Don't kid yourself, both parties are essentially the same, who feeds them just look different. On top of that, Congress continues to cede more powers to the administrative state.. It becomes all about control really..
The primary reason no one should have been worried when DT got elected is that for a great many years, the system was designed that no matter who is driving the ship, they won't sink it because they don't have that power (same goes for BO & GWB). But for years we've been pushing for more centralized authority with power resting at the figurehead, that really ramped up after '01, and later BO put it on steroids.
As private institutions fall away for newer generations, the govt becomes "something we all do together", and the primary solution for having someone else take care of societal problems for us, after all, it's what we pay taxes for...
Congress keeps outsourcing it's responsibilities to the president, no matter what letter, R or D is behind the name on the office door. Tariffs, wars, weaponized govt agencies, privacy rights, drone strikes, surveillance, and on and on...
This isn't a problem of the system, it's merely a symptom of the current state of our society and I personally don't think whether it's tariffs or privacy, little will change in a direction that we would like. The people want easy solutions, they want someone to take care of problems for them. That's exactly what we are getting.
That said, I agree with the spirit of your post, which is that every now and then we should scale that power back.
Also, your whole argument says “People are not happy with what’s going on only because they are facing the consequences of it”.
Duh?
It was never easy to explain why privacy matters, the argument that if you are not doing anything bad then you don’t have anything to hide was good enough for many.
Now, things are different. We have demonstrable implications of the privacy violations.
I think it’s not a Trump thing, if Hillary was the smarter one to use computational propaganda we would probably still have an expose considering that the population of Democrats and Republicans are roughly the same and all have been done by a state funded British TV anyway.
I don’t think that you’re claiming victimhood rightfully. The privacy discussions didn’t start with Trump.
Obama's campaign team bragged openly about doing the same thing, nobody cared.
For example: "mined an Obama backer’s Facebook network in search of friends the campaign wanted to register, mobilize, or persuade."
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/509026/how-obamas-team-us... (2012)
Definitely false, Apple even built business model around it and actively promoting it's privacy as a selling point over Android.
But surely Trump amplified it because, unlike Obama, he is very divisive.
Anyway, if you happen to have a time machine I will happily jump in with you and go back in time and warn against the dangers of data hoarding and privacy violations but I doubt that it will be effective because it's Obama and his campaign wasn't divisive so we will end up with the argument that if you didn't do anything wrong there's nothing to hide.
We wouldn't be able to demonstrate that with privacy violations you can divide a continent(Brexit) or make Trump a president.
Besides, I'm really not happy to approach the problem from the "What about Obama" angle. Is "what about" even a useful argument? What's to be achieved if you are right that Obama indeed did the exact same thing? Should we just go ahead and fill out the missing information on our Facebook profiles because Obama did it too?
I reacted back in 2012 to the fact that Obama's campaign bragged openly about doing same thing. Back then the problem statement was a bit newer to me, I guess I was a bit more sensitive to back then.
The few articles back then praised them about this.
Disclosure: I don't really mind that Trump became president or that UK decided to leave EU - wouldn't have cared if the outcome was the opposite either. It's just different approaches of running countries with different pros and cons.
"Obama and Trump both used user data" is equal to "Reddit and Hacker News are the same, both use upvotes".
The way that data is used is what all matters. The risk is to hoard and distribute data, the disaster is to use that data to manipulate the population to do something horrible(I'm not necessarily saying that Trump is horrible but there are many people who see it that way).
And...
>To clarify, the general public outlash started after Trump and Brexit.
You'll need to prove that one because we had multiple products and a giant corporation(Apple) targeting privacy cautious audience before all this happened.
Citation needed.
-Jean Paul-Sartre
Manafort served as Trump's Campaign manager from June 2016 to August 2016, but I guess that has nothing to do with Trump's Campaign.
Created an account to attempt to derail this conversation into being about Seth Rich and Hillary Clinton. lol.
Lets stay rational and stick to facts.
Sure, let's do that:
1) George Papadopoulos pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI.
2) Michael Flynn pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI.
3) Paul Manafort was indicted on conspiracy, money laundering, false statements, and failure to disclose foreign assets, not just money laundering.
