News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by PinguTS on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:25AM (#17152109)
Cash is cool. Cash is anonymously. Cash is independent from any payment processor. Cash has no payment fees. Cash does not require power, so it is somehow environment friendly. Cash is just cool.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by joncrocks on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:45AM (#17152253)
> Cash has no payment fees. Cash does not require power

This is a good example of 'out of sight, out of mind'.

There are obviously costs in creating cash, distributing it, maintaining it (take old/damaged currency out of circulation) and enforcement of counterfeit protection. And ditto for power.

These costs and power requirements are not obvious though, and so the end-user is not aware of the costs involved.

Any comparison between cash and non-cash needs to be sure to count the complete lifecycle of and payment processing and not just the bits that the end-user sees.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jlg23 on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:46AM (#17154184)
> These costs and power requirements are not obvious

At the time of payment they are irrelevant.

> Any comparison between cash and non-cash needs to be sure to count the complete lifecycle of and payment processing and not just the bits that the end-user sees.

Where is it convenient for you to draw the line? Do you include the production of card readers, the creation and maintenance of power and communication lines?

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Retric on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:36AM (#17154093)
The same is true of credit cards by design. People don't see what can end up as 25% of vending machines costs etc.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by philfrasty on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:29AM (#17152143)
"Cash has no payment fees" This is simply not true. Take a business for example:

1.) have a cashbox (or multiple)

2.) guard cashbox

3.) every evening count money in cashbox

4.) hope the cash you took in is still in the cashbox

5.) if not 4) --> accounting nightmare + fire employee

6.) bring cash to bank

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by PinguTS on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:05AM (#17153803)
A cash-free business:

1.) have a terminal that supports all the different card types

2.) guard the IT infrastructure according to the PCI rules (have you ever needed to implement those, especially for small shop owners with no IT know-how)

3.) every day/week/month accounting of the payments to the corresponding receipts

4.) hope that the customer doesn't initiate a reimbursement

5.) if not 4) --> accounting nightmare + loss of the reimbursed money

6.) spending weekends (small business) for the required IT infrastructure

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by h1d on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:44AM (#17154174)
1) What's the concern here?

2) Why does the seller have to guard the payment processor's IT infrastructure?

3) Certainly faster than counting cash on top of counting the reciepts.

4) The problem doesn't exactly lie in the cash less system. Dealing with complaint is your business' problem.

5) Reversing 1 entry isnt a nightmare.

6) Are you developing your own solution or something?

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by tluyben2 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:50PM (#17155517)
As a normal merchant you are getting an off the shelve machine which runs on existing infra so no idea what you are talking about in point 1, 2 or 6. The other points, sure, but they are the same with cash and with cashless they are mostly automated. You hook them up to Xero or something and everything goes straight from PoS to there. Cashless is definitely less hassle for the merchant (life altering experiences like being robbed was not mentioned but anecdotally I know at least two wine merchants who sucked up the small costs of cashless after they were robbed) ; the only things they will mention as negatives is the % on transactions and being unable to do stuff under the table easily.

It might be good to know as well that charge backs in the EU are not as common or easy as in the US.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Retric on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:37AM (#17154103)
But avoid "Pay payment processor ~30 cents per transaction AND ~3%."

Many businesses can't afford to offer credit card transactions because they would be extremely expensive.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by gruez on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:32AM (#17154054)
>2.) guard the IT infrastructure according to the PCI rules (have you ever needed to implement those, especially for small shop owners with no IT know-how)

is this really necessary? AFAIK it's only necessary if you handle credit card numbers, which you don't, and can be outsourced to the payment processor so you're not seeing credit card numbers at all.

>3.) every day/week/month accounting of the payments to the corresponding receipts

this can't be handled by the POS software?

>4.) hope that the customer doesn't initiate a reimbursement

probably not a big issue with card present purchases

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by therealmarv on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:58AM (#17152338)
I've read once that the break even cash vs. electronic payment is at around 5 Euros. If you pay more than 5 Euros it's cheaper at the end of month to use electronic payment.

