News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by Slartie on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:35AM (#16696907)
Now THAT explains a lot of that "she came from the shadows" and "a human driver could not have prevented this" and "The car didn't do anything wrong" bullcrap we've been reading from the Tempe Police right after the accident, as well as the quick release of the highly misleading (in terms of lighting situation) dashcam video.

Don't bite the hand that feeds you...

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by xvf22 on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @07:53AM (#16696982)
Yup, I was wondering why the police put up such a strong defence even before an investigation. I suppose this may explain at least some of that. I wonder if the post crash emails will ever come out.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by panarky on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:21PM (#16699052)
The Uber-Arizona story is the American economic-political dystopia in microcosm.

For-profit corporation helps elected politician maintain power.

Elected politician uses the power of the state to promote the corporation and eliminate oversight that would have been in the public interest.

All of this is done in secret, of course. The rubes who elected you don't need to know what their "representatives" are doing in their names.

The politician wins, the corporation wins, and the public is the big loser.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by shard972 on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @08:16AM (#16697083)
I'm not sure what you mean by don't bite the hand, I understand that the police would have a vested interested in defending uber but I couldn't imagine the police destroying their credability over some stupid little thing in the big scheme of things.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by jcranmer on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @08:55AM (#16697304)
I don't need to believe there was a conspiracy to protect Uber here. This spot apparently has a history of pedestrian crossing, and many police departments have a habit of assigning all blame to the pedestrian in a pedestrian/vehicle collision. This blame is reinforced by the driver's "evidence" (driver didn't see anything, but she wasn't looking) and the dashcam (can't see anything, but the quality is atrocious and not at all reflective of what most drivers would see).

One thing we should take away from this incident is that we need to seriously push back on immediate "pedestrian's fault" rulings when police make them after a pedestrian/vehicle collision. It was readily apparent within hours that the story didn't add up, but people only paid so much attention because it's the first such crash involving an autonomous vehicle.

The more interesting question is how that shockingly poor dashcam footage came to be. That quality is so poor that I find it hard to believe that Uber is actively using it as a sensor input. Hell, it's worse than most dashcams I've seen on Youtube...

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by mannykannot on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @09:40AM (#16697525)
I assume the poor dashcam footage came out because it fits the narrative they were all trying to push. I don't think there is any reason to believe it was the input to the driving system, but either way, it does not look good for Uber, and if it is apparently deliberately misleading, or, worse, has been tampered with, then that would take it to a new level.

The release of the interior shot might have been an attempt to throw the 'safety' driver under the bus, so to speak, and while her inattentiveness was a very serious matter, it also does not look good for Uber.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by scoggs on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:03PM (#16698849)
Yeah, they did not need to show the footage of her blatantly distracted away from the road. That was my biggest takeaway. I'm not sure who decided what footage got shown publicly but I immediately found that interesting to say the least.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by JKCalhoun on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @09:29PM (#16703812)
I thought it looked a bit like they were throwing their human backup driver under the bus as well. Not cool.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by JeremyBanks on Thursday March 29, 2018 @08:12AM (#16706311)
Why is it not cool?

Certainly Uber the company is systemically responsible for this failure, but the driver also had a role in preventing harm, and they were negligent. There's more than enough blame to share.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by cesarb on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @11:52AM (#16698704)
> That quality is so poor that I find it hard to believe that Uber is actively using it as a sensor input.

It probably isn't used as sensor input. It's probably an off-the-shelf dashcam (the cheapest they could find that could also record the driver) added as an afterthought. It also wouldn't surprise me if the windshield were tinted, which would make the dashcam recording even darker (since it's behind the windshield).

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by usefulcat on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:31PM (#16699167)
I don't know about AZ, but windshield tinting is usually illegal in TX, except (I believe) for certain newer methods of tinting that are designed to filter only IR frequencies. But I think those newer forms are also fairly rare. In any case, I definitely wouldn't assume the windshield was tinted.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by taylorexpander on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:38PM (#16699239)
You are severely mistaken. Window tinting is legal in AZ (resident) and a quick search tells me TX as well.

Maybe you’re thinking of the black out style tinting that you see in movies but most people tint to filter out like 5-20% light.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by c22 on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:19PM (#16700308)
Brief googling indicates that windshield tinting, beyond a small strip at the top, in both Arizona and Texas is illegal without medical exemption.

"Transparent material that is installed, affixed or applied to the topmost portion of the windshield if:

(a) The bottom edge of the material is at least twenty-nine inches above the undepressed driver's seat when measured from a point five inches in front of the bottom of the backrest with the driver's seat in its rearmost and lowermost position with the vehicle on a level surface.

