Out of genuine interest, do you have any citations from reputable physicists who agree dark matter is a "crack pot theory"?
http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1086/508162/meta
There is a great deal of evidence for dark matter that does not depend on Kepler's laws, please stop spreading misinformation.
Source: assistant editor of a physics journal, know several astrophysicists personally, currently dealing with a MOND paper this very week...
They do that based on a misapplication of the divergence theorem. They assume that all the mass inside an orbital radius can be treated as a point-mass which is true for uniform spherical distributions. They also assume the mass outside the radius has no net infuence - which is true for uniform spherical shells. Neither of these is valid for non-uniform distributions - a flat disk in not symmetric in 3-space. If they'd just do some electrostatics problems they'd know the different formulas for disks and rings. I was going to google a sample page but there's too many to sift through and I gotta run an errand.
Welcome to the club - it's incredibly small...
"The approximation that the mass distribution is spherical is reasonable for the dark halo, but not for the flat stellar disk. Better models suggest that this estimate is probably high by about 30%, since a disk requires less mass to produce a given centripetal acceleration"
And there you have it. While he notes that a spherical distribution is different than a flat disk, he estimates the error at about 30%. The problem is that the error is not one of a constant factor, it's a different function. This unspecified better model also doesn't seem to care about the matter outside the solar radius - which also affects our velocity in a disk, but not in a sphere.
There is a lot of math in chapter one, but also a lot of hand waving.
If anyone can tell me why Kepler applies galaxies (vs 2-body systems with certain constraints), I'd be happy to show where the error in that analysis is. Kepler doesn't apply to galaxies. It's really that simple.
I can't imagine the amount of superiority you must feel to assume that physicists don't know high school level integration of Newtonian forces.
Every couple days the department chair or some well-known professor would get a letter (this was before most of the crackpots had email accounts, I guess) claiming that some theory--particularly general relativity--was wrong and all it took was a simple application of high school arithmetic to see it.
One of our faculty happened to coin the phrase "dark energy" while I was there, and man did the letters start coming in after that. Of course, the only absolutely universal commonality among all of the letters was that they were all nonsense, like the above.
In general, I felt sort of bad because you could tell that a lot of these people were really not well, but it's still hard for me to see things from someone's perspective who genuinely believes that the entire astrophysics community (save a tiny handful of contrarian actual physicists) has somehow engaged in a massive conspiracy to ignore introductory physics in favor of some other vastly more complicated theory for absolutely no possible benefit. (Especially when these professors are literally teaching introductory physics to students while they're pursuing their research.)
I'm not claiming it is the case now (though it does smack of luminiferous aether a bit) but the scientific community can and has been wrong sometimes in the face of as yet undiscovered principles.
Someone else unwittingly suggested a parallel to Fermat, which I think hits the nail on the head exactly. If someone thinks they can prove Fermat's last theorem with some high school geometry, odds are pretty good they're a crackpot. If they're a well-regarded mathematician and they can build off new mathematics and make a few very complicated leaps by discovering new mathematics of their own, then people take them more seriously.
Scott Aaronson has a really great take on this here: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=304
As an aside that's probably only interesting to me, I went to a Great Books college. It's one of those hippy dippy liberal arts schools where there are no electives, no textbooks, no lectures, just primary sources. You learn mathematics by reading Euclid, Ptolemy, Newton, etc.
At any rate, for first-year "Labratory" class, you trace the atomic theory from the Greeks to roughly Avogadro. Along the way you read papers by and replicate the experiments of many influencial scientists along the way. When I mention that the above crackpots are "wrong", I don't mean it in the sense of the aether or analogous theories along the way to the atomic theory, namely phlogiston or caloric, two previous theories of heat. Those theories did not explain new observations and were rightly discarded along the way. Priestly and Lavoisier were brilliant and tried to make theory match observation, so now even though their theories are discarded, their work still stands on its own for the time. I wouldn't call them wrong. There's a definite difference between them and theories that are just wrong.
Nobody's going to get a Nobel Prize when they just make the world believe that they have obviated the need for dark matter by pulling out some high school math and some Kepler proofs.
Someone will win it if they ever make an observation that proves a MOND theory in a way that shows conclusively that dark matter is not needed to explain all current observations and in fact cannot remain compatible with this new observation.
There's a big difference between the two, I think.
This requirement is impossible to meet for sufficiently flexible theories. Eg no one will ever "win" over "God did it" according to your metric.