Cash gets more and more expensive (exponentially) on the amount of money (security, deposition etc.). On electronic cash it's like a flat line.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by ballenf on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:46AM (#17154186)
Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that it's cheaper to take one or the other, but if you mostly take credit cards then there is a marginal cost to also accepting cash? And vice versa. However:

- If I'm doing a large cash business then the next $5+ costs me basically nothing.

- However if I'm doing a mostly credit card business, the next $5 will cost me the same as the first $5.

With that, I think the analysis you read was funded by payment processors.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by therealmarv on Friday May 25, 2018 @04:28PM (#17157637)
It's a good mind trick to look on a single additional transaction. But you are also not thinking about all the costs you have per month for storing, securing, exchanging cash.

But to correct myself: This 5€ break even is on a macroeconomic level on all parties. Cash is more expensive on this level when you spend more than 5€ on a single transaction.

Just one example of the other party: the end consumer also cannot get cash for free (even when he get's it free from the ATM, there are costs the bank has and maybe you pay them indirectly).

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by ForHackernews on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:31AM (#17152152)
Only for businesses that handle large volumes of cash. For person-to-person transactions, cash is the way to go.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by dagw on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:26AM (#17154003)
Making change in person-to-person transactions is a pain. If I owe you $15 bucks and you and I only have 20s, there is no easy solution other than you owning me money, one of us writing off a debt, or me having to put off paying you. Much easier for me to pull out my phone, type in your phone number and the amount I want to give you and just hit send.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by ballenf on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:48AM (#17154212)
There are network effects. In Germany, everyone has the change on hand because they're using it so much. If they don't someone nearby will have it and be willing to help.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by harperlee on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:35AM (#17152180)
ATM withdrawal is not generally free; both the ATM network and your bank can charge fees for withdrawing money. At least in Spain this is true; I think it is generally true at least lso with French banks. Withdrawing abroad is normally with fees.

EDIT: Downvotes in HN are not a dissenting mechanism; they are there to bury inappropriate/misleading/etc. comments (not that I particularly care, but it seems a proper opportunity to clarify a misconception).

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by richardknop on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:37AM (#17152188)
In a lot of Europe it is free.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by aequitas on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:18AM (#17152835)
Just as free as free shipping, at the end of the day you pay for it someway, like (higher) banking fees, cost for (extra) card, reduced interest rates, etc.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by richardknop on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:57AM (#17154309)
Interest rates have been basically zero in all western world for a long time. Transferring money in Europe is also cheaper than in US, very few fees if any.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by tqkxzugoaupvwqr on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:46AM (#17152266)
In Europe, if you use ATMs of your bank’s network, it is free. For example, customers of a bank that is part of the UniCredit group can withdraw money for free from another bank’s ATM as long as this bank is also part of the UniCredit group.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by harperlee on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:54AM (#17152310)
In reality it depends on the ATM network, not on the bank (different companies!), although fees might be waived by your bank for commercial reasons.

For example, a spanish Santander card is free in the 4B network, but you will be charged on the german Santander ATM, as it is another ATM network (the Cash Group).

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by zingmars on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:52AM (#17152659)
> not on the bank (different companies!)

Not necessarily. Here in Latvia banks manage their own ATMs and whether you will have to pay a fee depends on your bank having a contract with the bank whose ATMs you're trying to use (usually there is no fee for taking money out of your bank's ATMs with a few exceptions, i.e. my bank has a 10% fee on withdrawals from credit cards, though most have debit cards anyway).

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by chrisseaton on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:59AM (#17153198)
> In Europe, if you use ATMs of your bank’s network, it is free.

Who do you think is paying to run that ATM?

