News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by lzw on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @11:18AM (#1690850)
This article highlights why I'm a fan of apple more than google. Apple is going to exert the power to control the carriers. Apple is about the only company that can, or will, exert this kind of power.

I hope google changes, and starts getting control over os installation.... But I can't see that happening.

In this case, the openness of android works against google.

As an app developer, I'm keen to put products out for android, but the combination of fragmentation and very slow adoption of latest releases by the android mass market are two of the biggest hurdles.

Apples market has little fragmentation and high hardware consistency.

But I digress. Without google imposing some licensing terms, android users are always going to have a poor os upgrade experience, it seems.

And I thin android is at risk of carriers introducing bloatware that you cannot uninstall.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by martythemaniak on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:53PM (#1691245)
Let's not kid ourselves - all the power Apple wrestled away from AT&T it kept for itself - the consumer didn't see much of a change, or saw a regression.

Prior to the iPhone, loading your own apps and changing settings on your smartphone was standard practice. What Apple did was bring the featurephone practice (jumping through somebody's beaurocracy to get to consumers) to the smartphone market. Suddenly, being in control of your own smartphone is an "openness feature".

Now, to loyal Apple fans, who love and trust Apple, this transfer of power/control from AT&T to Apple is the same as them (the Apple consumer) seeing benefits. To other people, it just means dealing with someone else, without any change in the fact that you still have to go through somebody.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by roc on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:38PM (#1691444)
There's a huge difference between a phone maker having control and a network having control.

Consider: When Verizon doesn't allow mp3 ringtones ... well, you just don't get phones with mp3 ringtones on their network [1].

When Apple doesn't allow mp3 ringtones, Verizon is compelled to open the door to Android phones that happily allow mp3 ringtones so that they can compete.

The only reason Verizon and AT&T have rolled back any of their customary phone-crippling practices is because other phones must compete with the iPhone.

Consumers have 'won' to an astounding degree since the iPhone released. I don't know anyone who's purchased a phone in the last three years, that didn't wind up with a device head and shoulders more capable and well designed than what they had before.

Frankly, I can't think of anything remotely close to a 'regression' that actual consumers would have been forced to swallow post-iPhone.

[1] Yes, I completely discount the existence of unlocked unsubsidized phones on US networks prior to the iPhone. 1. they were horrible, 2. there was no break on service fee for having an unsubsidized phone, if not an outright charge for bringing your own unlocked phone, making the effective price wildly prohibitive.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by doron on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:23PM (#1691645)
I just dont get this line of reasoning, i had a mediocre Windows phone on Verizon, and i could do anything on it including mp3 ringtones. there was no restriction on any element, that was before the iPhone was around.

I dont really trust either the operator or the phone manufacturer to restrict my phone experience, why should the choice for the consumer be a lesser of two evils when the obvious solution is right there, that is, no lock to either (if the consumer so chooses), i dont see the difference between restrictions imposed on sideloading regardless of the source

Frankly i consider not being able to change the default OS keyboard (say use swype instead) or default music player, or be forced to use Itunes a regression. Not to mention i have to connect it to a computer (an Authorized one at that to update the iphone, again forced to use that awful piece of software forced on me by the manufacturer)

If we suppose that the competition with the Iphone creates a better ground for consumer freedom, then it would not suffer from new players, on the contrary, it might force the iphone to be more open as well.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by roc on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:12PM (#1691862)
> "Frankly i consider not being able to change the default OS keyboard (say use swype instead) or default music player, or be forced to use Itunes a regression."

But you have none of those limitations on an Android phone. So how has the market regressed? Many, many more people are enjoying device freedom well beyond what your windows CE phone enjoyed and you're calling that regression just because one vendor doesn't?

Has the market regressed if Windows Phone 7 ships without replaceable keyboards? Was it regression when the Pre shipped without that?

Is it a regression of Android if a single Android handset ships with unremoveable crapware?

Or is the state of the market still improving, because even gimped android devices are head-and-shoulders better than consumer phones three years ago, non-gimped Android device choices abound and a new MS Phone and Pre are around the corner?

I guess you could argue that it wasn't the iPhone that forced Verizon (and AT&T) to offer these newer, better handsets without locking them down as they often would with even Windows CE and Blackberry phones (consider the state of data plans in the pre-iphone world).

