News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @06:59PM (#17096906)
Honestly, and none of you are going to like hearing this, and the Signal people aren't going to appreciate me saying it: if you're serious about messaging securely, don't use Signal Desktop; don't use desktop secure messengers at all. Desktop applications are incredibly risky, far more so than iOS mobile apps are.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by al_chemist on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:39PM (#17097213)
> don't use desktop secure messengers at all. Desktop applications are incredibly risky, far more so than iOS mobile apps are.

It's risky to use an open source OS. If you are serious about security, use Android or iOS. Instead of direct ssl connection to XMPP server, it's much safer to send all your data with Google Cloud Messaging. /s

Desktop computers are currently the most open sourced, least opaque, least spyware, non gps tracking, non "microphone always listening for 'ok google'" computer average person has. Why do you suggest that iphone is much more private device?

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by confounded on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:15PM (#17097845)
You have my upvote, but I imagine that tptacek means that iOS is very very well sandboxed, and has an extremely tight and well authenticated download and update system which is extremely difficult for a third party to monkey with.

This is security via centralization and trusting a benevolent capitalist dictator. As long as your personal interests are aligned with interests of the benevolent capitalist's shareholders, you should be fine.

It is my least favorite security model. But, in the case of iOS it seems to be working well (for now). My long-term hope is for a decentralized FOSS model, but for the time being, in the USA, on a multipurpose machine, the benevolent capitalist dictator beats it, especially on sandboxing and package/app authentication.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:20PM (#17097879)
I like open source software as much as most people on HN, and have worked with it for most of my career. But help me understand how a decentralized FOSS model gets ordinary lawyers, reporters, and congressional campaign staffers the level of security that iOS does? What are the mechanisms that assure safety for users?

The closest I can come to seeing something like this work is a Chromebook, and Chromebooks are locked-down and get their security model from a central authority.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by _emacsomancer_ on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:53PM (#17098568)
> What are the mechanisms that assure safety for users?

What are the mechanisms that assure safety for users of iOS? I understand that it's had a good track record so far, but the proprietary closed nature doesn't inherently inspire trust. Surely a decentralised FOSS model done right could be secure for lawyers &c.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by fjsolwmv on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:41AM (#17098750)
As the old saying goes, "if you could have invented a secure open source desktop chat app, you would have developed a secure open source desktop chat app."

In practice, empirict results win over theoretically optimal designs.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by _emacsomancer_ on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:24AM (#17102194)
And as the old saying continues, "...so instead you invented a proprietary one, with hidden code, and told everyone it's secure."
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by confounded on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:59AM (#17098827)
I think that’s unfair; the Ghost.io post from a day or so ago is a good reminder of just how much harder it is to do things when you have to make them work in a decentralized fashion. Decentralization makes everything harder.

Doesn’t mean it’s the wrong thing to do! :)

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by RVuRnvbM2e on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:01PM (#17098075)
You're right and this is just the classic walled garden tradeoff - freedom for convenience. Depending who you are, this might be acceptable, and it's good that we have choices.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by def_true_false on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:21AM (#17099914)
I'm pretty sure Signal doesn't send all your data through GCM.

Edit: https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/217524107

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by JepZ on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:07AM (#17100734)
Its sad enough they use GCM at all. Android Apps can works perfectly well without GCM.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by pfg on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:22AM (#17102178)
Signal merged support for devices without Play Services about a year ago. Is that what you're looking for?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by JepZ on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:12AM (#17107755)
In fact I am not looking for anything, as I am using conversations, but any unnecessary use of (Google) services is something I consider not privacy friendly, even if it is used just as signaling channel.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by wafflebear on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:17PM (#17097858)
You should be far more worried that desktop apps don't require permission before eavesdropping on your conversations using the microphone (including 3rd level sub-dependencies of that NPM module you installed), than that Android or iOS is secretly recording your conversations under the guise of "ok Google" or "Hello Siri".

Regardless of the device form factor, if you don't want the OS to have access to the microphone then you have to physically disable the microphone (but if you are that paranoid you should probably live in the woods away from all electronic devices).

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by jancsika on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:36AM (#17098730)
> Desktop applications are incredibly risky, far more so than iOS mobile apps are.

Ok, I'll play.

I get to choose 10 arbitrary apps from the Apple App store for you to install on an Iphone model of your choice.

You get to choose 10 arbitrary apps for me to install from the default Debian repos (which I believe excludes nonfree). Let's say Sid to make it interesting.

Who is going to be in worse shape after installing those apps?

