News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by braythwayt on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:33PM (#17040426)
Amusing, but the issues with Enterprise Software are far more complex than that. Having spent my career working with Enterprises of one sort or another, here are a few off the top of my head:

1. You are not the customer.

With ad-driven products, we have painfully realized that if we aren't paying, we aren't the customer, and when something seems awful to us, the explanation often lies in the fact that the thing that is awful to us benefits the real customer, or perhaps that the thing that benefits us is of little value to the real customer compared to things that do not benefit us.

The same is true of Enterprise Software. Most users are not the software's customer, and therefore their needs are subordinate to the needs of the individuals and departments who are actually paying for it.

2. Pricing-Driven Development

As Spolsky famously pointed out, Enterprises forcibly impose an insane cost-of-sales on software vendors. When you have to employ expensive salespeople, prepare proposals, apocryphally play golf with clients, or whatever, vendors must build those costs into the cost of the product.

Then they must justify those costs with features that sound like they produce big values. Typically these are not going to be things that make users' lives easier, they are going to be things that users may never see, like analytics and back-office integrations.

Like the "you are not the customer" problem above, this tends to create the illusion that the software sucks and that the vendor isn't improving it. In actual fact, the vendor is locked into a Red Queen's Race with competing vendors, and is improving the software constantly. It's just that users never benefit from the improvements, because UX improvements are not thought to "move the needle."

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by maxsilver on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:12PM (#17040812)
> Then they must justify those costs with features that sound like they produce big values. Typically these are not going to be things that make users' lives easier, they are going to be things that users may never see, like analytics and back-office integrations.

Yes, and depending on the enterprise, these "big features only there to justify high costs" may not actually be needed or useful or relevant. It might be 'OK' to have a bunch of interns slap something together, if it only needs to be "real" enough to look pretty and look functional in a few demos or in a few specific happy-day cases.

Analytics and Reporting is probably the most common example I've seen of this -- it's not a bad feature on it's own, but companies will sometimes pay top dollar for it, even in places it makes no sense and/or will never get used. If that gets delivered in a broken/unusable state, it's "ok" because the customer will never actually click that button anyway.

----

If "New Skype" is "enterprise communication support" in a corporate feature list (and not a real product filling a real need, as it used to be) then I can see how a broken or unusable Skype could still be a 'success' for Microsoft.

Note: I don't agree with any or support any of this. But I've seen this play out in real life enough to know it happens.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by CWuestefeld on Thursday May 10, 2018 @05:00PM (#17042928)
This cuts both ways. We frequently get requirements in an RFP that we've got to put resources into supporting, but when everything gets put into place, the customer never uses the feature that they demanded. They wasted the cost of our investment into their demands.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by JohnJamesRambo on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:07PM (#17040755)
>their needs are subordinate to the needs of the individuals and departments who are actually paying for it.

Are you implying people are paying for dropped calls and poor performance as a feature?

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by magduf on Thursday May 10, 2018 @02:00PM (#17041382)
The people experiencing dropped calls aren't the people who made the purchasing decision. The people experiencing poor performance don't have a say in the matter and are required to use the tool, and the people who made the purchasing decision are getting what they want out of the deal.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by badpun on Thursday May 10, 2018 @02:49PM (#17041841)
In case of my company (a 40k employees multinational), everybody gets to suffer from Skype for Business' ridiculousness, I'm guessing even the people who bought it (heck, I'm guessing even the CEO is cursing it on a regular basis). Still, we use it.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by xxs on Thursday May 10, 2018 @04:08PM (#17042510)
Skype for business is not even 'skype'. Actually, it's "lync" branded as skype. Overall it's an awful product with hilarious built-in html render that ends in CPU saturation during group chat and a bit of html content. It takes like a minute to close itself if there are 20-30 chats.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by usr1106 on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:25AM (#17045323)
Right. As a Linux user I skipped most of Skype for Business experience. It cannot even do passive screen sharing (i. e. display what others share). A web client that cannot show all contents... And that for a paid service, every free aka customer is the product service works in Linux browsers.

The old normal (not for business) Skype Linux client could even do active screen sharing (share your own screen) on Linux. Although it was limited to 1:1 calls IIRC. Haven't checked whether they have managed to break/remove that in the new Linux client...