But to that I would simply direct you to the lag between the G1 and the Droid, the lack of a Nexus One on Verizon, the rate of handset innovation in the last three years compared to the previous 7 and to the timing of the 'open network' pledge vs the iPhone announcement.

Without the iPhone upending the Apple cart, would you get a Pre? Would Microsoft be pushing Windows Phone to consumers? Would the Blackberry have a decent browser? Would Verizon be advertising consumer phones that aren't locked to their app market, ringtone market, etc? I just don't see it.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by doron on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:05PM (#1692074)
I Should be clear, i am now using Android and I am very happy with it. the ability to sideload gave me Swype beta which is not afforded through the android market.

If the service provider chooses to block sideloading on android, then they diminish the quality of the device. if the device has disabled sideloading by design by Apple, then it is also diminished in quality, to claim that restrictions made by one are preferable to the other just doesn't make any sense to me.

Apple surely had a great effect on the quality of manufactured devices as well as the range of offering, but i doubt that they had much of an effect on the openness of said devices.

If i understand the article, then the gist of it is that the quality of Android is stymied by service providers, that is true, but it is also true that you can compare apples to apples here, that is, which network provides me the best android experience, and that is a competitive advantage, there is no such option for the Iphone.

Put simply, let the service provider who offers the best most open and reliable experience win. Somehow there is this idea gaining audience, that the Android's "openess" is actually detrimental to it advancement, i just dont see how that can be true on the long run.

Right now, because we are stuck with oligopoly of cellular providers, there is little choice, this will not change until more service providers enter this field.

The statement above "Apple is going to exert the power to control the carriers. Apple is about the only company that can, or will, exert this kind of power" is naive.

Apple has no such power, quite the contrary, it is locked to a single US service provider that doesn't give their clients the best quality of service, consumers that are on AT&T that dont have the iphone dont seem to flock en mass to get one, and consumers on other networks, dont seem to migrate en mass to AT&T just to get it, so the market for Iphone in the US is increasingly limited.

A game of chicken of sorts, we will see who blinks first. The service providers limit access to device hardware in their stores the same manner that apple limits access to software on its online store, it is the practice rather then the practitioner that is at fault here.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by roc on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @05:42PM (#1692441)
The iPhone didn't make competitors take the open route. But if not for the iPhone, Verizon certainly would never have considered allowing Android devices on their network, let alone subsidized and championed them.

The gist of the article is that all phones are stymied by service providers. Even Apple, for all the ground it's gained for its own interests, has been hamstrung by arbitrary carrier requirements and restrictions.

You may have faith in the market alone to deliver unencumbered Android devices. I do not. The short history we have to this point has shown the US duopoly interested in competing only on how much functionality each successive device can gate off.

The carriers have every financial incentive to carve out functionality and wall it off behind premium fees. They have an incredibly strong incentive to not allow themselves to become commoditized data pipes. And they have demonstrated repeated preference for sharing the market over 'playing to win' at a lower rate of profit.

If the US duopoly is willing to collude on gimped android[1], as all evidence has shown, there is no market threat in not shipping an unencumbered Android phone.

[1] it needn't be official collusion; merely a lack of strong competitive moves in an area, as long as the other holds the line. E.g. the situation with US plan pricing, data plan policy and pricing, tethering charges, texting rates, feature-phone features prior to 2007, etc.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by fragmede on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @07:35PM (#1692707)
Let's not forget; way back in 2007, Apple went to Verizon first, and Verizon passed on the iPhone. Verizon just wasn't willing to give up any control to Apple. Way back when, Verizon deliberately disabled the Bluetooth stack on their phones, so you had to use their fee-based service to do something like copy photos off your phone.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by rbanffy on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:03PM (#1691563)
> There's a huge difference between a phone maker having control and a network having control.

There is, but it only distracts you from understanding that you should be the only one in control of your phone.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by roc on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:43PM (#1691729)
Understanding how things "should" be has nothing to do with being able to recognize improvements in the World That Is.

