News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by walterbell on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:32PM (#16774542)
Which languages have fewer vowels than English?
Re:Great Vowel Shift by nohat00 on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:53PM (#16775501)
Pretty much all of them. http://phonetic-blog.blogspot.com/2010/11/vowel-inventories.... says that the average number of vowels in a language is just below 6, and "large" vowel inventories are of size 7-14.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by 1maginary on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:55PM (#16774798)
Off the top of my head, most romance languages. You could argue some German dialects as well, Japanese, etc.

Maybe even Chinese depending on your definition of 'vowel'. Are you talking phonemes or actual phones?

English has ~17 vowels, which isn't the most a language has, but that's quite a few

Re:Great Vowel Shift by lifthrasiir on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:33PM (#16774562)
For starters, Japanese has five [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_phonology#Vowels

Re:Great Vowel Shift by lhorie on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:47PM (#16774717)
What about や (ya), ゆ (yu), よ (yo), わ (wa), ー (dash)?
Re:Great Vowel Shift by eecsninja on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:58PM (#16774835)
Those are modifications of existing vowels, or diphthongs.

E.g. し(shi) + や(ya) = しゃ (sha), still the same 'a' sound.

English has only 5 vowel characters but more than 5 vowel sounds.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by lhorie on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:27PM (#16775181)
I mean the weak `i` in や. きや (ki-ya, as in sukiyaki) sounds different than きゃ (kya, as in "argh"), similar to how "meow" can be pronounced /miˈaʊ̯/ or /mjaʊ̯/
Re:Great Vowel Shift by gizmo686 on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:16PM (#16776475)
I believe the sound you identify as a weak `i` is the IPA sound /j/.

This is not an unreasonably connection to make. /j/ is the semivowel corresponding to /i/. Essentially, /j/ is what happens if you produce /i/ with just enough constriction that it no longer is classified as a vowel.

It is not apriori unreasonable to consider semivowels as vowels. However, linguistics has (mostly) reached the conclusion that semivowels are best characterized as consonants.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by lhorie on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:46PM (#16776728)
That's really interesting. Does that mean then that the i in words like pai and イェス is classified as a consonant? I've seen ヴ - a variation of ウ (u) to simulate v, but had never thought of i as a potential consonant.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by gizmo686 on Friday April 06, 2018 @05:13PM (#16777503)
I would need to hear a native speaker say them to be sure.

With my untrained ear, I have heard Japanese speakers use the diphthong /aɪ/ and the vowel sequence /a.i/ interchangeably. However, I suspect they are actually always pronouncing it as /a.i/, and I am just not good at distinguishing it.

I they were to try and pronounce pie using the closest approximation available with Japanese phonetics, I suspect they will settle on /pa.i/, in which case it is a real /i/.

If they were to pronounce it as /paj/, then Japanese photostatic would require adding a vowel at the end, likely giving us /paju/, which is not what we get.

イェス (yes) is a bit more difficult to predict. Japanese does have all of the sounds nessasary to pronounce /jɛs/ without modification. The syllable structure would require the addition of a vowel at the end, giving us /jɛsu/. However, as far as I am aware, Japanese does does have the /jɛ/ sequence for some reason. The question is, how bad is the /jɛ/ sequence to Japanese speakers? If it is just a historical artifact that /jɛ/ doesn't occur in Japanese, then they should have no problem pronouncing /jɛs/ as such, in which case the イ would be the consonant /j/. However is /jɛ/ is actually a bad sequence, then it would be changed into its closest approximation, which would be /i.ɛ/, in which case イ is the normal vowel /i/.

Based on the spelling (in particular the small ェ), they are at least trying to be faithful to the original English; as /i.ɛ/ has a perfectly normal spelling as イエ.

To take a simmilar example from English. Consider the name "Juan" (ʒɒn). English speakers can typically pronounce this, but it sounds foreign, because English does not allow /ʒ/ to occur in the begining of a word. If they were to pronounce it the English way, they would get "John" (ʤɒn).

