News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Sunday June 03, 2018 @06:56PM (#17222904)
I live in SF. I am very, very tired of the homeless tents everywhere, dirty needles everywhere, and suspicious feces everywhere. The amount of bums living outside is unacceptable - this is perhaps the dirtiest city I have ever been to.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by 0x00000000 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:03PM (#17223640)
All they need to do is build some state institutions to provide care, but if you that NIMBYism is bad when it comes to housing, just wait until someone brings up that type of project. People are okay with just pretending they are doing everything they can, just as long as it stays mostly out of sight and the money is quietly spent. LA county spends a billion a year with little to show. Homelessness is 99% of the time a mental problem and no one wants to do anything about it
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by seehafer on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:12PM (#17224000)
Here's the problem with CA-brand NIMBYism: it's coupled with faux-bleeding-heart-ism.

We could have a state initiative to build Club Med for homeless people in the Central Valley, far away from anyone who could complain, and the same people who would complain if we put that facility in Hunters Point due to their NIMBYism would complain if we put it outside of SF because that would be "mean" due to displacing the homeless people (many of whom used to have residences in SF).

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by masonic on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:47AM (#17224741)

  build Club Med for homeless people in the Central Valley
Heck, homeless wouldn't use a nice, new facility in SF that was set up in 2015 in advance of the Super Bowl because is wasn't within easy access of usual gathering haunts.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by tim333 on Sunday June 10, 2018 @07:46AM (#17277661)
I googled that and it says (https://thinkprogress.org/san-francisco-clears-out-homeless-...)

>Yet the shelter is in such high demand that it has a waiting list 150 people long, all of whom were skipped over to relocate those who were moved to make way for Super Bowl visitors.

which sounds like they would use it

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Domenic_S on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:51PM (#17224187)
It’s not out of sight, not by a long shot - GP’s comments are not hyperbole. IMO the problem is people think it’s a simple home affordability issue when it’s like you said a mental health issue.

I think the term “homeless” does a grave disservice to that population, the term itself implies that it’s the home that’s a problem and not the zillions of underlying causes.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by test6554 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:25PM (#17224346)
The solution is for people to leave.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by masonic on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:44AM (#17224722)

  All they need to do is build some state institutions to provide care
You cannot institutionalize somebody against their will without legal adjudication (proving risk of harm to self and or others), since court rulings in the 1970s.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by fjsolwmv on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:09PM (#17223982)
That's not true, not until USA becomes a totalitarian country that can intitutionalize people against their will. Homeless people come to SF for the same reason yuppies do --- for the great weather. People who don't want help can't be helped.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by forapurpose on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:05AM (#17224524)
> I am very, very tired of the homeless tents everywhere

Let's be careful about confusing our frustrations with something that is wrong or illegal. Frustrating me isn't wrong and it isn't illegal; my frustrations aren't evidence of either - they are, in fact, irrelevant to those questions.

More importantly, many people and groups frustrate me, sometimes to a great extent. Political leaders stand out, as do many in tech; comments on HN sometimes frustrate me. Bigots frustrate me and cause great harm, IMO. I sometimes frustrate others. Why doesn't the state act against those people? Why doesn't it act against me? The state shouldn't act because we all have rights; it doesn't act because the people in this paragraph have political power. As a result, we all have to accommodate each other

Homeless people do not have power. They don't have political representatives who can insist on their priorities - who in fact must insist to keep their jobs - even when others don't like them, which is perhaps the only important meaning of power. If law enforcement acts illegally or excessively toward them, they can't protect themselves. And in the courts, they have no lawyers, and judges and juries give them no credibility and don't take their pleas seriously.

The great sin of government is the powerful abusing the powerless, the strong abusing the weak. It's long been a problem in the U.S. too; minorities, for example, could be publicly murdered or lynched and nobody would act; laws clearly abusing the minority, such as voting rights laws, can be implemented and they are powerless to stop it. I think we should be very careful to not let our frustrations drive us and repeat that grave error.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:19AM (#17224590)
So if the purpose of your comment is to point out that the homeless tents are not illegal, you are incorrect. The tents are illegal.

But my frustration, as you can see by my comments elsewhere in this thread, are grounded in that a city of such wealth and technological progress cannot take care of it's lowest citizens.