(b) The material is not red or amber in color."[0]

and

"Windshields Sunscreening devices must be applied above the AS-1 line. If there is no AS-1 line, sunscreening devices must end five inches below the top of the windshield. Sunscreening devices may not be red, amber, or blue in color. Sunscreening devices, when measured in combination with the original glass, must have a light transmittance value of 25% or more. Sunscreening devices, when measured in combination with the original glass, must have a luminous reflectance value of 25% or less. A clear (un-tinted) UV film is allowed anywhere on the front windshield without a medical exemption being required."[1]

[0] https://www.azleg.gov/ars/28/00959-01.htm

[1] https://www.dps.texas.gov/rsd/vi/consumerinfo/windowTint.htm

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by Implicated on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:35PM (#16700448)
You're not making the distinction between "window tinting" and "windSHIELD tinting".

Big difference. I'm not aware of anywhere that it's legal to tint your windshield below the top 4-5 inches. (Not saying it isn't but it certainly isn't in AZ or TX)

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by cesarb on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:57PM (#16700666)
> I'm not aware of anywhere that it's legal to tint your windshield below the top 4-5 inches.

In my country, you can put a tinted film on the whole windshield, as long as it allows at least 75% of the light to pass (the side and rear windows can be much darker: the film must allow at least 28% of the light). They're a common sight.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by Slartie on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @08:32AM (#16697173)
Imagine the police people having seen their governor (who effectively is their boss, as far as I know, so he is the "hand that feeds them") repeatedly be very, very protective and favorable towards Uber and the self-driving car testing program. Even if they never got an explicit order of the likes of "Courteously close your eyes when dealing with Uber!", they will be much more protective of Uber than they were if their boss was known as very critical regarding Uber. This is basic human instinct, and instinctive behavior often leads to decisions which might turn out to be obviously stupid in the long run.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by ramblerman on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @09:32AM (#16697482)
This is extremely naive, have you ever worked in organizations?

I'm not being facetious, but a little top-down pressure can go a long way. This isn't about a grand conspiracy as much as it is about simple human nature, and the act to please those above you, keep your job, and move up yourself.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by WillPostForFood on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:06PM (#16698873)
Except the Tempe police don’t report to the governor, and the mayor of Tempe is a Democrat, and an opponent of the governor. There could have been as much pressure to make it look bad as to minimize it. But more likely there was mo pressure either way, and the police just blame pedestrians by default.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by kartan on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @10:58AM (#16698164)
> but a little top-down pressure can go a long way

"The legal and philosophic aspects of obedience are of enormous importance, but they say very little about how most people behave in concrete situations. I set up a simple experiment at Yale University to test how much pain an ordinary citizen would inflict on another person simply because he was ordered to by an experimental scientist. Stark authority was pitted against the subjects' [participants'] strongest moral imperatives against hurting others, and, with the subjects' [participants'] ears ringing with the screams of the victims, authority won more often than not. The extreme willingness of adults to go to almost any lengths on the command of an authority constitutes the chief finding of the study and the fact most urgently demanding explanation."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by jonafato on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:16PM (#16698981)
It's a bit misleading to post that quote without including the validity section as well. People are not as quick to abandon their ethics as the original results of that experiment suggest.

In 2012, Australian psychologist Gina Perry investigated Milgram's data and writings and concluded that Milgram had manipulated the results, and that there was "troubling mismatch between (published) descriptions of the experiment and evidence of what actually transpired." She wrote that "only half of the people who undertook the experiment fully believed it was real and of those, 66% disobeyed the experimenter". She described her findings as "an unexpected outcome" that "leaves social psychology in a difficult situation." In the journal Jewish Currents, Joseph Dimow, a participant in the 1961 experiment at Yale University, wrote about his early withdrawal as a "teacher", suspicious "that the whole experiment was designed to see if ordinary Americans would obey immoral orders, as many Germans had done during the Nazi period."

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by pjc50 on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @08:48AM (#16697266)
That's .. not how credibility works for the police.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by baldfat on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:30PM (#16699155)
I still see facts as:

1) Nothing was reflective

2) She was walking across the road between street lights in a random space.

3) If a person hit the woman it would not have been homicide or manslaughter even if we didn't know the driver was on their phone.

I would say the pedestrian was legally more than 50% at fault in this horrible accident.

http://www.alllaw.com/articles/nolo/auto-accident/driver-at-...