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Aaargh20318 on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:39AM (#17152201)
As far as I know ATM withdrawals are free within Europe (if you're a customer of another European bank).
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by harperlee on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:43AM (#17152231)
Again, that depends on the bank. But there is no European legal obligation for it to be free of fees.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by richardknop on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:53AM (#17152301)
That’s true but practically speaking if you live in Europe 9/10 times you will pay 0 fees. If you don’t travel much (and during travel use ATM at the airport), you might never pay any fees.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by tluyben2 on Friday May 25, 2018 @01:04PM (#17155672)
In my experience in Spain for instance, most ATMs make you pay a fee unless you are with their bank or if your bank pays for it. In north EU a less common see fees charged.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Aaargh20318 on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:00AM (#17152345)
Why would you join a bank that charges a fee to use the ATM ?
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by harperlee on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:18AM (#17152449)
Perhaps because you save more money on a cheaper mortgage than you spend on ATM fees, as you don't take a lot of money from the ATM because you can pay by card almost everywhere, for example?
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Aaargh20318 on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:37AM (#17152988)
Except those aren't related at all. You can have a mortgage at bank A and a checking account at bank B. In fact, that's the most common case for most people.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by harperlee on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:42AM (#17153583)
They are indeed related, it is not uncommon for banks to offer reduced mortgage rates if you have with them also other products, and often people prefer dealing with just 1 bank. So I would also contend your point of "having just a mortgage with 1 bank and the checking account elsewhere" being the most common case.

And nonetheless you were initially asking why would anyone join a bank that charged them ATM fees; the answer is that it might still make financial sense or be convenient for people. We are discussing about why there is a sizable population for which ATM withdrawal fees makes them prefer paying by card; you can of course "blame the victim" and say that it is the fault of those people not choosing the proper back. But it is just avoiding the topic, which is: this is a problem when travelling to Germany, and it I not a problem when travelling elsewhere in Europe.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by tomhoward on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:29AM (#17153470)
> Downvotes in HN are not a dissenting mechanism

PG stated very early on in HN's history that downvoting to signal disagreement is reasonable [1], and that's been generally accepted as a guiding principle in the community ever since (though it's not in the guidelines, so it's a matter of individual preference).

What is in the guidelines is this: "Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." [2].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by harperlee on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:47AM (#17154206)
Fair point, I was mistaken on that.

How can the community learn about the rules if we should not point to or discuss the rules? If it were not for my comment, you would not have pointed that to me :)

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by tomhoward on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:42PM (#17160074)
:)

A good starting point, aside from keeping familiar with the guidelines themselves, is to follow dang's and sctb's comment threads, where issues like this are discussed freqquently. That's how I keep up.

https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=dang

https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=sctb

The reason not to comment on things like voting behaviour is that it takes discussions away from their primary topic and into the territory of being repetitive, uninteresting, and sometimes resentful and hostile. Of course that can never be avoided altogether, but it can and should be minimised :)

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by tluyben2 on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:59PM (#17155616)
Anecdotal again but for person to person I know few people who use cash anymore; Revolut, Wechat, Paypal and others are preferred: with most of them p2p payments are free, instant and easy.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by nbsd4life on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:37AM (#17152190)
guarding the cashbox isn't so bad because they have to do the same for the merchandise.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:50AM (#17153662)
No one ever got killed guarding a pin terminal.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jonknee on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:21AM (#17153956)
No, because you'll get robbed without ever knowing it (see Target or any number of other large POS hacks).
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:35AM (#17154085)
Sure, but the skimmers target the consumers, not the company. Having a lot of cash for places like Home Depot and so on is a real problem. It also enables all kinds of fraud and embezzlement.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jonknee on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:16AM (#17154485)
Target registered $252 million in expenses for the breach. Insurance covered $90 million or so, but either way that would add up to a lot of robberies.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jacquesm on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:19AM (#17154513)
Pretty sloppy processes if that went on for so long and they didn't notice.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by greggarious on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:23AM (#17153970)
I also find I spend less when I carry cash. I've moved to paying my online bills via credit card, but money for eating out, coffees, movies etc gets withdrawn in cash - and I often find I have more left over than if it was a line item in a budget spreadsheet.

(Fun fact: this effect is one of the major reasons casinos have you gamble with chips)

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Matt3o12_ on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:36AM (#17152185)
I agree with your first three points but the last ones are not true.

Case doesn’t have payments fees but it gets mishandled. You give away too much or a customer said I gave you 50, not 20, etc. Furthermore, unless you are a small business, cash needs to be handled and brought to a bank. That costs a lot of money. You have to pay an armed vehicle with a private security company to get to your store and drive it to the bank. You also have to have cash reserves at your store which can be stolen, etc. those are all cash “fees”.