You can know that you should be able to load an arbitrary mp3 as a ringtone on an iPhone, and still prefer the current state of affairs to the state of things a mere three years ago. I do.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by vidar on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:10PM (#1691600)
Should is a funny word. Just because our perception of fairness dictates that we should control our phones, its just not going to happen in the foreseeable future.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by abrahamsen on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:02PM (#1691813)
I'd say this particular should is more a question of enlightened self interest, rather than fairness.

It is in our long term interest to have as much control of our "digital assistants" (which includes both smartphones and personal computers) in order to ensure that they assist us, and not some other party.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by rimantas on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:36AM (#1693622)
And your network! Right?
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ynniv on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:56PM (#1691536)
Pfft. Smartphones used to be more open because they were the Lexus LSA that gets customers excited about buying their $20k Toyta (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect#As_a_business_model). Anything was acceptable because they were not seen as a primary market to optimize.

Enter the iPhone, the first smartphone to achieve mass market. The iPhone requires a premium data plan. The iPhone requires an additional data plan to tether only on AT&T. AT&T may have gotten veto power over certain apps in the AppStore. They certainly had input on the maximum file limits over cellular. You see that Apple has considerable power, and that AT&T still has power, but what you don't see is that the consumer has more power in this equation than in the Android formula. Android users can't even install a vanilla OS or their own updates half of the time.

Overall the consumer may have less power than in previous smartphone systems, but to lament this is to assume that the carriers would allow a previous smartphone system to become as dominant as the iPhone without imposing restrictions similar to the state of Android.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by jrockway on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @08:07PM (#1692780)
Pretty sure that Blackberries were pretty popular before the iPhone.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ynniv on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @08:25PM (#1692822)
Blackberries were corporate purchases with more restrictions than any iPhone. The parent was talking about consumer purchased smartphones like Windows Mobile or Symbian.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by awolf on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:24PM (#1691649)
You touched on this in your last paragraph, but I think it still deserves saying: Apple wields a lot of the power it wrenched away from carriers to the benefit of it's consumers. I'm stoked that my iPhone doesn't com preloaded with crap ware and that my girlfriend's 3 year old device receives OS updates immediately once they are released to the public.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ellyagg on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:47PM (#1691487)
You've got to be kidding. The iPhone has attracted hoards of new consumers to Apple who were not previously "loyal Apple fans, who love[d] and trust[ed] Apple". Apparently many normal people feel that they saw a major change for the better after this power redistribution.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ergo98 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:55PM (#1691780)
>Apparently many normal people feel that they saw a major change for the better after this power redistribution.

I would attribute the uptake of smartphones to the standard, endless evolution of technology. And while they fell behind, there is absolutely no doubt that Blackberry blazed the path after Windows Mobile faltered.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by padmanabhan01 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:50PM (#1691500)
//the consumer didn't see much of a change, or saw a regression

The consumers did see a change. The phones beacame usable (pleasure to use) from being unusable (pain to use).

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by rbanffy on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:01PM (#1691551)
And model selection came down from dozens to two. You can have it in any color, as long as it's either black or white.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by martythemaniak on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:58PM (#1691544)
This is what we call political point-scoring. I am trying to get a point across on a particular subject (power/control) and you're trying to muddle up the conversation by talking about something else completely.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by lzw on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:22PM (#1691367)
Prior to the iPhone, apps on an a phone were paying $3/month to a carrier for crappy junk. The phones were locked down. It was far from "standard practice" to load your own apps onto your own phone, and the apps you could choose to use were highly limited and far more controlled.

I think people forget that before the Apple AppStore there really were very few apps for phones.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by martythemaniak on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:51PM (#1691507)
You either didn't read my post or you're deliberately being obtuse to make your point - there was a huge difference between smartphones and featurephones.

What you're describe is the featurephone app model, which Apple made more user and developer friendly and brought to the smartphone arena.

