It even goes further than your request for an opt-out. All data collection must be opt-in, and opt-in requests must be written in such a way that your users can understand them.
Opt-out in combination with not ”providing consumers recourse after their data has been collected” is especially dangerous. Extreme example: application X installs a keylogger, and sends all your keystrokes to evilEmpire.com. Would you consider that to be OK, as long as there is an opt-out button? Would you be OK if evilEmpire.com kept the keystrokes it collected before you opted out?
Under a GDPR-like system where the purposes of data collection were specified as only fulfilling that core offering, you'd get a pretty good guarantee that it wouldn't be used for personalised marketing etc. Yet on my reading of this system, it'd be a class D since this data could potentially be used for targeted marketing.
But I stand by the general sentiment of empowering users to decide and telling them in plain language the reasons why their data is being collected.
That's exactly what the GDPR does. You can use the data for other purposes (e.g. marketing) as long as you request for that specific permission in "clear and plain language".
Citing the text:
"The principle of transparency requires that any information and communication relating to the processing of those personal data be easily accessible and easy to understand, and that clear and plain language be used."
I'm fine with a smart speaker securely storing my voice data in the cloud to provide me with personalised speech recognition. I'm not OK with that data being sold to a fraudster who wants to phone my bank and impersonate me. If you classify based on data collection alone, then both these scenarios would result in a "class D" rating.
Student clubs (yes, the GDPR applies to them, too, even if they are 100% volunteer run) that want to keep address info of past members for communicating with alumni, for example, have to make that opt-in.
“necessary for running the business” has some gray areas. For example, an athletics club will want to keep a list of club records, photos of past victories, etc. That’s something that is allowed as “necessary for being a sports club”. I don’t know whether there’s any case history on this)
Class A = 100% of retail cost
Class B = 75% of retail cost
Class C = 50% of retail cost
Class D = free
I'm convinced that the vast majority of those outraged by today's data collection practices will conveniently direct their ire to some other cause when faced with the possibility of actually having to pay for the services they've gotten used to having for free.
I have written more about this here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16351892
Maybe this is how the whole web-based fee structure should have been setup in the first place but it's not the current deal we have in place. How difficult will it be to shift an entire industry (and consumer mindset) to a vastly different fee structure?
Since they do such a terrible job of it anyway I can't imagine it being less profitable.
And then again, maybe actually paying for something like facebook is the right way to go.
Because that would provide an easy way out of the whole sitation. Just make the price ridiculously high, and all users will choose the free, your-data-belongs-to-us version.
It could actually be an eye-opener for many people. Most middle-class tech people would probably happily pay $10+ a month for the service Facebook provides, but if its something like $70 then Facebook is either scarily good at monetizing their information or unreasonably pricing the service.
On the flip side, you shouldn't be allowed to undercharge for the cost of a private membership. Transparency is good, let users be part of the free market for their data and make informed consent.
- big corporations which do collect the data will lawyer up and still collect data they do
- small companies will do whatever they can do and they will bet that enforcement is going to be sparse
- the enforcement will be non-existent
So nothing will change. The GDPR will not improve privacy, not improve users knowledge who is collecting what, will give false sense of privacy for some users, etc.
And ”enforcement will be nonexistent”, from a EU that has a history of taking on big companies on, say, cartel cases (http://ec.europa.eu/competition/cartels/cases/cases.html) or antitrust cases (http://ec.europa.eu/competition/antitrust/cases/)? Would you take that bet, again at percents of your global revenue?
The problem with tax law is the following:
- big corporations will lawyer up and still dodge taxes
- small companies will do whatever they can do and they will bet that enforcement is going to be sparse
- the enforcement will be non-existent
I don't know if you meant to do so, but you seem to be arguing governments are incapable of enforcing law against companies.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-google-antitrust/eu-fi...
Microsoft fined by European Commission over web browser
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-21684329
Apple ordered to pay €13bn after EU rules Ireland broke state aid laws
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2016/aug/30/apple-pay-b...
EU fines Facebook 110 million euros over WhatsApp deal
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-eu-facebook-antitrust-idU...
Europe is probably having a more functioning government than the US.
> Hell, where are the politicians who even have multiple words to say about privacy?
In the vein of Manufacturing Consent - the elites in the US are not split on the topic so there is no discussion. Larger companies, especially in SV, run on private data.
Of course, at the expense of privacy, but I'm still wearing my devil's hat here for a moment. And I would go as far as saying people by and large don't care as much about privacy as they do about cost, or getting free stuff (e.g. Facebook).
People won’t be immersed in something that doesn’t bring them value. Some products would make money from users by showing them ads, others would ask those users to pay. Both would want to create immersive experience in my opinion. I would even argue that less immersive experience (getting bored or distracted) leads to ad clicks. Whereas a service that charges wants to keep users truly engaged.
But let’s replace immersed with “enjoy using” or for it to be clear and intuitive. Some product designers and UI experts don’t need usage data, but I think a lot benefit from it to create a better and more enjoyable and clear user experience.
The rest of the apps - the less screen time they get, the better they're. I don't want to be "immersed" in Spotify. I want to find music I want and be done with it.
There's little to help UI design in data. Best way is watching your users (or at least using eye-tracker) and then talking to them. Looking at cold data, you never know why somebody took that long at certain step or kept clicking around. Why did they click wrong button - is it wrong color/positioning, unclear label or they just changed their mind? It's hard to know when users are annoyed or when it's stressful for them either.
Meanwhile data is great if you want to do shoot-in-the-dark A/B testing. Which is good to optimise for "more links clicked". But not so much for relaxed user happily doing his task in quickest way possible.
Class A - no data collection
Class B - anonymized statistics for diagnostics that cannot be used for marketing
Class C - anonymized usage statistics that can be used in aggregate
Class D - Targeted collection that can be used for targeted marketing
Consumers should have the explicit right to opt out of any and all data collection without risk of impairing the primary function of a device. For example there is no reason a TV should need to be anything beyond class A (maybe B). A smart speaker on the other hand needs to be a B maybe C. Nothing should need to be a class D.