News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by stordoff on Monday May 28, 2018 @07:51PM (#17175471)
There's also the question of what is misinformation? You have a continuum from differences of opinion, to people being mistaken, to deliberate misinformation. Where do you (reliably) draw the line? I can see why they wouldn't want them to be "arbiters of truth" -- I'm not sure I would want them to be either.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by optimuspaul on Monday May 28, 2018 @09:47PM (#17175868)
I'm not sure there is a question about what it is. Misinformation is what it is, information that is wrong, it is false information. Peoples opinions cannot be misinformation, they are opinions. I do agree there is a gray area between people being mistaken and deliberate misinformation, but there is no need to draw a line there, both should be addressed. People should be corrected and misinformation should not be spread further.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by vinhboy on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:48AM (#17176587)
There is nothing more infuriating than watching educated left-leaning people twist themselves into a knot trying side step calling lies, lies, because they want to appear impartial.

There are lots of people who will "question" endlessly the meaning of "misinformation". Trying to make exceptions for that .01% of the time a "gray area" can exist, while ignoring the real harm to society caused by the 99.99% "deliberate misinformation".

I guarantee you, the responses to your comment will be exactly that.

I would compare it to science-denial. Like people who refuse vaccines because of the tiny risks involved, while ignoring the outsized benefits.

People who continuously debate the nuance of "what is" "misinformation", while ignoring the harm it does, is no better.

And while one singular bit of misinformation may seem harmless, goofy, and opinionated, ie. Obama is a muslim, crowd size, "Uranium One" etc... A constantly stream of them practically creates an alternate reality for people who believes them, and that is extremely dangerous.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by sidr on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @10:07AM (#17179269)
> Trying to make exceptions for that .01% of the time a "gray area" can exist, while ignoring the real harm to society caused by the 99.99% "deliberate misinformation".

The .01% is enough of a basis for a lawsuit. And grandstanding by the right claiming the company is biased (never mind that almost all "misinformation" is right leaning, so it's likely the .01% false positives are also likely right leaning). I would absolutely not want to be taking on such risks from a business perspective. If it's societal good we're aiming for, let society (elected officials) figure out how best to achieve that. Do you really trust for-profit organizations to not have their "editors" swayed by customers?

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by ringbugger on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @03:31AM (#17177123)
If that infurates you, it is a sign to be a necessity. There is a reason why social networks do not want to certify information to be true or not. And it is certainly not because of some "twisted side-stepping".

Evidence can change and something regarded as false yesterday, can be true tomorrow. Congratulations, you committed censorship.

Take your example of vaccinations. Huge topic, even in my country which is at a 96% protected rate. Misinformation would evidentely be that anti-vaxxers are a significant problem that should be talked about and that we seriously need legislation to enforce vaccination.

Blatently false, the numbers show it. Having any other opinion is pure science denial.

That said, it can be a problem in other parts of the world. So what should be the reference here?

You aren't even able to develop a theory about the damage of misinformation that would withstand scientific scrutiny. Maybe only because of lacking data than there not being a correlation, but still.

So in the end I would conclude you only want to censor things you do not like.

If you are more certain about your point of view and are able to articulate it, maybe more people will believe you.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by ubernostrum on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @04:32AM (#17177360)
Evidence can change and something regarded as false yesterday, can be true tomorrow.

Earlier today I saw a thread of tweets criticizing a media figure for promoting the claim that Chelsea Clinton is married to a nephew of George Soros.

This is a relatively easy claim to check; the identity of Chelsea Clinton's husband is not a secret, and Soros' family tree is also known. Her husband is not, in fact, a nephew of George Soros.

Do you believe it is correct, then, to identify a tweet claiming "Chelsea Clinton is married to George Soros' nephew" as "misinformation"? Or would you, in a sense of charitable benevolence to the shifting nature of truth, want to hold off, just in case tomorrow she wakes up, decides she's unhappy, and files for divorce so that she can actually go marry a Soros nephew?