Aside from the odd choice of perspective - have you considered that the homeless may be infringing on others rights as well? The right to an unobstructed sidewalk? The right to feel safe in my neighborhood? The right to not have to watch out for needles when I visit my nearest Muni station (Van Ness)?

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by forapurpose on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:05AM (#17224812)
> illegal

Legality, while an important factor, is not the end of the discussion. Helping freed slaves was once illegal, using an extreme example. Legality depends on who is powerful, referring back to the GP.

> odd choice of perspective

Who says it's odd? Why would that be relevant? Is it odd to you because it isn't your perspective? It isn't the perspective you expect to see in this community? Is it good or bad to have 'odd' perspectives?

> the homeless may be infringing on others rights as well? The right to an unobstructed sidewalk? The right to feel safe in my neighborhood? The right to not have to watch out for needles when I visit my nearest Muni station (Van Ness)?

None of those things are really rights. Mostly, they are frustrations, and that's my point: I'm not saying people shouldn't come to accommodations with each other. I'm saying that frustrations of the powerful are not a basis of rights or of imposing on the powerless.

Imagine your homeless neighbors had a representative negotiating with you and your housed neighbors on an equal basis. How would you work it out? Has anyone asked your homeless neighbors what they need or want?

> purpose of your comment ...

That purpose is a creation of the parent, not me (the author of the GP). I'm going to stick with the words on the page.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by kirubakaran on Monday June 04, 2018 @03:53PM (#17231616)
It was you who brought up legality in the first place!

Relevant snippets:

googlemike: "I am very, very tired of the homeless tents everywhere"

forapurpose: "Let's be careful about confusing our frustrations with something that is wrong or illegal."

googlemike: "The tents are illegal"

forapurpose: "Legality, while an important factor, is not the end of the discussion."

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by forapurpose on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:09PM (#17233069)
I don't see how the parent adds to the conversation or says anything important about the accuracy of the GP. If the conversation was a contest between googlemike and me then we might need a referee to make sure we played fair. But it's not; we're just trying to advance ours (and hopefully others') knowledge a little.

Would it be better if I anticipated every possible response and addressed it in my GGGP comment? Uhhh ... probably not; that would be a very long comment and I don't have time for it. Sorry if that makes the thread confusing, but while suboptimal, I don't think it's hard to follow.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by zaarn on Monday June 04, 2018 @04:04AM (#17225541)
IMO your right to not have to fear needles, to feel safe in your neighboorhood and have an unobstructed sidewalk is trumped by the right of these people to survive. Even more important their right to live in dignity, which they are obviously not.

I consider the right to live in and be treated with dignity the utmost important one.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by manigandham on Thursday June 07, 2018 @08:50AM (#17255283)
Nobody is saying these people need to be destroyed. Not jumping to some extreme dystopian conclusion would help with the actual discussion. And if you're going to be ranking the importance of rights, how is the right to live in dignity more important than the right to survive?
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Nuzzerino on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:29AM (#17224646)
You could always do what I did and leave. Waiting for it to get fixed is unlikely to work out, and the tech industry is past it's glory days.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by paul7986 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:56PM (#17223903)
As a visitor of San Fran ... it's homeless population is a shock to the system and a very unpleasant one. Though they say thats just San Fran for ya? Crazy housing prices and an insane homeless population. What's the good thing about living there when here on the East coast like in PA or Baltimore suburbs that doesnt exist, housing costs are way lower, salaries in govt. IT are healthy and homelessness is not such epidemic... why do people want to live in San Fran who arent chasing the startup dream or living that dream? What's the allure?
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by flocial on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:18PM (#17224031)
But where would they go? Homelessness was a problem long before the tech industry sort of took over SF. The magnitude of the problem would require a massive political effort and innovation that is near impossible.

I'm more surprised by the fact that the tech industry chose SF of all the places in California.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Cogito on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:05AM (#17225047)
There are lots of reasons why Silicon Valley became what it is today, but it seems that by far it is because William Shockley [0] was born there - "Shockley is the man who brought silicon to Silicon Valley."

Shockley was working at Bell Labs over in New Jersey on solid state electronics, and was jointly awarded the Noble Prize for the discovery of the transistor effect. When he moved back home, angry at how the invention of the transistor had been handled at Bell Labs, he took a number of researchers with him. Together they were one of the first startups in Stanford's new "Stanford Industrial Park", and the first to use silicon. Some of those researchers later started Fairchild Semiconductor, from which came many companies like Intel and AMD.

