News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by btown on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:31PM (#16871397)
The linked article https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2018/04/18/no-boundaries-for-f... provides much more detail and links to source code, such as https://gist.github.com/englehardt/db3ecea255ccd6aa2b0cb73ca...

It's important to recognize that this is not an exploit or high-tech exfiltration: it's extremely well-documented in https://developers.facebook.com/docs/reference/javascript/FB... and https://developers.facebook.com/docs/javascript/reference/FB... - the Facebook library even assumes that potentially multiple scripts may be checking repeatedly, and caches accordingly. Facebook is incentivized to make it as easy as possible to integrate their login across the internet, and that entails removing any requirements such as server-side processing that would discourage every tag from including this code.

Seeing this and being surprised is like watching a teen movie where the gossiper invites the entire school to listen in on the phone line while the protagonist is (unwisely) sharing a secret with them, and thinking as you watch, "that's totally out of character for the gossiper - even though they want to collect people's information themselves, there's no way they would invite other people to listen in as they're in the process of receiving that information."

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @06:35PM (#16871863)
> It's important to recognize that this is not an exploit or high-tech exfiltration: it's extremely well-documented

This argument was used last time [1]. It didn't work then and it's a silly excuse now.

Users gave Facebook their "name, email address, age range, gender, locale, and profile photo" [2]. Some of them marked those data private (i.e. only for friends). Those data were shared, without the users' informed consent, with third parties through the log-in function.

Documenting a breach doesn't unmake it a breach. And a breach can be a breach without involving any technical exploits. This was a breach.

> Seeing this and being surprised is like watching a teen movie where the gossiper...

People didn't realize Facebook was selling their secrets. That may strike you as naïve. But it's this asymmetry, between specialists (e.g. Facebook employees and technologists at large) and non-specialists (i.e. most of Facebook's users), that drives the need for regulation.

An analogy can be found in lemon laws [3]. We protect consumers from specialists (e.g. car salespersons) taking advantage of the customers' reasonable ignorance of cars. Facebook is selling the world lemons and mocking them for buying.

[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/facebook-cambridge-analytica-wa...

[2] https://techcrunch.com/2018/04/18/login-with-facebook-data-h...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lemon_law

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by underwater on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:10PM (#16872069)
You’re either misunderstanding or misrepresenting what is happening here.

The website or app implements Facebook Login. When a user visits that they can choose to share their profile information with that app. Through poor security or malicious action that app leaks that information to third parties.

You can’t control data on systems you don’t own. So Facebook’s options are either (a) limit how platform apps use data via non-technical/legal methods (b) better educate users on the implications of sharing their data with external apps, or (c) refuse to share any user data with external apps.

We’ve seen the first option fail with the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Educating users consistently fails. And before Facebook built a platform, they were accused of building a walled garden.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by ljm on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:04PM (#16872339)
I'm not sure you can see this as a persistent failure in terms of FB (and similar) fighting against an unstoppable tide of ignorance. It's far more easier to see Facebook (and similarly Google with Android, for a very long time) sabotaging the effort from the start.

A user absolutely can choose what they share with Facebook, but Facebook makes no effort to tell you why you should edit the defaults. Instead, you have to click an edit button, and look at a list of checkboxes, and understand what each thing means, and double and triple check that this doesn't override your personal privacy preferences or have some other unintended side-effects. The default expectation from Facebook (and similar) is biased heavily against the user, purely by virtue of it being opt out.

It depends on users not being educated well enough, and giving them a good reason to care less about being more judicious with their profile.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by darod on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:36AM (#16874975)
Actually some apps wont allow you to login if you change any of the checkboxes.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by Angostura on Thursday April 19, 2018 @04:09AM (#16874172)
> You can’t control data on systems you don’t own. So Facebook’s options are either (a) limit how platform apps use data via non-technical/legal methods

Under GDPR, as a data controller, you cant share data with another organisation without ensuring that they follow the same rules that you have set out for processing data. This may get interesting in Europe.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by mixedbit on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:19AM (#16874894)
> Through poor security or malicious action that app leaks that information to third parties.

It's neither poor security or malicious action. Web site isolation rules by design give full privileges to any third party script the website includes. If a website uses facebook login, all third party scripts can access the facebook user name.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by zzzeek on Thursday April 19, 2018 @09:43AM (#16875811)
> And before Facebook built a platform, they were accused of building a walled garden.