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by ringbugger on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @04:49AM (#17177456)
I love this. Taking a politically charged topic and trying to prove something irrefutably false while trying to make a completely different point. Yes, of course that is misinformation.

Let's try it more neutral. Water is an aggregate state of carbon dioxide. Is this misinformation? Yes. Do I want social networks to be chemical teachers? No.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by creato on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @04:11AM (#17177274)
> Take your example of vaccinations. Huge topic, even in my country which is at a 96% protected rate. Misinformation would evidentely be that anti-vaxxers are a significant problem that should be talked about and that we seriously need legislation to enforce vaccination.

> Blatently false, the numbers show it. Having any other opinion is pure science denial.

For measles, the herd immunity threshold is 93-95% [1].

1. http://www.who.int/immunization/sage/meetings/2017/october/2...

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by ringbugger on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @04:26AM (#17177331)
That might be true. I should have added that protection rates are rising.

Even with legislation, you wouldn't achieve a 100% protection rate.

You can also verify the insignificance of this discussion if you look at the victims of measels.

You can always argue that one is one too many and I would agree. But I disagree about the means in case of doubt. But all that is off topic.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by baud147258 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @05:28AM (#17177652)
Misinformation can be true information, but presented in a way to mislead the reader.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by Bromskloss on Monday May 28, 2018 @10:03PM (#17175928)
Even someone's honest attempt at presenting the truth can be considered, by someone else, to be worded in a misleading way.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by masswerk on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @04:33AM (#17177365)
The problem is that there's no such thing as a positive truth. Truth always refers to a certain framework which is shared and acknowledged by a given group, which also distinguishes groups one from another. (So we may say, truth is necessarily a question of ideology.)

The interesting part is the mutual reinforcement of targeted content and what we may call "idiosyncratic truth," since both refer to distinctive group boundaries and the respective framework of shared world view. Social media will always reinforce such bias, it's part of the setup.

Lastly, if we acknowledge that there's no way to identify an unbiased (positive) truth, it may be also hard to identify bias at all. It may be possible to identify misinformation which is spread arbitrarily as part of a broader strategy (then better called disinformation) but even then it may be hard to reach consensus. (Elefant in the room may be the UN presentation proceeding the last Golf War.)

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @06:58AM (#17177987)
Much longer explanation that there is, in fact, truth: http://yudkowsky.net/rational/the-simple-truth/. And it's exactly that naive, obvious, intuitive thing you think of before trying to sophisticate or politicize the concept.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by taejo on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @06:00AM (#17177795)
> The problem is that there's no such thing as a positive truth. Truth always refers to a certain framework which is shared and acknowledged by a given group, which also distinguishes groups one from another. (So we may say, truth is necessarily a question of ideology.)

Aristotle defined truth essentially correctly: "To say of what is that it is not, or of what is not that it is, is false, while to say of what is that it is, and of what is not that it is not, is true."

Are you saying that reality is also ideological (quite a radical claim) or simply that perceptions of reality (and therefore what people think is true) are ideological (which is a rather tamer claim)?

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by masswerk on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @01:10AM (#17185226)
However, we do know, at least since Kant, that perception is not a simple matter of apperception. Reality is beyond reach and we have to resort to internal combinational capabilities to assert reality, thus considered a construct. Constructed reality always adheres to broader frameworks, retroactive interpretation, etc. Moreover, when it comes to abstract concepts, perception isn't really a means of asserting reality anymore. How could we check a proposition like, "The US is ruled by the deep state" by simple perception? In fact, when we are confronted with a proposition like this, it is much more for the overall credibility that we allow to be attributed to the proposition and/or its source and how it fits to our own broader world view, whether we tend to acknowledge the proposition or to reject it. (Fact checking may be here seen as a sophisticated approach to rejecting the proposition at first.) So, yes, ideology is a thing and is to be considered as part of what we use to acknowledge as truth.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by gadders on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @07:01AM (#17177999)
>> The problem is that there's no such thing as a positive truth. Truth always refers to a certain framework which is shared and acknowledged by a given group, which also distinguishes groups one from another. (So we may say, truth is necessarily a question of ideology.)