4) Rick Gates similar to Manafort, but has taken a plea deal.
5) 13 Russian nationals and 3 Russian companies indicted on conspiracy charges and identity theft.
6) Richard Pinedo pleaded guilty to an identity theft charge in connection with the Russian indictments, and is cooperating.
7) Alex van der Zwaan pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI about his connections to Rick Gates.
We can only speculate, but if you lie to the FBI, I would assume it's very likely that you have something to hide. Whether those plea deals led further down the rabbit hole to people who were guilty of further crimes we don't know. Maybe a few of them were on that list. Maybe some will get revealed later. I'm hopeful we will uncover the truth in time.
>stick to facts
okay.
FACT: You bet Manafort isn't a traitor.
Bob Mueller would appear to have a different opinion.
https://www.justice.gov/file/1038391/download
Guess who my money is on.
@dang, sir, I think you have a problem. Don't let HN be used as a platform to spread disinformation. Emerdata is starting up as speak.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-campaign-phased-out-use-o...
In late September 2016, Cambridge and other data vendors were submitting bids to the Trump campaign. Then-candidate Trump's campaign used Cambridge Analytica during the primaries and in the summer because it was never certain the Republican National Committee would be a willing, cooperative partner. Cambridge Analytica instead was a hedge against the RNC, in case it wouldn't share its data.
The crucial decision was made in late September or early October when Mr. Trump's son-in-law Jared Kushner and Brad Parscale, Mr. Trump's digital guru on the 2016 campaign, decided to utilize just the RNC data for the general election and used nothing from that point from Cambridge Analytica or any other data vendor. The Trump campaign had tested the RNC data, and it proved to be vastly more accurate than Cambridge Analytica's, and when it was clear the RNC would be a willing partner, Mr. Trump's campaign was able to rely solely on the RNC.
That might be technically correct, but CA was unquestionably working with SuperPACs[1] behind the scenes to get Trump elected in November. CA was particularly proud of it's crooked Hillary campaign ("the OO of crooked was a pair of handcuffs").
1. According to the Cambridge Analytica CEO in the Channel 4 undercover documentary https://youtu.be/cy-9iciNF1A?t=6m21s
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/how-democrats-use-...
Did you mean to reply some other comment? I never volunteered my opinion on SuperPACs one way or the other (for you to agree with). In that light your comment is an off-topic non-sequitur.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/bannon-oversaw-cambr...
Obviously CA was not infallible, they could only get Ted Cruz to second against Trump among GOP candidates in that initial mad scrum, Cruz thought he could win with only evangelical voters in the primaries based on what they looked at with previous GOP primaries and was blindsided by Trump coming at the primaries from a different angle.
On the other hand, the Obama campaign used sneaky Terms and Conditions to suck up friend lists and create a national social graph for the sole purpose of winning the General Election.
Like, I know the news media have spun the fact that one of Trump's big, important donors made them hire CA as proof they relied on CA to win the election, but really it should be the opposite - it should call into question whether their hiring was justified by what they offered the campaign.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5520303/Obama-campai...
This is typically what I cannot stand anymore in American politics, it has become so much "We" against "them" that each side gets the pitchfork out for things they would be perfectly fine to do if their side did it
CA sold data to Trump, Rubio, and others - pitchforks!
FB gives data to Obama and Clinton, marketing awards and praise.
Gonna need a citation of Obama being even remotely involved in something like that.
Classic deflection.
Story contains tweets from his campaign manager.
But here, have a link from somewhere else:
Forbes: https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2018/03/19/why-are...
Twitter: https://twitter.com/cld276/status/975568130117459975
Why are you bringing up facebook giving away data that they own?
Now when the enemy has (and use) the same technology, we’re forced to cry foul. Demand oversight. Demand regulation.
The greater public is OK with this technology. They’re Ok with sweeping data collection (Snowden Files). They’re OK with mining personal data (Facebook, Google, etc). Thy’re OK with 1984, so long as it’s their sides version of 1984.
It takes a Trump for your side to realize how shitty things got while you were enamored with charisma on your bliss box.
Edit: typing on my phone. Fixing grammar.