If you haven't heard of it yet, Stephen Fry has an excellent (if too brief!) podcast that goes through this and the history of other big advances in technology in great detail, called Stephen Fry's Great Leap Years.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Shockley

[1] http://www.stephenfry.com/greatleapyears/

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by pm90 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:01PM (#17224241)
SF wasn’t chosen by the tech industry. South Bay was. Most big Tech firms’ HQs are outside the city itself, precisely because of lower real estate costs.

The move to SF has been much more recent and mainly fueled by the desire of younger workers to live/work in more densely populated areas. And then most startups started basing out of SF proper to be closer to these workers (and appear “cool”) so now you have all the big startup successes based in the city proper.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by ulfw on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:33PM (#17224103)
The tech industry chose the (South) Bay because it was dirty cheap. A bunch of orchards and ugly factories, so they could build up their (silicon) factories etc. there.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Domenic_S on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:48PM (#17224174)
I’m surprised by how many people don’t know this history. SJ used to be a very affordable place, it was orchards and farmland.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by tropo on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:04AM (#17224518)
There is no better place to grow apricots. This is a tragedy: people can go anywhere, but you can't do that with plants.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by amacbride on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:44PM (#17224426)
The proximity of Stanford and Berkeley didn't hurt.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by TACIXAT on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:39PM (#17224128)
I'm moving to the bay area from Baltimore for a lot of reasons. First, the salary increase means I'll be putting away more money every year, housing costs considered. Second, Baltimore is a mess. The roads are horrible and there is an insane amount of crime. Third, the weather is better and there are fewer bugs.

Baltimore is cheap, but I want to live somewhere that I can ride my bike without the fear of getting killed for it.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by tjr225 on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:05AM (#17224526)
There's another great thing about the west coast that cheap houses can't get you- and it's a beautiful culture of outdoorsiness and insanely easy access to mountains, oceans, and desert within an hour or twos drive- this is true from Seattle to San Diego.

You can seriously go on a little mini vacation every weekend for almost no money. I suppose if money were no object - why would you choose to live elsewhere?

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by paul7986 on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:03PM (#17230366)
Same goes for Baltimore with mountains(Shenadoah, VA or mountains in central PA), beaches (MD, DE or NJ) and amusement parks all within 2 to 3 hour drive. Friends and I last weekend went hiking in PA (loop trail with 25 mid to large size waterfalls - Ricketts Glen) and after went to amusement park in the woods (Knoebels) for a few hours.

Cool you like the west .. it's just too expensive and socialistic for me. Independent voter here.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Apocryphon on Monday June 04, 2018 @03:33AM (#17225394)
That's why a lot of Californians have been moving to Denver or Boise.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by erikpukinskis on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:20AM (#17224882)
The mountains are more like a 4h drive from San Francisco though.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by tjr225 on Monday June 04, 2018 @09:49AM (#17227769)
Sure but you have incredible and unique protected beauty just north of the Golden Gate Bridge so SF gets a pass.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by erikpukinskis on Thursday June 07, 2018 @12:56PM (#17257701)
Beauty yes, not mountains.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by paul7986 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:53PM (#17224197)
Harford County.. Bel Air, Fallston .. Baltimore County like Hunt Valley and many other similar areas that are suburbs not city.

Buying a house in PA on almost Silicon Valley (working remotely) salary you can buy two and other investments.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by occamsrazorwit on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:55AM (#17225236)
"Crazy housing prices and an insane homeless population"

Those are two facets of the same issue which is a demand much higher than the supply. SF has one of the best tech scenes in the world (to the point where it becomes stomach-churningly nauseating), and it's also just a hip metropolitan city with other thriving non-tech scenes.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by welder on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:38PM (#17223174)
Yea, and it can be demoralizing to see them and know it's probably not going to get better for them.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday June 04, 2018 @07:22PM (#17233547)
Los Angeles and San Diego aren't far behind. Prop 13 pretty much guarantees the whole state to be fucked for a long time. Since 60% of the state either has a mortgage or owns their home outright, good luck convincing them to vote to over turn it.

The New York, Canadian, Australian, and English housing markets are showing signs that Q/E asset price inflation is over. But with Prop 13, outside of a HUGE global depression, it's hard to imagine prices dropping to reality.

