News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by Veedrac on Sunday April 01, 2018 @07:10PM (#16731071)
Meta rant: I would like people to remind themselves that HN's rules explicitly disallow shallow dismissals. Unfortunately this comment section seems to be nothing but.

The material science behind high temperature semiconductors has undergone radical changes in recent years. The techniques being used are largely well understood science and the downsides of previous approaches like ITER are explicitly avoided. There has been a visible explosion of commercial activity in recent years.

People bander around the "always 20 years away" moniker as if we should put today's estimates on the same grounds as the guesses from those early 1970s projects that were never even properly funded. People were not screaming "20 years more" at the turn of the century.

You don't get to discount something as potentially groundbreaking as this just because it's taken a little while to get here. Either put up or shut up. I would love to hear genuine substantive conversations here, if people were willing to have them.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by annywhey on Sunday April 01, 2018 @07:36PM (#16731178)
I can offer some economic perspective. Oftentimes the critical advance for technology to reach deployment is not a theoretical breakthrough in the primary science but rather a change in aggregate costs, ability to organize capital, secondary technologies, etc. It's stuff that pushes the tech past a threshold of feasibility. The Industrial Revolution itself, for example, was a mix of recent breakthroughs and older ones that started to be realized enmasse(e.g. coal mining and steam engines co-evolved during the 1700's).

So when researchers say, "this supporting piece of the puzzle has gotten much easier," as it is with the new magnets described in the article, that's actually a good time to listen since it might be the tipping point. Theory developments or experimental observations are exciting stories to read about but often have less imminent bearing on whether you're going to see it impact your life.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by alehul on Sunday April 01, 2018 @09:03PM (#16731510)
Could you recommend any resources (articles, books, podcasts, etc.) that go into more detail on the economic factors that come together to enable periods such as the Industrial Revolution, or really any period?

I think economics offers a great perspective to subscribe to, but haven't found much opportunity to learn it. Most "economics" podcasts are really just business-focused and describe modern events with little insight into the economics behind it.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by brownbat on Sunday April 01, 2018 @10:10PM (#16731785)
The best fast and fun one is "How We Got Here" by Kessler, I think it's free if you send an email. Draws a really clever line of related inventions from swords to microchips.

Specific areas after that...

"Brilliant" by Brox on the history of lighting.

"Salt" by Kurlansky.

"The Master Switch" by Wu on telecoms and broadcasting.

"Ascent of Money" by Ferguson has some critics, but it's got some great historical anecdotes on the history of financial tools, like fractional reserves and insurance, weirdly captivating.

Those are all economic history... If you really want a pop intro to econ principles, maybe Planet Money? Pretty much everyone should listen to Planet Money anyway, it's just great radio.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by anadem on Sunday April 01, 2018 @10:40PM (#16731904)
Here's Kessler's excellent How We Got Here (pdf): http://www.andykessler.com/andy_kessler/excerpts/How_We_Got_...
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by dmix on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:03PM (#16736474)
I gave Planet Money a shot but found the two hosts nearly unbearable and the typical NPR heavy-handed production and jumpy editing distracting.

They try so desperately to make the topics sound fun/accessible that it ends up sounding like a disingenuous forced comedic act rather than a natural, education conversation with the guests...I guess I'm not the target audience for this.

But I love the book recommendations. I plan to read that Kessler book tonight.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by antgne on Tuesday April 03, 2018 @08:58PM (#16750928)
You might be interested in the book "The most Powerful Idea in the World" by William Rosen.

It's common to point to technological advancements such as steam which gave way to the Industrial Revolution, that Britain had coal etc. And that's definitely important because steam powered factories which was a major change from household/hand/craft businesses.

In truth there were many contributing factors. But why Britain? Why was this the place where all these inventions were being made? Some historians get very creative in additional reasons for how this era came to be. Rosen makes the really interesting claim that it was the idea of intellectual property that triggered all the inventing-- that man could own an idea and make money from it!

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by TheCowboy on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:20AM (#16732300)
I thought Douglass North's textbook on economic history was useful when I studied it in school, and he likely has a lot of other articles and books you can pick and choose from. He died in 2015 but was quite prolific and won the Nobel prize. I have the last book he co-authored on my shelf that I still need to read.