That's not any kind of argument for the privacy-diluting practices of Facebook. If Facebook were a totally closed environment that shared your data with nobody, that's a problem for Facebook and the private companies who would prefer to exploit that information, not for the users, who at this point would very much prefer Facebook to be a "walled", but but in actuality a "regulated", garden.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:20PM (#16872124)
It's almost like it's a problem that cannot be solved without outside intervention.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by underwater on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:32PM (#16872187)
Are you suggesting regulation could have helped in this situation? Do you believe the problem is with Facebook sharing data (which they did with the user's permission) with an app? Or with an app failing to secure the data? Or with a third-party taking user data without permission?
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:38PM (#16872212)
> Are you suggesting regulation could have helped in this situation?

Facebook doesn't give a shit about its users. And for that I don't blame them. They're fighters. When they went public, so many assumed they were dead for lacking a mobile presence. Time and again, they've been called out as moribund and time and again they've won. That takes--and develops--thick skin.

That thick skin is now a hard head obstructing their view of the truth. When they drop the ball, it is never their fault. Someone is mis-defining a term, users aren't reading fine print, lawmakers are being mean, et cetera. The onus is put on us, the public, to determine how our rights can be balanced with their business model. As if their business is a given.

If Facebook were liable for repeatedly losing our data, for repeatedly refusing to tell users what it does with what they give them, for constantly lying about what it's doing and going to do, this would stop. Or Facebook would stop.

Neither users nor advertisers can unilaterally disengage. Not in meaningful numbers. Facebook is too powerful. The only solution is for it to be broken up.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by curiousgeorgio on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:57PM (#16872568)
Do you believe in the rule of law, or do you expect everyone to take the "moral high ground" (however you want to define that) all the time just because they should? Pick one or the other, but not both. Hint: one of the two is a fair and practical approach; the other is a pipe dream built from excessive virtue signaling.

Should Facebook be 100% held responsible to the law? Of course.

Should some laws be updated/created to help fill gaps where we might need more privacy? Possibly.

Should Facebook be held to some nebulous moral standard of what some people want but don't have the will power or public support to codify into law? Absolutely not.

Too powerful? If people actually cared more about privacy, then either the law would get changed (which is happening in some places), or Facebook would lose market share and be forced to make changes from market forces alone. No need for governments to arbitrarily pick winners and losers.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:57AM (#16873432)
> Facebook would lose market share and be forced to make changes from market forces alone

"Market failure is a situation in which the allocation of goods and services is not efficient" [1]. They are known failure modes that free markets suffer, and must be defended, from. Laissez-faire doesn't work.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by indemnity on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:22AM (#16874907)
Found the Facebook employee.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by jimbo999 on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:45AM (#16873394)
>Do you believe in the rule of law

Facebook Ireland Ltd. Does.

> Pick one or the other why not both?

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by Arbalest on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:46PM (#16872254)
All three options failing? So basically the very premise of Facebook is broken if we wish to uphold this value.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by ubernostrum on Thursday April 19, 2018 @02:50AM (#16873859)
The "not an exploit", I think, means something like "this is not, from Facebook's perspective, a malicious or unauthorized use of their platform and services".

In other words, it's not taking advantage of some accidental bug Facebook never intended to have; it's Facebook's system working as Facebook designed it to work.

Now, from the perspective of an individual person whose personal information was collected and distributed in this fashion, it certainly is unexpected and likely unwanted. But calling it a "breach" or "exploit" of Facebook implicitly covers for Facebook by implying that Facebook is a victim of some type of attack here. Facebook was not a victim of an attack.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by 734786710934 on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @06:54PM (#16871968)
> People didn't realize Facebook was selling their secrets.

Facebook doesn't sell data, it sells ads.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by tedivm on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:05PM (#16872035)
According to this article (as well as the Cambridge Analytica stuff) it doesn't sell data, it just gives it away.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by Twisell on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:32AM (#16873349)
Well it’s more like an exchange, because in the process they gain the ability to suck up virtually every piece of data you post in the external website because you basically hold them your key.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @06:56PM (#16871983)
> Facebook doesn't sell data, it sells ads

That sounds like selling data but with extra steps.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by amarkov on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:10PM (#16872070)
When you say Facebook is "selling data", I think most people would understand it to mean that advertisers can go to Facebook and buy a list of people who eat at McDonalds. That's very different from the opaque ad targeting Facebook actually sells.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by pests on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:35PM (#16872205)
There is a connection between the ad targeting information and the eventual anonymous click through though. You only need to connect that click to a real identity via either self disclosure (newsletter signup, social login, etc) or pushing your metadata through third party data brokers.

In the end you have a click associated with an advertising campaign linked to a real life (or even pseudo) identity.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by Satam on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:13PM (#16872376)
Are you implying that this is a problem that arises specifically from Facebook's targeted advertising? I genuinely don't think that's the case.