I recently finished Thomas Picketty's Capital in the 21st Century. Basically he says that the typical capital/income split is 700%, meaning assets are worth 7 times global output, meaning houses are usually worth 7 times median household income.

That's about the ratio you see everywhere in the world outside of the United States. Even in the priciest markets in the US like SF and LA, that rate hardly exceeds 300%. If anything, that book convinced me that unless we change our tax policies substantially, house prices are going to get MUCH MUCH worse.

I hope I'm wrong. But the book had 300 years of economic history to make me think the US post WW2 was under strange economic conditions that never existed anywhere else on the planet at any other time. Things aren't necessarily getting worse. They're just returning to normal ]=

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:55PM (#17223281)
Agreed. It seems like the city does not care. These people need avenues for help but also consequences for defiling city streets.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Balgair on Sunday June 03, 2018 @08:26PM (#17223430)
To be fair, YOU are "the city". This is a republic after all.

If you don't like it, show up and say something.

Rent Board contact info: https://sfrb.org/commission-meetings

SF Tenant's Union contact info: https://www.sftu.org/contact/

The last day to register to vote is THIS TUESDAY.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by otterley on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:06PM (#17223960)
I believe a link to a group of people who want the city to build a ton of housing (including public housing for the indigent) would be more appropriate. Controlling rent will do nothing for homeless people, and will make their plight even worse.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Balgair on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:30AM (#17228716)
Well, then post that link. :)
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Domenic_S on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:54PM (#17224205)
As I said elsewhere the term “homeless” is a bit of a misnomer that describes the ultimate consequence of a ton of underlying illnesses that result in eventual (actual) homelessness. Mental illness (I file addiction under that umbrella) is the root cause that should be treated.

Those people dumping needles on SF sidewalks won’t get magically well by handing them the key to an apartment. We need to treat the whole problem.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Balgair on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:35AM (#17228810)
Ok, go tell those boards this. Heck, make your own board. Grab a bunch of your friends, co-workers, etc. Attend, participate, make your voices heard. Democracy only works if you do.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by samcheng on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:15AM (#17224569)
Interestingly, many people say the same thing about our epidemic of gun massacres.

Are there any mental health startups out there?

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Balgair on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:33AM (#17228783)
Oh man, talk about only having a hammer! You don't need a start-up for mental health. You need funding for what we have already.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by samcheng on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:02PM (#17230352)
I don't think additional funding is enough. Funding doesn't appear to be the problem with respect to SF's homeless, for example.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:11PM (#17223995)
I would add https://cayimby.org. Rent boards and tenant unions are part of the problem.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Balgair on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:36AM (#17228828)
Great link, thanks!
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by psyc on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:18PM (#17223714)
Lol. The last thing the homeless need are more consequences. Let able-bodied and able-minded folk suck up their token share of the suffering.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by turtlecloud on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:35AM (#17227104)
Great. I sound like a good idea for a utility token sale ICO. :)
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by beenBoutIT on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:17PM (#17224312)
This recent change in Starbucks restroom policy should lead to a reduction in this type of behavior.
[dead]
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by fjsolwmv on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:11PM (#17223993)
Unclear if you are complaining about homeless people are tech company engineers.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by kjeetgill on Sunday June 03, 2018 @09:43PM (#17223840)
Out of curiosity, where in the city are you living? I see them around but I don't think they've ever bothered me. Usually when I hear that the city needs to do something about the homelessness problem, I assume they mean help FOR them, not for us.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:21AM (#17224598)
Around 10th and Market.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by noahdesu on Monday June 04, 2018 @08:46PM (#17234053)
Yeh, same location for me. It's not a great situation.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by toomanybeersies on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:12PM (#17224001)
I take it you haven't been to many developing countries then.

Upon saying that, things are pretty bad if all we can say is "at least it's cleaner than Phnom Penh".