I think he's most known for his work in the role of institutions (which I think helps elucidate the "economic factors that come together" part of your curiosity): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglass_North#Institutions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_institutional_economics

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by gerdesj on Sunday April 01, 2018 @07:51PM (#16731239)
I've had a quick shufti through the comments so far and I don't see too many "20 years" and anyway the meme was always 50 years. That said, I am with you - I think the 20, 25, 50 memes are badly wrong.

"People were not screaming "20 years more" at the turn of the century." - which century? I went to school in Oxfordshire, UK (later half of the 1980s) and studied physics to A level and went on a field trip or two to the local nuclear fusion project.

I clearly remember being told by everyone there how progress was measured. It seemed to boil down to a chart with time on the x axis and factors away from sustainable fusion on y. This may have been a "lies to children". The chart looked like an exponential decay with a rather wobbly tail starting in the late or so 1970s back then.

There is a good reason for the 20/25/50 years meme. It's the best model we have had for progress for a very long time. I will be ecstatic to get my 'leccy from nuclear fusion in my life time and unimpressed if my grand daughter is still waiting.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by ggm on Monday April 02, 2018 @02:02AM (#16732650)
As a serial offender, I think you're right to say this but there is the other side of the coin. Fusion is littered with giant claims, and huge funding holes. Skunk works are very cool but it's as far from contestable science as it's possible to be: the skunkworks doesn't want to be put underneath a critical microscope because its looking for exploitable trade secrets and patent material.

Groundbreaking is usually overused. How many genuinely groundbreaking things emerge from press releases as opposed to deep investment by state backed actors? Seriously, Edison (for instance) was a wizard at commercial applications but frankly useless as a scientist.

I call Leo Szilard groundbreaking. He really did have a flash of insight.

Crispr didn't just happen. It took a shedload of prior work. FMRI is groundbreaking except they're all walking back from the pop sci stories into more fundamental tests.

So is this stuff really worth substantial conversation? Who is going to invest in chatter here? MIT and Lockheed won't, for obvious reasons. And I doubt jet or iter scientists will, for other obvious reasons. Who is left who would meet your criteria?

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by MR4D on Sunday April 01, 2018 @10:04PM (#16731763)
May I quote from the end of the article:

“Prof Wilson was also cautious about the timeframe, saying that while the project was exciting he couldn’t see how it would achieve its goal of putting energy on the grid within 15 years.”

That’s deep enough for me.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by saudioger on Sunday April 01, 2018 @11:27PM (#16732078)
> he couldn’t see how it would achieve its goal of putting energy on the grid within 15 years.”

but in 16 years tho... maybe

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by godelski on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:33AM (#16732358)
>People bander around the "always 20 years away" moniker as if we should put today's estimates on the same grounds as the guesses from those early 1970s projects that were never even properly funded. People were not screaming "20 years more" at the turn of the century.

Well I think people have great reason to be skeptical. I hear "Fusion is around the corner" at least once a year. Usually it is by smaller companies but every once in awhile it is the bigger ones.

So let's look at the big one. In late 2014 LOCKHEED MARTIN announced that their compact fusion device would be demonstrated in a few years and have an operational prototype by 2019 [1]. Even Scott Manley has the top comment on that video as ""high risk" = we don't actually have it working, but there's a chance we could." Even in the video suggests it wouldn't get onto the grid by 2034 (20 years from their announcement).

So maybe you're right, it isn't 20 years away, only 16. Which serendipitously lines up with the 15 years claimed in the FIRST SENTENCE. Which is then given many asterisks at the end and doubted by the lead scientist.

TLDR: People band around "it is 20 years away" because experts are still saying "it is 20 years away." (including this article)

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlYClniDFkM

End note: That being said, I don't want to downplay the improvements. We are SIGNIFICANTLY closer than we were in the 80's/90's. Several of the major problems have been improved upon. And I do think I will see fusion on the grid in my lifetime. More so, I really think it will happen within 20-30 years.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by appleflaxen on Monday April 02, 2018 @08:14AM (#16733879)
I agree with you regarding shallow dismissals, provided the claims are deep to start with.

In this case, we start with a headline that the most transformative technology since combustion is just around the corner.

The basis for that claim? That they are going to create an experimental reactor using new high-temp superconductors.