It doesn't really matter if ads are served to everyone or if they are shown only to a targeted demographic - either way, only people who are interested will click on them. Also, I think it is safe to say that, roughly, it is only the efficiency of clicks per ad-view that will increase if one uses targeted advertising.

So, if the act of clicking a targeted advertisement does not in itself somehow "transfer" any more identifying data than a click on a regular ad would, which I don't think it does, then what's the problem?

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by kurthr on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @10:58PM (#16873024)
Facebook is incentivised to collect and collate product data because it can then sell targeted ads for those humans. As long as the most cost effective path to those targets is through Facebook, and the aggregate target volume is high enough they will make money. Distributing the login data is just advertising.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by whyever on Thursday April 19, 2018 @10:38AM (#16876237)
That argument goes both ways: When you say Facebook is "selling ads", I think most people would understand it to mean that advertisers can buy ads like in a paper magazine. That's very different from the tracking and targeting ads Facebook actually sells.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by underwater on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:16PM (#16872101)
“Hey, I heard you’re opening a baby store. Did you know John and Mary are expecting? Here’s their phone number, you should call them up.” vs. “Hey, I heard you’re opening a baby store. If I know anyone who is expecting I can let them know.”
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by pests on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:32PM (#16872184)
But really your second example ends with "But when they do come inside you'll know I sent them and you can ask them their name yourself."

Same knowledge as your first example (names, expecting). I do admit you only get the information from people who come into the store.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by underwater on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @10:43PM (#16872954)
They’re vastly different. John and Mary can choose exactly who they want to reveal information to.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by jnwatson on Thursday April 19, 2018 @02:20AM (#16873741)
Not on the modern web.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by EGreg on Thursday April 19, 2018 @05:25AM (#16874476)
How so?
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by propogandist on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:51AM (#16875050)
Signals. Searching for specific things, emails you're receiving in Gmail, videos you watch online etc.

Given Target was able to figure out someone was expecting based on behavior in their store, back in 2011 [1], even though they dont have a loyalty program, imagine what can be done with so many trackers that are on the web datamining your behavior from one website to another.

[1] https://mobile.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habi...

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by underwater on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:16PM (#16880995)
The original assertion that advertising and data sharing are equivalent. But even in your examples the information is still fire-walled.

Google can know that you're expecting, because of a congratulation email. Facebook can know you're expecting, because of a life event. Arbitrary companies can't know who their baby store ad is being shown to.

You can argue that Google and Facebook are too big, and data being shared between YouTube, Gmail, Google Adwords, etc. is suboptimal. But that's still better than a company that will freely sell a database of information to be resold, mixed, etc. forevermore.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by EGreg on Thursday April 19, 2018 @08:13AM (#16875169)
But what signals can third party domains get if third party cookies are disabled?

Is fingerprinting so good that cookies are now irrelevant? I mean most mobile devices have the same screen sizes etc.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by Rjevski on Sunday April 22, 2018 @08:48AM (#16895929)
Fingerprint coupled with IP tracking is pretty good.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by ensignro2340 on Thursday April 19, 2018 @03:04PM (#16879010)
> emails you're receiving in Gmail

I'm sorry but if you care about privacy, you shouldn't be using Gmail.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by joesb on Thursday April 19, 2018 @05:07AM (#16874402)
Right. "You can ask them their name yourself"

That doesn't mean they are going to give you their name.

And if they choose to give you their name, it's their right and responsibility.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by rmc on Thursday April 19, 2018 @10:03AM (#16875944)
It's important to remember, because someone might propose a law against a social network selling data. It could be heralded as finally giving users privacy. And Zuckerberg will be very happy that this PR mess has gone away
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by AznHisoka on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:07PM (#16872049)
They basically provide the data for free so you can buy more ads.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by ape4 on Thursday April 19, 2018 @10:06AM (#16875958)
That why I lied to Facebook about all the profile info.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by anonymouz on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @06:57PM (#16871987)
So... a user using the "Login with Facebook" functionality on some website is supposed to have read the developer docs of Facebook, to be aware that some of his Facebook profile data will end up being shared with some random third-party tracker/ad-ware?

The GDPR really can't come to soon. I hope it'll finally smite these crappy companies.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by dperfect on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:03PM (#16872338)
From a privacy standpoint, third-party scripts intercepting data is essentially no different from the "trusted" site explicitly sharing data with third parties. In both cases, the site using "Login with Facebook" is responsible for the data they gather/share, and that includes data gathered by any scripts they choose to embed on their site.

