a) Apple does a better job reviewing apps than Debian maintainers do.
b) iPhone app code is better quality than Debian packages.
c) iOS sandboxing is better than Linux.
Default configuration may mean c) is true. However not if you use wayland, apparmor, seccomp, namespaces etc. What do you think about a) and b)?
Oh wow, is there ever crud at the bottom.
Yesterday I apt-get install'd probably 5 such cruds just to record a small rectangle on my desktop. TBH I did this after apt-get install'ing 3 other animated-gif related cruds to do simple motion animation, then just gave up and used the half-baked Web Animations API in devtools of Firefox because it was easier and better documented than anything else I could find.
That's 8 total cruds written by who-knows, maintained by whoever, audited probably-never by no-one. Also, they pulled in various dependencies I didn't pay the faintest attention to.
How many of those 8 apps would you estimate sent my email contacts to a third party upon instantiation?
How many of those 8 apps would you estimate gathered various pieces of data to fingerprint my device? How many keep gathering data from every sensor source they can poll every time I run and use the app?
How many of those 8 apps would you estimate even touched the network at all?
Now let's suppose I download 8 cruds on iOS just as mindlessly as I did here. Do you think the answers to those questions will be different?
I'm not aware of any debian package (I don't use debian that often though so mind that) that A) installs a network service and B) uses unsafe defaults while C) activating the service on boot by default
For example, Chrome has process sandboxing. It might seem unnecessary because the code is written by highly professional developers, but it helps Chrome to be the most difficult to exploit browser. I am sure that if Debian could adopt something similar to Android permission system, it would make it even more secure.
Ok, I'll play.
I get to choose 10 arbitrary apps from the Apple App store for you to install on an Iphone model of your choice.
You get to choose 10 arbitrary apps for me to install from the default Debian repos (which I believe excludes nonfree). Let's say Sid to make it interesting.
Who is going to be in worse shape after installing those apps?
Edit: typo