Re:Arizona governor and Uber kept self-driving program secre...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 28, 2018 @12:47PM
(#16699346)
> I would say the pedestrian was legally more than 50% at fault in this horrible accident.
Which is fine for Uber-as-operator if they were operating in a state which uses a contributory negligence or modified comparative negligence rule, but a number of jurisdictions—Arizona, for instance—use a pure comparative negligence rule where, e.g., an injured party that is 99% responsible can recover 1% of damages from a party that is 1% responsible.
Moreover, it's no help for Uber-as-manufacturer if strict product liability principles are applied. Now, it's not clear to me that they would apply to Uber as manufacturer as long as the product isn't sold to a third party, but even if they don't apply under current law, Uber using operating a service directly with the product rather than selling it to other operators as an end-run around liability for an unreasonably dangerous product invites a change to the law which would extend such liability to manufacturer-operators.
Which is fine for Uber-as-operator if they were operating in a state which uses a contributory negligence or modified comparative negligence rule, but a number of jurisdictions—Arizona, for instance—use a pure comparative negligence rule where, e.g., an injured party that is 99% responsible can recover 1% of damages from a party that is 1% responsible.
Moreover, it's no help for Uber-as-manufacturer if strict product liability principles are applied. Now, it's not clear to me that they would apply to Uber as manufacturer as long as the product isn't sold to a third party, but even if they don't apply under current law, Uber using operating a service directly with the product rather than selling it to other operators as an end-run around liability for an unreasonably dangerous product invites a change to the law which would extend such liability to manufacturer-operators.