Well ok, great. But this is just a lame press release about how somebody HOPES it will work. It's not even a technical argument: it's basically a business argument, using currently available technology. Just the nuclear power version of the "suits" article that comes around every year, and that PG called out in 2005 [1]

So what, exactly, can a person substantively say against /this/ piece? I would argue: practically nothing. The best points raised by others relate to fusion in general, which we could have had without this submarine PR piece.

1. http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by sunstone on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:31AM (#16732353)
High temperature semiconductors and high temperature superconductors are quite different things.
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by brudgers on Sunday April 01, 2018 @10:22PM (#16731831)
My father was 14 when Ivy Mike blasted Elugelab below sea level. In 1982, I took my first college course. We read Herman Kahn's The Next 200 Years. Tokamaks were promising. I shared my seventeen year old enthusiasm for the fusion future with him. He introduced me to "Always twenty years in the future." He'll be 80 next month. The article's optimistic 15 years is 2033. For Dad, that would put it just over four "Twenty years in the future." For me, it would only be two-and-a-half. Sure there's a reasonable chance that the "always" in "always twenty years in the future" will be wrong some day. I'm skeptical this is that day because the basis for today's prediction is that the future is just like the present only more so. The article is a press release not science.

The just-over-the-horizon timeframe normally cited is 30 years, but the MIT team believe they can halve this by using new superconducting materials to produce ultra-powerful magnets, one of the main components of a fusion reactor.

Halving the just-over-the-horizon number isn't progress. It's marketing.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by tutanchamun on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:20AM (#16734217)
> The techniques being used are largely well understood science and the downsides of previous approaches like ITER are explicitly avoided.

I'm a layman when it comes to these things, but does that mean they have improved tokamak's or will future nuclear fusion reactors more look like the stellarator used in Wendelstein 7-X for example?

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by dekhn on Monday April 02, 2018 @09:26AM (#16734251)
Actually, you can easilly discount this, since they haven't run the experiment yet. Until that happens it should be fully discounted. Happy to pay attention when the experiment is run.
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by Ice_cream_suit on Monday April 02, 2018 @05:24AM (#16733306)
Semiconductors and superconductors are very different beasts.
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by cctt23 on Sunday April 01, 2018 @07:38PM (#16731187)
Unsolved problems for fusion as powerplant:

-Sputtering of shielding and every other part of the reactor from fast neutrons. If your reactor is becoming brittle as it’s in operation, and requires constant maintenance, it won’t be operating enough to be cost effective.

-Breeding blankets. If we’re not breeding tritium in the blanket (and no one has been able to sustain a reaction that way yet) then we’re just using fission a lot. Expense becomes an issue, as does radiological issues.

-The plasma diverter is very much an unsolved problem. I can get into more detail here, but in short this is the part of the reactor that “skims” some of the hot plasma off to do the work. The dynamics of very hot, magnetically constrained plasmas still escapes us, and when you throw a rock into that stream, the complexity increases. Current divertes wouldn’t last a day in an operating plant. Disassembling your whole plant every day and reassembling it is a non-starter.

-Containment of plasma at sufficient energies is still something measured in seconds, or fractions of seconds. The usual metaphor is trying to uniformly squeeze a balloon; it will just “squirt” out. For s research reactor a second or two of fusion is an achievement. For power generation it’s nothing.

-Neutron activation of otherwise inert materials means you’re going to have serious radioactive waste. It’s unclear just how dirty D-T fusion would be from soup to nuts, but “pretty dirty” seems like a good bet.

-Tritium penetration.

-Most of the energy produced is in the form of neutrons, and we don’t know how to use that as a source of power. Those neutrons, in addition to destroying the reactor itself and activating materials, represent a loss.

-What we really need is aneutronic fusion through alternative cycles to D-T, like p-p, but that’s a much hotter plasma and no one has a clue how to make it work yet.

-Coolant for a constantly running reactor is a boring, but unsolved problem.

There’s more, but these are the ones most poeple on HN probably are aware of when they dismiss this article.

Some further reading https://thebulletin.org/fusion-reactors-not-what-they’re-cra...

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by DennisP on Sunday April 01, 2018 @08:43PM (#16731432)
I spent several hours watching MIT's presentations about this reactor design.