Further, I suspect that the only reason English speakers can pronounce "Juan" so easily is exposure. I had a Brazilian Portuguese teacher (eg. a linguistics teacher whose native language is Brazilian Portuguese), whose name also begins with ʒ, but everyone pronounces it as "ʤ" and (it my experience), it was difficult to even understand what his name was until he pronounced it the with ʤ.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by khedoros1 on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:49PM (#16778173)
> However, as far as I am aware, Japanese does does have the /jɛ/ sequence for some reason.

I'm stretching a little bit, because I've looked into this in idle curiosity before.

The only connection I can think of is the brand "Ebisu", written "ヱビス", and sometimes romanized to "Yebisu". The character itself seems to be from a historical "we" kana, and I'm not sure of the reason for that.

Oh, and there's an archaic hiragana (but no katakana equivalent?) for "ye" (/jɛ/): 𛀁.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by mnemonicsloth on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:34PM (#16778093)
I’ve always thought of linguistics as a kind of human superpower. How much training have you had?
Re:Great Vowel Shift by gizmo686 on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:17PM (#16778332)
Just undergrad. I've also avoided phonology as much as possible, so I only have 1 semester of that. The only training in transcription was the phonetics section of the intro course (which consisted of only easy English transcriptions)
Re:Great Vowel Shift by Nadya on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:44PM (#16775390)
きゃ is not きや as in "kiya" but きゃ as in "kya" - the i in き becomes silent, きや would be something else. For example, 東京 isn't pronounced「とうきよう」but 「とうきょう」.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by amyjess on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:11PM (#16777931)
Oddly enough, it's been my observation that in きゃ and ぎゃ, the /a/ sound is considerably fronted compared to other syllables. It's usually realized as the central vowel [ä], but in these two, it's often fronted to [a]. This is why these syllables are used to render English words containing /kæ/ into Japanese, such as "cannon" (キャノン kyanon) or "cat" (キャット kyatto). Contrast with "cut" (カット katto) or "car" (カー kā).

Japanese has some interesting allophones. I also find the allophones in the Z-row fascinating as well ([z] and [d͡z] are allophones in free variation).

Re:Great Vowel Shift by lhorie on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:22PM (#16775864)
Right, Japanese has both /iˈ/ and /j/ sounds. Another example that happens outside the や column is イェス (yes).
Re:Great Vowel Shift by chadlavi on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:59PM (#16776288)
this is just because of the shift of historical "ヱ" ("ye") getting pronounced as "エ" ("e") then just not used anymore. They're using "イ" as a semivowel here, /j/, not as the vowel /i/.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by itsameta4 on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:55PM (#16776226)
Japanese de-voices vowels in certain contexts adjacent to voiceless consonants. The weakness you're describing is the lack of voicing (vocal cords vibrating).
Re:Great Vowel Shift by gizmo686 on Friday April 06, 2018 @03:11PM (#16776418)
The きや きゃ (kiya, kya) distinction is not a phonological alternation. For instance, we have ぎゃく (gyaku), despite the fact that /g/ and /y/ are both voiced.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by itsameta4 on Friday April 06, 2018 @04:11PM (#16776947)
I'm aware of this, however he specifically mentioned a weak sound in "sukiyaki" which is due to de-voicing the /i/.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by zodiac on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:24PM (#16775895)
I think that /j/ sound is classified as a consonant, not a vowel
Re:Great Vowel Shift by gizmo686 on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:37PM (#16776034)
/j/ is a semivowel. Generally, these are classified and behave as consonants, but their vowel-like behavior still creeps in sometimes.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by lhorie on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:39PM (#16776062)
Really? That's weird. It's the same /j/ sound as in portuguese pai[1] (/paj/) and it's unequivocally a vowel there.

[1] https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/portuguese-engl...

Re:Great Vowel Shift by gizmo686 on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:53PM (#16776213)
Is it?

I just did a brief search, and found this paper [0], which includes a phonological inventory of Brazillian Portuguese. It lists /j/ as a consonant.