Edit: typo

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:44AM (#17098763)
You will be in worse shape than I will be. It's possible, in that insane proposition, that your Debian machine will be conceding remote code execution to the whole Internet, while my phone will just have some crappy apps on the home screen.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by RVuRnvbM2e on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:24AM (#17098931)
Doesn't that answer assume some or all of the following?

a) Apple does a better job reviewing apps than Debian maintainers do.

b) iPhone app code is better quality than Debian packages.

c) iOS sandboxing is better than Linux.

Default configuration may mean c) is true. However not if you use wayland, apparmor, seccomp, namespaces etc. What do you think about a) and b)?

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:38AM (#17098977)
The question wasn't whether they could write an elaborate seccomp policy to contain any given Debian package. I just got to pick 10 of them, and install them.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tedunangst on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:49AM (#17099011)
The beep local root suggests the Debian review system has room to improve. It's a pretty deep barrel. You're sure there's no crud at the bottom?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by jancsika on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:53PM (#17105254)
Hi Ted,

Oh wow, is there ever crud at the bottom.

Yesterday I apt-get install'd probably 5 such cruds just to record a small rectangle on my desktop. TBH I did this after apt-get install'ing 3 other animated-gif related cruds to do simple motion animation, then just gave up and used the half-baked Web Animations API in devtools of Firefox because it was easier and better documented than anything else I could find.

That's 8 total cruds written by who-knows, maintained by whoever, audited probably-never by no-one. Also, they pulled in various dependencies I didn't pay the faintest attention to.

How many of those 8 apps would you estimate sent my email contacts to a third party upon instantiation?

How many of those 8 apps would you estimate gathered various pieces of data to fingerprint my device? How many keep gathering data from every sensor source they can poll every time I run and use the app?

How many of those 8 apps would you estimate even touched the network at all?

Now let's suppose I download 8 cruds on iOS just as mindlessly as I did here. Do you think the answers to those questions will be different?

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by pvg on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:07PM (#17105863)
You should try to think of some specific problems that can arise in each environment instead of conducting some sort of weird Socratic dialogue about imaginary apps and a seemingly made-up iOS.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by belorn on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:32AM (#17099970)
How is the beep local root different from jail breaks in the past? Seems both are local privilege exploit, and I recall seeing that iphone has had a long list of those in the past.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by zaarn on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:58AM (#17099792)
beepmargeddon is a local privilege exploit, not a RCE.

I'm not aware of any debian package (I don't use debian that often though so mind that) that A) installs a network service and B) uses unsafe defaults while C) activating the service on boot by default

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by codedokode on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:31AM (#17099963)
Mobile OS have much better isolation between apps than Debian has. In default Debian configuration any app can access all of your data, microphone, webcam, Internet, GPS sensors etc. While the maintainers do a good job reviewing all of the software, having isolation on OS level provides better security.

For example, Chrome has process sandboxing. It might seem unnecessary because the code is written by highly professional developers, but it helps Chrome to be the most difficult to exploit browser. I am sure that if Debian could adopt something similar to Android permission system, it would make it even more secure.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by 08-15 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:27PM (#17097114)
Care to explain? I mean, in principle. I distrust Signal Desktop, whether it's built on Chrome or on Electron, because either of those "platforms" are more complex than my OS (Debian GNU/Linux). But you seem to be making a more general point... what's the reasoning?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:37PM (#17097192)
No matter what Signal does with Desktop, it will remain a standard desktop application, meaning it will in general be as secure as the least secure application sharing that desktop.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by aidenn0 on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:46AM (#17099210)
Is there currently any desktop application delivery/sandboxing mechanism that has any hope of changing this situation in the future?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by lmm on Friday May 18, 2018 @06:14AM (#17100205)
Something like Qubes is the only way we'll ever get decent security on the desktop, I'd say.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by cyphar on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:14AM (#17099550)
Wayland, the xdg-apps sandboxing (now FlatPak), containers in general, etc.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by saagarjha on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:08PM (#17097449)
If all your software comes from the App Store and is properly sandboxed, it's possible for this to approach the security of iOS. Of course, many people will install unsandboxed software, making this extremely difficult to actually achieve, but it's at least possible.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by 08-15 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:17PM (#17097515)
What's a desktop and what does it mean to share it?

My applications share an X11 display, and if I'm not mistaken, they are pretty well isolated from each other. (Are you referring to MicroSoft Windows[TM] by any chance? Yeah, that's different.)

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by e12e on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:44PM (#17097674)
> My applications share an X11 display, and if I'm not mistaken, they are pretty well isolated from each other.

You are probably mistaken.

https://github.com/esonn/x11log

http://blog.martin-graesslin.com/blog/2015/01/why-screen-loc...

