News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by confounded on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:15PM (#17097845)
You have my upvote, but I imagine that tptacek means that iOS is very very well sandboxed, and has an extremely tight and well authenticated download and update system which is extremely difficult for a third party to monkey with.

This is security via centralization and trusting a benevolent capitalist dictator. As long as your personal interests are aligned with interests of the benevolent capitalist's shareholders, you should be fine.

It is my least favorite security model. But, in the case of iOS it seems to be working well (for now). My long-term hope is for a decentralized FOSS model, but for the time being, in the USA, on a multipurpose machine, the benevolent capitalist dictator beats it, especially on sandboxing and package/app authentication.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by tptacek on Thursday May 17, 2018 @09:20PM (#17097879)
I like open source software as much as most people on HN, and have worked with it for most of my career. But help me understand how a decentralized FOSS model gets ordinary lawyers, reporters, and congressional campaign staffers the level of security that iOS does? What are the mechanisms that assure safety for users?

The closest I can come to seeing something like this work is a Chromebook, and Chromebooks are locked-down and get their security model from a central authority.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by _emacsomancer_ on Thursday May 17, 2018 @11:53PM (#17098568)
> What are the mechanisms that assure safety for users?

What are the mechanisms that assure safety for users of iOS? I understand that it's had a good track record so far, but the proprietary closed nature doesn't inherently inspire trust. Surely a decentralised FOSS model done right could be secure for lawyers &c.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by fjsolwmv on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:41AM (#17098750)
As the old saying goes, "if you could have invented a secure open source desktop chat app, you would have developed a secure open source desktop chat app."

In practice, empirict results win over theoretically optimal designs.

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by _emacsomancer_ on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:24AM (#17102194)
And as the old saying continues, "...so instead you invented a proprietary one, with hidden code, and told everyone it's secure."
Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by confounded on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:59AM (#17098827)
I think that’s unfair; the Ghost.io post from a day or so ago is a good reminder of just how much harder it is to do things when you have to make them work in a decentralized fashion. Decentralization makes everything harder.

Doesn’t mean it’s the wrong thing to do! :)

Re:Another flaw in Signal desktop app leaks chats in plaintext by RVuRnvbM2e on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:01PM (#17098075)
You're right and this is just the classic walled garden tradeoff - freedom for convenience. Depending who you are, this might be acceptable, and it's good that we have choices.