Cash requires power to “create”. You can’t just create it by changing some bytes. They need to be replaced every 5 years or so. And with all the chemicals used to make it secure, it wouldn’t surprise me if it was worst for the environment. Unfortunately I couldn’t find any sources to confirm or deny that, so that is only my speculation.

Your other points are valid and the only advantage card payments have is that they can be analyzed (which is good if you do that but bad if someone else does it to sell you something) and that you can’t lose it (you only have to pay a small fee to get a new card if you lose it).

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by kuschku on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:44AM (#17152239)
A study by Steinbeis, funded by the German Central Bank, discovered that the transportation and production costs of cash are equivalent to around a fee of 0.2%

For comparison, the German EC card system has fees of 0.125%, and most credit cards had fees of around 2-3% (VISA, MasterCard) or even in some situations up to 7% (AMEX, certain goods).

This combined with credit cards banning users and merchants for sellibg goods based on their own discretion (see the trouble the Rossmann group had selling Cuban goods in their German stores) should explain by VISA and MasterCard have to be eradicated.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Matt3o12_ on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:55AM (#17152317)
Thank you, I had somewhat around .2% in mind but I wasn’t too sure. Obviously that depends a lot. For a small business (a one or two person shop), those fees can be essentially 0 because they can just bring it to the bank themselves. I an area with a lot of tourists, the cost can be a lot high due to a high amount of thieves. When I was in Amsterdam there were signs at tourist location to leave cash at the hotel and only use cards because of the high risk of theft.

2-3% fees for credit cards are common in the US if I remember correctly, but the EU has capped the fees to .3% for credit cards and .2% for debit cards. My point was just that cash isn’t free. It’s not that much more then a card.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by CaptainZapp on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:39AM (#17152198)
"Cash requires power to “create”. You can’t just create it by changing some bytes."

Compared to the power utilization of some crypto currencies I'd argue that this is negligible.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by Matt3o12_ on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:45AM (#17152256)
We are not talking about crypto currencies. We are talking about visa and MasterCard which use a centralized network to process those payments. That is as cheap as it can get.

The power requirements for crypto currencies are the main reason I oppose them. They are a great idea but useless because mining and verifying transactions puts such a strain on our environment that I couldn’t justify the advantages for everyday use. And a crypto currency with doesn’t require a lot of power kind of misses the point.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by drdaeman on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:45AM (#17152252)
> Cash is anonymously

Every note has an unique ID. But unlike with an online transaction, tracing a bank note requires a significant effort, sometimes even impossible. An average cash register doesn't log such things.

> Cash does not require power

It most certainly does. First, printing requires power. Any large transaction would likely to require use of a note-counting machine (unless a precise amount is not important). Any small transaction requires human power to process (counting, change) - and it's not free, because it takes power to provide suitable operational conditions. Given that humans are orders of magnitude slower, it could indirectly contribute to a significant resource waste (like queues are being slowes, so mall's parking lot being more occupied, requiring more power to drive around to find a spot, etc etc).

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by sorokod on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:10AM (#17153836)
Every note has an unique ID. But unlike with an online transaction, tracing a bank note requires a significant effort, sometimes even impossible.

"Sometimes impossible" implies some sort of parity with "Sometimes possible" which I think is incorrect.

A challenge: AH26 184646 is the serial on a five pound note in my hand. Where did I get it from?

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by drdaeman on Friday May 25, 2018 @12:23PM (#17155242)
How I'm supposed to know this? I'm not even in Europe or UK. Yet, the fact I can't know it doesn't mean no one can.

Banks may (and most likely do) know which exact ATM had issued this bank note to whom. As well as when it was last encashed and from whom. This does not guarantee anything (the note could've swapped hands a few times), but it's less than perfect anonymity, and I'm sure big data can reveal a thing or two.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by sorokod on Friday May 25, 2018 @02:25PM (#17156536)
If it was a dollar bill would it make easier on you?

As to less than perfect anonymity , yes, it is imperfect compared to an abstract definition but, boy is it sparkling perfect compared to a credit card transaction.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by drdaeman on Friday May 25, 2018 @03:08PM (#17156927)
Of course, no. It is almost irrelevant what the currency is.

You know, the fact I'm not working for Facebook and just can't access your profile info didn't made data there private from, say, Cambrige Analytica. Hopefully, you see the idea - it's the same logic here.