You might want to look at qubesos :

https://www.qubes-os.org/doc/gui/

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by bigiain on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:19PM (#17098162)
I dunno if it's still true, but it used to be that every process running in your X11 window had access to every keystroke from every other application. Like, say, every password you type into a terminal window or browser... If it _is_ still true (and I've noticed a bit of recent discussion asking why Ubuntu 18LTS is switching back from Wayland to X11 which hints to me that it might be), then your apps are _very_ much not "pretty well isolated"...
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by dasyatidprime on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:23PM (#17097557)
What are you using for X security context isolation? I've been wanting a good solution for that one for a while now, and the end of my list is still “write my own isolating proxy” since I never found a good one.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by e12e on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:45PM (#17097678)
See: https://www.qubes-os.org/doc/gui/

(they have essentially written 2500 lines of c that acts as a proxy of sorts)

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by 08-15 on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:50PM (#17097695)
Nothing... but can X11 applications actually steal data from each other? I wouldn't know how to do that, but I know precious little about the X11 protocol. (Screen shots are an awkward option, I guess.)

If I was worried enough (I'm not), I could use multiple logins. Two different X servers under different users would be completely isolated.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by icebraining on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:52AM (#17099226)
Even using two X servers under two logins, the fact is that desktop apps by default have much more freedom and therefore much more surface to attack. Even the kernel syscalls alone are not safe; exploits that elevate processes to root are not rare. You'd need to lock them down much more than just using different users.

By the way, they may have an history, but nowadays I wouldn't bet on the security of the average distro vs Windows, and I say this as a dyed-in-the-wool Debian user. For example, their Desktop environment does have protections against cross-application attacks, unlike X.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by phyzome on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:39PM (#17103352)
Yeah, I definitely don't like hearing that, because phones can fuck right off. That's not my computer, that's someone else's computer that they're letting me use.

I'm not going to get a smartphone just to use Signal. I'll use my spare laptop instead, that I already have, and just run Signal on it. It's not going to get compromised by Boogeymen From The Scary Browser Tab because I won't be running a browser on there.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:36PM (#17103835)
I think that is a fine plan for the "people who have spare laptops they use to run single programs" people.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by phyzome on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @12:46AM (#17123784)
Well, a spare computer is cheaper than a spare phone. You can get those suckers free on the curb sometimes.

Anyway, I don't think we should give up on user-controlled platforms so readily, even if there's a slight short-term benefit to privacy or security.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by belorn on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:33AM (#17101278)
This is easily proven false by simply looking at professionals which either by necessity or regulation require a strict secure environment.

How common is it that the military use iphone apps for classified information or to interface with military equipment. Do operators in powerplants or other sensitive infrastructure use iphone apps as interface to their systems. When security is a primary objective then having it hooked up with a third-party that continuously collects information that you have no control over sounds as a very bad security recommendation, especially when it has a independent GPS, GSM, and network capability which bypass normal network security tools.

If signal crashes and a crash report is generated, who get access to it on a iphone? Who might get a potential memory dump with plaintext? If that party is apple I would strongly recommend that one is first okey with the idea that apple has access to the plaintext before using such app.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @06:12PM (#17105340)
If your standard for operational security is the military, I have very bad news for you. Or good news, if your opsec goal is "be way better than the US Military" (that news is: you are already way better than the US Military).

The military obtains what security it has by attempting complete segregation and isolation; because it's the USG, the world's largest IT department, there are "public" and "private" networks, both clones of each other, both running the same insecure software. Both public and "secure" networks have been owned up comprehensively by malware in the past.

To get a sense of how bad the situation is, go look at the Common Criterial EAL vendor list, note which vendors have obtained EAL4 certification, and then compare to the security track records of those versions. That'll give you the spirit of the situation without requiring to you actually endure an EAL validation, which is something I have had the misfortune of participating in.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by JasonFruit on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:28PM (#17097129)
This may or may not be true, but in a lot of cases where you need encryption, you also need not to have a GPS tracker on you while you're using it. You have (at least slightly) more chance of being anonymous with a dedicated laptop computer than you have with any smartphone.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by saagarjha on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:05PM (#17097426)
Ignoring the recent LocationSmart revelations, if you disable location access you should basically have the same level of geospatial anonymity.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by confounded on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:06PM (#17097793)
> Ignoring the recent LocationSmart revelations