I think that is a great example of something which is obviously untrue.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by masswerk on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @01:40AM (#17185345)
If we may not connect directly to reality, which has been a well established idea for the last 250 years, how could we deny that what is reality to us is essentially a construct?
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by catawbasam on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @05:57AM (#17177782)
2+2=4 regardless of ideology.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by masswerk on Wednesday May 30, 2018 @01:19AM (#17185263)
However, Gödel…

(Also: Let "x" = 1", "2" = "++x" and "4" = "2(++x)". Results may depend on your C implementation.)

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by thaumasiotes on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @06:09AM (#17177831)
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by croon on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @07:26AM (#17178099)
That's not a counterpoint. That strip is countering a statement based on the flawed assumption that aliens would count using the same base-10 system most of us here use.

Which really is the argument that falsehoods are [some portion of the time] rooted in wrong assumptions and premises.

I would argue that this only strengthens the statement that facts exist.

That some people (here on Earth) want to claim that 2+2=5 because they have invented their own number 2 (which they conveniently withhold), is precisely the kind of misinformation being discussed in the thread.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by thaumasiotes on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @05:59AM (#17177789)
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by allenz on Monday May 28, 2018 @08:47PM (#17175645)
I agree that it's a difficult social and political problem. Interestingly, companies are fine banning hate speech, for which the same can be said.

There might be better solutions. One idea is to pay nonpartisan organizations to fact check viral posts. Another is to reduce the use of engagement as a metric, which tends to promote emotionally charged rather than factual content. For example, in January Facebook committed to prioritizing "meaningful social interactions".

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by jrs95 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @08:23AM (#17178451)
And if what’s generally taken to be true actually fits the definition of misinformation, and other misinformation networks are created with the intent to combat that, is this really any different from how politics has always been? It seems we are exchanging a lot more bullshit now, but at least it can be more easily observed when it’s on the internet vs a physical medium. Right now I think the internet has generally made things worse, but it seems possible that we can raise the standard as time goes on. At least now I think a subset of highly interested people are able to more accurately determine what’s factual than anyone would have been able to just a couple decades ago.
Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by CM30 on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @02:39AM (#17176952)
The key part is probably the distinction between deliberate and accidental misinformation. Yes the latter can be problematic as well, but it would seem ridiculous to ban someone for simply making mistakes. Everyone does so, from professional journalists to average Joes on the street.

Unfortunately, even if those pushing deliberate misinformation are banned, then the problem will keep going since others will spread the information because they mistakenly believe its true.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by stordoff on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @01:49PM (#17181394)
That's in a way a similar problem - how do you distinguish between deliberate and accidental (especially if you start banning deliberate misinformation, and deliberate misinformers start trying to make it look accidental)? You might be able to catch the more blatant examples (such as it being the only thing they tweet about and it being consistently wrong), but in general I'm not sure how you can look at a false message and decide if it was deliberate or a mistake.

If you then decide to ban all misinformation (because false information is a problem even if it is a mistake), that goes back to the difficulty of deciding what is misinformation - people can cherry-pick true information in a way that gives a misleading impression, or if someone makes a statement that might be true, but there is no evidence for it, do you have to assume that it is false?

I agree that there is a problem here, but I don't know that banning misinformation is the right way to solve it - there are too many gray areas, and it grants _a lot_ of power to social media companies to let them determine what is true.

Re:Anatomy of an online misinformation network by olefoo on Tuesday May 29, 2018 @12:45AM (#17176572)
Also things like, sarcasm, metaphor and weird twitter.

Which by their very nature subvert and stretch the simple true/false dichotomy.