I used to have a blackberry (and yes, I had both apps and games on it) and when I bought the original iPhone, I had to jailbreak it in order to be able to do the same things I could do before. That's a regression.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by jonknee on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:41PM (#1691462)
I think you're confusing smartphones and feature phones. You're right that the experience of apps on feature phones was lackluster (it still is actually). The iPhone helped catapult smartphones into the mainstream, but there wasn't a lack of smartphone software before the iPhone. Palm, Symbian and Windows Mobile (and BlackBerry to a lesser degree) all had a wide array of apps available before the iPhone was ever announced.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by jad on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:01PM (#1691807)
It's pretty clear to most people that the smartphone app market that exists today is qualitatively different than the one that existed before the App Store. I think that's the point the parent was trying to make.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by jrockway on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @08:09PM (#1692787)
Definitely. The emphasis now is to get your potential users to spend 99c as many times as possible (with "do one thing" and shiny graphics; see "fart apps"). Previously, everything was either free, or something you found for $20 at some commercial vendor's website.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by there on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:47PM (#1691488)
I think people forget that before the Apple AppStore there really were very few apps for phones.

really? i've owned a palm treo and nokia e71 that both had hundreds of applications available that i could just download and install right from the device's web browser. no market, no restrictions.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by nailer on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:38PM (#1691443)
> I think people forget that before the Apple AppStore there really were very few apps for phones.

Fewer than today, sure. But Windows Mobile had thousands of apps and a pretty decent app development ecosystem.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by demallien on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @11:54AM (#1690986)
Yup. And I'm starting to wonder if in the end Android isn't going to reverse the trend towards carrier openness started by the iPhone. (A quick aside, when I say carrier openness, I mean that the carrier starts acting as just a data conduit, instead of imposing their branding everywhere on the user experience. So the iPhone introduced manufacturer-initiated updates, no operator logos stuck on the phone, apps controlled by Apple, not the operator, etc. The iPhone experience is the same regardless of which operator you find yourself on, around the world).

So, with Android proving itself to be a decent competitor to the iPhone, it has reduced Apple's bargaining power with operators. That, added to the fact that the "openness" of Android ironically allows the operators to lock it down, means that we may very well be seeing the end of a very short era where handset manufacturers could dictate a decent amount of the user experience. If the difference between the iPhone and all previous phones is an indicator, this is a great shame.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by loewenskind on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:07AM (#1697162)
>dded to the fact that the "openness" of Android ironically allows the operators to lock it down

Why would this be ironic? It's very obvious that the more open you are the more people can do exactly what they want, and that includes locking down.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by demallien on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:45AM (#1697244)
I don't have any figures to back this up, but frankly I would be astonished if it turned out that most people didn't expect 'open' to mean 'not locked down'. The trick is that Android isn't actually open for all parties concerned, only for the integrator. The integrator may then decide to make the resulting device open, but that is not a foregone conclusion, as proven by some of the devices beginning to appear on the market. But that message isn't what is being marketed - people are being told that Android is 'open', by which they naturally understand that they can do what they want with their device. But in reality, not so much. Anyway, way too many words to say that this is a very ironic result if you don't take care to explicitly define the parties concerned when talking about openness/locked downedness of a device...
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by jokermatt999 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:20PM (#1691356)
I agree that Apple has done a lot to reduce carrier control, but I don't like Apple's control either. The main issue I have with them is not allowing sideloading of apps and their strict control over the App Store. I see that as just as evil as what a lot of the carriers were doing beforehand. That's why I look more toward Android than Apple. Yes, Android is not as free or open for the end consumer as it could be because Google has made too many concessions to carriers (modifying UI, apps that cannot be uninstalled, slow updates, etc). However, their model is still far more open than iOS, for the simple fact that you can install anything you want on it. Yes, Google still does not allow all apps in the Marketplace, but there's still sideloading.

Edit: Just to make it clear, I agree with the article. I don't mean to say that Google/Android will fix everything. The real issue is still the carriers. However, I think Google is a better example of open than Apple, even if that works against them sometimes.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by loewenskind on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:20AM (#1697197)
>I see that as just as evil as what a lot of the carriers were doing beforehand.

Seeing Apple's behavior as evil is just not rational. It is a simple, obvious trade off. By having the control they do they can control the iPhone experience and make sure as few people as possible have a bad experience (and since they're selling phones they want to make sure no uninformed user can blame the phone for a bad experience. The only way to do that is try to make sure they can't download misbehaving apps). The cost are: people can do every possible thing they would want to and may not like that, developers have to wait for their app to be on the store, it may get rejected, etc.

Android chose the opposite, an app marketplace that's almost completely open (I'm assuming they don't allow obvious malicious software). This is not more or less evil, it is simply a different trade off. The costs are: people can do anything they want and will sometimes do bad things (accidentally or on purpose), etc.