You can't, though; that's kind of the point.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by e12e on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:28PM (#17097588)
There's a "herd immunity" component - if you're in a group of 10 000 people with GPS tracking on - your position might be possible to guess quite precisely based on meta data like IP, network latency etc - that can be compared across a large population.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by chatmasta on Friday May 18, 2018 @02:19PM (#17103680)
All somebody needs to find your location is a list of SSIDs and MAC addresses within range of you.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by detaro on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:02PM (#17096929)
And we're back at "really good security is to inconvenient to use" :/
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:05PM (#17096952)
This is a rare case where things are inconvenient for nerds to use, but more convenient for ordinary people, who tend to be more comfortable doing stuff on mobile platforms than nerds are.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by detaro on Friday May 18, 2018 @07:14AM (#17100457)
Is that also true for professional use? For private use/relatively few threads I'd agree with that, the insistence on IM on desktop is a niche, but I'd think most people using chat a lot professionally (e.g. Slack) do not use it mobile-only. And if you'd want them to shift communication away from e-mail, it gets even more important.

(as p49k alluded to, iPads help, but few professional users have them as the primary device)

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by p49k on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:14PM (#17097007)
To be fair, Apple has done a great job at making a device that does both without much compromise.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by 4ad on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:11PM (#17096987)
Desktop applications are incredibly risky, yes; as for iOS mobile apps we can't even know, as these devices don't allow auditing what software is running on them.

PGP has many problems and I hope a better replacement will come along, but the first step of secure messaging can't be using devices with closed, unauditable software...

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by kasey_junk on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:30PM (#17098206)
A reason you are getting downvotes is that it’s not true that closed source software is unauditable.

This is a common but untrue belief. It’s a fundamental axciom of software security that you can’t trust source, so you must diagnose the binary.

Source may be helpful, but in the grand scheme of things lots of other properties are more important.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by mbid on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:20AM (#17099329)
> It’s a fundamental axciom of software security that you can’t trust source, so you must diagnose the binary.

What if you trust the build tool chain and can reproduce the binary from source?

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by kasey_junk on Friday May 18, 2018 @06:34AM (#17100289)
That’s functionally harder in most cases than just inspecting the binary.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by kome on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:28PM (#17097128)
They down-vote you, but you are 100% right. Using a mobile phone is intrinsically more insecure because they can track you much more easily, and you have much less control over the OS.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by KKKKkkkk1 on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:12AM (#17098889)
I vaguely remember someone on HN (or maybe some other forum) making loud endorsements of Signal over any other encrypted chat app. Even a statement like "9 out of 10 cryptographers would recommend Signal". What's the difference between Signal Desktop and Signal?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:15AM (#17098898)
Signal Desktop is one of several clients for Signal Protocol; the most common client is --- I believe, but am not sure, but have good reason to believe --- either the Android or iOS mobile client, neither of which is a Javascript application.

We've recommended the mobile versions of Signal for a long time (see, for instance, the Tech Solidarity security resources, which haven't changed in a year), and everyone still recommends Signal Protocol. I think we all should have been noisier about the security limitations of the desktop app environment. And about Electron.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by wepple on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:06PM (#17096958)
I was always uncomfortable about signal on non-iOS devices. I feel the same about password managers too, it’s a giant PITA but I specifically do not want all my passwords in one place if that places is a wild desktop.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by saagarjha on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:04PM (#17097410)
A properly sandboxed desktop application is no more dangerous than an iOS app. Of course, Chrome doesn't work in that sandbox, and they're using Electron, so this doesn't quite work.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by esaym on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:34PM (#17097624)
>Desktop applications are incredibly risky

Oh so just use your phone that has a 100 background crapware apps running and a hidden baseband OS running under the parent OS/UI?

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by pvg on Thursday May 17, 2018 @08:45PM (#17097675)
Remember that time another app (and the baseband!) compromised Signal on iOS?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by bigiain on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:33PM (#17098225)
FWIW, the sort of people with access/leverage to be able to compromise a device through the baseband probably don't leave behind traces revealing it happened. They just drop hints to the local cops that they ought to find a reason to pull you over for a traffic stop and coincidentally smell pot smoke to give them probably cause to search your car...

(waves at the NSA guys...)

I _hope_ that sort of capability is still a year or two away from guys with an Ettus USPR and a bunch of open source software and hacking tools glued together with Python... But keep your eyes on DefCon and CCC to be sure...

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:41PM (#17098266)
They probably don't leave traces because compromising a modern Apple device through the baseband would be quite a trick, given that it's an independent peripheral connected to the AP over on-chip USB.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by bigiain on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:09AM (#17098864)
That's good to know (and for almost anybody else I'd add "citation needed"...)

Didn't the iPhone baseband processor at some time in the past have dma? I vaguely recall a perhaps Usenix paper that seemed to claim any phone that had a software unlock where you could disable the carrier locking, was almost certainly using dma connections between the baseband and AP. Any hints or links or search terms which would show me how modern an iPhone needs to be to be "safe" from that?

