15PM (#17242147)
Wouldn't that just make it better?
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Isamu on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:45PM (#17241867)
I am reading this now, it's pretty good.

I think some misunderstand this book, maybe because there is a tendency to interpret any talk about how the world is improving as blindness about world problems. Or that admitting there have been gains made is the same as saying it's time to take it easy, stop trying to improve.

This is nonsense of course. The point of finding out what has improved is to find out what works, and do more of that. See if you can apply what works in one place to another place, another problem.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by onion2k on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:31PM (#17241739)
I like to think of myself as reasonably well-informed and unbiased, with a pretty decent set of tools for looking at things I see in the news but when I read it recently I learned quite a lot. It's a very good book.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by kaypro on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:04PM (#17242039)
I just finished this last night in fact. My first thought upon completing it was that this should be required reading in every high school curriculum. Very cool to see this happening. Highly recommended read.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by BadassFractal on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:24PM (#17242209)
What are some other great resources for de-biasing oneself? I believe Charlie munger did a whole talk on this back in the day.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by rhombocombus on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:17PM (#17241621)
This is great, I wish he were giving it to high schoolers and GED recipients too.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by opencl on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:32PM (#17241759)
There's no actual requirement of proof that you're graduating from college. It's just a free download that makes you click a button saying you are.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by onetimemanytime on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:32PM (#17241747)
No one knows the difference online, just choose a college from the drop down and via
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by rdlecler1 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:27PM (#17241705)
And the far right and far left.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by tudelo on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:29PM (#17241724)
We are running out of categories. Really, everyone will have availability to the book given that the chances that one person will upload it is pretty darn high if it isn't already available.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by bonsai80 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:34PM (#17241775)
From the comments on that page it sounds like you just need to fill out the form with anything and you get the file. No validation. Also libraries :)

Anyway, I hope it's a clever trick to get people to feel like they beat the system and go read the book.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by fjsolwmv on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:51PM (#17241921)
That's exactly it. Classic parental psychology trick: "are you sure you're grown up for this stuff? I don't know...."
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by briantmaurer on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:55PM (#17241959)
It would be great if the publisher would make digital copies of this book available to everyone for free. I wonder if Gates explored that option but the price was too steep.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by sharemywin on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:56PM (#17241968)
Was reading about the income levels I-IV in the book and looks like II-IV have access to cellphones form this article:

http://newsfeed.time.com/2013/03/25/more-people-have-cell-ph...

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by johnsonjo on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @10:44PM (#17243982)
Funny. I just graduated and bought the physical copy like last week. It’ll be nice to have the ebook too. I haven’t really started it yet, because sadly I hoard books, and collect a lot faster than I read. I’m interested in the topic though. I would love to learn more about how we make mistakes in our assumptions, and statistical fallacies.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by pg_bot on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:40PM (#17241824)
It is incredibly important to see that the world on a macro level is improving at an incredible rate. Hans Rosling was a brilliant educator and while I haven't read this book yet, I will be adding it to my backlog today.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by xg15 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:17PM (#17242165)
As others have said, it's a good thought to have (and the book indeed sounds like an interesting read), but we should still define what "on a macro level" actually means.

E.g., is "macro level" the average? Then it could just as well be a rich elite (or the spike part of a power law distribution) pulling up that average.

Even if it's not, we should investigate how different parts of the world are improving differently and why.

E.g., yes, eradicating certain diseases in African countries is laudable - but in an age where others dream about genetically augmenting humans, is that the bar we should use?

And even if the overall measure of health and well-being might go up, why is it that nevertheless statistics for certain groups seem to regress? Like job security or the ability of low/middle-income groups to make savings?

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by IkmoIkmo on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:35PM (#17242306)
Great, let's me buy a cheap one second hand!
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Dowwie on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @07:17PM (#17242978)
borrow from a library?
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by megamindbrian2 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @11:42PM (#17244210)
Stephen Peterson says facts are relative.
[dead]
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by _grep_ on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:51PM (#17241912)
Just FYI, I think you commented to the wrong article by mistake.
[dead]
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by technotony on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:03PM (#17242029)
I don't think the average reader has a problem comprehending what you wrote, they just don't define better the way that you do (ie they don't include unborn babies lives as equally valuable until a certain age in the womb). Your core point that given any set of facts you can define a value system such that it's improving is true, but that's not how most people define their value system.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by rwcarlsen on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:18PM (#17242169)
I think maybe OP was just trying to say that the means matter - not just the end. End state of no more down syndrome humans is good, but maybe just aborting them all before they are born isn't good - depending on your beliefs/values. I think it is a valid point to consider even if their tone wasn't very constructive.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Retra on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @07:36PM (#17243142)
On the other hand, just because a point is valid doesn't mean it is also useful. Especially compared to all the other points that could be raised in its stead.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:48PM (#17242376)
> Proof of this statement is the average reader's inability to comprehend what I've just written.