[0] http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0023830902045002...

Re:Great Vowel Shift by dredmorbius on Monday April 09, 2018 @06:37AM (#16791827)
NB: I've finally addressed a request for clarification from a couple of weeks back:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16687856

Re:Great Vowel Shift by mcv on Friday April 06, 2018 @06:31PM (#16778074)
> English has only 5 vowel characters but more than 5 vowel sounds.

So what are we counting here? The sounds or the characters we use to represent the sounds? Because if you go by sounds, I think Dutch has more than 14.

(a, aa, o, oo, e, è, ee, u, uu, i, ie, eu, ui, au, ij, oe)

I've heard that in Czech, the 'r' can be a vowel. In a name like Brno, for example. Those are apparently two syllables. (I don't speak Czech, so no idea if it's true.)

Re:Great Vowel Shift by jcranmer on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:06PM (#16775665)
English is on the heavier side of vowels, although much of it is diphthongs.

The "standard" vowel system is 5 basic vowels (vaguely an a, e, i, o, u, although not as English tends to pronounce those), although some languages (e.g., most American languages) have only 3 or 4. Many languages have a few more monophthongs. English has an additional mid a/e sound, an additional i sound, and another few more u's. There's also the unstressed vowel (aka schwa), and a couple of diphthongs.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by thedirt0115 on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:14PM (#16775016)
Tagalog/Filipino (the national language of the Philippines) has 5, very similar pronunciation to vowels in Spanish.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by bassman9000 on Friday April 06, 2018 @12:45PM (#16774690)
Spanish has five. Period. No exceptions. And crystal clear.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by egwynn on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:43PM (#16775373)
1. You deserve my downvote for claiming “no exceptions” in a linguistic matter.

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_phonology#Exact_number...

    There is no agreement among scholars on how many vowel
    allophones Spanish has.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by thaumasiotes on Friday April 06, 2018 @11:57PM (#16779295)
Allophones are not a great thing to cite in a dispute over how many vowels a language has. Unless you know you're in a context where people are talking about allophones specifically, no one will care.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by spanxx on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:49PM (#16775450)
Frontera tour link:

> According to Eugenio Martínez Celdrán, however, systematic classification of Spanish allophones is impossible due to the fact that their occurrence varies from speaker to speaker and from region to region. According to him, the exact degree of openness of Spanish vowels depends not so much on the phonetic environment, but rather on various external factors accompanying speech.

So parent point stands. That's my opinion as well as a Spaniard.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by ithkuil on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:25PM (#16778393)
"no exceptions" sounds like the focus is on rules, in particular on orthography (correct writing). It's easy to ban exceptions if you make the rules. This is the realm of prescriptive linguistics.

The very fact that there are individuals and whole group of people who actually talk differently can, has been, and still often is dismissed as either ignorance, class, personal idiosincrasies, ...

There is a different way at looking at the thing: observing it objectively as other things in nature. This descriptive linguistics is endlessly fascinating to me, as it's less infected by human desires that have nothing to do with linguistics and all to do with politics.

An example of where those two viewpoints begin to present reality in a quite different way and yet don't require to be a trained linguist to grasp it is the definition of where a dialect ends and a language begins.

Re:Great Vowel Shift by nohat00 on Friday April 06, 2018 @01:50PM (#16775466)
Well, except for the 14 diphthongs and the fact that /e/ and /o/ are more like /ɛ/ and /ɔ/ in certain closed syllables. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_phonology#Vowels
Re:Great Vowel Shift by kolpa on Friday April 06, 2018 @02:31PM (#16775963)
Those diphthongs have the same sound as combining the sounds of the two letters used to spell them, though.
Re:Great Vowel Shift by DonaldPShimoda on Friday April 06, 2018 @07:22PM (#16778371)
The sounds may be similar, but they are not identical. Diphthongs are considered to be single segments phonologically, and some pronunciation changes can occur in "blending" the component parts together.

But I'm not sure I would go so far as to say all of the diphthongs should be counted as separate "vowels" in the language.