Re:All disk galaxies rotate once every billion years: study
by coldtea on Thursday March 15, 2018 @12:33AM
(#16590418)
Whereas professional physicists can't and haven't taken those maths into account?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:All disk galaxies rotate once every billion years: study
by phkahler on Thursday March 15, 2018 @05:53PM
(#16596825)
That would be correct. I wondered if the problem was me reading things like Wikipedia which says the expected galactic rotation curve should follow something based on Kepler's laws. Then someone got me a subscription to Nature... You know the prestigious "peer reviewed" journal where the serious stuff is. Don't get me wrong Nature had some really awesome content. But there was a paper about a galaxy found in the early formative stages and the authors measured a rough rotation curve and felt the need to compare it to something Kepler would predict. Ugh.
If anyone can tell me why Kepler applies galaxies (vs 2-body systems with certain constraints), I'd be happy to show where the error in that analysis is. Kepler doesn't apply to galaxies. It's really that simple.