Also, if you see how many people in high academic positions are obviously wrong about simple stuff they use every day like p-values, nothing will surprise you any more.
I'm not sure I see how your second point is relevant. You seem to imply that I think that academics are infallible in all areas not even related to their expertise. Do you truly see no difference between non-statistics researchers incorrectly calculating statistical values and dozens of unrelated experiments all leading to the same result?
>"I'm not sure I see how your second point is relevant. You seem to imply that I think that academics are infallible in all areas not even related to their expertise. Do you truly see no difference between non-statistics researchers incorrectly calculating statistical values and dozens of unrelated experiments all leading to the same result?"
This is series of strawmen... I'm saying widespread confusion can, and currently does, exist on a topic even amongst the experts. Therefore it is not unbelievable that it does on other topics as well.
Also, dark matter is an interpretation of a result, not a result itself, so an experiment cannot lead to it directly. Finally, I don't think there are any actual experiments that have supported dark matter, only astronomical observations. Correct me if wrong but I found this after a quick search: https://www.sciencenews.org/blog/science-ticker/results-slew...
Actually another point is that this is not the issue. The calculations are fine, they are just calculating something other than they think: p(Data | Hypothesis) when they want p(Hypothesis | Data).
That is very similar to what the OP claimed about calculating a model that assumes a sphere to describe a disc (no idea if they are correct on that).
Crackpot theories are eccentric and not commonly believed.
I am interested in crackpot theories because sometimes they end up turning out right, and I think within that dynamic there are important lessons for humanity that we end up learning in very hard ways.
For example, the Great Depression paved the way for the acceptance of Keynesian economics--ideas previously written-off as crackpot theories. Another: NASA engineers warned of the exact dangers of a foam strike, under the exact conditions in which it took place, were at the time written-off by senior management. Social scientists that studied this described part of the problem as Groupthink.
By that I mean that the edges of galaxies experience a "reference" spacetime (e.g. constant period), while the interiors experience a stretched out version spacetime (i.e. inverse time dilation and length constriction)?
Or did the entire community of astrophysics simply ignore high school physics in favor or something vastly more complicated because reasons?
In physics, how well your model can predict past and future states from the current state is rather important. Though future states more than past state but any model should be able to also somewhat agree with it's the past it generates.
You can't simply say "this model also predicts that" without giving on how accurate it does predict and comparing to existing models. Otherwise we'd be using flat earth models for building bridges and planning ship routes.
You'd do well to do a little more research on the topic before posting so many comments on HN.
There is a ton of evidence for dark matter. We still don't know exactly what it is, but we do know lots about it (e.g. it is not baryonic matter because observation differs from theoretical models of how it would interact with ordinary baryonic matter). As for all that other evidence, the first hit on Google is for laymen: https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/five-reasons-we-think-...
TLDR: gravitational lensing, missing mass, and three other really good reasons that dark matter is a serious subject of study.
Disclaimer: I am not a physicist. And I'm trying not to represent myself as one on HN.
Talking about this stuff is fun, sure. It's great to learn! But please don't spread ignorance with such high confidence. As for "just" Newtonian physics, there's a whole research field called "Modified Newtonian Dynamics" (MOND). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics
TLDR; there are lots of problems with MOND, and it doesn't explain gravitational lensing and other effects of dark matter that we see.
Mg = C1 * Rg * Rg
Is not a good assumption for the discs we observe in the universe, because they do not have a constant surface density. The picture is further complicated by the fact the many disc galaxies also contain a central bulge, large enough to effect the potential (to say nothing of Dark Matter).
Mg = C1 * Rg * Rg
where C1 depends only on shape and is basically the same across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
Orbital speed of stars in the disk is proportional to the square root of the galaxy's mass (the observed absence of the other otherwise must-have orbital velocity equation component - ie. 1/SQRT(r) - is what causes crack pot theories like dark matter) :
Vdisk = C2 * SQRT(Mg) = C2 * SQRT(C1) * Rg
where C2 also dependents only on shape and is basically the same across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
Thus Vdisk = C * Rg where the C is pretty close to being the same across all the spiral/disk galaxies.
Angular speed of a star in the disk at the distance "r" from center is
Vdisk / (2pi * r) = (C * Rg) / (2pi * r)
which at the edge of the galaxy, ie. where r = Rg, becomes
(C * Rg) / (2pi * Rg) = C / 2pi
ie. the same constant across all the spiral/disk galaxies. The end.