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by sixothree on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:03AM (#17044892)
Even the executable is still named lync
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by ConceptJunkie on Thursday May 10, 2018 @04:17PM (#17042572)
And this is proof that Microsoft is still a monopoly, because they can still force people to use software they don't want. Microsoft's biggest accomplishment in technology in the last 20 years is to teach everyone that software is horrible and there's nothing that can be done about it.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by jodrellblank on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:11PM (#17043969)
Windows, macOS and iOS quality usability and discoverability have dropped year on year, Linux usability has stayed abhorrent, every major website I use that has done a big redesign has made it worse for me with more focus on whitespace, style, hiding UI elements, and adverts than substance and usability. Google search experience has gone seriously downhill, Amazon's marketplace and search has increasing quality problems, Facebook's redesigns are much hated, Reddit's redesign has hidden UI features and turned it into a bloated whitespace-obsessed ad-heavy image-centric style. Chrome, Firefox, the hiding of useful UI elements, the increasing resource demands.

Software is horrible.

Software that looked like Excel 2000 with visible accelerators was clean, easy to use, discoverable, fast, not very aesthetically pleasing but at least consistent. macOS of 5+ years ago was more human-friendly.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by magduf on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:08PM (#17048456)
>Linux usability has stayed abhorrent

Linux usability is only abhorrent if you use Gnome (3). It's fine with KDE, Xfce, and others. I started using Xfce recently at work and it's great: usability is just what I expect (i.e. it doesn't do any weird UI experiments like Gnome3, Windows, etc.), it's stable and reliable, and discoverable since it was designed back when they thought discoverability was a good thing. KDE5 is pretty good too.

Stop using UIs that have been taken over by people trying to "revolutionize" UIs and you won't have the problems you're seeing. Linux has plenty of such UIs, but for some odd reason they're not the default setting of the mainstream distros.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by jodrellblank on Saturday May 12, 2018 @06:36PM (#17056389)
I'm not even talking of GUIs, I'm talking of exchanges like this:

root@server:~# ip route add 192.168.1.0/30 10.0.0.1

Error: either "to" is duplicate, or "10.0.0.1" is a garbage.

The "help" is literally a dump of the grammar, which doesn't contain enough detail to add a route (the syntax of PREFIX is not described). The error message is bafflingly useless. Of all the options available relating to routing, the two I use most are "route a network via a gateway IP" and "remove a route" and I'm going to guess that those are the two most common operations for most people not doing any advanced networking.

Note that this is the replacement to the old "route" command, which had a single line of help: "inet_route [-vF] add {-host|-net} Target[/prefix] [gw Gw]" which is way way more helpful for this use case!

Of course it's possible to go into `man ip` and then find routing help is elsewere and go into `man ip-route` and at the bottom of a 400 line document there is /a single example/ of adding a default route which doesn't include a subnet definition, and then to decode that the error message about duplicate/garbage means "you didn't add the word "via"" and then to backtrack into the grammar dump and trace where that was mentioned.

And of course this is but one tool.

And of course it's better for many use cases that it be stable and performant than that it be frilly.

But all over, it feels like this. Usability, quality error messages, making the common things easy and discoverable, are all afterthoughts with priorities somewhere between "caveat user" and "it's free so shut up" and "we refuse to change it because ~POSIX~" and "usability is for wimps, Linux is for clever people (where clever means 'able to edit a text file and willing to do everything the hard way')" and "we benefit from people buying RedHat Certifications so why should we make it any easier than we have to?".

I'm not saying it's incapable or unstable or useless, but I am saying usability for common tools and overall experience is really, really, really, really poor. With possible exception "install Ubuntu/Mint/flavour-of-day and run FireFox to get to your Googles".

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by pasabagi on Saturday May 12, 2018 @12:42PM (#17054832)
I think it's because if you start using Linux, you want to feel like you're using something new and high-tech. So the super-chrome UIs tend to win out.

I like my setup (i3wm), but it would be a horrible default. You have to read a manual to make it usable. Gnome is a kind of nice default - since everything looks modern and works out of the box.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by magduf on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:40AM (#17046847)
They're not a monopoly, and they're not forcing anyone to use software they don't want. There's a bunch of different options if you don't like Skype. I've used GoToMeeting in the recent past, and it worked fine. The problem is that people are just too stupid to look for alternatives to Microsoft products, and would rather complain than do something about it.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by Pica_soO on Saturday May 12, 2018 @09:49AM (#17054057)
Oh, my, the customers got stupider. They could use the old skye just fine, but then the IQ sank - and its been rock bottom ever since.