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by jadedhacker on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:57PM (#16700093)
These facts are only relevant if you disregard LIDAR and you believe that the camera showed what the human eye would see. Videos on youtube (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRW0q8i3u6E and also https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1XOVxSCG8u0&feature=youtu.be) and ABC news footage (http://abc7.com/video-shows-self-driving-ubers-fatal-collisi...) at the scene of the crash paint a much brighter picture. The street lights in the footage appear to be distinct while the background is dark, indicating the gain of the sensor would appear to be reduced. Try taking a picture of streetlights at night, if the street is visible, they will appear as stars. Additionally, the safety driver was not paying attention.

EDIT: In my opinion, the more you think about this crash the worse Uber looks. The LIDAR should have worked, the lighting was likely brighter than the video shows, the weather was good, no obvious distractor objects, the road was straight, no parties were impaired. The pedestrian had a big bulky bike and crossed at right angles to the car. This is nearly the most basic test of self-driving cars and it failed. The only way Uber would look worse is if it had happened in day time. On top of that, Uber disabled the Volvo auto-braking safety system. (https://www.sfgate.com/business/article/Uber-Disabled-Volvo-...)

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by Filligree on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:41PM (#16699278)
The test for a self-driving car isn't "does it drive as well as a human," it's "does it drive as well as a self-driving car which normally beats a human should."

This might sound like it makes no difference, but the car had LIDAR. That the scene was badly lit, whether true or not, is irrelevant; the car didn't use ambient light to see. If it could hit her under these circumstances, then it could just as easily hit her at noon.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by zodPod on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:03PM (#16699515)
This is what gets me! I really wish they would talk about why the LIDAR didn't notice her. Was it off? Was it malfunctioning? Was there some other issue there? I've been puzzled about how it didn't see her!
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by FreeFull on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:32PM (#16699832)
The theory I've seen the most is that the LIDAR probably did detect her just fine, but Uber's software failed to act on the data.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by thaumaturgy on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:56PM (#16700662)
According to Reuters, Uber had changed from a network of 7 LIDAR sensors on their vehicles to just one: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-uber-selfdriving-sensors-...
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by SpikeDad on Thursday March 29, 2018 @11:17AM (#16707718)
Which brings up the real question - do we want self-driving cars that ONLY drive as well as humans. I for one would be terrified at that criteria.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by drjasonharrison on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:50PM (#16700019)
According to discussions I have read. The LIDAR was disconnected as part of a test of "visual only" navigation. Why didn't they keep the LIDAR on for safety?
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by baldfat on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:15PM (#16700271)
If they did that I would say sue them out of existence. That killed a woman and harmed the industry.
Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by panarky on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:42PM (#16699295)
Human drivers and other autonomous cars could have avoided this accident.

Uber's systems failed spectacularly, and should not have been on public roads.

Now we learn that Uber and the governor secretly collaborated to enable this, to neutralize any effective oversight, and to keep the public in the dark.

Blaming the victim doesn't illuminate any of these issues.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by phyzome on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:05PM (#16700762)
If you even believe the video is representative of what a human would see (which is totally false, as recent local videos of that stretch have shown), then the car was driving beyond its headlights. That's unsafe driving.

Deer are not reflective. Random objects that have fallen off a truck are not reflective. People are often not reflective, and there is no law requiring them to be.

And this woman was wheeling a bright pink bike, which shows up quite well. (It may also have had standard spoke reflectors, which might not show up in this video. hard to say.)

And finally, there weren't any crosswalks in that area for her to use. Yes, she misjudged the speed of the car, but her choice to cross the road at all is pretty solid.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by romwell on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @06:12PM (#16702484)
>If you even believe the video is representative of what a human would see (which is totally false, as recent local videos of that stretch have shown), then the car was driving beyond its headlights. That's unsafe driving.

This point needs to be understood by everyone discussing the issue.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by koreyb on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:22PM (#16700952)
Well there is a crosswalk at the light..intersection of Curry & Mill.

What's interesting is the X paved walkway in the median. You can see it here: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Tempe,+AZ/@33.4364759,-111...

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by vkou on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @02:04PM (#16700165)
> If a person hit the woman it would not have been homicide or manslaughter even if we didn't know the driver was on their phone.

That's because the bar for vehicular manslaughter is incredibly high. There is a huge range of shitty road behaviour that is not illegal, but you should never do, for the sake of yourself and other people.

Driving faster then you can see is one of those behaviors. Hitting someone because you had legal right of way is another. Right of way is good and all, but your first job as a driver is to avoid crashes. Right of way is just a set of guidelines for avoiding crashes... And a way to assign legal blame when one happens.

When I sea kayak, I have right of way against large boats in some situations. I'd be a complete, and dead idiot if I were to exercise my legal right to stay on course.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by andrewla on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:29PM (#16699804)
I would like to see the more detailed telemetry that the car gathered at the time.