People need to take the emotion out of the argument. The iPhone isn't becoming a legislated requirement or anything, there is no reason to get emotional about it.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by lzw on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:28PM (#1691391)
Think about it this way. You can install any app you want on your iPhone as well.

The thing is, Apple charges $99 a year for the privilege. Get a developer account, and run whatever you want.

In order to have any security, you need to sign executables, and Apple's $99 essentially covers the cost of doing that. This is much better than the $100 per app up to many thousands that previously you'd have to pay.

Maybe unsigned executables is a risk you're willing to take on, but given the level of derogatory misinofrmation that people spread about apple as it is, I understand why they want to limit the potential damage. The media does not distinguish between some code downloaded over the internet for jailbroken phones and something from the appstore, as it is.

And everyone is apparently very eager to make hay whenever they can blame something on Apple.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by fragmede on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @07:26PM (#1692690)
Let me describe an app that doesn't exist, would do well in the app store, but will never be allowed.

What the app does does, is turn the iPhone into a normal usb drive when connected to a computer. On top of that, your music is available in normal folders, that you can drag to your computer. Additionally, you can drag music onto that drive, and the music will be playable on the iPhone after you disconnect.

(Yes, iPhoneBrowser and DiskAid kind of allow you to do this, but I'm talking about having the iPhone handle it natively.)

And y'know what?

I blame Apple for this app not existing.

$100 doesn't allow me to run whatever I want if it doesn't exist.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by loewenskind on Thursday September 16, 2010 @04:23AM (#1697202)
Most people don't need or want what you're describing. I use iTunes (on OSX) and I like it. I prefer it to manually laying out folders of music. Folders don't make sense for music anyway because how the songs should be organized depends on what mood I'm in at the time. Tags would be much better. Which is what you can do with iTunes.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by Zak on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:07PM (#1691587)
The problem with having to buy a developer account or jailbreak the phone is that many of the apps that wouldn't be approved never get written. The commercial viability of an app is somewhat limited when the first step in the installation instructions is "jailbreak your phone".
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by jsz0 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @05:32PM (#1692406)
Android apps that appear in the top 10-20 paid apps require rooting which is more or less the same barrier of entry. (I can't remember if this requires you to check "unknown sources" or not. Maybe by default they don't appear)
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by patrickaljord on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:11PM (#1691605)
> but the combination of fragmentation and very slow adoption of latest releases by the android

Actually, Android is doing not doing worse if not better than iOS here thanks to over-the-air updates of android. To update your iOS you need to connect it to a PC and sync it with iTunes, too much for many people whereas Android updates automatically over the air which makes updates applied very fast once available, check out the numbers here:

http://www.androidpolice.com/2010/09/11/the-state-of-android...

> Apples market has little fragmentation and high hardware consistency.

>But I digress. Without google imposing some licensing terms, android users are always going to have a poor os upgrade experience, it seems.

Again, I couldn't disagree more. Not having to use iTunes and over-the-air updates is such a better experience than updating an iPhone, so much that Android users update their OS sooner than iPhone users. Plus if you look at the stats, most of the big phones got their update 1 to 2 months after the official release of Froyo, so it's not that bad. And if you have a Nexus or a rooted phone, it's instant upgrade.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by alttab on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:47PM (#1691749)
The upgrade experience is better - but you do that a lot less than making phone calls.

I had an iPhone and just switched to Android. After a couple of days Android is annoying me. With my iPhone, after unlocking my phone I hold the home button then click on a name to make a call.

On Android, I unlock the device, click Phone, click favorites, click the name, then click call. I went from 2 clicks to 6. Its just not as usable.

My fiance got a Palm Pre and despite the lack of "apps" I like the interface way more than Android phones.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ek on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @10:14PM (#1693063)
When you first got your iPhone, you probably had no idea that you could hold the home button to get to your favorites. By the same token, there are similar shortcuts on Android which you probably have yet to discover. Holding the search button to voice dial would be one option, like the other poster in this thread said. On HTC devices, there is a favorites widget, so that potentially you could be calling one of your favorites in merely one click.