End users might not understand the technical details, but one should assume that if you're giving company X access to your data, company X could potentially share that data with companies Y and Z. Company X's privacy policy should cover their use (and sharing) of the data in either case, and if they didn't anticipate companies Y and Z intercepting data when this is clearly documented as a possibility in Facebook's docs, then I agree - company X should be held accountable.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by dbasedweeb on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:29PM (#16872452)
If you print out FB’s T&C’s, plus all of the layers of embedded links within links, it’s 87,000+ words. That is designed to be unreadable and incomprehensible, it’s an attempt to baffle. Even stupid people, illiterate people, and just plain lazy people don’t deserve to be taken advantage of.

If you want to talk about what people “should” know, there’s s reasonable man statute, and it definitely doesn’t include what you’re describing.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by dperfect on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:33PM (#16872474)
I agree with you on that. I'm just pointing out that the data isn't being shared with "some random third-party tracker/ad-ware" (it's either a conscious decision or a serious security mistake to include third-party scripts on your site). This particular method of "leaking data" shouldn't be treated any differently from direct, deliberate information sharing because it's not some kind of unanticipated "hack" as the story might sound.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by bigiain on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @09:18PM (#16872640)
"These scripts are embedded on a total of 434 of the top 1 million sites, including fiverr.com, bhphotovideo.com, and mongodb.com. … We believe the websites embedding these scripts are likely unaware of this particular data access [5]."

From an end user point of view - I don't think it's reasonable for a bhphotovideo.com user logging in with Facebook to assume their Facebook data is being sent to ntvk1.ru

I suspect it's not even really reasonable to expect the website owner at some of those "434 of the top million sites" to be technical enough to understand the privacy implications for their users of running both "Log in with Facebook" and 3rd party ad serving on their sites at the same time.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by gaius on Thursday April 19, 2018 @01:54AM (#16873620)
and mongodb.com

To be fair everyone expects MongoDB to leak data like a sieve.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by Semirhage on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @06:00PM (#16871632)
Seeing this and being surprised is like watching a teen movie where the gossiper invites the entire school to listen in on the phone line while the protagonist is (unwisely) sharing a secret with them, and thinking as you watch, "that's totally out of character for the gossiper - even though they want to collect people's information themselves, there's no way they would invite other people to listen in as they're in the process of receiving that information."

Doesn’t that depend on who’s surprised? My parents would be shocked by this, people working in the software industry should be less shocked. I bet that a poll of 100 randomly selected people asking, “What does documentation mean in the context of software?” would discover that few knew the answer. Never mind actually reading the docs, or understanding their implications.

Facebook goes to some trouble to ensure that only a small minority of people grasp the implications of how they’re monetizing their users.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by thisisit on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:32AM (#16873347)
It's important to recognize that this is not an exploit or high-tech exfiltration: it's extremely well-documented in https://developers.facebook.com/docs/reference/javascript/FB.... and https://developers.facebook.com/docs/javascript/reference/FB.... - the Facebook library even assumes that potentially multiple scripts may be checking repeatedly, and caches accordingly. Facebook is incentivized to make it as easy as possible to integrate their login across the internet, and that entails removing any requirements such as server-side processing that would discourage every tag from including this code.

Maybe I am reading this wrong but if Facebook makes an assumption which is inherently unsafe and publishes it. And then someone utilizes the unsafe assumption to siphon data, the ball is still in Facebook's court. They have to ensure that scripts cannot do this.

Sure, this might make it difficult for anyone trying to develop using Facebook library. But that is still better than asking people to read T&C and ensuring data is not leaked.

Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by vageli on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:53PM (#16872296)
It's ridiculous to expect average people to have even a passing familiarity with Facebook developer documentation.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by dang on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:28PM (#16872445)
Ok, since that's the original source, we've switched the thread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16871054 to this one, which was posted earlier. Thanks!
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by IBM on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:53PM (#16872551)
Why not just change the URL? That one had over 200 upvotes, this one will probably just fade off the front page in a few hours.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by dang on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @09:34PM (#16872691)
This way is fairer to the original submitter, and it's a big enough story that it's unlikely to suffer in terms of rank or time on the front page.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by cfadvan on Thursday April 19, 2018 @07:44AM (#16875013)
I’m ok with this, the new article is unquestionably a better source.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by nashashmi on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:53PM (#16872554)
First time I have seen that happen. The comment posting timing has been reset unfortunately.
Re:No boundaries for Facebook data: third-party trackers abu... by fjsolwmv on Thursday April 19, 2018 @12:55AM (#16873422)
That's a bizarre analogy that doesn't add anything more than the description of Facebook you already gave. Is their a teen movie cliche I'm unaware of?