For a human driving the car, the dash cam together with personal testimony would probably put the issue to rest; although the fact that the pedestrian was in the roadway before they entered the lane looks very suspicious because a human likely would have seen them because of headlights on an open road even if not illuminated by streetlights. Nonetheless, the dash cam shows what it shows, and human sense and memory is fragile.

Not so for a self-driving car -- the memory is not fragile, and should be preserved. If it is not preserved and there is no remaining copy of the car's telemetry at the time, that in itself is a detail that can point towards gross negligence on the part of Uber. If it is preserved, the question becomes, would a "reasonable person/software" have acted based on what was shown there, and that goes towards whether there is negligence or recklessness. But we (or at least, investigators) need to see that telemetry to make that decision.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by hcknwscommenter on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @01:56PM (#16700073)
>the dash cam shows what it shows

The dash cam is either proof that: i) that dash cams are far inferior to human eyes in terms of dynamic range (certainly true); and/or ii) the video was purposely darkened or compressed to mislead the public into believing a human driver would have hit the pedestrian (see, https://arstechnica.com/cars/2018/03/police-chief-said-uber-... ).

I think it was both i) and ii).

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by cr0sh on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @03:11PM (#16700835)
I'd like to see the actual data it gathered as well. Plus, I'd like to see the software system, ML models, etc - to run the data against.

The dash cam video is very suspicious. What I want to see is the actual computer vision camera footage; it's never been made clear whether the footage that has been publically made available is from a dashcam or CV camera; I suspect the former.

On the notion of the LIDAR - the device spits out 64 beams; it appeared in the video the woman who was hit was wearing a fuzzy and dark color jacket (was she? I don't know for certain). If this is so - it is possible that any reflections for the LIDAR returns only came from the bottom half and the bicycle at best. The top half would have been either absorbed, or possibly filtered as "noise" prior to the classification algorithm.

Which is why the ML algo's matter - how did the classifier classify the data? Did it think what was moving across the road was something other than a human? Without the data and the algorithm, there's no good way to know.

But now I hear it's possible the LIDAR was turned off to run a "vision only" driving system. Was it? Who knows; we may never get the truth of what happened here.

Form a personal standpoint, it saddens and perplexes me - and makes me upset to a degree - that this happened here in my city. I recently completed the Udacity Self-Driving Car Engineer nanodegree, and I tend to wonder if this incident will somehow potentially color any future employment opportunities in that field, should I pursue them...

The whole political angle of this thing - sigh.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by andrewla on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:04PM (#16701403)
The software system and ML models would only be necessary if an analysis of the underlying data showed that there should be a reasonable chance of avoiding the accident. If that were the case then the models and training process could well be distinction between simple recklessness and gross negligence.

I doubt the LIDAR data would be that useful compared to the enhanced high fidelity video just because of how interpretable it would be to a jury.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by andrewla on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @04:00PM (#16701352)
The first point is, as you say, certainly true.

The second point is an allegation of criminal obstruction of justice, which would be taken into account both as a crime in an of itself and also as an overt act in furtherance of a conspiracy. These are very serious charges, that would result in prison time for people throughout the program. Thus it's my tendency to assume good faith on the part of Uber since the consequences are so dire.

Most likely the higher fidelity video and sensor logs are being held back pending a warrant or subpoena for them so that Uber can conduct an internal investigation to figure out how avoidable the collision was, and to avoid giving ammunition to a wrongful death civil suit.

Until the footage is released to investigators or potentially to the public, I think both sides (unfortunate accident vs. gross negligence or recklessness) are possibilities. I personally think the latter is likely -- purely a gut feeling based on the video released. If the underlying footage was not automatically archived or otherwise somehow lost then I think that has to be significant evidence regarding "intent" in a criminal case for manslaughter.

Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre... by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:47PM (#16699346)
> I would say the pedestrian was legally more than 50% at fault in this horrible accident.

Which is fine for Uber-as-operator if they were operating in a state which uses a contributory negligence or modified comparative negligence rule, but a number of jurisdictions—Arizona, for instance—use a pure comparative negligence rule where, e.g., an injured party that is 99% responsible can recover 1% of damages from a party that is 1% responsible.

Moreover, it's no help for Uber-as-manufacturer if strict product liability principles are applied. Now, it's not clear to me that they would apply to Uber as manufacturer as long as the product isn't sold to a third party, but even if they don't apply under current law, Uber using operating a service directly with the product rather than selling it to other operators as an end-run around liability for an unreasonably dangerous product invites a change to the law which would extend such liability to manufacturer-operators.