But I stand by the general sentiment of empowering users to decide and telling them in plain language the reasons why their data is being collected.
That's exactly what the GDPR does. You can use the data for other purposes (e.g. marketing) as long as you request for that specific permission in "clear and plain language".
Citing the text:
"The principle of transparency requires that any information and communication relating to the processing of those personal data be easily accessible and easy to understand, and that clear and plain language be used."
I'm fine with a smart speaker securely storing my voice data in the cloud to provide me with personalised speech recognition. I'm not OK with that data being sold to a fraudster who wants to phone my bank and impersonate me. If you classify based on data collection alone, then both these scenarios would result in a "class D" rating.
Under a GDPR-like system where the purposes of data collection were specified as only fulfilling that core offering, you'd get a pretty good guarantee that it wouldn't be used for personalised marketing etc. Yet on my reading of this system, it'd be a class D since this data could potentially be used for targeted marketing.