Re:Nuclear fusion on brink of being realised, say MIT scient...
by ggm on Monday April 02, 2018 @02:02AM
(#16732650)
As a serial offender, I think you're right to say this but there is the other side of the coin. Fusion is littered with giant claims, and huge funding holes. Skunk works are very cool but it's as far from contestable science as it's possible to be: the skunkworks doesn't want to be put underneath a critical microscope because its looking for exploitable trade secrets and patent material.
Groundbreaking is usually overused. How many genuinely groundbreaking things emerge from press releases as opposed to deep investment by state backed actors? Seriously, Edison (for instance) was a wizard at commercial applications but frankly useless as a scientist.
I call Leo Szilard groundbreaking. He really did have a flash of insight.
Crispr didn't just happen. It took a shedload of prior work. FMRI is groundbreaking except they're all walking back from the pop sci stories into more fundamental tests.
So is this stuff really worth substantial conversation? Who is going to invest in chatter here? MIT and Lockheed won't, for obvious reasons. And I doubt jet or iter scientists will, for other obvious reasons. Who is left who would meet your criteria?
Groundbreaking is usually overused. How many genuinely groundbreaking things emerge from press releases as opposed to deep investment by state backed actors? Seriously, Edison (for instance) was a wizard at commercial applications but frankly useless as a scientist.
I call Leo Szilard groundbreaking. He really did have a flash of insight.
Crispr didn't just happen. It took a shedload of prior work. FMRI is groundbreaking except they're all walking back from the pop sci stories into more fundamental tests.
So is this stuff really worth substantial conversation? Who is going to invest in chatter here? MIT and Lockheed won't, for obvious reasons. And I doubt jet or iter scientists will, for other obvious reasons. Who is left who would meet your criteria?