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:25AM (#17224625)
Been to quiet a bit of the Middle East, as well as some very poor parts of the former Soviet Union.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by elcritch on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:18AM (#17224878)
I thought Phnom Penh was overall a much cleaner city than SF... Lots of people and haphazardness in PP, but mostly cleanish. I’d agree with your statement based on where I’ve been too. Also poor doesn’t always equate to "squalor".
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by toomanybeersies on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:54AM (#17225233)
I was last in Cambodia about 7 years ago, so a lot has probably changed. But when I was there, parts of it were basically an open air landfill.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by 10065 on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:37AM (#17224953)
Ok, and what are your solutions to the problem?
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by knuththetruth on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:37PM (#17223168)
Unacceptable in what terms? I imagine the people living in those conditions are more exhausted by then than you are by your observing them.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:51PM (#17223248)
Unacceptable in that people shouldn't be living outside, on city streets. Unacceptable that there there is such a lack of mental health care, support, and facilities available to these people. Unacceptable that the city seems to have no solutions or plans in place. Unacceptable that the politicians live in Pacific Heights away from where the majority of the problems are so they are not affected by them like the actual citizens of the city. My exhaustion is not one of observation, I am exhausted that a modern, high tech, wealthy city looks like this.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by knuththetruth on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:55PM (#17223276)
Ok understood. Apologies.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by askafriend on Sunday June 03, 2018 @08:11PM (#17223348)
Also don't overlook the public health crisis that it creates. Feces, urine, needles, and other human excrement openly getting kicked up into the air we breathe and thriving on the surfaces we come into contact with on a daily basis is terrible for EVERYONE. It's completely unacceptable to have to encourage that kind of environment.

Homeless people aren't just a danger to themselves. They are disproportionately a danger to everyone around them.

In the current situation, everyone on every side of the issue loses - there are no winners. Something needs to change.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by forapurpose on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:02PM (#17223937)
> public health crisis

Is there any evidence of public health consequences, much less a crisis. This argument looks suspiciously like the rationalizations long made for people to discriminate against those they feel uncomfortable around.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by pm90 on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:40PM (#17224407)
Absolutely not. Getting rid of human waste is one of the most important issues in developing countries precisely because of the public health effects it has: transmitting pathogens, contaminating water supplies etc. It isn't hard to see that being the case in an Urban area like SF, especially since the density of people is so much greater.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by forapurpose on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:06AM (#17224821)
I know why human waste is dangerous. I asked if there is evidence that there is such a problem in SF, and if there is evidence of that problem being a health "crisis". So far, no evidence is cited in this thread - which certainly doesn't mean there isn't any.

It does seem like the ideal talking point - it's disgusting, a bit frightening, and thus shifts readers from reason to a strong emotional reaction. Let's try to shift back. If there's evidence of a problem, it absolutely should be addressed.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by Redoubts on Monday June 04, 2018 @02:56AM (#17225241)
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by forapurpose on Monday June 04, 2018 @06:03PM (#17233030)
Thanks! That might be the most valuable thing posted on this thread. Still, some research would be a lot better than journalists' observations.

It seems to me that porta-potties, and some needle-safe trash cans, would be cost-effective, temporary solutions.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by yourapostasy on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:26PM (#17224352)
Basic public sanitation measures, including isolating human waste from open air spaces, is the most significant factor to increased average lifespan than medical technology. Reverse that in even just one of the legs of basic sanitation and you invite in a host of (in America) extraordinarily expensive pathogenic consequences. Expensive to treat and expensive to prophylactically ward off after an outbreak starts.

Like code defects, it is magnitudes cheaper to fix earlier in the development pipeline.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by otterley on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:08PM (#17223976)
You're aware that human waste carries pathogens, right?
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by bigbluedots on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:07AM (#17225867)
There is human shit and needles all over the streets and you're arguing there may be no public health consequences?
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Sunday June 03, 2018 @08:01PM (#17223302)
No problem. To your comments below about class warfare, unequal societies and corruption. I think the homeless here are both of the vulnerable, drug addicted, mentally unwell kind that have been abandoned by society, but there is also a whole cadre of their homeless peers that is mentally far healthier and preys on the others - chop shops, black market economies of drugs and prostitution, etc. That being said, a city should not be this dirty and unsafe. Families of all classes and backgrounds should feel safe walking around city streets at all hours of the day, which is far from the case today.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by randycupertino on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:48PM (#17223231)
Not really... the homeless by choice types are tweakers who move to SF to intentionally live on the streets and have easy access to cheap and plentiful drugs. SF basically created hamsterdam, and addicts from all over the country flock here so they can get high and enjoy life on the streets with impunity.