Completely impplaussible that maybe those stupid people do not use the alternatives, because they suck even more? As in, they are non standardized, not easy to setup et etc.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by magduf on Monday May 14, 2018 @09:28AM (#17065280)
>They could use the old skye just fine

The old Skype was great. But it's gone now; that's how the world works: things change, and not always for the better. You have to adapt.

>Completely impplaussible that maybe those stupid people do not use the alternatives, because they suck even more?

Given all the complaints I've seen about new-Skype? No. It's because people are just too stupid to look for alternatives when the thing they've been using turns to crap.

>As in, they are non standardized, not easy to setup et etc.

The newer alternatives are web-based and easy (or, at least, no more difficult than new-Skype). And WTF does "standardized" mean? There's no standardization for video chat programs; that makes as much sense as asking about standardization for social media websites like Facebook.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by braythwayt on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:30PM (#17041055)
I'm implying that sometimes, "Improve ability to handle scale as measured by X improvement in dropped calls and Y improvement in user-reported call quality" is always going to be in the backlog, but it is probably being starved by other initiatives like "Support integration with BigClient Internal System Z."

That's a scenario where the needs of the people making and receiving calls are subordinate to the needs of the people paying for Skype.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by braythwayt on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:50PM (#17041266)
But reading what I wrote, I see why you asked. Yes, sometimes there is a thing that is bad for the user and simultaneously perceived to be good for the person paying, like a lot of the ceremony you have to do to get anything to happen in JIRA.

But sometimes it is a question of different priorities, and I did not mention that above. Good catch.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by smsm42 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:13PM (#17060795)
That sounds plausible but does not explain why UI became so progressively horrible lately. I get that they may be developing corporate features I can't see, but why did they spend time on developing series of new UIs, each of them slower and crappier than the previous one?
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by pvg on Thursday May 10, 2018 @06:19PM (#17043436)
How does one play golf apocryphally?
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by wdmeldon on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:31PM (#17044359)
Playing without the intention of treating it as a sport, but as an excuse to drink outdoors.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by pvg on Thursday May 10, 2018 @10:44PM (#17044633)
Somehow... that doesn't sound quite right.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by risotto_groupon on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:19AM (#17047915)
I think they meant "apothecarily". As in, I play golf to self medicate.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by braythwayt on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:15PM (#17048521)
Hilarious, I want to snarf that!

But actually, I meant that it is apocryphal that salespeople have to play golf to close Enterprise Sales. It's more of a stand-in catch-all term for semi-formal socializing with the client.

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by pvg on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:07PM (#17048997)
Right but it's not really apocryphal because apocryphal doesn't connote or denote stereotypical, proverbial, cliche, conventional wisdom, caricature, etc. Salespeople playing golf with customers to close enterprise sales is not some uncertain thing that has reached us through dubious sources.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by smsm42 on Sunday May 13, 2018 @04:18PM (#17060830)
It isn't? I certainly doubt whether it's true (not being in enterprise sales myself and not being important enough to end up on the other side of those sales) enough to make a cliche (I don't doubt somewhere somebody invited a client to golf to make a sale - but how common is it?) and haven't seen any reliable sources on the prevalence of it.
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by pvg on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:07PM (#17061054)
It's a big fat cliche. For instance, here's how Tony Rodoni (Executive Vice President for the Commercial Business Unit at Salesforce.com) starts a blog post of some sort:

"When I started in sales, my boss told me, "Your job is to get to know your customer and build a relationship. Nothing is more important than building a relationship.” The second most important thing was to make sure that the customer always won when we played golf."

https://www.forbes.com/sites/salesforce/2017/01/03/the-death...

Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by dzonga on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:27PM (#17044046)
I have been trying to find that Spolsky article, please link it up if you can
Re:Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand by braythwayt on Friday May 11, 2018 @05:37AM (#17045969)
"Ask Joel," February, 2004, fourth item:

https://discuss.fogcreek.com/askjoel/default.asp?cmd=show&ix...

"With software sold in corporations, as soon as your price gets up in the $3000 level, the amount of approval it needs is so absurd that you are not going to sell products without a salesperson making a few visits. Hiring the salesperson, sending them out to make presentations, hotels, airfare -- now it costs $50,000 to get the sale done just in sales closing costs. That's why you see a lot of software products at $100,000 and a lot under $3000, but anywhere in-between and it's impossible to make sales. (It's sort of funny -- these big corporations create so much bureaucracy around purchasing in order to protect themselves against losing money, but they just force the vendors to spend a fortune on salesforces, which results in vastly higher prices for the big corporations)."