This statement is ridiculous without providing some sort of evidence to support your assertion that the average reader is unable to comprehend your statement. I might guess that we are to assume that a low score for your comment is such evidence, but the arrogance of such a position is so astounding that I'm inclined to give you the benefit of the doubt and say you just left off any support for your assertion at all rather than assuming you're the sort of person who would nonironically proclaim that "Nobody understands my genius because I am so deep!"

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Jolter on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:02PM (#17242020)
I'm pretty sure whatever you've been reading was not Hans Rosling.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by Torwald on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:59PM (#17241991)
Yo, Bill, what about your own degree? LOL.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by jakelazaroff on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:47PM (#17241879)
1 in 7 people in the U.S. face hunger every year and Flint still doesn't have clean water, but sure: let's buy every college graduate a book!
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by yoran on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:56PM (#17241964)
Arguably, turning college graduates into better citizens by giving them a book can have a bigger long-term effect than directly solving the problem. Not that immediate action shouldn't be done, but both are valid attacks to the same problem.

I think Bill Gates' underlying reasoning is that by giving all college graduates this book, the future generation will be better thinkers and therefore that society will be better than today's. Hopefully, this will lead to a situation where that 1 in 7 number will turn into 1 in 70, and every place in the US will have access to clean water.

It's kind of like that saying "Give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish, and you feed him for a lifetime.".

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by hkmurakami on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:00PM (#17241999)
One might call it leverage.

Also, any good is better than no good, if by requiring a person to pursue the maximum good, they would have not had the emotional catalysis for pursuing the good.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by amykhar on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:53PM (#17241934)
Hungry people and Flint are not Bill Gates responsibility. If he choses to give a gift to somebody, that's a kind and generous thing to do.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by JoshCole on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:26PM (#17242239)
Your intuition that the existence of more than one bad things means that people can't solve other bad things is exceedingly wrong. It flies in the face of the fact that humans regularly tackle more than one issue at a time.

Also, its not lets. Someone else is buying this book, not us. Their money does not belong to us. So we do not have the right to claim credit for this charitable deed. You especially, in opposition to this charitable deed, do not have any claim to it.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by AriaMinaei on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:56PM (#17241963)
If he was to spend that money to fight hunger, how should he have done it exactly? What would he spend it on? How lasting would its effect be?
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @06:34PM (#17242683)
How much do you think it costs to give away 2 million pdf files and how much do you think it would cost to feed 44 million people?
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by lev99 on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @04:54PM (#17241946)
I'm pretty sure the statistic is that every year 1 in 7 people in the U.S. face hunger.

Saying 1 in 7 people in the U.S. face hunger every year implies that the same group of people are hungry year after year. While a large portion of the hungry population probably are hungry multiple years, surely not all of them repeat every year.

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by frebord on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:52PM (#17242407)
I ate a donut this morning and I could have had a banana.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by ralusek on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:06PM (#17242062)
There is not a hunger issue in America, there is an obesity epidemic among the American poor.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/paulroderickgregory/2011/11/20/...

Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by enraged_camel on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @05:27PM (#17242248)
This is very incorrect.
Re:Bill Gates is giving Factfulness to those getting a degre... by ralusek on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @09:54PM (#17243809)
On increasing rates of obesity: http://time.com/4980225/obesity-rates-adults-children/

Association of obesity with socioeconomic status: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/databriefs/db50.pdf

"Among women, obesity prevalence increases as income decreases."

Here is what is strange, from a National Geographic article on hunger in the US: https://www.nationalgeographic.com/foodfeatures/hunger/

'It’s the same every month, Dreier says. Bills go unpaid because, when push comes to shove, food wins out. “We have to eat, you know,” she says, only the slightest hint of resignation in her voice. “We can’t starve.”'

But in the very same article: "Chances are good that if you picture what hunger looks like, you don’t summon an image of someone like Christina Dreier: white, married, clothed, and housed, even a bit overweight."

A bit overweight. That is not what starvation looks like. That is not what hunger looks like.

We can talk all day about strategies for strengthening the social safety net, but it is simply not true that people are going hungry in the United States.