The street denizens in SF building encampments, shitting on the sidewalk, breaking into cars to get their fix and blatantly operating chop shops aren't hard up people who are just down on their luck and between jobs... these types move here to specifically live on the streets and get high all the time.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:54PM (#17223273)
Yes. We need a two part solution. For the first part, the city should offer all the medical (mental and physical) care they could want, as well as any help they may need to get off the street. For the other part, the city needs to arrest and prosecute those who do are clearly mentally stable and just enjoying a drug filled vagabond life on the city streets.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by 5DFractalTetris on Sunday June 03, 2018 @08:35PM (#17223471)
What about individuals who prefer tent dwelling and regular work (paid and volunteer) but eschew both illegal drug use and unemployment?

I have a tent I could call a home but am not entirely comfortable crashing wherever I can, although generally I like being outside as much as possible. Tent dwelling is also historically well-respected, hard housing being the niche of farmers and royalty. I'd go as far to say that if people in tents aren't safe it's not a good neighborhood, because tents are fragile. They're also not garbage: some of them are fireproof and UV resistant with two or three shells. And, if you've never built housing, I can tell you: it is a huge chore for hundreds of people, including chemical workers, lumberjacks, metalworkers, and coal miners.

Why not build a Black Rock City where the Burn never stops? If cities sponsored that niche, the gig economy would ramp up to "unstoppable machine" instantly. Sociologically, there's not much difference between a tent city at a festival and an apartment building with a range of incomes, in terms of deviancy and community struggles. From a housing and urban development perspective, some of the new textiles are better and more sustainable than industrial construction.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by defen on Sunday June 03, 2018 @11:41PM (#17224415)
> Why not build a Black Rock City where the Burn never stops?

You know, that would actually be a fascinating thing to see. I doubt it will ever happen given how litigious our society is, but that seems preferable to what we're doing now. San Francisco spends about $250 million on homeless services[1], but you'd never know from walking around. You could probably fund a non-stop Burn with that; the budget for a 65,000 person burn for a week is 37 million[2]. You'd have fewer people and less overhead so I think it would work.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_San_Franci...

[2] https://burningman.org/expenses/expenses-2016/

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:22AM (#17224610)
San Jose had one of sorts, iirc it was destroyed because it was a hotbed of assaults, drugs, rapes, and pollution (illegal fires and dumping).
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by prawn on Tuesday June 05, 2018 @10:08PM (#17243844)
How coordinated was it though? I also think part of the solution is to provide something more appealing to the mentally ill homeless and the lifestyle-homeless. There is a lot of space an hour or two from most major cities that could be used in a project like this.

Something of a commune, heavily staffed with mental health professionals and with very attentive services (medical, cleaning, garbage). Encourage the more willing to undertake/share those roles. Make it feel somewhat self-organised and free.

Run a very loose "street school" - open-air where possible, 1-2 hours a day, variety of interesting topics. (I'm surprised they don't try doing that in SF.)

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by masonic on Monday June 04, 2018 @01:01AM (#17224799)
"The Jungle". Over 618 tons of trash (not counting hazardous waste) were removed upon its closure.

http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-silicon-valley...

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by masonic on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:55AM (#17224768)

  Why not build a Black Rock City 
Burners are mandated to be self-sufficient and leave no trace; only chemical toilets are provided. If that ethic was practiced by this population, there would be many more options.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by yrusowrong on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:29AM (#17228683)
70% of homeless in SF were previously housed in SF at one point. Citation needed for your narrative.

Source: hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/2007-SF-PIT-Report.pdf.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by knuththetruth on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:53PM (#17223265)
It’s amazing that in a such a demonstrably corrupt and unequal society as America in 2018, that people cling to these insane narratives about the most vulnerable people in society.

I guess if you’re going to side with the rich in this ongoing class war, this is the kind of stuff you have to tell yourself to sleep at night.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Sunday June 03, 2018 @07:55PM (#17223275)
Do you live in San Francisco? His narrative is far closer to reality than yours.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by yrusowrong on Monday June 04, 2018 @11:28AM (#17228672)
No it isn't. 70% of homeless in SF were previously housed in SF at one point. Citation needed for your narrative.

Source: hsh.sfgov.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/2007-SF-PIT-Report.pdf.

Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by fjsolwmv on Sunday June 03, 2018 @10:07PM (#17223971)
You can leave. The homeless people are probably tired of you too.
Re:Nearly half of Bay Area residents say they want to leave by googlemike on Monday June 04, 2018 @12:23AM (#17224614)
Me as in a working, tax paying, citizen? What if all the working, tax paying citizens left - what would we have then? I do not find your comment or attitude constructive.