Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient...
by godelski on Monday April 02, 2018 @12:33AM
(#16732358)
>People bander around the "always 20 years away" moniker as if we should put today's estimates on the same grounds as the guesses from those early 1970s projects that were never even properly funded. People were not screaming "20 years more" at the turn of the century.
Well I think people have great reason to be skeptical. I hear "Fusion is around the corner" at least once a year. Usually it is by smaller companies but every once in awhile it is the bigger ones.
So let's look at the big one. In late 2014 LOCKHEED MARTIN announced that their compact fusion device would be demonstrated in a few years and have an operational prototype by 2019 [1]. Even Scott Manley has the top comment on that video as ""high risk" = we don't actually have it working, but there's a chance we could." Even in the video suggests it wouldn't get onto the grid by 2034 (20 years from their announcement).
So maybe you're right, it isn't 20 years away, only 16. Which serendipitously lines up with the 15 years claimed in the FIRST SENTENCE. Which is then given many asterisks at the end and doubted by the lead scientist.
TLDR: People band around "it is 20 years away" because experts are still saying "it is 20 years away." (including this article)
End note: That being said, I don't want to downplay the improvements. We are SIGNIFICANTLY closer than we were in the 80's/90's. Several of the major problems have been improved upon. And I do think I will see fusion on the grid in my lifetime. More so, I really think it will happen within 20-30 years.
Well I think people have great reason to be skeptical. I hear "Fusion is around the corner" at least once a year. Usually it is by smaller companies but every once in awhile it is the bigger ones.
So let's look at the big one. In late 2014 LOCKHEED MARTIN announced that their compact fusion device would be demonstrated in a few years and have an operational prototype by 2019 [1]. Even Scott Manley has the top comment on that video as ""high risk" = we don't actually have it working, but there's a chance we could." Even in the video suggests it wouldn't get onto the grid by 2034 (20 years from their announcement).
So maybe you're right, it isn't 20 years away, only 16. Which serendipitously lines up with the 15 years claimed in the FIRST SENTENCE. Which is then given many asterisks at the end and doubted by the lead scientist.
TLDR: People band around "it is 20 years away" because experts are still saying "it is 20 years away." (including this article)
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UlYClniDFkM
End note: That being said, I don't want to downplay the improvements. We are SIGNIFICANTLY closer than we were in the 80's/90's. Several of the major problems have been improved upon. And I do think I will see fusion on the grid in my lifetime. More so, I really think it will happen within 20-30 years.