- The inner wall of the reactor is 3D-printed and replaced annually. This is easy because they've found they can make joints in the superconducting tape that add very little resistance, allowing them to include hinges letting them open the reactor.

- Surrounding the inner wall is FLiBe molten salt. It's heated by the neutron radiation, acts as coolant for the thermal cycle, and as the breeding blanket (each high-energy neutron releasing two neutrons from impact with beryllium, providing plenty of neutrons for breeding tritium from lithium). Having a liquid blanket makes tritium harvesting easier.

- Stronger magnetic fields damp down plasma instabilities, making containment easier. For years MIT has been running the Alcator C-Mod, which has more powerful fields than any other tokamak in the world, so they have some direct experience here.

- The neutron-activated wastes would only need containment for several decades.

(I don't know anything about the diverter, and I'm interested if you want to get into more detail.)

The MIT folks argue that we understand tokamak plasmas much better than any other configuration, and have gotten far closer to breakeven than alternative designs, so that's where we should focus.

However, there are some projects working on aneutronic fusion, mainly with p-B11. The biggest project is Tri Alpha, with $500M invested. They've achieved stable plasma at 10M degrees, and are about to start testing a new reactor which should reach 100M degrees. If the plasma continues working as the expect, they think it's a straightforward path to a production reactor; of course there could be surprises.

Another approach is laser fusion with petawatt picosecond lasers. We're not far off from having a laser with the specs to attempt this, and these lasers improve by a factor of ten every three years.

Helion, funded by YCombinator, is attempting a hybrid D-D/D-He3 reaction. (The output of D-D is half He3, and half tritium which decays to He3 with a 12-year half-life.) They say the hybrid reaction would release only 6% of its energy as neutron radiation. I don't know how it's going though.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by ISL on Sunday April 01, 2018 @07:47PM (#16731217)
The waste problem from neutron activation is beginning to get the publicity it deserves in both articles and in comments like the parent's.

Fusion is advertised as a clean power-generation technology, but it will, in general, have its own radioactive-waste disposal problems.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by tigershark on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:28AM (#16732529)
It’s still a couple of orders of magnitude or more better (in terms of half life of the byproducts). So if anyone knowingly compares fission waste and fusion waste putting them on the same plane is simply lying.
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by cctt23 on Monday April 02, 2018 @01:37PM (#16736891)
Or they recognize that for a human and generations of their descendants, 30,000 or 300 years doesn’t change anything for them. Either way it’s longer than the US has been a country for one metric. Both cases require similar solutions, long-term containment, and so both run into the same political inertia fielded by NIMBYism.

To claim otherwise is, as you would have it, lying.

More importantly, both are solved issues from a purely technical standpoint, it’s just that everyone wants someone else to deal with it. As a bonus, we can actually use fission to produce energy, right now. There’s no issue of, “it will be great when...” grid storage is solved along with intermittency for renewables. There’s no, “it will be great when...” fusion is producing energy rather than heavily parasitizing from the grid. There’s no waiting until we’re completely screwed by climate change effects.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by cctt23 on Sunday April 01, 2018 @07:49PM (#16731227)
And if we’re willing to deal with that waste, then we already have a viable source of atomic energy from fission! The future is whenever we decide to deal with the problem instead of leaving it pools or casks to solve itself.

@csallen: Be willing to actually dispose of it. We need to commit the money and political will to set up a single disposal site. Right now it’s a NIMBY nightmare so we get the worst outcome.

Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by csallen on Sunday April 01, 2018 @08:20PM (#16731347)
Curious what you mean by "deal with" it. Somehow make it non-radioactive, or improve our disposal techniques, or what?
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by pasabagi on Sunday April 01, 2018 @09:02PM (#16731506)
I think the tradition is to dump it off the coast of Somalia.
Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient... by arcticbull on Sunday April 01, 2018 @11:54PM (#16732190)
My thinking is more around using thorium cycle nuclear reactors which consume almost all their input material [1].

1T of thorium produces the same amount of energy as 35T of uranium or 4166000T of coal. 83% of the waste products are inert, and 17% require only 300 years to reach background levels of radiation. Much safer than uranium cycle too.

This technology is very promising IMO, though given the general attitude people have towards nuclear, it's not surprising it is underdeveloped, more research is needed.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_fluoride_thorium_reacto...