I don't argue it's great and provides lots of anonymity and are essentially untraceable without a great effort. Still, just theoretically speaking - if your bank knows a serial number of every note you withdraw and every note stores encash with them, they have some of data to profile.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by bigpeopleareold on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:31AM (#17152158)
"Cash is anonymous" : This is a feature it seems particularly for Germans, known for their privacy laws and privacy efforts.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by a254613e on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:43AM (#17152237)
No it's not. Because Payback has 30 million customers in Germany. Their whole business model is literally based around mining user data. In markets you'll see people paying with cash and then using the Payback card for the bonus points.

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Payback_(Bonusprogramm)

https://www.payback.net/de/ueber-payback/daten-fakten/

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by teamhappy on Friday May 25, 2018 @07:58AM (#17152704)
Paying cash and using a loyalty card for your day-to-day shopping and then not using it at your local pharmacy, sex-shop or whatever is exactly the same thing as using Chrome for your day-to-day browsing and Tor Browser for looking up that weird thing on your foot, or closing your curtains when you change your clothes.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by anotheryou on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:44AM (#17152245)
I wonder what GDPR does here.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by perlgeek on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:54AM (#17152308)
Even 5 years ago, you had to agree to at least 3 pages of information about how your data is being processed.

I guess it's 10 pages now.

If you as a consumer agree to your data being processed and shared as a business model, GDPR can't really do much for you.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by krageon on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:08AM (#17153831)
If they make it very difficult to say no to extra processing (more than is required for the core business) that comes very close to coercion. Once the storm of US companies not complying (and let's be honest, the big corporations are currently not compliant in the least) and being fined has died down I can't imagine the regulatory bodies will not go after this kind of behaviour.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by s-macke on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:34AM (#17152173)
As long as cash is available, it is difficult to charge penalty interest on your bank account.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by hknd on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:37AM (#17152194)
"Cash does not require power, so it is somehow environment friendly" This is not true. Notes last ~15months in average and use cotton and linen > this is bad for the environment because creating those products requires heavy use of water, pesticides and fertilizers. And coins are _super_ bad for the environment: Extracting metals is not only environmentally taxing, it's also energy-intensive. Think about the mining, milling, and smelting processes.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by quohM0Ho on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:39AM (#17152210)
It's not like you need to mine new metals every time you mint new coins. Old ones can be recycled.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by aequitas on Friday May 25, 2018 @08:22AM (#17152870)
But then that recycled material can not fill other demand for material so eventually you end up mining more nontheless. Also recycling itself it not free, depending on the quality you need you need to put in energy and resources (chemicals).
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by pgtan on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:40AM (#17152215)
Obviously you don't stay everyday in a line for hours waiting for Germans to count their coins back and forth.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by chopin on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:12AM (#17153310)
I stand everyday in a line waiting for Germans finishing their electronic transaction.

Cashless may have its virtues but speed is not one of them.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by some_account on Friday May 25, 2018 @06:39AM (#17152202)
Cash also keeps the power to pay for something in your hands instead of the banks.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by awat on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:43AM (#17154159)
I think this is an underated pro of cash. You can’t manipulate or freeze cash assets on someones person or just out of the bank without real world intervention.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by bluthru on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:45AM (#17153613)
Cash can be created without giving a private bank interest.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by dominotw on Friday May 25, 2018 @09:48AM (#17153642)
as a scatter brain prone to losing things. You can also lose cash or have it stolen from you, with no recourse.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by wil421 on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:18AM (#17153927)
Cash can be stolen. Cash can be misplaced or lost. Cash can be destroyed by fire or other natural forces.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by jonknee on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:20AM (#17153943)
I'd wager the vast majority of money stolen is done so electronically.
Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by wil421 on Friday May 25, 2018 @10:41AM (#17154131)
Yea and it’s been done to me twice. Guess what? The bank and credit cards refunded the charges 100%.

Guess what happened when I lost my wallet? Or when I washed some dollars in my pants? All my money was gone.

Re:In Germany, the use of cash has become a proxy for concer... by JoeAltmaier on Friday May 25, 2018 @11:45AM (#17154796)
ATM fees