Another thing is that Android's extensibility automatically lends itself to your being able to customize your personal user experience in a vast multitude of different ways. If you really wanted to maintain the "hold the home button and get contacts" behavior of the iPhone, for example, you could replace the stock launcher with a third-party application like ADW.Launcher or Launcher Pro and then modify the home button behavior.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by patrickaljord on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:08PM (#1691841)
You can just say 'call bob' and it will make the call.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by andrewljohnson on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:43PM (#1691470)
As a developer of both iPhone and Android apps, I see the biggest problem with Android as being the friction to buy.

On iPhone, every single person is pretty wealthy, and more importantly, has a credit card entered into iTunes. On Android, the first app you buy usually involves inputting CC information.

If Android can't address this issue, then the handset measure is meaningless. Android will need to sell 100 or 1000x more than iPhone to create the same market for developers like me.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by rimantas on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:49AM (#1693643)
There are many many countries you cannot use Android marketplace at all.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by kenjackson on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:06PM (#1691044)
Actually I think the opposite. Google and MS will exert more control over carriers. MS in particular.

The problem with Apple is that they signed an exclusivity agreement with a single carrier. I'm sure that if Google told Verizon, "The only place an Android phone will be for the next four years is Verizon", Verizon would jump through hoops for them.

But by getting the phone on all carriers, yet still doing 90% of what Apple is doing on a single carrier is impressive.

And MS has taken this a step further with the hardware requirements and no skinning, and one centralized market. Yet, they're doing this across all carriers.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by nanairo on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:16PM (#1691076)
You make it sound easy. Apple would have loved for nothing more than having their phone on every carrier. But at the time they were a nobody in the mobile arena, and not only was their phone a huge departure but they also wanted to keep the look and feel untouched and have the carrier implement some ad hoc changes for things like visual voicemail.

By the time Google had to make a deal, Verizon was seeing their customers moving to AT&T and needed something to rival the iPhone. Before the iPhone Verizon is said to have told Apple that its contract (to have a Verizon iPhone) were not acceptable. I doubt Verizon would have replied like that had the roles been inverted.

Anyway, the exclusivity will hopefully end soon. What will be your stance at that point?

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by kenjackson on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:32PM (#1691412)
I'm not sure where I said it was easy, or implied it. I'm not even sure what you think I believe is easy.

In any case, my point is simply that exclusivity of a phone OS to a single carrier IMO is not a net win.

And my additional point was that MS is getting most of the win that Apple has today, but is applying it across all carriers.

I think Apple ending the exclusivity will be a great thing. You seem to imply that I'd think otherwise.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by nanairo on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:16PM (#1691622)
But you are comparing apple and oranges. You are comparing Microsoft today with Apple in 2007. There were a _lot_ of people doubting Apple would succeed if they ever tried to move into the phone market. And carriers (at least in the US) had a solid grip on the market.

Nowadays the situation is completely different. Apple had showed that their vision of smartphone is successful: Microsoft (or Google) don't need to prove that anymore. Also carriers have lost a bit of their power, and are more afraid of ending up with a world controlled by one company than before.

The point of the exclusivity is that if it runs out in a few months as many expect, that's pretty much when the new MS phones will come out (give or take a couple of months). So I don't see what damage Apple made.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by kenjackson on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:33PM (#1691687)
No, I'm comparing Apple today with MS today. What Apple did in 2007 was great. But the exclusivity that exists to this day, is not, IMO.

I never said that Apple damaged the market. Someone made this comment, "Apple is going to exert the power to control the carriers. Apple is about the only company that can, or will, exert this kind of power."

I said I thought the opposite. That the power to control the carriers will be stronger with Google and MS. Largely because they will be on all the carriers, and while imposing looser requirements on the carriers, capture the core requirements (again, MS in particular -- Google less so).

Lets be clear. I'm not saying Apple has done anything bad, but I do think that their impact has been weakened with their exclusivity for four years on ATT. I find it hard to believe that Apple couldn't have negotiated a shorter exclusivity deal, while losing almost nothing.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by nanairo on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:43PM (#1691727)
Oh, I definitely agree that their impact was weakened by the exclusivity... for a start because Android would have been less popular.

My guess (and it's purely that) is that the deal was extended (maybe one year... dunno) in exchange for the iPad deal. Not a great move, I agree.

