There are lots of people who will "question" endlessly the meaning of "misinformation". Trying to make exceptions for that .01% of the time a "gray area" can exist, while ignoring the real harm to society caused by the 99.99% "deliberate misinformation".
I guarantee you, the responses to your comment will be exactly that.
I would compare it to science-denial. Like people who refuse vaccines because of the tiny risks involved, while ignoring the outsized benefits.
People who continuously debate the nuance of "what is" "misinformation", while ignoring the harm it does, is no better.
And while one singular bit of misinformation may seem harmless, goofy, and opinionated, ie. Obama is a muslim, crowd size, "Uranium One" etc... A constantly stream of them practically creates an alternate reality for people who believes them, and that is extremely dangerous.
The .01% is enough of a basis for a lawsuit. And grandstanding by the right claiming the company is biased (never mind that almost all "misinformation" is right leaning, so it's likely the .01% false positives are also likely right leaning). I would absolutely not want to be taking on such risks from a business perspective. If it's societal good we're aiming for, let society (elected officials) figure out how best to achieve that. Do you really trust for-profit organizations to not have their "editors" swayed by customers?
Evidence can change and something regarded as false yesterday, can be true tomorrow. Congratulations, you committed censorship.
Take your example of vaccinations. Huge topic, even in my country which is at a 96% protected rate. Misinformation would evidentely be that anti-vaxxers are a significant problem that should be talked about and that we seriously need legislation to enforce vaccination.
Blatently false, the numbers show it. Having any other opinion is pure science denial.
That said, it can be a problem in other parts of the world. So what should be the reference here?
You aren't even able to develop a theory about the damage of misinformation that would withstand scientific scrutiny. Maybe only because of lacking data than there not being a correlation, but still.
So in the end I would conclude you only want to censor things you do not like.
If you are more certain about your point of view and are able to articulate it, maybe more people will believe you.
Earlier today I saw a thread of tweets criticizing a media figure for promoting the claim that Chelsea Clinton is married to a nephew of George Soros.
This is a relatively easy claim to check; the identity of Chelsea Clinton's husband is not a secret, and Soros' family tree is also known. Her husband is not, in fact, a nephew of George Soros.
Do you believe it is correct, then, to identify a tweet claiming "Chelsea Clinton is married to George Soros' nephew" as "misinformation"? Or would you, in a sense of charitable benevolence to the shifting nature of truth, want to hold off, just in case tomorrow she wakes up, decides she's unhappy, and files for divorce so that she can actually go marry a Soros nephew?
Let's try it more neutral. Water is an aggregate state of carbon dioxide. Is this misinformation? Yes. Do I want social networks to be chemical teachers? No.
> Blatently false, the numbers show it. Having any other opinion is pure science denial.
For measles, the herd immunity threshold is 93-95% [1].
1. http://www.who.int/immunization/sage/meetings/2017/october/2...
Even with legislation, you wouldn't achieve a 100% protection rate.
You can also verify the insignificance of this discussion if you look at the victims of measels.
You can always argue that one is one too many and I would agree. But I disagree about the means in case of doubt. But all that is off topic.
The interesting part is the mutual reinforcement of targeted content and what we may call "idiosyncratic truth," since both refer to distinctive group boundaries and the respective framework of shared world view. Social media will always reinforce such bias, it's part of the setup.
Lastly, if we acknowledge that there's no way to identify an unbiased (positive) truth, it may be also hard to identify bias at all. It may be possible to identify misinformation which is spread arbitrarily as part of a broader strategy (then better called disinformation) but even then it may be hard to reach consensus. (Elefant in the room may be the UN presentation proceeding the last Golf War.)
Aristotle defined truth essentially correctly: "To say of what is that it is not, or of what is not that it is, is false, while to say of what is that it is, and of what is not that it is not, is true."
Are you saying that reality is also ideological (quite a radical claim) or simply that perceptions of reality (and therefore what people think is true) are ideological (which is a rather tamer claim)?
I think that is a great example of something which is obviously untrue.
(Also: Let "x" = 1", "2" = "++x" and "4" = "2(++x)". Results may depend on your C implementation.)
Which really is the argument that falsehoods are [some portion of the time] rooted in wrong assumptions and premises.
I would argue that this only strengthens the statement that facts exist.
That some people (here on Earth) want to claim that 2+2=5 because they have invented their own number 2 (which they conveniently withhold), is precisely the kind of misinformation being discussed in the thread.
There might be better solutions. One idea is to pay nonpartisan organizations to fact check viral posts. Another is to reduce the use of engagement as a metric, which tends to promote emotionally charged rather than factual content. For example, in January Facebook committed to prioritizing "meaningful social interactions".
Unfortunately, even if those pushing deliberate misinformation are banned, then the problem will keep going since others will spread the information because they mistakenly believe its true.
If you then decide to ban all misinformation (because false information is a problem even if it is a mistake), that goes back to the difficulty of deciding what is misinformation - people can cherry-pick true information in a way that gives a misleading impression, or if someone makes a statement that might be true, but there is no evidence for it, do you have to assume that it is false?
I agree that there is a problem here, but I don't know that banning misinformation is the right way to solve it - there are too many gray areas, and it grants _a lot_ of power to social media companies to let them determine what is true.
Which by their very nature subvert and stretch the simple true/false dichotomy.
Edit: let's have a look at https://twitter.com/afneil/status/1001158920663109632 - Andrew Neil is Chairman of the Spectator (important "serious" rightwing politics magazine) and a BBC presenter. He's accusing the NYT of "Stalinism". One of these has to be wrong.
Oh, at least ten thousand of those retweets were post-correction, as is usual on Twitter.
Was that really necessary? Casual racism completely undermines any point you might be trying to make.
The paper also finds that many misinformation accounts are not bots. Currently, misinformation is not a bannable offense for most social networks. Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube leaders have said, verbatim, that they don't want to be "arbiters of truth". Of course, that leaves open the question of what responsibility they have and what actions they should take.