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:19AM (#17098915)
I don't know what the first iPhone to have an HSIC baseband was, but it has been awhile. I assume every iPhone anyone is really using today fits the description I gave. The iPhone 4 does. This is a really basic security design concern for mobile devices; you can assume that neither Apple nor Google (for their own Google-branded phones) ships products where a corrupted baseband can simply DMA its way into the AP. It is a little weird to me that people on message boards assume they've outguessed the hardware security teams at both Apple and Google on one of the most obvious attack vectors for their phone designs; both companies spend huge amounts of money on this stuff.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by lawnchair_larry on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:56AM (#17099036)
"It is a little weird to me that people on message boards assume they've outguessed the hardware security teams at both Apple and Google on one of the most obvious attack vectors for their phone designs; both companies spend huge amounts of money on this stuff."

For what it's worth, that isn't the assumption people are making. The easy assumption to make is that the security teams were unable to convince product owners at these companies that the extra expense of solving this was worth their investment. Especially because practical baseband attacks still haven't hit them as an issue, and it's very rare for product owners to take on major changes or invest in security for "theoretical" threats.

Just look at all of the services still allowing SMS for 2FA - it's not because the security team doesn't know that is an insane thing to be doing in 2018.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:57PM (#17102992)
No, it's because end-users don't adopt 2FA via TOTP and, to a first approximation, nobody uses U2F. It's not a corner security teams are cutting. Microsoft's security team makes the same decisions.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by lawnchair_larry on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:59PM (#17104521)
Microsoft doesn’t have “a” security team. They have dozens of security-ish teams. And I can assure you that none of them made that decision. The product teams did. And security people there disagree with it. You likely think security teams at BigCorp have more teeth than they do. With a few exceptions, Microsoft is known for hiring well qualified security people and then giving them no authority to do much until something is already on fire.

Search for a tweet by Kostya expressing surprise and delight at the fact that they actually fixed an internal find a couple years ago. Or grab a beer with the nearest ex-microsoft security person and have them tell you stories about servicing internally discovered vulns.

You’re right that the security team aren’t cutting corners. Because that isn’t how things work.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by pvg on Friday May 18, 2018 @08:03AM (#17100712)
it's not because the security team doesn't know

It's also not because they don't think it's 'worth the investment' or due to extra expense.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by pvg on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:46PM (#17098286)
No, it's cheaper for them to just replace the person you're talking to with a Cylon.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by bigiain on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:11AM (#17098876)
Some may argue this has already happened - to at least half their social circle. (Not me though, I consider myself "recreationally paranoid" rather than "raving looney paranoid" - other people's opinions on that probably differ...)
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tedunangst on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:02PM (#17097763)
No?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:03PM (#17097773)
I think he forgot a /s. (Seriously).
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by pvg on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:06PM (#17097798)
You people!
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tedunangst on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:27PM (#17097928)
Dang it.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by bigiain on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:28PM (#17098192)
Signal runs just fine on an iPod Touch (after a little fussing around getting it set up with a phone number...)

If you're paranoid enough, it's easy enough to avoid installing things that're likely to be crapware on your secure comms device.

Apart from Signal, the only other non iOS supplied apps I have installed on mu iPod are a bitcoin wallet and Onion Browser - both of which I angst a little about, since they're both in the first category of app I'd attempt to subvert if I were a nation state actor, or a blackhat looking to steal bitcoin from people least likely to report it to authorities...

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by lmm on Friday May 18, 2018 @06:17AM (#17100215)
If you're willing to adopt "run a dedicated device for crypto" approach, something like Tails running on a USB-key-like device gives you the same kind of security position and without having to trust Apple.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by bigiain on Saturday May 19, 2018 @02:10AM (#17106870)
Yeah, I do that too (and an offline wallet on a RasPi which has never been internet connected) - but for secure messaging and for some bitcoin transactions, I want that device in my pocket. I treat the iPod cryptocurrency wallet like, well, a wallet - containing amounts I feel comfortable carrying around (like the couple of hundred in cash I might have in my wallet at any time). I "trust" Apple enough to store that. I wouldn't treat the iPod as a bank, storing significant or lifechanging amounts of value.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by ianopolous on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:39PM (#17098508)
What about qubesOS?
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by wolf550e on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:38AM (#17108051)
Not mainstream, and there must be a reason why. I guess ease of use, though I don't know.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by ianopolous on Monday May 21, 2018 @05:18AM (#17117134)
Its popularity is irrelevant to how secure it is.