Finally, I agree MS stands in a strong position too. But not Google. As long as Android is open, and as long as there are many manufacturers of Android phones, you have a situation where the very few phone companies have an oligopoly on demand and hence have the upperhand: if Motorola doesn't play along, they can go to Sony, or HTC, or Samsung, or LG... and others are coming up soon. Then Motorola can either lose a lucrative business without little harm to the carrier or is forced to oblige.

That said if one particular brand would become the most appealing for some reason, that company would definitely regain some bargaining power.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by Retric on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:48PM (#1691227)
Apple created real smartphone competition in the form of high quality UI linked to an unlimited data plan. They only needed to get AT&T to move a little before competition forced Verizon etc to keep up.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by rimantas on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @04:03AM (#1693660)

  And MS has taken this a step further with the hardware
  requirements and no skinning, and one centralized market.
  Yet, they're doing this across all carriers.
And what leverage MS can use? MS first have to convince phone makers to use their OS instead of Android.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by doki_pen on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:18PM (#1691348)
I think the balance for Google is whether they fight Apple, or the carriers. Fighting the carriers will fight themselves out of existence. If they cater to the carriers, they can kill the iPhone.

That doesn't mean I like it. Just as locking down devices and forcing apps through the App Store, although beneficial to Apple, doesn't make it good for consumers.

Ultimately, I want an open phone that works on the carrier of my choice. I just don't know if that formula could ever win.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by loewenskind on Thursday September 16, 2010 @05:21AM (#1697305)
> Just as locking down devices and forcing apps through the App Store, although beneficial to Apple, doesn't make it good for consumers.

Nonsense. Consumers don't want to have to know all kinds of useless details just to be able to use their device. Personally I hate installing software on windows. There is a vast amount of it, but there is no one there making sure it's not going to damage my system (for the most part, of course you can restrict yourself to only software that has the MS seal). On OSX this is slightly better, but I still hate it when that little box opens up asking me to grant access.

On iOS however, I install without much thought. I know that anything I download there has been vetted by someone with a strong interest in making sure their platform doesn't look bad (among some other interests that are less to my benefit). For me the trade off of not ever having to think about this stuff is worth missing out on things like Google Voice.

I don't think the reason Android has been doing well in the US has anything what so ever to do with silly "open" dogma, but rather that it's cheaper and isn't tied to AT&T.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by doki_pen on Thursday September 16, 2010 @02:14PM (#1698605)
There is nothing wrong with the App Store concept. There is a huge problem with locking down a device that is the property of the consumer. Adults can choose to only install apps from the App Store, and it may or may not be a good idea for most users.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by lzw on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:32PM (#1691414)
Think about your assertion that the appstore isn't good for consumers. Do you really believe that?

Consumers are not hackers. Consumers do not really understand technology that well. The appstore provides a safe buying experience for consumers, and now, rather than the app marketplace being infintesimal, it is massive and growing quickly.

Apple lit a powderkeg there. How is this not good for consumers?

Imagine if Apple had not provided any protections? You'd have malicious apps all over the place, and constant stories about how bad and dangerous iPhone apps are, and a lot less consumers using apps.

I don't really buy that the iPhone is closed. Any app I can think of that is not evil, Apple will approve for sale on the store. If I want something that doesn't make sense to sell, then I compile it myself and sign it myself with the developer certificate.

The random consumer is not going to be even installing XCode, let alone figuring out how to build even open-source software. So, the $99/year for the keys to sign apps is not really a big deal to me.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:45PM (#1691740)
You think Firefox and Google Voice are "evil"? Apps that duplicate functionality are "evil"? One more fart app is "evil"?

Your positive regard for the App store may be partly based on ignorance of Apple's stated conditions.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by billmcneale on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @09:29PM (#1692975)
Right, because Apple's influence over AT&T has led to drastic reductions in monthly fees for all iPhone owners and given them access to additional features such as MMS, tethering and unlimited data for free.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by evgen on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @12:20AM (#1693304)
The words of someone who obviously never paid for a cellular data connection before the iPhone came along. For approximately the same cost as my previous usb dongle and data plan I get to unplug the dongle from my computer and use it to make phone calls and play games.